User blog comment:LB&SCR/GWM Episode 1: Douglas Haig vs. Robert Nivelle/@comment-36053634-20180705030703

Guitar's edges

Rifles: The SMLE shoots much better and has a better capacity. The Lebel is slower to reload on average.

Edge: Douglas

Pistols: The Webley and Modele are diffrent and both pistols succseed the shortcoming of the other. I could not decide on which diffrence is important.

Confusing Edge: Tie

Machine guns: The chauchat's infamous jams is gonna kill the guy using it because it would probablly jam after 3 rounds fired. You can watch that on Mr gunny's lock and load machine gun episode. I havent heard of the lewis but i havent heard a lot of bad things about it that can compromise this edge here.

Major edge: Lewis

grenades: Confusing to say at best again. Its like every grenade is a copy of each other. Only a few diffrences can be noted but even that cannot give a proper edge for me.

Confusing Edge: Tie

Tactics: Im gonna agree with battle, Your troops fight better if they know your victories compared to not having knowledge of you at all. Doug gets this one again

Major Edge: Douglas.

Summarry: Doug gets this one due to better rifles and MG's paired with tactics. Robert seems to rank a bit lower.

Winner: Douglas