User blog comment:Tomahawk23/John Marston VS Cole Phelps/@comment-3166030-20110803012251

Marston shouldn't have explosives, if Cole does not. The High Powered Pistol is the Colt M1903, and it does not stand to the .45 ACP of the S&W M1917. Edge: Cole

The Browning Auto-5 is Semi-Automatic, however the Thompson has a superior fire rate. (I'd figure that Marston would pack the Mauser at Mid-Range as well), but with the fire rate: Edge: Cole

Long Range: The BAR has an effective range of 1,500 meters.... that's overkill. Edge: Cole

Special Weapons: The Knife and Tomahawk have more kill potential than the Baton. Edge: John Marston

While John is a more disciplined shot, the overwhelming firepower that Cole will bring will carry the day.