User blog comment:JGM007/S1, E2: Edward the Black Prince VS William the Conqueror/@comment-24180428-20130102225135

Alright so...

Long range-I give this to Will, for the same reasons you mentioned. Edge William the conqueror

Mid-Despite being heavier the Wlesh bow has better range and fire rate. Edge Edward

Short-The norman sword is lighter however the english sword is longer. Edge Even

Armor-Look at how well William's sword faired aginst Joan of Arc's plate armor. It does practically nothing. WIlliams armor is way more likely to give in. Edge Edward

Tactics-William will likely set up his catapault send in some guys at the English, then retreat. The english will leave their defense to chase the normans who will then fire on them with the catapault. Edge-William the  conqueror

Winner-This will be a close match up however my edge is with William the conqueror. His armor may not be as good nor his mid range weapon, but he in my opinion will out smart Edward and his troops with the feined retreat. When those numbers drop Edward will have to go up aginst WIlliam face to face, and despite lacking the better armor I think William will kill Edward since he will likely target Edward's unarmored areas after striking plate armor fails. Vote:William the conqueror