User blog comment:Geekboy27/Jonah Hex vs John Marston vs Silas Greaves/@comment-26150944-20140708040628

TheWetWaffle's "Cowboys Can't Shoot Slow or They'll End Up Below" Edges

Melee: The Rifle Butt isn't a good weapon in my opinion, at least when compared to other blunt or bladed weaponry. Unless the warrior is trained in using their Rifle Butt (i.e. an ex-military member such as Bill), it doesn't impress me. Next out is the Bowie Knife, it has a shorter range than the Tomahawk. I find that the Tomahawk's longer handle will give it greater reach and will make it easier for Hex to throw it.

1st Edge: Jonah Hex

2nd Edge: John Marston

3rd Edge: Silas Greaves

Short Range: This is a tough comparison, as all of these revolvers are just so similar. They all weigh roughly the same at 4 pounds. However, the Single Action Army is out first, since there is only one. Since the other two pistols are plurals, that means there are multiple. But this barely goes to the Rangers aka the Colt Walkers, since they have a bit more range than the Dragoons.

1st Edge: Silas Greaves

2nd Edge: Jonah Hex

3rd Edge: John Marson

Mid Range: First to go is the Double Barreled Shotgun, even though it's the weapons of a pretty badass dude, it lacks the ammo to make it practical. Next to leave is the Browning Auto-5, since it can only have three to five shots, which means Marston will have to make them count. The Winchester Rifle gets this, thanks to it's superior caliber, range, and ammo capacity.

1st Edge: Jonah Hex

2nd Edge: John Marston

3rd Edge: Silas Greaves

TBF