User blog comment:Sppople/Aragorn vs Jack Sparrow/@comment-3189283-20150813140154

I'm going to side with Jack Sparrow for this battle. Aragorn is the superior close range fighter without a doubt but Jack simply brings the harder hitting blackpowder weaponry and when you add the fact that he's an incredibly skilled marksman, he will easily be able to take Aragorn down from a distance. Even if the battle moves into close range Jack's cunning and brilliant mind will allow him to figure out a way to turn the tables on Aragorn and come out on top. Aragorn is too reliant on Anduril in this fight due to his lack of experiance with his other two weapons and this will be his downfall especially against someone as resourceful as Jack.