User blog comment:JWarrior89/Judge Dredd vs Batman/@comment-2186558-20110909005213

I have to go with Judge Dredd. While Batman's possibly better in hand-to-hand combat, Judge Dredd's distance weapons are made to kill unlike Batman's (call me crazy, but I think a pistol is more likely to kill then a boomerang), and he could easily take Batman out before he got the chance to get up close.

Besides, Judge Dredd's X-Factors are much, much, better.

(By the way, I bet you at least one person while reading mistook me for the user with the similar avatar.)