User blog comment:El Alamein/Native America Battle Royale!/@comment-2228834-20120108154518

My votes is, first Incas, second Aztecs, third Apache and Sioux, last Mayas.

The reason for this is that the Incas had the superior training and actual bronze weaponry, plus they are trained for being a battle machine, and of all the natives, they are the ones that conquered the most in the shortest amount of time. The Aztecs are second, they have elite units, but that's it, they would, on the whole, not be able to beat the Incas. However, their weapons are deadlier and more advanced than the others. The Apaches will basically strike by surprise, but once the surprise is over, they will find that they have not killed every opponent and then will be overrun. Their tactics are better on a long period of time, not on a single battle. The Mayas get last place because they will try to fight individually in a collective fight. If the Romas showed us something is that an organized army will beat barbarians charging and fighting you one on one will not work. The Sioux will attack most likely when the battle is at its apex or in decline, when all the others are tired. But their technology is not enough to get them the upper hand, the Aztecs of Incas will eventually overrun them, but by then the Mayas would have been wiped out, so that's why they don't get last place.