User blog comment:Alockwood1/Abraham Lincoln (Vampire Hunter Film) Versus Abraham Lincoln (Vs. Zombies)/@comment-3189283-20150816200053

Lets see shall we

Special 

Both of these weapons are roughly the same length and are both equally difficult to wield due to their length and weight. Vampire Abe wins out though because his axe contains a gun in it's handle, giving it added range and a surprise factor that Zombie Abe will not be expecting and he can also throw the axe with great accuracy, giving him even more options in combat. Vampire Abe is also stronger and more agile, allowing him to wield his axe more easily and avoid the swipes of the scythe.

Edge: Vampire Hunter Abe 

Regual Melee

Both are a simular length and perform a simular fuction but once again Vampire Abe's higher strength means he can do get more peneration behind his blows, giving him a better chance to get a killing strike.

Edge: Vampire Hunter Abe 

Single Shot Pistol 

The Flintlock Pistol is notoriously ineffective, with an incredibly long reload time and a high chance of misfire of malfunction, so much so that Flintlocks were often disgarded after one shot. The Derringer is much more reliable and easier to reload, making it more than just a single shot weapon and giving Zombie Abe more chances to get a good shot on Vampire Abe.

Edge: Zombie Hunter Abe 

Revolver 

Both of these weapons are the same in terms of effective range and shot power but what gives Vampire Abe the advantage is that his weapon can be fired in a six shot burst before having to be reloaded while Zombie Abe has to cock his pistol between every shot, which doesn't give him as high a rate of fire and the few moments spent cocking the colt could cost him dearly.

Edge: Vampire Hunter Abe 

Final Verdict 

This should be an easy win for Vampire Abe. He has the overall better weaponry and in close range he completely dominates due to his superior agility and strength, allowing him to easily overpower his zombie hunting counterpart and dodge his attacks. Vampire Abe is used to fighting Vampires which are both smarter and harder to defeat than Zombies and he will have no trouble dealing with a slower and weaker human.

Vampire Hunter Abe: 

Zombie Hunter Abe: