User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 3 Episode 1: Frank West vs Rick Grimes/@comment-6771148-20130331232807

melee: West,since his baseball bat has  longer reach than Ricks Gator Machete. Plus the blunt trauma of the bat may allow it  do more damage with less effort.

Revolver: Edge rick, his is lighter and can be aimed faster.

Handgun: West, higher caliber gun does more damage

The rest of the weapons are all about even for both men.

Rick has a large training advantage over West. I see training as being the most important x -factor in this match up. Rick being an ex-police officer will give him a big edge or West, as he has been trained in armed combat and usage of basic tactics. Rick will beat west easily in ranged combat, but will struggle agianst his opponent at close range.

my vote goes to Rick Grimes