User blog comment:BeastMan14/Craig Boone vs The Sniper/@comment-24180428-20130308221749

Utter noob's "Snicker the sniper" edges:

Rifle-The Sniper's rifle doesn't need to be reloaded. Edge The Sniper

Melee-The machete has a longer blade. Edge Craig Boone

X-factors-I give this to The Sniper, he may not have more experience, but he still has some decent experience and a better mindset. Edge The Sniper

Winner-The Sniper has this due to having a better long range weapon, which is an extremly important factor.