User blog comment:Elgb333/Iron Men Challenge: Ned Kelly vs Jim Miller/@comment-5900266-20160726042624

MoA's Edges:

Short: Colt Peacekeeper vs. Beaumont-Adams. These two are pretty even weapons. The double-action nature of the Beaumont-Adams is canceled out by the extra round and superior stopping power of the Colt Peacekeeper.

Edge: Even

Mid: Coach Gun vs. Colt Revolving Rifle. The Coach Gun is far more effective at armor penetration. However, this is not a one-on-one. In a squad battle, the Colt Revolving Rifle has superior capacity and range, making it better suited to the engagement.

Edge: Ned Kelly

Long: Winchester Rifle vs. Spencer Rifle. The Winchester destroys the Spencer. Superior capacity, easier to operate, superior stopping power. Need I say more?

Major Edge; Deacon Jim

Special: Sharps Rifle vs. "Betsy". Sorry. Ned but "Betsy" is useless. With the modifications, the carbine has less range with no benefit. An unmodified marksman rifle such as the Sharps wins over the awkward weapon "Betsy" has become.

Edge: Deacon Jim

Armor: Frock Coat Breastplate vs. Kelly Armor. The Kelly armor may have superior defense but that's where advantages end. It's heavy and restricts a lot of things such as mobility, vision and breathing. Deacon Jim's armor may have less protection but is lightweight and restricts nothing. It's a more combat-practical piece of gear.

Major Edge: Deacon Jim

Overall Winner: Deacon Jim

Ned Kelly will fall to the Deacon in this battle. In a direct comparison, one-on-one, Deacon Jim's lighter armor and less restricting armor will allow him to run circles around Ned. In a squad-on-squad perspective, the superiority of the Winchester will leave Ned's bushrangers dead in a ditch. Deacon Jim and his assassins win.