User blog comment:WanderingSkull/Jack vs. Frank West/@comment-379205-20120916195319

119's "I've Covered Wars Before" Edges


 * Melee: The chainsaw is a heavy, unwieldy weapon that is potentially dangerous to the user, while the baseball bat is capable causing severe blunt trauma in a powerful, lightweight package Edge: Frank
 * Pistols: Jack's Glock 17 takes this one for is large magazine. Edge: Jack
 * Shotguns: Frank's Remington and Jack's Mossberg are both 12-guage shotguns with 8-round mags. Even
 * SMGS: The UMP is more powerful and easier to control, but the Micro Uzi is faster to draw and has a larger mag. Still, slight Edge to Jack's UMP .45
 * Assault Rifles: Both the AK47 and the M4 are reliable, combat proven assault rifles, normally I'd call this even, but in this case, I'll go with the larger mag of the AK, as Frank is using a 20-round mag.
 * Special: This one is difficult, you can't really compare the two directly. However, the Reaper seems a bit unwieldy, whereas the landmines and gas tanks are lethal, and the bear trap can immobilize, allowing Jack to stay in a defensive position. Edge: Jack


 * Overall: This well be an extremely close match, but if, as the descriptions says, Jack, like Frank, has fought human enemies as well as zombies, then I can see this one going in Jack's favor, though Jack might not get out uninjured. OVERALL: Jack