User blog comment:Pygmy Hippo 2/Booker DeWitt (Bioshock Infinite) vs. B.J. Blazkowicz (Wolfenstein:The New Order)/@comment-21025171-20180814040122

Waffle's "Book End" Edges

Melee: I'll agree with S119 in that these weapons are even. The Combat Knife is as simple of a weapon as can be, being used as a projectile, stealth weapon, and can even be dual wielded. On the other hand, the Skyhook is a more versatile tool on the battlefield, allowing Booker to travel fast and efficiently while using it as a weapon. Both have their uses, but it's a draw for me and their usefulness will be based on the wits of both men.

Edge: Even

Pistol: Again, versatility plays a role again but this time in favor of BJ. His handgun has a variety of uses including being a stealth weapon, an accurate but robust pistol, or a rapid-fire machine pistol. Booker's Broadsider isn't too shabby in its own right and has a very unique round, but BJ's weapon is the more robust and modern of the two.

Edge: B.J. Blazkowicz

Automatics: The Triple-R is a dated, 9mm SMG based on a design from the mid-20th century, so however the hell Booker got one is beyond me in the late 1800's is beyond me. TBF in a few minutes