User blog comment:Weew1213/The Man with no Name vs Rooster Cogburn (1969) "Gunslingers in 60's"/@comment-5795750-20160304125717

BG1's "Ya Feel Lucky? Oops Wrong Movie" Edges:

Melee: Same same on the face of it

EDGE: Even

Short: Yeah EA's got it right they are both the same type of gun... but I'm not going to call it even because of that - I'm gonna call it even on the basis that Clint's gun is customised to fit his shooting style but Rooster's got 2 guns meaning twice the ammunition he can spend

EDGE: Even

Medium: Rooster gets the edge here since the double-barrelled shotgun is technically a poor choice of shotgun - sure it's got a bit of power behind it but its got a short range plus its a bit of a hassle to reload since essentially in firing it you fire off both rounds (methinks) whereas the Coach Gun fires its shots one at a time so not much finicky reloading in the middle of the fight

EDGE: Rooster

Long: There is a very good reason why the Winchester was called the gun that won the west - sure the Sharps and Henry rifles offer Clint a good range advantage but the Winchester is an evolved form of the Henry rifle and has a faster and safer rate of fire than either gun (after all, the Sharps is single-shot and while the Henry is also a repeating rifle, it lacked a safety mechanism meaning if it was cocked it could potentially misfire)

EDGE: Rooster

X-Factors: Average of 87.75 for Blanco; Average of 80.25 for Rooster

EDGE: Man with No Name

Overall Winner: Despite Rooster possessing the better long range weaponry and the experience of being a Civil War vet, he is too old, drunk and visually impaired to take on the best gunslinger of the cinematic west The Man With No Name. Rooster may be skilled at dual-wielding but The Man can make up for this with his skills in quick-draw and fanning - I mean throughout the course of the Dollars trilogy, the Man certainly has managed to effortlessly take down outlaw thugs with his six-shooters (in addition to the other weapons in stock) and thus when it comes down to the showdown then the Man is certainly in his home territory.