User blog comment:MilenHD/Australian Aboriginal vs Apache/@comment-2602:30A:2ECF:CF60:1113:2C6F:4924:3FDE-20171018184539

GT25's Edges

Close Range (Nulla Nulla vs. War Club): Okay, I had to look up the Aboriginal's shield and what kind of shield the Apache has (which is a rawhide shield). After looking into it, I would have to say that the Nulla Nulla would be able to get past the shield of the Apache more than the War Club. However, I must point out that the War Club is longer and its weight would give it a greater striking power. So, while the Nulla Nulla plus the shield would be better in a fight, the reach and weight of the War Club evens things out here. Edge: Draw

Medium Range (Giant Sawfish Rostrum Club vs. Tomahawk): Yeah, this is nearly not even talking about. The Rostrum Club sounds like the Macuahuitl, but that also means that it has its main weakness that it will loose what it needs to cut a person open. On the other hand, the Tomahawk is better made and can be thrown at an opponent which gives the wielder more options. Edge: Apache

Long Range (Woomera vs. Bow & Arrow): Again, not much to talk about here. The Woomera may have the superior ammo, the Bow is simply more accurate and it has the superior reload time. Also, while the ammo of the Woomer is superior, the spears could be evaded quickly due to their larger size making them relatively easier to see coming. Edge: Apache

Special Weapons (Boomerang vs. Knife): So this is a hunting tool that can be thrown against an actual weapon that can be both thrown and used in melee. Yeah, it won't have the same range of the Boomerang, but the Knife provides more options to the wielder. Edge: Apache

X-Factors: Starting off, it's the Australian Aboriginal's 84.5 to the Apache's 87. Other than that, the Apache has the edge in training while the Aboriginal has a slightly superior killer instinct and physicality. Yes, the Aboriginal has the edges in these categories, but keep in mind that it isn't by much. On the flip side, they both are tied in terms of Endurance and the Apache has the superior training by an actual large margin. So, with the edge in training and having the slightly higher average, I'll give the edge to the Apache. Edge: Apache

Overall: One thing I think it has to be remembered is that the Australian Aboriginal is carrying a wooden shield that could protect them against the range weapons of the Apache. In addition to this, it could be used to push the Apache back with this shield compared to the rawhide shield of the Native American. However, I feel that once that shield is lost, the Apache would get the better chance of winning the match with his weapons. Yes, the shield would protect the Aboriginal, but the Apache is bringing the superior weapons to the fight and their training would give them a better edge than the Aboriginal's killer instinct and physicality. Another thing is that three of the four weapons of the Apache can be used at range while the Aboriginal has two and one of them is for hunting rather than fighting. So, ultimately, I'll have to side with the Apache on this one.