User blog comment:Atila the hutt/Batman vs Captain America/@comment-8012490-20130705004327

Close: Captain America and Batman both use their fists. The difference between them is that the Captain has super strength and Batman has better training in martial arts. Edge: Captain America.

Mid: The batarangs are very versitile and effective; however, they are small and don't do much damage. They are also not very useful for close-quarters combat. The shield can be thrown and can bash enemies. It also weighs a lot. Edge: Captain America.

Long Range: Although I question picking, out of what Captain America uses in the film, the binoculars as his long ranged weapon, I also say that they are better than the bolas. They will allow him to see Batman from very far away. Edge: Captain America.

Special: The gas pellets are not very lethal and Captain America's superior physical systems may cancel them out. Edge: Captain America.

Experience: Batman has fought many enemies wielding powerful weapons; however, Captain America has fought in actual war and fought foes that may have been more powerful than many foes Batman faced. Edge: Captain America.

My vote goes to Captain America.