User blog comment:LB&SCR/GWM Episode 3: Alvin York vs. Anibal Milhais/@comment-35680048-20180814163023

Tybaltcapulet's "F*ck  the rules of war I'll kill them all" Edges:

Rifle: The SMLE has more ammo and is slightly lighter. The M1917 may have a longer range but it isn't so much that the SMLE is totally outclassed in that area as well. Anibal will be able to fire twice as many bullets and it will overall be more effective in this battle.Edge:Milhais

LMG: The Lewis gun is heavier but has more rounds and the BAR is the opposite of this.At the end of the day i'm going to give it to the Lewis gun for it's longer continuous fire and it has a much better range compared to the BAR. 3500yds vs 1500? That's not even close in my book.Edge:Milhais

Sidearm: This is even in my opinion. While the Savage Model 1907 has 3 more bullets and is lighter the Colt has better stopping power and range. Overall this is dead even in my opinion. Edge:Even

Overall: I'm going to give the victory to the lesser known '''Anibal Milhais. '''His rifle while having a smaller range, has a much larger capacity and can hold back York for a longer time than vice versa. His Lewis Gun is the same story but not only has more rounds but a much better range and may be heavier and may shoot quicker but this will at least in my opinion work to Anibal's advantage(at least the RPM). WIth a slower fire rate, recoil is less of and issue and Milhais isn't wasting as many bullets as the BAR. The BAR already has a low capacity and will deal with the higher rate by having to reload way more often and will harder to control. And their sidearms are just about even for me, with the Model 1907 taking weight and capacity, and the M1911 taking power and range. And the most important part of this is the fact that York's famous battle is not nearly as impressive as Milhais's.

Capturing 132 German prisoners with 7 privates and yourself is impressive but it's not killing two entire German regiments by yourself impressive. Killing 6 Germans with your pistol is nothing in my opinion compared to Milhais's ability to singlehandedly keep the enemy back and making it so that none of your retreating men die. And he also did this for three whole days? Yeah York can't even touch that.

Anibal Milhais:3500

Alvin York:1500