User blog comment:WinterSpider/The Winter Soldier vs The Red Hood/@comment-5078776-20160516192241

WHO THE HELL IS JASON? Bucky easily takes this edge, for a number of reasons. Todd's certainly not the best fighter of the Robins, but his skill is arguably on the level of Bucky. Where the assassin takes his edge, though, is physical. The NR-40 may not have the length of the Kris, it does boast a more practical, and therefore lethal, design. Bucky's also better physically- his enhanced strength, speed, and reflexes will make him far more difficult to fight in a head-on brawl, especially with his bionic arm in play. Todd's the better skills most likely, but his human body simply won't be able to compete for a long time in a knife fight compared to Bucky's superhuman physicality. Todd's use of the D'Eagles is typically impractical- however, he's shown to easily wield both of them with pinpoint precision (out of all the Robins, he's considered the best marksman, throwing weapon or fireaem). With enough firepower to counter the P226's one single round advantage, Todd manages to tie an otherwise wash category based on his skill alone. While Bucky's certainly a skilled marksman in his own right, the advantages that would normally give the P226 a statistical edge are countered by Todd's own skill.
 * Melee: Winter Soldier
 * Handguns: Even
 * Submachine Gun: TBA
 * Explosive: TBA
 * WINNER: TBA