User blog comment:SPARTAN 119/Louis Riel vs Macario Sakay/@comment-24180428-20121109221408

You want a vote?Challenge execepted.Now you may read Utter noob's noobish edges:

Knife:Reil has this as long longer blade means more likely to kill and not be killed.

Melee:The hatchet is not as fast as the bolo is when reacting/attacking.Edge Sakey

Handgun:I like having a strong weapon but I also like having a fast weapon.Edge even

Rifles:I agree with you,they are very similar.Edge even

Repeaters:Lever action firearms are faster then bolt action if the user is used to lever action friearms.If I can shoot faster with a higher magazine I have a obvious advantage.Edge Riel

X-factors:Seemed even but tactics win the day.Edge Sakey

Winner: Riel has a better repeater and knife if it comes up close he will still have a better advantage.