User blog comment:123chaseyoung/Doc Holliday vs Wild Bill Hickok/@comment-5043545-20140307032843

WanderingSkull's GraveDigging Tunes "Shadows Of Noon" 

Melee: Both are the same thing so there is no real reason for me to compare these two weapons and plus they will probably never even get close enough to using these weapons only add to the draw. EDGE: Even

Revolvers: These weapons are the real game changers as this is likely the weapons they'll use the most often in the fight. Doc's revolvers are simply too advanced for Bill's older revolvers to keep up. Doc has the ease of reload as weapons use cartridges rather than the more complicated ball and cap method. The greater stopping power of the Colt Peacemaker only adds to Doc's edge. EDGE: Doc Holiday

Long: I'm calling this even for a reasons that offer this comparison to be close. The double barrel offers an extra round and they'll likely be fighting at a close range for the duration of the match and this weapon can get the job done in a single shot. The Springfield on the other hand simply offers a greater range and makes this match even. EDGE: Even

Deadliest Warrior: Doc Holiday- Both of these men are skilled gunfighters who are willing to push themselves to great limits to defeat their foes. That being said though Doc Holiday takes the weapon edge that is really going to play the largest role in this match. His ease of reload and greater stopping power allow him to pull through this match.