User blog comment:El Alamein/Highlander vs. Huskarl/@comment-422690-20120811012146

So... edges...

Close: Saxon Longsword wins. It's got more of an ability to penetrate the chaimail than teh Warhammer does. Edge: Huskarl.

Mid: Claymore wins. Same reason as close range: The Claymore can slash and stab with equal effectiveness, and stabbing with an axe is hard (unless you're Kelsier in the Dalinar v Marsh script). Edge: Highlander.

Special: Seax wins. The length of it gives it an edge. Edge: Huskarl.

Overall: The Huskarl has better weapons, which should give him the win.