User blog comment:Drayco90/Marvel vs. DC- Captain America vs. Batman/@comment-4555900-20111027012852

I give this to Cap honestly. He has the experience and the preperation for almost any scenario. That's the main thing that gives him the edge I think. Sure, Batman is smart, but Cap is also a great tactician, so that makes up for it a little. Cap is faster, stronger, and more battle-hardened than Batman. Both hesitate to kill, but I beleive that Cap would kill first if given the chance. In the case of guns, I don't see them making as giant of a difference then most of you believe. Batman constantly deals with guns, Cap isn't amazing with guns, he uses them as last-resort weapons, so he probably isn't as good as a shot as some of you think he would. That shield though makes the biggest difference. It reminds me of an Ancient Greek Spartan shield honestly. It can take everything that Batman has with him, making it a efensive item. It also doubles as a offensive weapon becuase of the power and accuracy at which Cap can throw it. I doubt that Batman could block the shield if it was coming at him. He'd more than likely have to either make it veer off-course or dodge. Overall, I'd say Cap wins because of experience and preparation. Batman's smart, but no matter how smart you are, if you come to a battle unprepared, then the odds are already considerably against you.