User blog comment:Jackythejack/No Normal World Anymore: Katniss vs Rick Grimes/@comment-25253035-20191217152049

Bow vs Colt Python: I respect Katniss Everdeen's skill and marksmanship with a bow and arrow. But seriously its too primitive to compare agaisnt a pistol. Not only can Katniss have to constantly reload that thing, but Rick doesn't even need to pull any string (he can just shoot and aim). Katniss was once able to shoot a bunch of holographic enemies during her training in that second movie, but she will be outgunned and taking cover as Rick unleashes his python.

Edge: Rick Grimes

Hand Axe vs Knife: I'm giving this one to the knife. An axe is more powerful and can be swung in a wider killing field, but the knife can both stab and slash. Katniss also doesn't have to worry about getting her knife stuck to a body like Rick's axe.

Edge: Katniss Everdeen

X-Factors: Rick is better trained and in better physical and mental health than Katniss. He was a former sheriff after all, unlike the more hesitant Katniss who basically had to learn by herself before finally getting some training. Also, Rick had to go through a lot of shit in his life and still stood strong, while Katniss cried and raged throughout her early days.

Edge: Rick Grimes

Final Verdict: I give this one to Rick Grimes. He's got the better and more practical firearm, training and better physical and mental will. And its kinda obvious really since Rick had to constantly defend himself and his family from daily threats, while Katniss's experience are more episodic, fewer and far in between.