User blog comment:MrPacheco101/The Night Brimestone and Fire Poured From The Sky: Etrigan The Demon & Edward Elric/@comment-1017446-20120414002605

Edward Elric has my vote. He possesses greater tenacity and health. Anything that Etrigan will throw at him won't be very effective considering he can survive fatal wounds. In addition, Elric can form holy relics to defeat Etrigan since he can form things out of random substances. However, Etrigan's real weakness is his vulnerability to iron. Again, Elric can form iron weaponry to defeat Etrigan.