User blog comment:Kazanshin/"But why? Why would you do that?" Gungan vs Tusken Raider/@comment-422690-20191216152225

So...

Primary: The Tusken Cycler gets this pretty easily. The Raiders can simply shoot all twenty Gungans while the idiots flail ineffectually with their knockoff Ewok primitive weaponry. Further, as the Gungan's plasma shielding seems to be ineffective against things with mass, the Cycler can most likely rip through their shitty protection like nothing.

Secondary: The Blaster Pistol takes this pretty easily again. Sure, they have similar range, but what's equally important in these sorts of fights is reliability. The Gungans rely heavily on their physical abilities, and because their skeletons are cartilaginous that's going to wane very quickly simply by being out of the water. Basically, the Atlatl's performance will get notably worse as the battle goes on, but the blaster will (likely) perform exactly the same.

Melee: Gaffi Stick wins. As mentioned above, all of the Gungan's weapons require heavy physical exertion. By the time the Raiders even get into melee range, the Gungans will have tired, and most likely have been demoralized by being mostly dead. The Gaffi Stick will simply see more effective use, because the Raiders are not already tiring themselves out.

Gonna skip X-Factors, because they're not really worth mentioning. There's a reason the Gungan slaughter mission in the OG Batttlefront 2 was so easy.

Overall: Tusken Raiders win this quite handily. The Gungans are simply awful warriors with awful weapons and should not fucking exist in the first place. They will get utterly annihilated, with the Raiders taking few if any losses.