User blog comment:Killermoves/Lancer vs Hugo Coghlan/@comment-17814994-20181217114727

Elgb's "Chu Chulain vs Chu Chulain" EDGES!!!

Offensive Powers: It's really hard to decide since the feats listed here are fluffy to say the least, all bordering on "this attack can cause effects like this and that (for the case of Lancer)" or "this dude killed a god so he's tough (in this case, Hugo)". In the end I have to give it to Lancer. The Gae Bolg Attack no 2 won't do much against Hugo, but Gae Bolg no 1 which has tremendous hax and durability negation magic that it will no doubt go through Hugo's durability. It may not kill him but it may cause significant damage to cripple him. EDGE: Lancer

Defensive Powers: Easy edge to Hugo Coghlan. The dude took on Godzilla, gods and even the Gladiator and survived. Lancer wasn't really known much for his durability (he is a Lancer after all, all about speed and such). Hugo is built like a tank against almost anything from physical and magical attacks (though contrary to what you listed above, Hugo is NOT overall immune to magical attacks since the Pink Child has taken hold of him once IIRC). Even so, the big dude can tank almost everything Lancer can throw at him besides Gae Bolg Attack no. 1. EDGE: Hugo

Physicality: This I have to give to Hugo. He is stronger, durable,stealthier and probably even smarter. The only thing Lancer has going for him is his speed and agility advantage which he can use to try and prolong the fight. But the moment he gets caught (and the Hugo himself ain't that slow himself) he is toast. Almost all the categories in physicality goes to Hugo. EDGE: Hugo

Deadliest Warrior?

I love both Fate and the LXG Universe even though I am not that knoweldgeable with their lore as other experts in this wiki. That being said I think Hugo Coghlan may win this battle although barely. He can practically shrugg off almost all of Lancer's attacks and one shot from him is enough to take the skinny looking Lancer down.

However, he still has to catch Lancer first before he can do that. Hugo has taken down the equally fast Hugo Danner before by letting the latter be too confident to get up close, well enough for Hugo Coghlan's reach. Hugo would no doubt do the same. The only thing that Lancer can use to damage Hugo is his Gae Bolg Attack no. 1 which would pretty much bypass Hugo Coghlan's defenses and strike him down. However, it won't be a game ender here since that attack has been tanked by other weaker characters before and Hugo, who has survived gods, may be able to survive it long enough to counter attacl. Lancer cannot spam his special attacks and once he used up his Gae Bolg Attack no. 1, he's pretty much out of options.

That being said, this is the anime version of Lancer that was used here. If this was the RPG version of Lancer with all of his Rune Magic, Batle Continuation A, Disengage C etc, the results maybe different.