User blog:Greenberet69/Elrond vs Duncan

 Elrond: The Half-Elven Lord of Rivendell who lead the Elves during the Last Alliance of Elves and Men to defeat the armies of Mordor and assist in defeating Sauron's physical body.

vs..

 Duncan: The Grey Warden Commander of Fereldan who went on a jorney to recruit Grey Wardens for the Battle of Ostagr to try and stop the Blight before it could start even recruiting the soon to be Hero of Fereldan.

WHO IS DEADLIEST!









Battle Notes
5 vs 5

Elrond and 4 Elves vs Duncan and 4 Grey Wardens

The Elves will be wearing Elven armor and will be weilding swords used during the Last Alliance

The Grey Wardens will be wearing Grey Warden Plate Armor and will be wielding Longswords and Grey Warden shields



Battleground

 * Ostagar

X-Factors
Elrond/Duncan

89 Training 82

EDGE Elrond: Elrond had formal army training to prepare for the Last Alliance battle where Duncan didin't receive a lot of training until joining the Grey Wardens very late in his life.

90 Combat Experience 90

EDGE Even: Both have had their same amount of combat experience against the forces of Evil in their lands

83 Armor Metallurgy 80

EDGE Elrond: Elven made material has been known to be very powerful and as seen in the Last Alliance the armor does not retrict a lot of movement. Duncan has armor only covering his chest and arms leaving his legs very exposed.

83 Soldiers Armor Metallurgy 74

EDGE Elrond: Elronds soldiers wear the same armor he does. The Grey Wardens Plate armor is good but it will retrict a lot of movement and will cause heavy fatige.

95 Audacity 95

EDGE Even: Both will charge into battle against the forces of Evil and will never surrender

95 Generalship 95

EDGE Even: Both were great leaders of their armies.

0 Terrain Familiarity 100

EDGE Duncan: Duncan knows all about Ostagar where Elrond doesn't

Who. Is. Deadliest? Elrond Duncan

Personal Opinion: I give my edge to Elrond. He has the majority of X-Factors on his side and has the better armor and weapons