User blog comment:WanderingSkull/Jack vs. Frank West/@comment-5365724-20120917235440

Melle

Let's see just like about everyone said the baseball bat is an overall better weapon. While, the chainsaw is much more power it makes way to much noise easily giving away where Jack vould be hiding. The baseball bat ia also a lot more simple and easier to use overall just swing awau and break an arm or two. EDGE: Frank West

Pistols

As much as I love the M1911 for it's famous stopping power the G17 just beats it. A 7 round mag vs. 17 gives a pretty good adavantage to Jack here. The gun although not as powerful gives more room for error. Frank also has to try to line up his shots wasting more time than needed. So overall Jack will get the edge in this category. EDGE: Jack

Shotguns

This is tie. The weapons are to evenly matched in this category. The buttstock on the Remington provides better recoil control but the shorter Mossberg is easier to turn covers with.EDGE TIE

SMG

The micro UZI is good but not as good as the UMP the much powerful round gives it a better edge here. Although it does have a smaller clip it's only 5 bullets that shouldn't make much of difference when it already has a prettty decent clip size. Edge JACK

Long

AK47 all the way here baby. Sorry had to let that out since I love the Ak series of guns. The larger more crippling round of the AK gives it the edge here. The M4 is good but the much smaller mag size plays a huge difference here.EDGE: Jack

Special

Traps versus Reaper. This took me a while to figure out but in the end I give the advantage to the traps. The Traps geuinly can tip the favor of the battle in Jack's. If placed correctly they will allow Jack to kill Frank easily. The Reaper you have to get close and in your rush to reach your opponent you might just step on a landmine. Edge: Jack

WINNER: JACK

I tossed the idea of who should win this fight for awhile but I give it to Jack. He has much superior weapons overall from contuning in all of the edges. Frank West although a total badass has only lasted maybe for a week in total in a living hell while Jack I from when I checked it really did survive atleast 400 days just needed to make sure you weren't lying; apparantly did survive that long. I played Dead Rising before so I know that although Frank has fought plenty of infected and humans. Jack has most likely fought more zombies and humans in his time in hell. So like the winner says I'm giving this battle overall to Jack.