User blog comment:Battlefan237/Tony Montana vs, The Penguin ( comics)/@comment-27334870-20170906202847

Dargoo Faust's [REDACTED] Edges: "I hope you brought an umbrella..."

Killing Devices

Blade - The Penguin

While the Penguin's weapon is much less conventional and probably pretty clunky, it has two advantages that make up for its shortcomings. One, clearly, is range - the umbrella in a 1v1 melee battle will just give the Penguin more reach. Two is that the fact that the Penguin's dagger is in his umbrella (where he stores many of his other weapons) gives him an edge in versatility, since swtiching between weapons will be far quicker.

Handgun - Tie

More ammo 9/10 times makes a pistol better going off of my previous votes, but the inferior stopping power of the Beretta will really hurt the gun, especially since the Penguin actually has bullet-proof armoring in the form of his umbrella. If the Penguin didn't have acess to his umbrella I'd just throw this to Tony, but the ammunition really makes it hard for me to go all in for him. Therefore I'll leave it at a tie; Tony will get more use out of his gun, but the Penguin will subsequently get better use out of his gun.

TBC