User blog comment:Cfp3157/The Light of Apocalypse's Dawn: Woodbury Army vs. Fireflies/@comment-26150944-20150214030442

TheWetWaffle's "Light My Fire" Edges

Bladed Melee: Considering the dangers of bladed weapons in this fight and the lack of first aid a larger blade may seem like a benefit to have. However, considering that the machete here is in the hands of some generic Firefly goon who probably doesn't have the strength of The Governor a smaller blade isn't much of a setback. With the Governor's dominating strength he'll be a force to be wrecken with.

Edge: The Woodbury Army

Secondary Melee: Although it is shorter the Hatchet is arguably the more efficent weapon due to it being lighter but albeit shorter and the metal head causing more damage than the Bat's blunt end. The Bat may be able to break the Hatchet but I don't see this as much of an issue when the Bat wielder has his hands cut off.

Edge: The Fireflies

Pistol: This is essentially the classic M1911 vs. Beretta 92 argument I've learned to embrace and the outcome is typically the same with the Beretta getting the edge. The Beretta has more ammo which is better in a prolonged firefight where reloading may be dangerous. Even then the .45 of any other 1911 isn't here so that benefit is thrown out the door meaning it's a wash for the Beretta.

Edge: The Woodbury Army

TBF