User blog comment:MilenHD/Celt vs Comanche/@comment-17814994-20170120170448

Elgb's "Native Badasses" EDGES!!!

Short: The sword provdes swifter and smoother hits than a warhawk (which is basically a pike put in a stick). The former is longer and has the wider surface area to deal more damage, and it won't get stuck when it hits. EDGE: Celt

Mid: It's a tough one. The war lance maybe shorter but it is more maneuverable. Still, I gotta give this to the lancea due to the fact that it's got twice the reach of the lance. EDGE: Celt

Long: Bow easy. They can be aimed farther and more accurately, fired more accurately and is far more lethal. EDGE: Comanche

Special: A "scalping" knife is still technically a knife so there's nothing specail there. The burda club may lack a sharp edge, but it does have the reach and the power to make up for it. EDGE: Celt

Deadliest Warrior?

At first I thought that the Comanche may win since his horse is maneuvarable and also because his bow and arrow will be instant death to any dumb naked Celt that may try to charge at him. But even if the Celt lack long range weapons, and since both have armor and are fighting in a swift chariot/horse, the Celkt's more practical and brutal close and mid range weapon will prevail. With his shield a Celt can protect himself against the Comanche's bow, and when the two finally gets close, then the Celt's superior melee weapons will destroy the injun.