User blog comment:Killermoves/Billy the Kid vs Henry Lightfoot/@comment-27043000-20191025094907

Pygmy Hippo's "Will Walker's Fight Be Finished?" Edges

Melee:The Bowie Knife is the much more practical weapon that can kill easier and is actually designed for combat but the Improvised Clothing has sheer variety and surprise on its side. Still I can't see any of the Clothing being as effective as the Knife which could potentially be thrown. Edge:Billy

Short:The Webley RIC has the deadlier round and can fire more quickly while the Colt Peacemaker has a faster muzzle velocity and longer range. Both have the same capacity so it comes down to what advantages are better, at close range a quicker gun with arguably equal killing potential is better. Edge:Henry

Mid:The Coach Gun is probably the more reliable weapon in that it's not a sawed-off rifle and a shotgun which should mean less recoil and it has equal firepower. The Howdah Pistol is an interesting concept but in practice seems like a massive pain. Edge:Billy

Long:The Lee Metford Carbine has the deadlier round, faster muzzle velocity, longer range, and better firing system while the Winchester Model 1873 has more ammo in its magazine. The Lee has enough advantages to completely dominate the Winchester in this comparison despite less ammo. Edge:Henry

X-Factors:Billy the Kid takes Experience and Intelligence and Leadership while Henry Lightfoot takes Training and Brutality.Experience is usually better than Training in combat and Brutality is worthless in a fight between two murderous outlaws while better Leadership helps out a lot in a squad battle. Edge:Billy

Final Verdict:These two matched each other blow-for-blow but while Billy the Kid's weapon edges are arguably worse than his foe's, his superior X-Factors turn this fight in his favor. Henry Lightfoot's revolver and rifle are the two biggest equipment advantages in this match but his other weapons are improvised and impractical along with being the less experienced fighter despite his military training. Billy's going to have a hard time dealing with the good parts of Henry's arsenal but he's got the skills to win this gunfight anyway.

Winner:Billy the Kid

P.S.:Want to do a vote trade on my DBD Killers vs. HOD Hunters?