User blog comment:Guitarcar/The Keeper vs Pyramid Head battle/@comment-35680048-20180804190524

Tybaltcapulet's "Creepy guys with Creep heads" edges:

Primary: Pyramid Head's great knife is much longer and more powerful than the meat tenderizer. I don't think the meat tenderizer is going to kill Pyramid head as easily as the Great knife will to the Keeper. And his greater physicality will assist him in using this weapon. Edge: Pyramid Head

Secondary: A spear vs meat and hooks? Yeah a spear is an actual weapon that can be used to stab, block and even  hit  the Keeper. The sack can only really be used a club. Edge: Pyramid Head

Special: A trap vs  a long tongue. Both are suited for different purposes. Pyramid Head's tongue is for an offensive fighting style that thrives of unpredictable movement. The Bear traps are meant for a more defensive" have the enemy come to me" strategy. I have to again give it to Pyramid Head because he always has his tongue while the Keeper has a limited number and must hope Pyramid Head gets injured by it.Edge: Pyramid Head

X-factors: The Keeper takes durability, Pyramid takes Physicality and they tie in experience. The Keeper certainly is shown to be able to take bullets,chainsaws and other weapons. But these are from opponents that don't have the physicality and strength of Pyramid Head. He as the author has detailed, able to literally rip people apart with ease, while The Keeper has not. I believe that Pyramid Head's better physical ability makes up for his lack of durability if only just. SLIGHT EDGE: Pyramid Head

Overall: I think it can be seen that I think Pyramid Head will win. His primary is more powerful being able to rip people apart with ease. His spear is easier to use and can be used in more ways than The Keeper can use the meat and hooks. The trap while useful for ambushes is not the most effective weapon because it is stationary, while the tongue can be used at any time. And ever so slightly Pyramid Head is the better warrior, not exactly being a tanky individual, but overall better suited to destroying The Keeper than vice versa. The Keeper will fight hard, but will be curbstomped by Pyramid Head.

Pyramid Head: 3500

The Keeper:1500