User blog comment:JGM007/Robert E Lee VS Napoleon Bonaparte/@comment-5559147-20121215192934

Lee is easily going to take both fiearm edges, for reasons already covered and even if Bonaparte has the better sword it's not gonna matter much as he'll likely never get close enough to use it.

As is

WINNER: Robert E. Lee.

That said its seems like the match might be fairer if you pulled the Confederates arsenal from earlier in the war when they were still making more frequent use of things like the Nippes 1840 Musket and the Aston or Palmetto pistols.