User blog comment:Lasifer/Welcome to Rapture: Booker DeWitt vs. Jack Ryan/@comment-5232784-20140210001931

Okay woodcampers, its DEADLIEST FICTION DAY

1. WEAPONS

a. Melee

A pipe is a good bludgeoning weapon, and good for a poke to the gut. But it looks like a Mattel toy compared to a three bladed rotating hook, which looks like something Pinhead in hellraiser would use for dental work.

EDGE: Booker DeWitt

b. Handgun Booker's Boradsider has 18 rounds and fires rapidly, while Ryan's revolver has only six rounds and fires more slowly. Not to mention that the former is a more advanced weapon technologically. Any questions?

EDGE: Booker DeWitt

c. Shotgun

Both shotguns house four rounds, though the Spencer has slugs instead of regular shells, so we wont have a bunch of shot spread over a wide range when the Spencer goes off, but a more directed hit. Still lethal, but I'd rather have a guy peppered with shot than a guy with one bullet in his belly. Slugs are just not as devastating, nor do they spread death and misery over a broad area (either opponent might inevitably get a bunch of allies on their side for this fight). Still, the Spencer has a more rapid rate of fire. I give this the draw.

EDGE: Dead Even

4. submachine guns The Thompson and the Triple R are both rapid firing weapons, but the Thompson has five extra bullets...

EDGE: Jack Ryan

5. long range

While the Springfield is a more advanced technological weapon, the Crossbow has an extra projectile, can fire incendiary bolts, and can fire more rapidly. Unless I get evidence that the gun has better range and or better accuracy, I have to go with Ryan

EDGE: Jack Ryan

6. Special weapons The barnstormer has two rounds and a low rate of fire: the grenade launcher has six rounds and a faster rate of fire. Any questions?

EDGE: Jack Ryan

B. Magic

More to Come...