User blog comment:El Alamein/Day Three: Hunger Games Tournament Redux/@comment-4661256-20160629202953/@comment-5078776-20160630005343

If this were something minor like getting a nonpoisoned cut or getting a bruise, that's understandable and acceptable. However, considering the fact that dehydration and starvation are very viable factors for a survival-based tournament such as this, it is debatable. A starving, dehydrated warrior is most certainly a factor, especially considering those two factors are derived from poison, and far more than an added flair to the battle.

It's entirely relevant, and completely curing her of those previous ailments suggests either complete healing overnight (which is impossible), or ignoring all stakes of the previous battle. Both situations harms your position as the tournament runner; it shows a lack of listening to your set canon (not a huge deal), but also that you are completely ignoring the consequences of the last battle for one warrior, which is unfair for Garrett, since his injury is left as is while Shiloh's condition is fixed. That, quite simply, is unfair.

As much as their intent to simply add an interesting narrative is noble, they're also factors that simply must carry over between each Day.