User blog comment:Samurai96/The Rookie vs Issac Clarke/@comment-4248317-20111028060026

I'm voting for the Rookie. Isaac is an engineer, whereas the Rookie is special forces. He is also far more psychologically healthy than Isaac, which means he will perform more efficiently in combat. He also had to survive on his own, in an occupied city, filled with intelligent opponents armed with weaponry superior to his, while Isaac fought the Necromorphs, who are pretty much a vicious infection and don't use weapons (that I'm aware of). Overall, Rookie takes this fight due to his superior training, mental health, and the fact that he has fought and won against opponents far stronger than Isaac.