User blog comment:Sir William Of Chalitton/Red Queen Mother Vs Balrog/@comment-5795750-20140414132945

BG1's "I might as well chip in my two cents" Edges:

Short Range: Weapons such as an axe and a mace are always superior to teeth and tongues as killing machines

EDGE: Balrog

Medium Range: Because of the nature of the Alien claws and the Queen's resistance to fire, I think all the Alien Queen can try to do is grab the sword and toss it aside; if that doesn't work then at least a parry with a spear-like tail ought to even things out

EDGE: Alien Queen (Just)

Long Range: Despite the liquidity of the acid, I doubt it will extinguish the flames that emit out of the Balrog; to the contrary the fire will boil up the acid before it even touches him; the fire whip is a tried and true weapon that should grab for the Balrog a higher killing chance

EDGE: Balrog

Special: Being strong, large and fast is good for an extra-terrestrial creature like the Red Alien Queen but the Balrog is much bigger, much stronger and with wings, perhaps a lot faster and more agile than the Alien Queen; and if by fire snorts you mean the Balrog can breath fire then its game over for the Queen despite her durability - if she is exposed to enough fire, then she burns

EDGE: Balrog

Overall Winner: Balrog. This is almost no contest - the Balrog is a lot larger than the Red Queen, more powerful with weapons and abilities that cover a long range and well... the Balrog is one tough creature to kill and yes the Red Queen might be too but her durability and strength are not at the Balrog's level. This fight is over before it gets too heated (no pun intended).