User blog comment:WanderingSkull/The Road Less Traveled: Doomguy vs. Master Chief/@comment-25221333-20140726154354

Melee- At a glance the chainsaw would appear to be the superior weapon because its a giant cutting machine but it has its problems. Unless this is some special chainsaw, it could only be effective if it was held against chief for a long time. Even then it would slip because of the shields which in the books made it difficult for a Spartan to even walk but I'll keep to the video games. It would take a long time to get to the flesh unless Doom Guy was to go for the visor however if bare flesh is exposed the chainsaw would take this. Its weight would also be a problem when faced against a knife, Doomguy really has to make a good strike in order to stop Chief (who has very fast reactions. Edge-Even

Pistol-While Doom Guy has the advantage of less recoil and a higher rate of fire with a 9mm pistol, with Chiefs armour it would have only a small effect. All it could do is annoy Chief or maybe if it hit is visor enough, to blind him. The Magnum on the other hand is much more powerful. No matter where it hits it is bound to hurt Doom Guy. It may not kill him but it would be more effective than a 9mm with its explosive and armour piercing properties. Edge-Master Chief.

Shotgun-Its difficult to say as even on the Doom wiki there is not much information that marks it as any better or worse than Chiefs shotgun (Bullet Type, Range, Stopping Power) I would probably give it to Chief but its hard to distinguish the effectiveness of one shotgun to another unless one is more prone to jamming or has a weaker punch. I'll give Doom Guy the benefit of the doubt and call it even. Edge-Even.

Automatic-A little more information on this which is good. Playing Halo I know that the MA5B is considered a good gun in its universe but I don't know how effective it is compared to a gatling gun. Chiefs armour is strong but I don't think it could withstand a barage of 9mm bullets. while Doom Guy may not have as good armour, he could keep Chief suppressed pretty easily. Weapon for weapon I'd give it to Doom. Edge-Doom Guy.

Uberweapon-This is a case of strength vs speed. The BFG's advantage is that it has a steady stream of lasers while the SPARTAN has one massive laser attack. The BFG would be very effective at draining Chief's shield and armour to expose his defenses while the Spartan laser could only be effective if Doom was in a large vehicle where he would be an easy target.Edge-Doom Guy

Explosives-Its difficult to judge rockets when it is a one on one battle. In large numbers they would have a better effect so my choice is obvious. Chief's doubl barrels will make it easier for him to hit a single target because he has two chances while Doom only has one. While Doom's launcher might be more powerful, I doubt that it would compare to Chief's rapid fire. Edge-Master Chief.

Edges-The weapons are at a draw of 2-2. WQhat really sets the two apart though is there stats. I mean Doom Guy is stronger, faster and more brutal while Master Chief only has an advantage in training and experience. When added up it is 455-440 in Dooms favour. While close, it is not enough to beat Doom in a single battle. Out of the two of them Chief is by far my favourite so it shame me to say....

Winner-Doom Guy