User blog comment:El Alamein/Annie Wilkes vs. Jack Torrance/@comment--20150630053734

Anon's "Here's Johnny!" Edges:

Primary:

As much as I love Sledgehammers, I say the fire axe is more lethal. Sure one swing from the hammer could kill a man. But, if you miss you'll be left right open. While the axe is simpler to wield and far deadlier in my opinion.

EDGE: Jack Torrance

Secondary:

Its like Inyankapemni VS Knife all over again. The mallet is devious for sure but I can only see it killing someone if hitting them in the head and not even that is enough to suade me. While the knife is more spread out through fiction. You can slash with it and stab wilth it.

EDGE: Annie Wilkes

Special:

Ghosts over double-barrel shotgun on anyday of the week. That gun wont protect you from the dangers hidden inside the Overlook Hotel. I can see Wilkes shooting Torrance with it but completely missing as she is being taunted and harmed by the ghosts. A unique concept for sure.

EDGE: Jack Torrance

X-Factors:

All I needed to see was experience. Wilkes and Torrance are farely evened out in the majority of factors, aside from experience. So therefore I have to give to Wilkes only slightly.

EDGE: Annie Wilkes

Summary:

Erg! This is a tough one. I want to say Jack Torrance would win, but, I think that is just me being biases. Because I can't really think of any reasons why he would win. Perhaps the ghosts. However I see WIlkes experience as a hard hitting factor in this fight combined with her being just a littlle bit saner. So here it goes if it comes down to a knife and Croquet mallet fight I say WIlkes all the way. But if comes down to a who can withstand more damage I say Torrance. But for the purposes of this fight I general I say Wilkes is gonna win. Very difficult decision though.

Overall Winner: Annie Wilkes