User blog comment:Goddess of Despair/Season 5 battle 2 Comanche vs Aztec Jaguar/@comment-5232784-20130531014456

Okay woodcampers, let get this party started in here

1. Short range

The Macuahitl is heavier, larger, and longer than the war hawk. Though the latter has a superior iron blade, the obsidian blade surrounding the front part of the Macuahitl is larger over all (encircling the outer side of the upper part of the weapon) and is super sharp. Indeed, a swipe from a Macuahitl can decapitate a horse!

EDGE: Aztec Jaguar

2. Mid range

the war Lance is larger, longer, and has a larger iron blade, as opposed to the smaller obsidian one. No contest

EDGE: Commanche

3. Long range

Though the Atlatl has a lot more power (Bison skulls from the ice age have been found with clovis points imbedded in them, due to the power of their Atlatl spear throwers) the bow and arrow has longer range and I believe accuracy. It takes a lot less training to use bow and arrows than it does a spear thrower.

EDGE: Commanche

4. Special

The Scalping Knife has an iron blade, which i superior to Obsidian. Also the iron blade is better designed as a stabbing weapon than the Tecpatl.

EDGE: Commanche

Overall I give this to the Commanches: though the Aztec jaguars have cotton armor, they lack the long range factor, and have inferior special and mid range weaponry. Plus, Commanches have horses, creatures which frightened the Aztecs the first time they saw them; horses will give Commanches speed as well as a psychological weapon. Horses are big and strong and can trample the mightiest of Jaguar warriors; Commanches reign supreme.

COMMANCHES CHEW UP AZTEC JAGUAR WARRIORS