User blog comment:SPARTAN 119/The Killer Girl Next Door: A Manga Horror Battle Royale: Rena Ryuguu vs Mai Mashiro vs Rio Miyaichi vs Satsuki Miya/@comment-17814994-20150125002310

Elgb's "Fucked up version of Lucky Star! All Female Anime Stereotypes Unite!" EDGES!!!

Weapons A: Of all the weapons, the nata due to the large surface area and probably cuts deeper and does more damage that the others. The next best weapon is the baseball bat due to its length and powerful blunt force. The third best weapon is the meat cleaver, although the user would have to get close and put more force to actually deal some great damage. The weakes is the novelty baseball bat which is fragile and lacks range and power than the other weapons

1st: Ryuguu

2nd: Miya

3rd: Mashiro

4th: Miyaichi

Weapons B: The collapsable baton no doubt. Its built as an actual weapon with durability and can inflict painful damages to the body, while also giving the best speed and range. Second is the Metal pipe which can deal also considerable amount of damage and range but lacks speed. Third best weapon is Rio's boxcutter which severly beats Miya's due to the fact that the former is more outright brutal and sadistic up close, and when she's grabs the inexperienced Miya its game over for her. But boxcutters themselves are fragile and won't cut that deep.

1st: Mashiro

2nd: Ryuguu

3rd: Miyaichi

4th: Miya

Weapons C: The Awl is the most effective weapon is this category. Its thin spike can easily go through skull although it won't do well if not used on a vital part unless multiple stabs are made. The second one is the syringe with its thin needle and sedative which would knock out anyone. It's also easy to conceal and Rio can use it as wither a last resort or a quick concealed counterattack. The thirdone is the glass shard which offers some considerable killing potential but will break easily, making it a one-shot one kill weapon. The weakest for me is the garrote. Miya would have to use both hands to use that thing, and it's also built as a stealth weapon, not a weapon you use for up close and personal fights.

1st: Mashiro

2nd: Miyaichi

3rd: Ryuguu

4th: Miya

Deadliest Warrior:

1st: Rena Ryuguu

Although she doesn't have the best weapons in the last two categories, what gave her the win is that, unlike the other three who relies in stealth and manipulation, she's been through more fistfights and close quarters battles. Her durability and savagery would destroy the others when things turn into an up close physical battle, and that nata would dominate any weapon in this category. Her upbringing in that crazy town gave her more experience in fighting crazy people than the other three.

2nd: Mai Mashiro

She dominates in the last two categories and her baton would allow her to disarm anyone and butcher just as efficiently. Her skills in fighting more than one opponent would be useful in the early run.

3rd: Rio Miyaichi

The most stealthful (and the hottest [hic]) in the bunch. Her experience to take time and plan out attacks, while attacking her opponents when they don't realize it will be useful. But she lacks experience when things go up close.

4th: Satsuki Miya

Although probably the craziest of the bunch, she's also the most fragile, having little experience in a bitch fight. Although I respect her skills, she's still on her path to becoming a serial killer.