User blog comment:CuchulainSetanta/Elliot Stabler vs. Marcus Reed/@comment-3239346-20110509143357

Baseball bat beats Nightstick - it's longer and has just pure raw hitting power.

I'd have to give it to the Sig in mid range because it's the weapon of military and special forces - S&W's are mainly paramilitary sidearms

H&K beats the dual MAC-10's because even one assault rifle still has more range and accuracy than two submachine guns.

Beanbag shotgun beats flash grenade because it can be fired multiple times (unlike the grenade) and has a longer range (unless the grenade is thrown).

Well, stabler gets my vote because all reed's got going for him is the bat and the beanbag shotgun, which I think is nonlethal, while Stabler is packing much more heat with all his guns and special weapons. He'll win with around 550 kills in a close battle.