User blog comment:123chaseyoung/Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson vs Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday/@comment-5043545-20140412015742

WanderingSkull's GraveDigging Tunes "Logic, Reasoning and Bullets" 

Melee: Giving this to Wyatt and Doc, due the fact that Sherlock's melee weapons lack lethality. Watson on the other hand has a cane sword as his disposal which can be effective at keep Doc and Wyatt at bay. The Bowie Knives can be thrown and the pistol whip is easy access since Wyatt will already have the weapon in his hand. Due to greater leathalty and options, Wyatt and Doc win out in melee combat. EDGE: Wyatt Earp and Doc Holiday

Sidearms: Watson may have excelled in melee combat, but his pistol isn't going to serve him well during the resulting firefight. Doc and Wyatt both excel in this category due to their gunfighting history and taking on criminals. Sherlock's sidearm doesn't fair much better because of the lack of range and accuracy. Doc has two sidearms and Wyatt's own sidearm in total have more rounds than Watson and Sherlock combined. EDGE: Wyatt Earp and Doc Holiday

Main: Another edge for the famous American duo as their effective combination of range and power give them the win. Sherlock's Pepperbox lacks range and killing power. Watson's rifle on the other hand sort of makes up for it as it has some good range and penetration power behind, but Wyatt's Winchester has more rounds as its disposal. Doc's double-barrel on the other hand has some massive killing power if the detective duo get close and will blast them apart. EDGE: Wyatt Earp and Doc Holiday

Deadliest Warrior: Wyatt Earp and Doc Holiday- If you've seen my edges then you could basically tell who I was going to give the win too. As Bulls put it, if Sherlock and Watson had some prep time then the outcome of the match could've changed, but that simply isn't the case here. Doc and Wyatt are both packing some serious firepower and experience in extended gunfights. They are ultimately more street-smart and brutal in their approach rather than Watson and Sherlock's methods. Both are also experienced in the quick-drawing thus allowing for Doc and Wyatt to get some shots in early.