User blog comment:Appelmonkey/Rematch: Sayaka Miki (Puella Magi Madoka Magica) vs. Kirito (Sword Art Online)/@comment-379205-20151223040052

119's "Being Meguca is Suffering" or "It's a MuMORPerGer" Edges:


 * Swords: Kirito's Holy Sword Excaliber has one of the strongest stats of any weapon in the game, but at the end of the day, it's still only one sword. On the other hand, Sayaka has an infinite number of supernaturally powerful blades which she can use both in melee and as a devastating sword spam. Edge: Sayaka Miki


 * Powers: Sayaka's invulnerability except for her soul gem is a major advantage. Also, she is able to heal from any damage to her body at an accelerated rate, presumably able to rival Kirito's abilities. Sure, Kirito can fly, but Sayaka can more than jump high enough to avoid his attacks. Edge: Sayaka Miki


 * Special Abilities: Oktavia takes an edge of this as she is essentially a massively powerful summonable entity capable of fighting along side Sayaka, as opposed to simply a transformation. Two is better than one. Edge: Sayaka Miki.


 * X-Factors: Since this is Rebellion!Sayaka, and she has her past memories, she probably has much more experience than Kirito, even with his years of time in various VR MuMORPerGers. In terms of brutality, Sayaka has threatened to kill Homura and Kyoko (before she went yuri for the latter, at least according to the fan artists), but never killed a human that we know of. As for Kirito, he has killed, but only in a VR "Death Game", so it's not like he saw his victim bleed or die in front of him like he would in reality- and he still hated himself for it, so neither of them score high in brutality. In terms of mental health, TV series Sayaka was absolutely fucked up, but as for Rebellion, Sayaka's mental health has healed. As for Kirito, he is only somewhat scarred, but this may surface if this match has the "feel" of reality- like killing in real life- and make him hesitate, so slight edge Sayaka.

Overall Winner: Sayaka Miki takes this victory for her superior weapons and powers, as well as her slightly greater X-Factors. This will be a close fight, but in the end, Sayaka will put the fear of Madokami into Kirito!