User blog comment:Leolab/User Siege Tourney, Round 11 of 91: Cfp (Tian/Christian) v MoA (Master)/@comment-5465602-20130525025153

BeastMan14's "Honor the fallen? Nah" edges

Attacker Conditions:

Overrun the castle: Highly likely. Cfp's much more intricate attack plan pretty overwhelms Moa's tactic of "Last stand", which means he might deal some casualties, but going last stand does not equal victory by attrition instantly.

Force Defender to Surrender: Highly likely. Cfp's tactics means he could forgo the offensive against the last stand entirely and just bombard them into surrender. MoA's low troop loyalty doesn't help.

Win Single Combat: Maybe. I'll get to those edges later.

Defender Conditions:

Force Attacker to surrender: Not likely. Cfp would have to be an idiot to surrender with such a clear advantage over MoA's disorganized, disloyal mess.

Annihilate Attacker: Slim Possibility. MoA and his men could fight off any attacks by Cfp LNG enough for his forces to wear down, but the odds of Cfp attacking in such a manner that they could be beaten back without heavy casualties is unlikely.

Survive for 4 Months: No chance. Cfp won't wait out MoA that long, and MoA certainly won't be able to hold against seize warfare and constant attacks by a superior general.

Win Single Combat: Maybe. But I'll get to those edges later.

Tie Conditions:

One side meets the victory conditions but loses general: Very very slim possibility. Maybe MoA could get a lucky shot in before Cfp finishes off his men, but I doubt it. And MoA doesn't have much chance of meeting the conditions.

Both Sides lose general: No. See above.

Single Combat:

Main: Cfp's attack/defense combo trumps a simple offense/offense attack, considering the mace is heavy and slow, while the Ild want scratch the shield. Edge: Kenway

Polearm: The Xyston has more range and power over the Jida. Edge: Kenway

Armor: Kenway has a much more detailed armor weaponry, which clearly covers his entire body. Besides, a lamellar is just a thin plate. Which can't guarantee protection. Edge: Kenway

Winner of single combat: Kenway.

Deadliest Warrior: Kenway is going to annihilate Master. He brings in a much more loyal army, better intelligence, and superior weaponry. I see him winning in a matter of days with few casualties.