User blog comment:Leolab/User Siege Tourney, Round 38 of 54: Beastman14 (Ryan) v Goddess of Despair (Celina)/@comment-4661256-20140116232119

El Alamein's "Catapaults, Battering Rams.. and ... whatever the hell the original title for these battle votes were" Edges:

Attacker:
 Overrun:  Ryan's army is poorly equipped and even more poorly armored... and his entire strategy is a balls-out charge in a straight line. That takes guts... but it won't win any battles.

Edge: Celina Lucyna

 Force Surrender:  Mental warfare doesn't work too well when the enemy team isn't intimidated because your army is a ramshackle compliation of random people with pointy sticks. There's no reason here for Celina to surrender... and she won't.

Edge: Celina Lucyna

Defender:
 Force Surrender:  I mean yeah, Celina's army is better off than Ryan's, but that's only because they're the ones camping inside their castle. I'm pretty sure Ryan's army isn't going to really have the chance anyway, as Leo has already pointed out, since they're kind of running in a straight line directly at it.

Edge: Ryan the Dreaded (I guess...?)

Edge: No One

 Edge: NOT THIS WIKI 

 Annihilate Attacker:  I guess. Although this isn't really a testament to Celina's skill, rather than a testament to Ryan's stupidity.

Edge: Celina Lucyna

 Survive for Four Months:  Assuming that Ryan's army lasts that long... yeah.

Edge: Celina Lucyna

WINNER: CELINA LUCYNA

I mean, both sides are pretty poorly set up here, but Celina has a defensive advantage and that's pretty much the only factor tipping this in her favor. Ryan's "charge-in-a-straight-line tactic" has pretty much cost him every viable edge, so it's no wonder that he's gonna lose this battle. But as I mentioned above, this is more of a testament to Ryan's lack of skill as a general than Celina's skill.