User blog comment:Leolab/Ancient User Tourney, Round 2: Oliver Moreau (Winter) v Sir Bors of Newcastle (Elgb)/@comment-4661256-20160526193432/@comment-4661256-20160526225159

Okay, fair enough, but I was under the impression that the bios were copy-pasted exact and not summarized (I'll keep this in mind for future blogs), and the summary does not say that he has mercenary combat experience. Anyway, I'd argue that Sir Bors' formal combat training and regular military experience will still be more valuable than Moreau's mercenary experience simply because it means Bors' discipline and experience will be uniform, rather than Moreau's motley collection of potentially incompatible fighting styles.

Fair enough for the katars, but I also believe that you're severely overestimating the ability of one weapon to win the entire match for a warrior, especially when weapons with greater reach like the halberd and longsword are in play. Yes, the katars will likely be Moreau's single most effective weapon, but you're under the assumption that the vast majority of the time, Moreau will take one look at Bors and immediately equip his katars. Considering he's got a hugely diverse (if somewhat less effective, in my opinion, based on my edges) arsenal, it's likely he'd try to use the various weapons pretty equally. There's nothing that implies he favors this weapon (in fact, it specifically says that he's still learning to use it--so sure, it might not require a huge degree of skill, but he himself says that he's still a newbie with it).