User blog comment:GSFB/Harley Quinn (DC comics, no firearms) vs Goliath (Christianity)/@comment-4661256-20160519021706

El Alamein's Edges:

 Close Range: Wooden Mallet vs. Sickle Sword:  All right, so for the first weapon comparison, I think it's pretty safe to say that there's no contest. Material-wise, we've got wood aganist bronze, so obviously Goliath's weapon is more durable. I do think that this is slightly less relevant that usual, simply because Harley Quinn's weapon is a blunt trauma weapon rather than a slicing/stabbing weapon (so she doesn't need a sharp edge to do damage, and wood can inflict significant trauma if it's the right type) -- however, it's still made up of the inferior material. Not only that, but Goliath has bronze armor, which can and probably will absorb a lot of the energy inflicted from Harley's attacks with the mallet. On the other hand, Harley has no armor at all, so a giant sword will do exactly what it's designed to do if it hits her. Yeah, she's agile and can probably avoid some swings from Goliath, but it doesn't change the fact that his sword is still better than her mallet.

Edge: Goliath

 Mid Range: Cork Pistol vs. Giant Spear:  This is even more of a curbstomp in Goliath's favor. It is a bit ironic because, yeah, he was killed by a weapon that functions similarly to the cork pistol, but there's a fundamental difference here. Harley's cork pistol has its projectile attached to a string, making it a very short-ranged weapon, so she has to pretty much get right in Goliath's face to use it. The spear, for obvious reasons, is much more lethal, and it has a more effective reach.

Edge: Goliath

 Long Range: Boxing Glove Spring Pistol vs. Javelin:  Um, yeah. Goliath's armor will protect him, assuming Harley even gets close enough to hit him. The javelin will probably be Goliath's least effective weapon simply because the highly acrobatic Harley will probably be able to dodge a large projectile, but it's still way, way deadlier. No need to repeat what's already been said dozens of times.

Edge: Goliath

 Special: Hyenas and Acrobatics vs. Armor and Strength:  Okay, so in my opinion the hyenas will be little more than annoying distractions for Goliath. Since they won't be employing Harley's tactics of acrobatics and constant motion to avoid Goliath and his weapons, they'll probably be crushed/impaled/brutally gored almost immediately when they charge him. In terms of her sexual distraction techniques, I'm not sure they'll work on Goliath, considering he's a trained professional in a standing military. Even dating back to Biblical times, there are records of most professional armies having employed concubines or prostitues to accompany soldiers on campaign specifically to address this purpose.

That being said, Harley Quinn is still more agile and can probably leap and jump all around Goliath, evading a lot of his blows and making him frustrated. Her intelligence will also work in her favor because she can irritate and annoy him in an effort to psych him out--the more pissed off a warrior gets, the worse they'll do in a fight. None of Harley's weapons could really hurt Goliath all that much even without his armor, so it's basically just slowing him down at this point, whereas Harley's natural abilities and demonstrably superior intelligence will work in her favor if she employs it correctly.

Edge: Harley Quinn

WINNER: GOLIATH

Yeah, I don't see Harley coming out of this alive. She's sadistic and everything, but she tends to draw things out for too long and she's not necessarily a killer, at least not when compared to a professional soldier who does it for his job. Goliath's armor will make basically all attacks useless. Harley will have to climb up Goliath and snap his neck or choke him out to kill him, and with javelins, swords, spears, and shields involved I don't see her doing that. The hyenas aren't going to be too effective, her weapons aren't going to be too effective, and at the end of the day she's going to have to fight Goliath hand-to-hand. He might be slower than her, but it's not like he moves in slow motion or anything like that. Goliath is a big guy and the whole David story was pretty much used as a point to show how cool David was. Against someone who isn't Biblically backed up by God, Goliath probably won't get cheap-shotted like that. I can see him using his armor and weapons against Harley effectively, because the one thing a lot of people are forgetting is that he's a soldier with training and combat experience.