User blog comment:Weew1213/Dementor vs Ringwraith "Soul Sucking Demons" (Season 1 Finale and Halloween Special)/@comment-379205-20151014181723

119's "From the Shadows" Edges


 * Offensive Abilities: The "Dementor's Kiss" is a close range weapon, but instantly effectively fatal to a human, but it is unclear if it would have any effect on a dark wraith such as a Nazgul. On the other hand, the Nazgul's swords are no ordinary blade, but rather are embued with a dark sorcery, particularly the Morgul daggers, which will eventually kill anyone who is stabbed by them, but again, would this hurt a Dementor? EDGE: Even


 * Defensive Abilities: Both of the creatures are nigh-immortal, with the Nazgul being vulnerable only to magic weapons, while the Dementors have never been seen to be killed, though it is implied they can be controlled by the likes of Voldemort and the Ministry of Magic, suggesting that the extremely powerful wizards may be enough of a threat to force them into obeying. The closest thing ever mentioned to even the possibility of mortality of Dementors is the suggestion that the could not survive long in bright tropical sunlight- and that was pure speculation on Harry's part. EDGE: Even


 * Overall Winner: With the both offense and defense being even, this is a close fight, however I give a narrow victory to the Nazgul simply due to the greater power behind their magic, that of Sauron- essentially an entity of godlike power.