User blog comment:Postapocfan1999/Season 1 Ep 3 Rick Grimes vs Max Rockatansky/@comment-13937974-20130802102522

Revolvers-Model 29 vs Colt Phython. While both are incredibly effective weapons, I would give it to the Model 29 as it packs a bit more off a punch because of the longer barrel.

Edge-Model 29

Semi-auto-The Glock is possibly the greatest pistol ever made.The hammer of the gun is not exposed and each shot is double action so when in action, where it is incredibly stressful, you can still fire off rounds comfortably despite the decrease in motor skills.

Edge-Glock

Close Range-While the sawed off double barrelled shotgun can get 2 rounds of very quickly, it would have to be reloaded very often. The Mossberg has twice the ammo capacity and the same rounds. The range of the Mossberg would also be higher than that of the double barrelled and easier to control because of the stock.

Edge-Mossberg 500.

Long Range-The M4 is one of the best known riles today. While the m1 carbine would be more accurate because of the long barrel. The M4 as more ammo and using bursts, it would keep Max pinned behind cover. Although the full auto would cause Rick to waste bullets quicker.

Edge-M4

X-Factors, you have already decided them yourself...

Winner-While Max is a more capable fighter, Rick would win mostly because of his better weapons. Winner-Rick.