User blog comment:Lasifer/Welcome to Rapture: Booker DeWitt vs. Jack Ryan/@comment-5078776-20140128021412

CFP3157'S EDGES OF MASSIVE DESTRUCTION: "'''Would you kindly get Elizabeth for me?" '''

Weapons
Melee: Jack Ryan 

The Pipe Wrench gets the edge here. Booker's SkyHook may deal an incredibly destructive amount of damage, but it's bulky and it's possible to hurt itself. Against melee enemies like the Thuggish Splicer, it'll be heavy to deal damage against these fast foes. Meanwhile, the Pipe Wrench is a simple and easy weapon that, combined with Jack's superhuman strength, will deal just as much damage at a faster rate.

Pistol: Jack Ryan 

The Revolver may have a low amount of ammo, but it's firepower and logistical advantage gives it an edge. The Leadheads give Jack a complete logistical advantage, giving him ammo to collect from their dead bodies. Add that firepower, and Jack has an incredible advantage that he will not kindly ignore.

Shotgun: Even 

The Spencer has a faster rate of fire, but the Quick Handed Gear will give Booker a reload advantage that just about evens things up. Even with that ammo advantage the Leadheads provide, they're a random factor that is a hit-or-miss kind of up and Booker has the same advantage given the generic ammo.

SMG: Jack Ryan 

The Tommy Gun wins this quite easily. It's firing a bigger round and has a little more ammunition, and the ammo advantage of the Leadheads will give him an edge logistically. Jack Ryan's strength will let him take the recoil, and Booker's lack of durability advantages could be fatal here.

Long Range: Jack Ryan

The Springfield has an undeniable range advantage here, but it's low rate of fire loses it's edge here. The Crossbow offers versatility in the form of fire bolts, and it's higher rate of fire gives it an edge. Plus, a crossbow bolt goes in a lot messier than a bullet does.

Explosives: Even

The RPG may be more accurate and have more firepower, but the Grenade Launcher holds more ammo with that bigger area-of-effect nature. It evens out, as both weapons offer advantages and disadvantages.

Powers
Fire Power: Jack Ryan 

Despite the Devil's Kiss' spread ability, the Incinerate! Plasmid is far more accurate and offers several tactical advantages in the field.

TBF