User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 3 Episode 1: Frank West vs Rick Grimes/@comment-4541447-20130326201812

So-Pro THE WARRIOR's Edges

Melee Edge Rick Grimes: I don't care that the Baseball Bat has the better reach. The Gator Machete is going to kill a lot more quickly and can actually be used to disable Frank by say cutting off his arm or something. The Baseball Bat may hurt and could insta kill depending on where Frank hits Rick but the Machete will kill or incapacitate Frank no matter where he is hit.

Revolvers Edge Rick Grimes: The Python can fire much more faster then the M3 thanks to its Double-Action compared to Single Action, is a bit more lighter, and in the hands of Rick being his personal weapon a accurate shooter with it.

Pistols Edge Rick Grimes: As much as I love the Colt 1911 it just doesn't stand a chance here against the Glock which clip houses more rounds to fire at Frank and then the fact that if Frank has to reload this could give Rick the chance he needs to end the fight with a quick run to his position and then a bullet to the head.

Shotguns Edge Even: There is not much difference between these two guns.

AR's Edge Rick Grimes: Much like Sabre said below Rick actually has formal training to back up his gun skills meaning that he will likely try not to waste all of his rounds at first and will try to make each and every shot count.

SR's Edge Rick Grimes: Once again same thing as Sabre below. Rick has shown to be much more skilled then Frank who while also skilled isn't nearly as skilled as Rick is.

The Deadliest Warrior.....

Rick Grimes: I give my edge to Rick Grimes. Sure he may be a "little" messed up in the head...But he does bring in some factors that should lead him to victory. He has some formal training in the Police Force meaning he knows how to use firearms a bit more better then Frank does, personally Frank is a bit more better when it comes to human vs. human firefights having done this multiple times before and a little bit during the Zombie Apocolypse where as Frank has faced mostly Zombies on his part, facing human foes here and there. But there also should be the Factor of Determination in this Fight actually. Rick still has his son Carl according to the Info above. This means that Rick will do anything to protect his son and will be highly determined to survive and go back to his son including fighting Frank if he needs to.