User blog comment:Leolab/Siege Tourney Pre-Game: X-Factors/@comment-422690-20130210214150

Time for me to weigh in, along with the chosen icons. Scale is as follows:

0: None 25: poor 50: Average 75: Good 100: Perfect. Ratings will be a little lower.

So...

Lloyd

Icon:

Mental Health: 80. Lloyd would have a very good mental health, since he is not only trained, he hasn't had a good deal of trauma.

Loyalty: 65. While his troops won't desert, since he does not switch sides, he is still a mercenary. Troops have a large distrust of mercs. His reputation will mitigate that by a lot, but that brings it from below average to above average.

Intelligence: 80. He's been trained to be a thinker.

James Evans

Icon:

Mental Health: 45. Witnessing your parent's death is... not good. At all. Plus, from the bio he seems to be untested. He's not going to be able to hold up in a battle too well.

Loyalty: 45. He's young, untested, and bent on revenge. Not a good sign for the troops.

Intelligence: 75. He's been trained by multiple cultures, as well as his uncle. He seems to be smart enough to put this into practice.

Tian Shang/Christian Kenway

Icon:

Mental Health: 75. Has had the experience of being in war and working as an assassin. This helps harden him to war.

Loyalty: 45. He's a merc. Soldiers distrust mercs. He will have had a reputation, so that will keep people with him. However, he will need to re-bond with the troops each time he fights.

Intelligence: 80. He is smart enough to use naming to his advantage, and is also intelligent enough to have put his experience into practice as a general.

Ryan the Dreaded

Icon:

Mental Health: 75. No reason to think otherwise.

Loyalty: 35. This is where Beast falls apart. His troops aren't going to be all that loyal to him when they know he will sacrifice them at whim.

Intelligence: 72. He seems competent enough.

Markus Thaowan

Icon:

Mental Health: 80. He's been raised to lead, which gives him a nice sense of stability commanding. He has nothing else wrong with him, so 80 it is.

Loyalty: 90. He grew up alongside his troops. That's impressive loyalty for ya.

Intelligence: 80. He's quite solid there.

Cadwalader Owain Jones

Icon:

Mental Health: 80. Trained for war, so he has a good stable mindset.

Loyalty: 90: Having served with your general is an excellent ground for loyalty.

Intelligence: 79. He's an incredibly solid general. However, what could possibly be blind patriotism slightly lowers it.

Austonio Machete Michelangelo Rasputin Elder III

Icon:

Mental Health: 2. Shit's crazy, bro.

Loyalty: 25. Shit's crazy, bro.

Intelligence: 40. Shit's crazy, but not stupid, bro.

Celina Lucyna

Icon:

Mental Health: 40. Having your hometown razed can do awful things to a mind, even as an adult.

Loyalty: 45. Being revealed as a girl would be shit for loyalty. A lot of the soldiers would be wondering what else she was hiding.

Intelligence: 80. After all, she was able to disguise herself well enough for her gender to be obscured after a rise to power.

Yao Long

Image:

Mental Health: 50. He was a monk. No matter how good a combatant he is, he hasn't faced actual war. He's getting an average score here because he's got the mindset of an average person.

Loyalty: 50. Same as to any general.

Intelligence: 50. Again, average.

"Master"

Image:

Mental Health: 50. No info.

Loyalty: 5. As Code Geass shows us, troops are quick to desert if they don't know your name or anything about you.

Intelligence: 53. Boosted 3 point for an incredibly rudimentary grasp of propaganda.