User blog comment:WanderingSkull/Jack vs. Frank West/@comment-4098900-20120922041434

Hawk's Hawk-Eyed Edges:

Close Range: A chainsaw is easily better then a baseball bat. It can cut that thing right in half. It ain't like a chainsaw is much weight either. 10-20 pounds. Anybody of decent strength can wield that thing real fast. And while there's no proof, it's quite obvious Jack is pretty strong. As for the pistols well.....Glocks are great for hostage rescue in urban enviornments. They have a lot of rounds, a high rate of fire, and are accurate. The M1911 is accurate, has a decent rate of fire (a pistol champion can fire it REAALLY fast. But neither of these guys are anything like that) but only has 7-10 rounds. Vs. the Glock's 17-20 rounds. Thing is though, neither of these guys are wearing any body armor. If they were (especially since they aren't great marksman who can easily aim and put bullet in your head before you can even if you're just waiting at a door aiming your gun waiting for them to come in) wearing body armor, I'd probably give it to the M1911 for a decent rate of fire, stronger round, and pretty much equal accuracy. Eh, probably call it a tie. Either way, neither of these guys are wearing bodyarmor, and it ain't like they have the skills to make easy head shots or get a ton of rounds off quickly into the armor so armor will barely even matter.

Edge: Jack

Mid Range: These shotguns are pretty much the same. They don't have much difference worth mentioning so I'm just gonna call that even. Micro Uzi Vs UMP 45. UMP=larger weapon, still compact with larger bullet, higher accuracy. Micro Uzi=Higher rate of fire, more compact, larger magazine. See, once again these guys ain't wearing body armor. The Micro Uzi being more compact, having a higher rate of fire, more ammo, them not being at much distance to accuracy won't be to big, and not wearing body armor so the larger round ain't to big a deal, is why the Micro Uzi gets the edge here. So tie for shotguns, edge Frank in SMGs.

Edge: Frank West

Long Range: M4=more compact, more accurate. AK-47=Larger bullet, MUCH more reliable, higher rate of fire, simpler and requires less skill to operate. I find it hard to believe that the AK being simpler will make a difference. These guys both know how to use their weapons. The M4 will be quite an advantage if it gets room to room, not if it gets street to street. That advanatge in room to room will be due to compact size. The AK's less accuracy won't make much difference. A lotta people say it's cheaply made and inaccurate. And you know what, that's mostly true. But it doesn't take much to shoot a man with one of those things at a 100 yards. And a 100 yards is about the range they'll be shooting. Normally I would say the AK's reliability won't mean shit in an urban enviornment. But it's quite obvious the streets will be flooded with zombie guts, and with zombies coming in close, it's quite obvious that the M4 could jam. Although I find it unlikely that it will be enough to get anything to jam, I don't think this gonna be where he's on the ground and literally everything is something that could jam it. M4s jam a lot less then their M16 predessesors anyway. Again as I have said before, these guys aren't wearing bodyarmor. Bigger bullet won't be to much a factor. The M4 will also be an advantage if he get surrounded by zombies from all sides, more room to shoot. I'll have to give a slight edge to the M4.

Edge: Frank West

Special: The traps easilt take this. The Reaper is just another melee weapon. Jack can lay these things all over the field. Do you know what, Frank might be able to see them. But when he's being forced by zombies into one place, or is moving back, or maybe he's just to focused on Jack to notice the traps, that will be quite a problem for Frank.

Overall Winner: Jack

 Like Wass pointed out, Jack fought actually sane humans, Frank fought demented douche bags. He actually has experience fighting humans who can think logically. The traps will be a HUGE factor. Frank's not trained in such away where he won't get so focused on something that he won't notice another thing. Once he gets really focused on some zombies or Jack, he won't notice those traps at all. Maybe he does notice them, maybe some Zombieds are forcing him to walk right into one......