User blog comment:BeastMan14/One Last Ride: Samurai Jack vs Logan!/@comment-17814994-20170523033344/@comment-17814994-20170523111651

I see, well here's my vote...

Elgb's "The Old Breed" EDGES!!!

Weapons: This was a tought one. When in comes to melee weapons between these two badass blade-killers, Logan's adamantium claws is second to none. He can easily cleave through any metal in his universe, and there's no doubt he'll be able to cleave through Jack's spear, sword and knives. The spear is handy though with its stun gun and armor piercing capabilties, but it won't be able to block an attack from Logan's calws, nor can they cut just as deep. However, Jack does have the advantage in range weapons. He's already an amazing marksman with bows, which can be transposed when he started using a laser pistol. Logan himself can be put down with a continous barrage of bullets (unless he uses that green liquid thing), and if he gets hit by a more advanced and lethal laser pistol, the effects will be devastating to him. Overall, if this battle ends in melee Logan does have the better close range weapons, but if Jack can shoot at him with that laser pistol, Logan's toast. EDGE: Even

Abilities: Both warriors have abilities that can counter each other. Jack's stealth will be utterly useless against Logan's enhanced senses, and I do beileve that Logan's more durable with his adamantium skull and skeleton. But Jack for me is faster, smarter and a better hand to hand combatant. In his adventures Jack can dodge automatic fire and energy weapons like they were nothing while Logan tends to be a bullet sponge when faced with range weapons. So there's no foubt that the slower Logan won't be able to tag Jack that easily. While Jack will have problems getting past that adamantium skeleton, a few shots from his laser pistol and multiple hits with his melee weapons, while making sure to dodge every attack, will put down Logan for good. His healing factor wasn't strong as it used to be, and large amounts of pain and exhaustion can knock Logan down. But in the case of Samurai Jack, he'll be able to put down Logan as the battle drags long. EDGE: Jack

Weaknesses: When talking about which weakness has more effect on these two, I think that Logan's failing healing factor will affect him more than Jack's hallucination. Jack maybe crazy, but he was still able to put up well-calculated fights. Logan on the other hand, couldn't rely on his healing factor anymore to survive. He was a bullet sponge so every attack done to him was crippling, and he needed the help of others to save him during his last adventures. EDGE: Jack

Deadliest Warrior?

After some time thinking I have to give this one to Samurai Jack. It was painful to see Logan stumble and fall his way through that film. He was largely dependent on his healing factor and as it failed him, his fighting tactic of barreling through enemies while soaking up damages killed him. He needed Laura Kinney and a bottle of green liquid to last a little longer in his final adventure.

Samurai Jack on the other hand, though crazy, still retains his prowess in battle. He's way faster than Logan and his laser pistol will be devastating on the poor mutant. He's way smarter and he doesn't have any poison on him to cripple him down. If Jack plays smart and keeps his distance against a berserking Logan, which he will, then he'll be able to put down Logan for good and put that hero out of his long, hard misery (cue "Hurt" by Johny Cash).