User blog comment:LB&SCR/Unknown Tales of Private Investigations: Pinkerton National Detective Agency vs. Baldwin-Felts Detective Agency/@comment-26384220-20150817000043

These two are private investigation but, there can only be one! '''There can. Only. Be. ONE!'''

Melee: Clip Point Knife vs Maxam Knife. The Clip Point is made for combat while the Maxam is for hunting. The clip point takes it here.

Edge: Clip Point Knife.

Primary Sidearm: Colt Mod. 1851 Revolver vs S&W Model 3. This is the exact weapon to me and it's a tie.

Edge: Even.

Primary Rifle: Henry Repeating Rifle vs Winchester Model 1886. The Henry Repeater is supposed to compete with the WInchester but, the Wincheseter was known as the weapon that won the war.

Edge: Winchester Model 1886.

Secondary Rifle: Spencer Rifle vs Sharps Rifle. The Sharps Rifle looks to be a much more accurate weapon but, the Spencer has a better fire rate. I'm still going to give it to the Sharps.

Edge: Sharps Rifle.

Shotgun: Coach Gun vs Colt Model 1878. Looks like the Colt will fire 2 at the same time and the Coach gun will only fire one, which will give it the advantage.

Edge: Coach Gun.

X-Factors: The Pinkertons average is 78 and Baldwin Felt's sverage is 76.33

Edge: Pinkertons.

Overall Verdict: The score is 3-2-1 with the Pinkertons taking the win with one point ahead. They may have tied with the Baldwins in the Sidearms category but, they beat them in the X-Factors, which gave them the win and will be a huge edge in this fight.

Verdict: Pinkerton National Detective Agency.