User blog comment:Lasifer/Welcome to Rapture: Booker DeWitt vs. Jack Ryan/@comment-5043545-20140201023553

WanderingSkull's GraveDigging Tunes "The Hollow Men"

Weapons

Melee: Well overall a close category as we are comparing a simple and easy to weapon of the Wrench vs. the weapon that is effective for transportation and can be used as a melee weapon. The Skyhook can originally was going to be next to useless as a weapon until the introduction of Elizabeth into the match. Now Booker can use it as a method of transportation around the area and still use it as a weapon. The Wrench on the other hand is a simple to use tool and with in combination of Jack's massive strength can deliever crushing blows to Booker. So it's versatility vs. simple and blunt power and in the end I have to call it a slight edge to Booker put as a weapon Jack's is superior. Slight Edge: Booker

Pistol: Well once again this is an amazingly close edge but I'm going to have to give a very slight edge to Jack thanks to his logistical advantage. The Broadsider is quick and has a larger clip size plus in combination with Booker's training he can use it to greater effectiveness. On the other hand, Jack is packing a revolver with much more power and Jack has ammo avalible to him in the form of Splicers. Jack also has a weapon with a slightly more controllable fire rate and thanks to his strength he can control the recoil. Slight Edge: Jack Ryan

Shotguns: Slug vs. Pellets is what this comparison is going to come down too and it's another close one we got on our hands. Jack's shotgun can be used for more precise and damaging hits while Booker has a shotgun in which the spread can do some serious damage. The spread damage of the China Broom is reduced thanks to Jack's high pain tolerance. I would've given this to Jack thanks to his shotgun having a faster reload but Booker has a can negate this thanks to one of his abilities making this even. EDGE: Even

Will finish soon.