User blog comment:Jackythejack/No Normal World Anymore: Katniss vs Rick Grimes/@comment-27043000-20191214011236

Pygmy Hippo's "Khan vs. Cortés:Fictional Edition" Edge

Range:The Bow might have more range if it's anything like it's ancient counterparts, the composite Asiatic bows could go up to 300 yards at least, but the Colt Python doesn't have to reload after every shot although after six shots are fired, reloading will be longer. The Bow is almost completely silent while the Colt's louder and deadlier, in the end, I've got to side with Skully as it's easier to hit with a modern revolver than a bow. Edge:Rick

Melee:The Hand Axe is longer but the Knife is likely lighter and can stab or slash unlike the hacking only Axe. What the Axe does have is more lethality if it hits, thanks to the weight and size of that blade, and as Skully again mentioned, Rick's a better melee fighter. Edge:Rick

X-Factors:In Physicality, Rick Grimes takes it as he seems to have much more success in hand-to-hand combat and has survived explosions while Katniss is faster. In Experience, Rick Grimes takes it as he's been fighting for much longer and facing foes who are similar to Katniss' best on a regular basis. In Training, Katniss Everdeen gets the edge as military training usually is superior to police training. In Accuracy, Katniss Everdeen takes the edge as she has hit impressive targets from farther away than Rick who sticks to the Dozen Club instead of the Hundred Club. Edge:Tie

Final Verdict:Both of these two are known for marksmanship that's usually found in snipers but Rick Grimes has the better tools for this fight. Katniss Everdeen might make up for the tech disadvantage at long range but once it gets into melee combat, Rick will dominate and he has the experience to survive that long. Katniss has more training but that's always been secondary to experience and accuracy and physicality just go with the equipment so Grimes has more going for him here.

Winner:Rick Grimes