User blog comment:MilenHD/Celt vs Comanche/@comment-3189283-20170107184143

Let's see shall we

Close Range 

Obviously the Longsword. While both are the same length the Longsword has a larger lethal surface area as the War Hawk is limited to the relatively small spike at the tip. I'd also imagine a sword would be easier to use on a chariot than a War Hawk would be on horseback.

Edge: Celt

Mid Range

The Lancea's much longer shaft makes it the better weapon on during the initial part of the battle and if I remember correctly can even be thrown to give it greater versatility. However once the battle switches to infantry I actually think the shorter War Lance will have the advantage as the length is more managable and easier to use.

Edge: Even

Long Range

I'm not even going to dignify this with a detailed comparison.

Edge: Comanche 

TBC