User blog comment:BeastMan14/Judge Death vs Batman (Earth-43)/@comment-6507091-20130216050230

I'm going to quickly give this to Judge Death. Starting of with teeth and claws, they both have that, though it wasn't stated that Batman could rip through steal, so based on the info, Judge gets the edge. Illusions vs Strength i've gotta give it to Batman. Illusions are a distraction, not a weapon. For phasing vs flying, i give it to Judge, mainly because you can't stop him once he's already going through something. With a flying object, they can easily be stopped. As for the rest of the things Judge has, that's just icing on the cake for judge.

Winner: Judge