User blog comment:WanderingSkull/Jack vs. Frank West/@comment-3189283-20120917062632

Lets see shall we

Melee 

The chainsaw is certainly powerful and would rip through frank if jack actually manages to trap him with it. However this is highley unlikely to happen as the chainsaw is hard to wield, heavy and bulky and unless he has immense upper body strength he will be reduced to ethier a full out charge or a slow moving advancement both of which are easy to counter and avoid. It also takes away the one advantage that a melee weapon has over a firearm; the fact that it has no ammo. The chainsaw will burn through it's fuel pretty quickly and even if jack swings the chainsaw about like a mad man it will do little damage besides a little bit of blunt truma. The baseball bat is lightweight, simple to use and west can just dance around jack with it and keep hitting him with quick blows which will eventually bring him down.

Edge Frank West 

Pistols

What this really comes down to is does a bigger clip size beat a more powerful bullet. Jack will certainly get more shots off with his glock but frank's shots are more powerful and will do more damage if they hit. However it's not the bigger clip size alone that wins the edge for jack it's the fact that the clip size is so much larger that it completely blows the colt out of the water. Even through the bullets are not as hard hitting or powerful the sheer number of them means it will be unlikely that jack won't hit frank at least once and if it comes to a fire fight he can afford to be more wasteful with his shooting giving him more oppourtunities and chances to get a hit on west.

Edge Jack 

Shotguns 

TBC