User blog comment:SPARTAN 119/French Revolutionary Militia vs Ikko-ikki Rebel/@comment-5078776-20130128204317

Cfp3157's "Sure, let's give Spartan some more votes. remeber that everyone?" edges:

Daggers: The Main Gauche, while designed to be able to block SWORD attacks, loses the versatility that the Tanto has. Edge: Ikko-Ikki

Improvised #1: The hatchet can be thrown as a mid range weapon, while still retaining some nice close range potential. Edge: French Militia

Improvised #2: I imagine the whaling hook as a modern day grapplong hook. It may cause damage to the user. Plus, it'll be slower than the Kama. Edge: Ikko-Ikki

Sword: The Katanna is a fanboy weapon. It lacks the versatility and close rnage potential of the Saber. Given the close enviroments of French cities, the longer Katanna will fail in the CQC conditions. Edge: French Militia

Pistols: The Flintlock is more reliable and MAY be more accurate. Edge: French Militia

Muskets: The Charlevielle has a more reiable mechanism. Edge: French Milita

WINNER: French Miltia

The fact that the French have better firearms, a better sword, and a better improvsied weapon. While the Main Gauche and hook will fail, the Militia simply bring the better weapons to the job. Add their brutality and technology, and you got the winner.