User blog comment:123chaseyoung/Doc Holliday vs Wild Bill Hickok/@comment-379205-20140303000945

119's "Quick draw" Edges:


 * Melee: The two weapons are identical, and in any case, I suspect they will not get anywhere near as much use as the rifles and longarms. Even.


 * Handguns: The Colt Single Action Army "Peacemaker" and the Colt Lightning both use metallic cartridges. This means the weapons are easier to reload than the cap-and-ball Navy Colt. Not to mention the Peacemaker also had the advantage of a larger round, and thus greater stopping power. Edge: Holiday.


 * Longarms: The double-barreled shotgun has an extra shot, however, I'll give this to the Springfield for its much longer range. Edge: Hickock.


 * Overall Winner: Both men were skilled gunfighters, known for their exploits in the old west. Overall, however, I have to give this match to Doc Holiday, mainly due to his superior pistols, likely to be the most used weapons in this fight.

WINNER: Doc Holiday.