User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 3 Episode 1: Frank West vs Rick Grimes/@comment-4803039-20130326171451

I'll try to break the tie then..

Affectos's Emotions: "This may not be a democracy anymore, but at least I'm sane."

Melee:  he bat may be great againts the undead, but with human you need to cut the arteries and viens. Edge: Rick

Revolvers: Others may discuss the wieght of the revolvers, but I have to go with the faster shooting double action that deals more damage. Edge: Rick

Pistols: No competition here. Frank's forte at close range is with melee and thrown weapons, not handguns. Rick has the greater ammo count. Edge: Rick

Shotguns:  The pistol grip will give Rick better manuverability and accuracy. Edge: Rick

Assult Rifles: I see no real difference in this catagory...Edge: Even

Sniper: The slightly lighter Winchester will let Frank be able to get to his next weapon just a bit faster. Edge: Frank

X-Factors:  The biggest factory I see here is the level of sanity and the experience they both have had. Frank has dealt with all kinds of crazy in the mall, including people like Grimes, who has lost almost his whole family. The only counter I see here is that Grime's lack of sanity may, on occasion, give him the upper hand, but this alone isn't able to save him.

Overall Edge: Frank West

While Rick may have the firepower, I foresee the saner of the two to make it out alive.