User blog comment:Appelmonkey/Undertale vs. Puella Magi Madoka Magica Mini Series, Episode 1/Sans vs. Homura Akemi/@comment-4661256-20160729210023

El Alamein's "I Have No Idea What's Going on with Either Warrior" Edges:

 Offensive:  In my opinion this is a clear advantage for Homura Akemi. Sans' attacks might be magically enhanced, but they're slower and follow exploitable patterns, neither of which contribute to an effective fighting style. The bones and ghaster blasters will certainly provide some sort of magical shock-and-awe, but these pale in comparison to Homura Akemi's overwhelming loadout of firearms. The guns have faster rates of fire, and they're being used by a warrior with better combat experience and a higher killer instinct, which will both work to hone her skills with these firearms. Sans' attacks are predictable since they follow a pattern and his lower combat experience and killer instinct will compound to make him lose out in this category.

Edge: Homura Akemi

 Defensive:  I think that Sans might have an advantage here. His superhuman reflexes and teleporting skills will help him significantly in avoiding Homura Akemi's attacks (which he will need to employ when going up against bullets). With high attention to detail, he could probably do something like figure out when her magazine is about to run dry or something like that to exploit a weakness in her fighting style. The shield that Homura Akemi carries around is nice (I'm not sure if it's magically enhanced in terms of defensive capabilities) but its primary use seems to be storage and transportation rather than defense. The fact that she doesn't feel pain is a detriment in my opinion because if a body is seriously injured, continuing to fight or push past the limits that pain usually present will only damage the body further. Sans has a better defensive game as a result--avoiding an attack is better than just trying to shrug it off.

Edge: Sans

 Weaknesses:  Uh, yeah, so I'm not really sure if I'm misinterpreting this or not, but Sans loses hard in this category. A paltry 1 HP and 1 defense means that any type of serious attack will kill him instantly. The end. Game over. He will really have to be on the defensive this whole time if he hopes to win, and being on the defensive in a fight is usually the more compromising position. Since Homura Akemi carries the gem around with her, it's not like it can really be separated from her, and I'm not really sure what turning her into a witch would do, but it probably wouldn't affect her combat abilities. Overall, Sans' incredible crippling and debilitating weakness will be his undoing.

Edge: Homura Akemi

 X-Factors:  Homura Akemi wins again. Combat experience and killer instinct are highly important in a fight where reflexes and conditioning will be everything. This will be a high-stakes, high-intensity fight, and the disadvantages Sans has here will only make things harder for him in the long run.

Edge: Homura Akemi

WINNER: HOMURA AKEMI

I can't believe that I'm actually voting for an anime character, but... well, here we are. Sans is incredibly reliant on his defensive game, and while it's nice that he did get an edge there, he loses out everywhere else. Homura Akemi simply has the arsenal to wear out Sans, especially when it only takes one good hit to kill him. He can dodge 99% of her attacks and still ultimately lose the fight. Homura Akemi's higher combat experience and killer instinct are also incredibly important X-Factors which will enhance her prowess on the battlefield, whereas Sans' good-naturedness and comparatively lower combat experience will leave him woefully unprepared to take on an opponent of this caliber. Bones, magic, and teleportation are all nice abilities to have, but it doesn't matter when all it takes is one shot to end you.