User blog comment:Elgb333/I Will Survive! Hugh Glass vs Alexander Selkirk/@comment-11361577-20160907105257

Appelmonkey's "Oscar Worthy" Edge's

Hawken Rifle vs. Brown Bess Musket: This is a bit of a hard pick, the Hawken is OP in case of a long range battle, because of it's acuracy and range, but the Brown Bess has a faster rate of fire and higher caliber. In the end the guns are effective, and who gets the edge is only determented on how away they are from each other, so I am calling it a tie. Edge: Even

Hunting Knife vs. Dirk: This is a slam for the dirk IMO, even at it's shortest lenght (9 inches) it's longer then the hunting knife (6 inches). Not only that, but the fact that the dirk is double-edged makes it a more versitile blade. Edge: Alexander Selkirk

Hatchet vs. Spear: And Hugh comes back with the hatchet for a revenge slam. This is pre-stone age tool up against iron age. Sure the spear is longer, and has a biger chance to wound Alexander, if thrown, but again, its an iron tool against sharp wood. Edge: Hugh Glass

X-Factors: When it comes to expiriance, both fought in wars, but Hugh has more expiriance fighting on land and woods, Alexander is stronger I would say because he actauly trained his body, sure Hugh took on a bear, but who says Alex couldn't. As for survival skill, they are both though SOBs so its pretty even there. Edge: Even

Deadliest Survivor: TBC