User blog comment:JWarrior89/Season 3 Episode 4: Han Solo vs Indiana Jones/@comment-4555900-20120529201447

Short- Indy. The Machete is a more lethal weapon, plain and simple, it is more likely to kill, and easier to maim with also. It also has more range.

Mid- Indy. The whip is longer, and while the Vibroblade can cut through it, Indy is amazing with his whip, and will more than likely catch Solo off guard and trip him up.

Long- Solo. The Blaster Pistol is stronger, and does not need to be reloaded as much as the Python does. The Python also takes longer to reload unless Indy has a speed reloader with him. The Blaster Pistol probably has more range than the Python too.

Explosive- Solo. I don't really know much about the Model 1912 grenade, but I believe the Thermal Detonator has more than enough explosive power to match the Model 1912, it can also stick to walls, which means it has more uses than a regular grenade will.

Overall- Indy. The Revolver, while not as effective as the Blaster Pistol, can still kill Solo fairly easily seeing as how he has no armor to speak of, and Indy's whip can be used to keep Solo farther away, if it does get closer, then the Machete is much more useful than the Pistol Whip, and it is a much more close-quarters weapon than the Vibroblade. Indy has this one.