User blog comment:Wassboss/Deadliest Warrior Rematch: Comanche vs Mongol/@comment-27043000-20181102052858

Pygmy Hippo's "We Khan Defeat The Comanche" Edges

Close Range:The Scalping Knife was 8 ounces on the show while this one is longer, I doubt it's that much heavier. The Mongolian Knife is 14.9 ounces which makes it heavier but it's still longer and steel and wood>iron and bone. Edge:Mongol

Mid Range:The War Lance is 5 pounds which makes it much heavier than the Turko-Mongol Saber. It's longer but it's also got less of a blade, iron <steel, less options, and it can't be used as effectively on foot. Edge:Mongol

Long Range:The Comanche Self Bow is 4.5 feet long making it longer than the Mongol Recurve Bow and as DW showed, it's more accurate but it does have less power and range meaning that the two bows are evenly matched. Edge:Tie

Special:DW's tests already showed why one weapon beats the other but to recap, the War Hawk can put a nasty hole in someone's head, the Flanged Mace can completely anhilate someone's head. But the War Hawk can be thrown? That's nice until the Comanche misses with a small point for an actually lethal hit. Edge:Mongol

Armour:I would like to point out the Comanche wore bone armour but it's obvious that even if it was included, the iron and leather lamellar combo offers far more protection and the Mongols have a silk vest underneath for even more protection. I don't think the helmet can defend against anything but the War Hawk though and the Buffalo Hide Shield is impressive but the requires more movement to actually defend against blows which is difficult when you're using both hands to use a bow or lance while riding a horse. Edge:Mongol

Mount:As Tybalt mentioned below, endurance isn't going to play a major role in a 5 on 5 while the faster Native American Horse gives the Comanche the ability to attack when he wants to and possibly even avoid attacks, the Mongolian Horse and the Mongols just can't keep up. Edge:Comanche

X-Factors:The Comanche take Situational Experience and Physicality while the Mongols take Training, Experience, and Brutality. They tie in Archery. Edge:Mongol

Final Verdict:It shouldn't be a surprise that the Mongols will win this fight with their superior arsenal, armor, and the most important X-Factors,Experience and Training. The Comanche are stuck at long range with their bow being their only weapon advantage and even it's tied with the opposing bow, weak body armour anda difficult to use shield on horseback, and Situational Experience which helps somewhat but considering the Mongols are far more advanced than any Native American tribe and have fought across Asia and Europe along with being an actual army. The Comanche may have won in the show but it's clear Deadliest Fiction has the accurate result.

Winner:Mongols