User blog comment:So-Pro Warrior/Lucas McCain vs John Marston/@comment-4255975-20111217224732

Edges

Close Range- The Single Action Army is more accurate and has a faster reload time. Edge- Lucas McCain

Mid Range- Very similar weapons. But I vote for the 12 gauge shotgun for it having a larger blast radius. Edge- Lucas McCain

Long Range- Look at the DW test. Edge- Lucas McCain

X-Factors- Marston is high in all categories and the quickdraw wins it in old west battles. Edge- John Marston.

WINNER- Lucas McCain. Smarter, better weapons and calmer under fire.