User blog comment:So-Pro Warrior/Captain America vs Master Chief/@comment-2187602-20111206044732/@comment-216.159.104.202-20111209180820

I think we're talking about the movie version, since Cap is using M1911 which he only used in the movie adaptation and he didn't start fighting Hydra till he joined the Avengers. Captain America will most diffidently NOT be as experienced as Master Chief. Also, the whole "Surviving Cosmic beings thing"? That won't work. The Cap in the movie has never fought a cosmic being in the film. Red Skull, though, does have Above-Human attributes. But at the same time, Cap didn't beat him, being that the Red Skull was destroyed by the Cosmic Cube thing.