User blog comment:ReyesRebels/Saracen vs. Visigoth/@comment-3018037-20111118041901

Alright, I'll give my edges, but won't vote.

Close: The Hairus is fearsome and when stabbing, has a very large chance of penetration. The Saif is a scimitar, Much sharper than the Hairus and a better weapon, but the Lorica hamata will restrict and major damage. It's a tough call but: EDGE: VISIGOTH

Mid: An 8 foot spear vs. a 6 foot one? EDGE: SARACEN

Long: Bow vs. Sling. Classic. EDGE: SARACEN

ARMOR: the Visigoth is wearing lorica hamata, which will protect against the main weapon of the Saracen, The saif and will restrict and spear (You can do this) slashes. Lamellar is not too good against stabbing weapons, which the Visigoth carries. And The visigoth has a helmet. EDGE: VISIGOTH

Skills: You don't need calvary to do the fire and pelt. even though you need more time to do it. I give my close edge to the Saracen.

Who wins? Your opinion.