User blog comment:Postapocfan1999/Joel (The Last of Us) vs Bill (Left 4 dead 1)/@comment-10190509-20130714035455

Sergei's Badass Zombie slaughter-ers edges and vote!

Pistol: I give this to Joel because his pistol is a .357 magnum revolver while bill's is a .45. The major difference in my opinion is that the .357 has been known to blow entire limbs off in a single shot, and is easily fatal with a single chest hit. EDGE: Joel.

Shotgun: Bill get's this one due to the beneli M4 shotgun is semi automatic and has a bigger mag against the mossberg. EDGEL Bill.

Mid Range: I'm giving this to Bill because the full size M16 has a better range over the M4a1, other than that, they are pretty equal. EDGE: Bill.

Long Range: This is a very close call because both rifles use the same caliber. The Winchester would be better at longest range due to it's better accuracy, but the ruger 14 allowes faster fire rate. EDGE: EVEN.

Melee: i'm giving this even since both are improvised melee weaponry and are not going to be lethal in one hit. EDGE: even.

Explosive: both weapons are improvised, but Joel's nail bomb can be used as a trap and a grenade, where Bill's is just a improvised grenade. In addition, Bill's pipe bomb has a long timer and beeps, allowing Joel time to move before it goes off. EDGE: Joel.

Special: Bills grenade launcher causes a massive explosion that WILL be fatal to the user if used in close range. Joel's flamethrower can be equally dangerous, but can be used at closer range than the grenade launcher. EDGE: even.

X Factors: Joel wins this one because he has better physical fitness and survival skills, and bill only beats joel in a single X - factor. EDGE: Joel

overall winner: joel, in my opinion, he has better equipment and skill to fight this through, in addition to being able to set up traps that may kill or at least slow down Bill.