User blog comment:ILoveBattles/ILoveBattles (Collab with WanderingSkull) - Season 1 - Episode 4 - James Gang vs Dutch's Gang/@comment-17814994-20160222151441

Elgb's "A Million Ways To Die In the West" EDGES!!!

Close: Both look the same to me. The hunting knife has that slightly longer blade. But the bowie knife can be thrown (I'm guessing this is the blade in RDR so I'm sure it won't be thrown here). EDGE: James Gang

Pistol: This is an easy win for the Borchardt. Not only is it a semi auto compared to James' revolver, but it packs the bigger punch, can be reloaded faster, has the faster rate of fire, and its elongated spitzer bullet has the larger muzzle velocity and penetration power. EDGE: Dutch Gang

Rifle: I'm almost inclined to give this to the Evans repeater. But the thing is, is that it lacks range and power. And the reason why it didn't became popular in the West was because it was also prone to jamming adn was unreliable in the dusty Old West environment. The WInchester fires the larger bullet and was more reliable. Still, the Evans does have a 10-round advantage. So I'm giving this an even. EDGE: Dutch gang

Special: Funny. There were no actual historical accounts that Jesse James used a dynamite. But still, a shotgun is still the more practical weapon here. It can be aimed, shoot, and one shot can kill a man easier. EDGE: Dutch gang

Deadliest Warrior?

This is an obvious stomp for Dutch and his gang. I respect that Jesse james was a bushwacker and all, and he does have the more loyal troops (at least pre-Northfield Gunfight anyways). But Dutch is just packing the deadlier weapons here.