User blog comment:So-Pro Warrior/Captain America vs Master Chief/@comment-4552610-20111207043613

I have to go with Master Chief. While ranged weapons are only a part of a good arsenal, it is a major part. The Cap's shield is deadly at a distance but he just made himself vulnerable to one of Chief's attacks. Cap's M1911 will do jack and shit but the M6G will go strait through Cap's body armor. At the end, a shield can't protect you from everything. Master Chief has the superior weapons and the superior stats. That's all he needs.
 * Typicaly, I try to avoid Halo Warriors but picking Chief was inevitable.