User blog comment:The Deadliest Warrior, Jr./British Redcoats vs. Cowboy Outlaws/@comment-3166030-20110116073327

I'm goign for teh Cowboys on this, solely because Oklahoma is home to the Cowboy hall of fame, and the way I see it...

Bayonet vs. Bowie Knife, While the Bowie Knife can hack and slash at a closer range, and can be thrown, the bayonet can turn teh Musket into a deadly spear. Edge: Redcoats

Wheellock Pistol vs. Shotgun: Knowing that the Wheellock Pistol is a French Weapon, you'd figure the Redcoats would use Flintlock....  But anyway, we all know the reliability of the Wheellock, and it's nothing compared to a good ol' fashioned American double barreled shotgun. Edge: Outlaws

Musket vs. Revolver: This one should be a no-brainer. The Musket may have a slight edge in range.... however, it's only one shot, with a 10 second or higher reloading process. The Revolver however, is 6 shots, and in a good hand, it's vicious. Edge: Outlaws

Musket Volley vs. TNT: The TNT, you have to wait for your enemy to come near it, or throw an individual stick out, as a grenade. Meanwhile, five musket shots (I assume squad on squad) will tear holes into some outlaws from a distance, if they're good shots. Edge: Redcoats.

Geoff Desmoulin: Overall, after the tests... I have to give my edge to the Outlaws of the Wild West. They're vicious, deadly, and have a century of greater technology.