User blog comment:WinterSpider/William Munny vs Rooster Cogburn/@comment-27043000-20190925020532

Pygmy Hippo's "My Home State's the Setting?" Edges

Primary Handgun:The 1858 Starr Revolver shoots faster thanks to double action but the Colt Single Action Army Peacemaker has the deadlier round and a faster muzzle velocity. Both have the same amount so it basically comes down to speed against power and I'm actually siding with the Colt on this one. Edge:Rooster

Secondary Handgun:The Colt Dragoon has a faster muzzle velocity but the Schofield Revolver has the deadlier round. Both are single action with a six bullet magazine so this is actually even between these two sidearms. Edge:Tie

Rifle:The Spencer Carbine has the deadlier round but the Winchester Model 1873 has more rounds, is longer and lighter, and has a faster muzzle velocity. They're even in the other categories but the Winchester is still clearly superior. Edge:Rooster

X-Factors:William Munny takes Brutality, Handicaps, and Intelligence while Rooster Cogburn takes Experience and Accuracy. Brutality is useless but Rooster's alcoholism is a really damning weakness that can screw over his other edges and even without it, William's in better shape at least. Edge:William

Final Verdict:I have to go with the major here and give this to Rooster Cogburn for his harder hitting sidearm and more reliable rifle. William Munny can take this fight if his opponent’s drunk but that's pretty much the only advantage he has here besides an equally unimpressive secondary sidearm. As long as Rooster hasn't been drinking, his experience and accuracy should make him win this fight with his better weapons.

Winner:Rooster Cogburn