User blog comment:1298god/First User Warrior Battle: The Owner vs Claimteoir Meisce/@comment-379205-20191212035755

119's "OC Insanity" Edges:

Short Melee: Ordinarily I would give the edge to the KA-BAR Ice Axe for its greater likelihood of a lethal strike in any give blow, but given that Claimtoir is master of stick fighting, he is a master of using the shillelagh and should be able to parry or evade any attacks from Kyle. Edge: Claimtoir

Long Melee: The shark tooth macuahuitl is intimidating, and would prove very nasty against an unarmored opponent, but Claimtoir is wearing armor, and even if his neck is not covered, as a trained martial artist, he should be able to parry the attack with his messer or shillelagh. While Claimtoir is not trained in swordsmanship, he will still be able to move more quickly and better be able to parry thanks to his martial arts training, so I still give his grosse messer the edge. Edge: Claimtoir

Ranged: I can't see the spear gun punching through the lammellar armor that Claimtoir is wearing. The flammenwerfer may not kill Kyle outright with his superhuman durability, unless the heat reaches a point where it "cooks" his heart or brain from within, but it sure will slow him down by burning away his muscle tissue and making him weaker, perhaps even incapacitating eventually. Also, the attached Semtex makes a handy last resort if Claimtoir runs out of fuel, if Kyle takes the weapon from him, or other such situation. The blast of the Semtex and any remaining fuel could potentially kill even the insanely powerful Kyle, or at least burn or blast away limbs, leaving him a very easy target. Edge: Claimtoir

Special: Rose is a second combatant and potential distraction, and she is very strong, but the problem with seals is that they are not very agile on land, where this fight is likely to take place, so could probably avoided. If she does become a problem, she will be an easy target for the flamethrower. The kukris are thing special, but I see them being more use in a fight, especially as decapitation is on of the methods confirmed to be able to kill the inhumanly strong Kyle. Edge: Claimtoir

X-Factors: In terms of physicality, Kyle gets the edge for his horror movie slasher-levels of strength and, in particular, durability. As for experience, Claimtoir has fought fully armed cops, vigilantes, and even special forces, while Kyle has not faced any heavily armed foes before now, in spite of spending an extended period of time killing. Neither are particularly tactically brilliant, but are capable of ambushing their foes, even if they usually attack head on.

Winner: Claimtoir Meisce wins that battle mainly due to his superior weapons and experience in combat against heavily armed foes. While he lacks quite the level of superhuman physicality and durability of Kyle, his greater experience will allow him to defeat his enemy.