User blog comment:MrPacheco101/a MrPacheco101/Omnicube1 Collaboration:The HOTD Gang vs. The Walking Dead Survivors/@comment-3195617-20110319152152

Short Range: HOTD (DOuble the rounds) Mid Range: WD (It's pump, but it's a superior weapon, imo) Mid Range 2: HOTD (Options kills) Long Range: WD (Yes it's semi-auto, but that only means fires as fast as you can pull the trigger.  It's got more round, and you wouldn't be wasting any of them, unlike a full-auto weapon.)  Melee: HOTD (Katanas are boss)  Overall winner:  HOTD by a small margin of 520-480