User blog comment:Guitarcar/Left 4 Dead survivors vs Zombieland survivors/@comment-36053634-20180828045831

Guitarcar's "Civil zombie hunters" edges

Melee:

Easy win for the Zombieland crew here. The L4D's weapons are crude (A frying pan, really) and heavy and were not built for combat (Except for the fire axe, I guess).

Major Edge: ZMB

Short range: The ZMB survivors have less effective tools here. The Double barrels have less range and ammo and there M9 and Revolvers are outclassed by the harder hitting Shotguns despite having a better firerate.

Edge: L4D

Long range: The longer barreled Special combat assault rifle light and the M16A2 would cost them this mall matchup. I remember the pain US soldiers went through clearing houses with an M16 compared to M4.

Edge: ZMB

Special:

The Van could only be used as cover in the mall matchup and this barricade cover tool is still easy to bypass (Either you pass them via another path or use bullet richochet to hit your targets behind). The Grenade launcher while suicidal to use in a building, is better than a van.

Major Edge: L4D

X-Factors:

The L4D crew is much smarter and better experienced and have seen more action than the ZMB survivors. There teamwork also gives them a massive edge aswell.

Major Edge: L4D

Sumarry:

The more combat experienced L4D crew paired with their shotguns will put them on top of this battle against the less experienced and less co-ordinated enemies of theirs

Winner: L4D survivors