User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 1 Episode 4: Crazy Horse vs Ned Kelly/@comment-5195329-20120626211633

Close Range: [NED] - The club breaks and needs more precise shots. The dirk is more likely to cause more damaging wounds. Also, from the image Ned seems to have a helmet, so that makese it less helpful.

Mid Range: [NED] - The Colt is a single actions whilst the BA is a double action, and thus a faster rate of fire. Plus the rounds are about the same so there's no big difference in knock-down power.

Long Range: [CH] - Much more rounds and also faster/easier to load. The lever actions is also a lot better on the Henry. Edge goes to Crazy Horse.

Special: [NED] - Faster rate of fire and easier to aim. Also, back then getting shot usually meant it was over for you. I also can't see the special tactics CH used being helpful in a 5 vs 5.

WINNER - Ned Kelly, Crasy Horse is more of a warrior but due to Ned's forces having more gun power and faster rates of fire (minus the rifles but I doubt that advantage would be enough), I think he'll win.