User blog comment:SentryNeo/Carmelita Fox vs Fox McCloud/@comment-4803039-20131128190641

Affectos's Emotions: "Cue the Romantic Fan Fiction..."

Pistols : 'Sly: Thieves in Time' gave us the best demonstration of Carmalita's Shock Pistol where we see take out not only missles, but also a mecha-robot. While I am tempted to side with a laser that has taken down enemies for good, but Carmalita shows some experise and options with the Shock Pistol. Edge: Shock Pistol

X-Factors: I'm tempted to debate the Close-Quarter and Calm Under Fire for Carmalita. When playable, her melees were short and unreliable, plus when Sly gets involved, she can fly off the handle.

Beyond that, Fox was meant more for space battles than the ground, unlike Carmalita who missions are all ground oriented.

Overall? I want to say that Fox will out muscle Carmalita, but she's seen things that Fox hasn't namely time travel. That aside, I'm siding with Carmalita.