User blog comment:Jackythejack/Island Residence: Purna Jackson vs. Sheva Alomar/@comment-17814994-20181226082405

Elgb's "Undead Grils" EDGES!!!

Melee: Interesting comparison. There's no doubt that the stun baton is the tool specifically made to eba weapon. It can cause blunt force trauma and can even stun enemies. The torch though... I'm not so sure. Incendiary melee weapons did exist (like the flaming pole used by the Knights of St. John during the Siege of Malta), but an actual torch? It's good against animals, and deadly for brain dead zombies, but its success against a fast moving highly trained warrior? I'm not saying its not deadly or lethal, but the stun button looks like the more ergonomic and effecient weapon here. EDGE: Sheva

Pistol: Giving it to semi-automatic here. A magnum pistol has its worths in a zombie apocalypse, and many would agree its the best thing to have for self-defense in a post-apocalyptic zero resources type of world. But in a battle such as this, having more bullets, a faster reload, and faster rate of fire is better. A large caliber won't do much if there's no body armor in this battle and your enemy has thrice the magazine count. EDGE; Sheva

Shotgun: The Mossberg has one more round in its tube but that's just about it when it comes to its advantages (besdies being a great weapon in tight places). The M3 Benelli has the slightly longer range, a shoulder stock and a pistol grip for better handling. Also, having a wider choke actually makes your gun more accurate up close since its got a larger range of target (though its range and accuracy drops at longer ranges). EDGE: Sheva

Rifles: If this takes place in a jungle or a savannah, the AK-47's reliability might give it an edge. But since it takes place in a city, the latter falls beneath other rifles. The Sig 556 packs the longer range, the (somewhat) larger magazine here and a highter rate of fire. Admitedly, the AK has the more lethal round but the NATO can still kill a person nonetheless. EDGE: Sheva

Special: Special edge goes to the Deo Bomb. I mean look at it, its both a fragmentation AND incendiary grenade (awesome). EDGE: Purna

Deadliest Fiction?

I have to give this one to Sheva hands down. Purna is probably the better tactician since Sheva msotly relies on Chris in many adventures, and the former does have the homefield advantage. But having homefield advantage won't get you that far if you have vastly inferior weapons (jsut as the Imperial Japanese when the US marines came a knocking).

Its crude logic really, that a girl with specialized military training with military hardware will defeat a policewoman with a set of civilian weapons.