User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 3 Episode 1: Frank West vs Rick Grimes/@comment-5465602-20130324213337

BeastMan14's "Rick could take down Daryl? Lolno" Edges

Melee: A slight edge to the Machete, mainly due to that exact that it can kill a lot easier than the bat, despite its weaker reach. Edge: Rick Grimes

Revolver: The Python has a faster fire rate, and is more accurate. Edge: Rick Grimes

Handgun: The Colt wins it due to its larger clip size. Edge: Rick Grimes

Shotguns: This is pretty even, the guns aren't that much different. Edge: Even

Assault Rifle: Rick wins it mainly due to the reasons stated by Sabre. Edge: Rick Grimes

Sniper Rifle: The guns are really the same, with Rick's training being a major factor. Edge: Rick Grimes

Overall Edge: Rick Grimes, after sweeping my edges, should dispatch Frank after a tough fight. Rick would crush Frank in a straight-up clash, but the fact that the shows writers thought they should flanderise Rick's mental health issues in the comics into full-blown insanity, means Rick could fall back into a spottable pattern that Frank could take advantage of. However, Rick is ultimately more savage, better trained and better armed than Frank. Not even his war coverage can save Frank now.