User blog comment:Elgb333/A Grim Fairy Tale: Jack Horner vs Blue Fairy/@comment-27043000-20190703070651

Pygmy Hippo's "I Think I'm Back" Edges

Powers:As far as physicality goes, Jack Horner takes both strength and durability as the Blue Fairy only takes speed and had to rely on healing spells but looking at their other powers is more interesting. I don't think Blue has anything to take out Jack considering how much stuff he's survived even if she made another Hrunting which she probably wouldn't even use it if she made it and he disrupts offensive magic anyways along with being a shapeshifter so it's unlikely she could take his heart out or turn him into a cricket but there's nothing stopping her from paralyzing him or putting him to sleep. Anyways while the Fairy is hard to hit, Horner's abilities aren't going to be hindered in any way and he could potentially distract her long enough with The Pathetic Fallacy to trap her in the Devil's Burlap Sack which she won't be getting out of anytime soon.

Overall, both have their methods of incapacitating each other but Jack could possibly kill her with great difficulty and is physically superior although the Blue Fairy would most likely incapacitate him first and that's what actually matters here. Edge:Jack

X-Factors:Once more, Jack Horner has a clear edge over the Blue Fairy due to his superior personal combat experiences, beating giants and supernatural foes who she'd need her magic to triumph over, and being skilled with a variety of weapons including firearms. I also believe that Jack's smarter as while Blue is a good leader, this is a one-on-one fight and outsmarting devils and gods is more impressive than a queen and Rumplestiltskin. Edge:Jack

Weaknesses:Both have weaknesses I've talked about before but Jack Horner can still be easily incapacitated and the Blue Fairy can be easily tricked and killed. Jack likely won't turn into a dragon as there's probably not a lot of gold lying around in town and I don't think Blue's going to lose her wand or run out of fairy dust in combat. Ultimately, the Fairy has more range for an incapacitating than Horner has for it or a killing blow.

Final Verdict:I was actually thinking Jack Horner would win before I got to the weaknesses tab and now it's clear the Blue Fairy will win in my opinion. Her incapacitating spells seem to be her go-to method of dealing with opponents and he doesn't have immunity against it either. While Jack could trick Blue or overpower her in CQC, it's a lot more likely the fight ends as quickly as an Old West quickdraw.

Winner:Blue Fairy