User blog comment:Lasifer/No Hope for Mother Earth: The Reapers vs. Giygas (Collab w/ Beast)/@comment-5795750-20131229032232

BG1's "Mother Earth here is not a bitch" Edges:

The Supreme Commander/Leader Unit: As far as I see, this is a match-up between a universal god-like creature and a wannabe god and for me, I have to give this to Giygas - sure he might not be as smart or as experienced as Sovereign but this setback is reconciled by two things: 1) Giygas's raw strength and abilities that allow him to attack multiple foes left right and centre (plus the Devil Machine which can send the Hades Cannon right back at Sovereign - lets see the latter defend himself against his own weapon); and 2) his Apple of Enlightenment should effectively cancel out Sovereign's edge in tactics, intelligence and experience (since Sovereign is unlikely to have faced a psychic enemy before)

EDGE: Giygas

The Second-in-Command/General Unit: Porky's abilities might be able to damage a lot of the Geth units but against Saren, he is going to have a hard time, especially considering that with the Hoverboard he can move a lot faster than Porky thus dodge some of his lethal moves and the biotics/tech he harbours can tear Porky apart whilst Porky is defenseless to counter such manoeuvres

EDGE: Reapers

The Main Fighting Force/Army Units: There's always one thing to remember when crafting an army - can your own units survive their own weapons? In this case I would have to say that if the Starmen can follow-up their power reflections with their own PSI firepower then there may be a chance that the Geth will eventually be defeated and their armour shattered; combine that with the fact that the Starmen can apparently have healing factors and can revive their team-mates and you have an almost unstoppable force that the Reapers can just about but not quite compete with

EDGE: Giygas

Expendable Units: Mushrooms vs Zombies... this seems laughable at first but when you consider that the shrooms can conjure up fire and ice and can heal and have shields then the advantage the Husks have in numbers diminishes although I will concur with others in saying that the attacks the Shrooms have against normal Mother in-universe people that have PSI don't work here against Husks who don't use such things so the shield might be useless at best; I will actually have to call this a tie since the shields and healing stuff should cancel out the firepower the Husks have and the fact that the Mushrooms can disorient attackers seemingly diminishes (but not by a lot) the advantage the Husks have in humbers

EDGE: Even

Overall Winner: Even if Porky is down, Giygas should be able to take command of his Starmen and Mushrooms without any difficulty and given his level of power, he alone can wipe out most of the expendable units and general army units; as you can gather by that, I'm going against the tide and saying that Giygas and his troops should be able to overcome the massive firepower and such stuff that Sovereign, Saren, the Husks and the Geth should throw at them; they might have an advantage in the early stages of combat but after a while, Giygas's troops should be able to get the upper hand thanks to their balanced offensive and defensive capabilities