User blog comment:WraithOfWaffle/Battle Eight: Carnegie (The Book of Eli) vs. The Governor (AMC's The Walking Dead)/@comment-13937974-20140214190638

Melee-The machete definetly takes the adavantage in length however the Bowies purpose is for combat, its a close one but....EDGE-Governor

Pistol 1 - This is a more obvious choice, they are more or less even however the Beretta has a higher muzzle velocity. EDGE-Governor

Pistol 2 -The Beretta has a larger clip and while the 9mm is not as strong as the .45, although the Berettas muzzle velocity more than makes up for it. EDGE-Carnegie

Shotgun - The UTAS is a much more modern gun with an extra 5 rounds over the Moss 500. EDGE-Governor

Rifle 1 - While the AUG is a newer weapon I believe that the AK-47s reliability and stopping power will be more of an advantage in this fight. EDGE-Carnegie

Rifle 2 - The FN Fal is a superb weapon with more manageable recoil and better accuracy, the M14 is completely outclassed- EDGE-CARNEGIE

Explosive - The AT4 is newer and definetly is more improved than the RPG. EDGE-Governor

Heavy Machine Gun - The Browning is a much newer and possibly effective weapon but the Gatling gun just brings that little bit more to the fight. EDGE-Carnegie

Deadliest Warrior- While my voting in weapons adds up to a tie, the Governors reputation in combat gets him my vote. While Carnegie has some pretty effective weaponry, the Govenors soldiers give him that little bit more support. While Carnegie wins in intelligence, the Govenors brutality will help more in a batlle.

Winner- The Governor.