Board Thread:Warrior's Pub/@comment-11361577-20160801143105/@comment-5078776-20160801213243

Actually, the events of Red Dead Redemption take place in 1911 (historical inaccuracies aside), and the time gap is, while still larger than the mentioned battle, only a one-hundred year difference. My argument here is that placing it off time gap alone would not be enough for reason to declare unfairness, further explained below.

And while it's true the starting gun is a single action revolver, he does "upgrade" per day to more evenly match able weapons such as Mauser pistols, Browning Auto shotguns, and even anti-tank rifles (once again, historical accuracy aside).

As for apples to oranges comparisons, that may be required here, although this type leans far more on the "interesting" side of things rather than the ludicrous.