User blog comment:MilitaryBrat/Batman (Nolanverse) vs Red Skull (MCU)/@comment-4803039-20130629010039

Affectos's Emotions, "When Movies Collide"

Close: This is where the training x-factor kicks in. While the blades may not be as versatile as the SS Knife, Batman's increased Hand-to-Hand combat training easily makes up for it. Edge: Batman

Mid: Again, we see that experience X-Factor. Batman is used to having guns shot at him, but unlike Cap's shield, the Baterangs are silent and hard to see at high speed when flung at you. Edge: Batman

Long: Pulling the infamous Star Wars question in, "Who shoots first?" Red Skull gets a HUGE advantage here if he gets his shot off first, since I doubt that even Batman could predict that kind of a weapon coming at him. Meanwhile, if Batman shoots first, there is the chance that he can disable the Death Ray, but this chance is much smaller than with Red Skull. Edge: Red Skull

Special: While Batman's experience and Batsuit have him covered for the MP 40, the explosives are going to deal more damage to Bats than to Red Skull. While Red Skull may only be stunned, Batman can actually take damage from the others. Edge: Red Skull

Other: I've gotta take Mobility here. It's not easy to hit a moving target, especially if he's good at manuvering the vehical and grapple hook. Also, I'm not seeing the enhanced strength do that much for Red Skull, Batman fought Bane, and I think he's stronger than Red Skull in that film...Edge: Batman

Overall, Batman takes the cake here. He has had experience fighting foes with greater physicality than him (Bane) as well as having to face explosives (Joker) before. The only thing that should put him off his game is only at long range and special weapons, but those have never really been Bat's strong suit before...