User blog comment:BeastMan14/Arrow vs Nolan, Part 3! Malcolm Merlyn vs Daredevil!/@comment-17814994-20160319101014

Elgb's "Damn... This Could Have Been Better If This Was Between Malcolm and Frank Castle... But Still Nice Fight Though XD" EDGES!!!

Equipment: Like what Wass said, this is a very tough one indeed. In terms of weaponry, Malcolm definately takes the overall edge. His bow and his scimitar are far more lethal than the billy club/staff Daredevil is using, as well as offering range and versatility. Still, Daredevil's suit will be very difficult to get through, seeing that it can block melee and projectile weapons. But in the end, I think Macolm can find a way to get past it. Overall the suit does have limitations and Malcolm himself is nos tranger to fighting guys with armors. EDGE: MM

Martial Arts: Easy edge for Malcolm here. DD got most of his training from the Stick, but it was short-lived. MM was traiend by the League of Assasins in way more martial arts than DD. EDGE: MM

Powers and Skills: While malcolm has the edge in martial arts, Daredevil takes almost all other edges in the bag. He's physically superior than Malcolm, being more durable, stronger, faster and more agile. While Malcolm is the more devious, Daredevil trumps him when it comes to physicality. With these superhuman attributes and his superhuman senses, Daredevil can get past Malcolm's weapons and beat the shit out of him. EDGE: DD

Deadliest Warrior?

I really still feel like it would have been better if the Punisher was in this battle than Daredevil. But fanboyist childish complaints aside I got to give this one to the Red Blind Devil. While most edges favored Malcmolm, there is just one thing that Daredevil have that he doesn't: superhuman physicality. Both of these guys make a living by going mano-a-mano with people so physicality is a main forte for them.

On the other hand, while Malcolm may have the bow and scimitar, Daredevil's armor, senses and agility can nullify them. If Daredevil can dodge automatic pistol fire at close range then a simple bow would do. Both are stealth and physical fighters but it was Daredevil who has a more consistent experience in the craft, than Malcolm who's too busy planning and doing supervillain BS and letting his henchmen do the work. In the end, the Man from Hell's Kitchen wins this.