User blog comment:SPARTAN 119/Game of Thrones Season Six Special: Tywin Lannister (Game of Thrones) vs Tallard Graham (The Lord Marksman and the Vanadis)/@comment-26032472-20160507111028

MilenHD's"The Lannisters send their regards"edges

Swords:Edge Even:Both are the same type of sword,an ordinary longsword.

Blugeon Weapons:Edge Tywin:While this is not the morning star flail,the axe still gets the edge because of the huge amount of chopping power,also the axe has superior lenght and it's more practical than the morning star.

Mid:Edge Even:Both the pikes and the lances are the same.

Bows:Edge Tywin:As you said the longbow has more range and Tywin probably has skilled archer.The composite is no doubt lighter and more manueverable,also it has faster rate of fire,but I don't think will outstand the longbow's superior range and penatrating power.

Crossbows:Edge Tywin;This sounds crazy but I have to give it to the crossbow,because it reloads faster and Tallard will look like hedgehog with all the bolts sticking in him.Yeah the stopping power of the arbalest is good,but the faster rate of the crossbow wins here.

Siege:Edge Tallard:The Mangonel requires less energy and less man to be used in those types of battles,If this was small skirmish than no,but this is massive army fight.By the way the Mangonel can also be used for biological warfare,which will be deadly in this scenario.

Siege Projectiles:Edge Tywin:While the grapeshot is nasty weapon,the Wildfire is even nastier.The wildfire is smart addition to the projectiles,because it's flamable and will destroy the Mangonel because it's made of wood,also if the ships came for help,they will also be destroyed because it will burn on water.

Winner:Tywin Lannister,as much I hate the Lannisters(except Tyrion),he will be able to pull this battle rather easy and this match will end very similar to Stannis vs Hilmes,because in Westeros they seem to pick good weapons and armor to beat the anime guys.Also Tywin superior intelligence and experiance will help him defeat Tallard Graham.

P.S:Hey SPARTAN,can we make a vote trade.