User blog comment:El Alamein/Annie Wilkes vs. Jack Torrance/@comment-17814994-20150630090829

Elgb's "El Alamein... I've read all your awesome battles... and there's no doubt... I'M YOUR NUMBER ONE FAN ;D" EDGES!!!

Primary: There's no comparison here. The axe is a more practical weapon that's able to deal a more killing blow than the heavy and cumbersome hammer. It's got a blade and a spike to boot. EDGE: Jack

Secondary: The mallet may seem to be the longer weapon, but it's wooden structure and brittleness aren't something you should be looking in a weapon. The knife may be smaller, but it can kill you more with just one strike. EDGE: Annie

Special: I don't see Jack able to actually use the ghost for his bidding. Yes they are on his side, but they only appear when they want to and Jack seem to not have any way to call them. They may seem powerful in causing derangement in the building, but they still couldn't prevent a berserking Jack from dying. In terms of damage, the shotgun deal the more damaging blow, while there's been no accounts of the ghosts actively harming anyone physically. EDGE: Annie

Deadliest Warrior: Annie Wilkes

I don't really know why I choose Annie as the deadlier warrior than the more physically imposing Jack (there maybe some dark forces that's making me do so). But it stems out to the fact that Annie's got a frigging shotgun. Jack's weapons like the axe, mallet, and his entourage of ghosts aren't up to par with the lethality of a simple shotgun. One shot is enough to kill an out of control berserking Jack. Sure he is the more brutal of the two, but Annie is the more cunning, resourceful, and had the more control of herself than the impulsive Jack.