User blog comment:GSFB/Night of the Living Dead Survivors vs Mughal War Elephants/@comment-5795750-20121211051548

BG1's "House Under Siege" edges

Short: I agree with your opinion - the talwar is a sword meant for combat whereas the tools the survivors have are basically improvised EDGE: Mughal War Elephant Medium: I bet that despite the 1 shot vs 6 advantage the survivor's have, there can be a strategy that might develop out of this - the Mughal crew can fire their hand muskets and throw their spears AFTER they let the survivors waste their ammo in the revolver; that being said, though, the armour might not be able to stop bullets from piercing it (why else did they drop the idea of armour when muskets and matchlock rifles became all the rage in the military) EDGE: EVEN (with a slight edge going to the Mughal War Elephant) Long: I have to sorta agree with you with the rifles and stuff but like the medium range weapons I can see a strategy that could develop out of this; also with the weapons the elephant carries, if it does get close to the house and smashes it - the weapons might be able to harm the inhabitants inside EDGE: EVEN (ditto) Special: I agree with you wholeheartedly with the molotovs vs elephants thing - also, the survivors would have to throw multiple cocktails since the elephants may be coming from all sides; theres also the problem that the Molotov cocktail may explode in the wrong place and perhaps may inflict damage upon themselves EDGE: Mughal War Elephant

Overall winner: Mughal War Elephant - Even if the survivors have the more modern weapons, the Mughal War Elephant and their crew are better organized and tactical in their approach; and cmon, I don't think the crew would harm an animal would they?