User blog comment:Leolab/User Siege Tourney, Round 2 of 91: Cfp3157 vs Drayco90/@comment-422690-20130310160439

Since there's so few votes, I'll give my edges.

Army v Army:

Sheng/Kenway takes this one, by far. His army is much better organized, and while they have a limited ranged option, the painted armor of Austonio's forces gives them a much nicer target. Shooting Greek Fire out of a canon may be impractical - not sure if even a sabot will help with the forces involved - but normal cannonballs should have a very, very easy time penetrating.

The only problem Sheng/Kenway's army has is that it's designed for open combat rather than a siege.

Austonio's army, on the other hand, is just impractically designed, and the incendiary cannonballs are useless without a crew manning the cannons. The cannons may serve as the "Quaker Guns" of Civil War fame in deterring enemy attacks, though.

Now, the X-Factor of loyalty plays in. Kenway/Sheng has a score of 55 - rather low. It is still higher than Austonio's score of 29, the second-lowest of all the generals. Most of his troops will likely be gone withing the first month or two.

Sheng/Kenway takes army v army.

General vs General:

Since there's a chance for single combat, all edges will be given.

Long Range: English Longbow wins. It's a more reliable weapon than the hat-based flamethrower. Edge: Sheng/Kenway.

Polearm: Xyston wins, for it being an actual military weapon rather than a testing device. Edge: Kenway/Sheng.

Main Hand: Shortsword wins, due to length. Edge: Austonio.

Off-Hand: Steel Hoplon wins. A flail in the off-hand is a recipe for disaster. This alone would lose Austonio single-combat. Edge: Sheng/Kenway.

X-Factors: This is a no-brainer. Sheng/Kenway sweeps all categories, with a final average of 70 to Austonio's 29. What'll really kill Austonio, though, is his mental health rating of 10.

Overall: Shang/Kenway wins. He's got too much of an advantage in his army and in his mental health.