User blog comment:El Alamein/The Malmedy Survivors vs. Hiroo Onoda/@comment-3189283-20120731205254

Lets see shall we

Close range: At the end of the day both of these weapons are the same thing. Edge Even 

Mid range: I'm gonna call this one even. While the shin gunto has the longer reach, the knife can be used faster and more fluently in combat. Edge Even 

Long Range: The M1911 has superior stopping power and seeing as how they have the same amount of ammo this is the only real edge I can give. Edge Malmedy Survivors]

Final Verdict 

I'm gonna go with the malamady survivors in this one. While Onoda survived for 30 years when he was fighting it was mostly against police forces which are nowhere near as well trained or well equipt as SS troopers. The Malmady survivors had to hold out against much tougher forces with less provisions making them much more experianced in combat and have proven their skill is far above a soldier like Onoda

Malmady Survivors: 3,900

Hiroo Onoda: 1,100