User blog comment:Geekboy27/Big Daddies vs Jiralhanae/@comment-5795750-20121205060713

I have to say, my edge goes to the Big Daddies because of their superior weapons AND you have to take the combatants armours into account - for the Big Daddies, their armour seems harder to penetrate than that of a Brute (but then again I haven't played Bioshock so I won't know how many shots are needed to take down a Big Daddy; I do know that it takes a lot of rifle fire, plasma fire and/or several rockets to take one of the Brutes down)