User blog comment:Sith Venator/Jack Bauer vs John "Soap" MacTavish/@comment-1017446-20110821194502/@comment-1017446-20110824223241

So...was not victorious since he obviously didn't take down the biggest objective of them all. Plus killing Shepherd wasn't a victory at all, it was just revenge since the only benefit was for Price and Soap and that act only put them in deeper crap.