User blog comment:Leolab/Siege Breakers Season, Battle 3: Guts (Berserk) vs Nightmare (Soul Calibur 3)/@comment-5078776-20131022003722

CFP3157'S EDGES OF MASSIVE DESTRUCTION: "Finally! One of these where I know a warrior!"

Weapons: Guts 

Guts' sword is much larger and seems more versatile. Soul Edge is a great weapon and Nightmare can do massive damage with it, but he lacks the versatility needed to take an edge in the arsenals.

Mobility: Nightmare 

Guts' gigantic sword comes at a price;  It's big, clunky, and heavy when compared to Soul Edge. His wide variety of gadgets serve as weapons, not tactical assistances for mobility. When Nightmare gets into his Night Terror form, he gets to fly. Not to mention, he's wielding a lighter weapon.

Strength: Nightmare 

Nightmare is a powerful demonic entity, Guts is simply a normal human being. Pretty simple edge, right?

Durability: Nightmare 

Like I mentioned above, Guts is a normal being. He's capable of mentally taking massive damage, but the human body WILL break, whether he likes it or not. Nightmare is a demon and is capable of taking a shit ton of damage, and that's before his transformation.

Options: Nightmare 

Guts has a large amount of gadgets, but they're all, at the core, attacking weapons. Guts doesn't have any tactical assistances. Meanwhile, Nightmare can transform into Night Terror, and his abilities are vastly expanded.

WINNER: Nightmare 

Honestly, this is a rather easy win for Nightmare. He's capable of dishing out and taking much more damage than Guts, and he has more options when in combat.