User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 3 Episode 1: Frank West vs Rick Grimes/@comment-5228865-20130328042047


 * Whistles* God Damn, this is gonna be a big one. Either way, it's gonna hurt to watch one or the other die. Right on to my vote.


 * Melee goes to...Rick Grimes- The machete is a weapon with a blade. If it hits, it's gonna do some really good damage, regardless of where it hits. The bat can't fully compete with something like that. Blunt vs Blade, Blade wins.


 * Revolver goes to...Frank West- While Grimes may have a faster gun, I doubt that will help. If he gets hit by that butterfly, he's gonna be broken. More firepower, more damage, same ammount of rounds. Given Grimes state he'll probably just waste bullets faster than West would. I'm not sure speed will help in this case, as such it's the power that gives the Schofield the edge.


 * Handgun goes to...Rick Grimes- The Glock is a much better gun. Bigger clip. The extra bullets will help, and when it comes to that, It wins. Hands down.


 * Shotgun goes to...Neither/Even- There is no big difference when it comes down to it. There is a slightly increased weight for Frank's gun, but in this case I doubt that makes a big enough difference to declare a winner. Their both Even in my eyes.


 * Assault Rifle goes to...Neither/Even- These weapons are both identical. Their share the same things all down the line. As such, I'm declaring them even.


 * X Factor goes to...Frank West- There are a few reasons besides just Grimes's mental health, which day play a big factor in my decision. For starters, Fighting crazies with better training, and better weapons, is nothing new to Frank. He's done this all before. He survived the military, bat shit people with nothing left to lose, and everything in between. His combat experience is also better. While Grimes may be more brutal, that doesn't help given his mental health. If anything his brutality will work against him, especially because he has snapped. It makes him undpredictable, but also exactly like everyone else Frank has fought. Add to the fact Frank West is a creative bastard, who always has a trick up his sleeve. And when he doesn't, he can improvise on the spot, and he always find something, the moment he needs it. This one goes to Frank West.