User blog comment:Владимир Эльясов/Alexander Nevsky vs Richard the Lionheart/@comment-5931345-20130718030132/@comment-26074921-20130720153846

I have yet to read all of this debate, but docking someone because the victor did not take all of the weapon edges?

You're joking right? there is no drop in logic or misuse of information here, it happens all the time. Sometimes the victor comes less well equipped, or has more experience using their weapons.

If we had a battle with a gang member equipped with top-of-the-line millitary grade hardware, and a trained experieced soldier with outdated weapons most people would still give the battle to the soldier. Its not that uncommon of a circumstance

Bulls did not violate your voting criteria nor is his vote worth getting demoted.

(Not to mention you have a very weird voting criteria making Edges required)