User blog comment:Guitarcar/Hashashin vs Sicarii/@comment-27043000-20180727083913

Pygmy Hippo's "Assassin's Creed" Edges

Armor:The shield might not be the stealthiest thing but then again these two groups are master assassins who are skilled at avoiding detection and any protection is better than nothing. Edge:Hashashin

Short Range:The Poisoned Khanjar promises a kill if it hits but the Cloak has a lot of versatility with being able to hold blades back or used as a sling. Combine that with the concealable Dagger and the combo gets my vote. Edge:Sicarii

Mid Range:The Scimitar is longer but the Sica is more concealable. Edge:Tie

Long Range:Slings are one of my least favorite weapons, not really deadly and overly difficult to use. The Throwing Knives are fast and lethal. Edge:Hashashin

X-Factors:The Hashashin take Experience and Training while the Sicarii take Stealth. Edge:Hashashin

Final Verdict:It looks like we disagree for once. The Sicarii may have the more stealthy arsenal but I think you forgot that the Hashashins would be used to killing stealthily with their weapons as well. The Dagger and Cloak combo is versatile but it's the only real advantage the Sicarii have.

Winner:Hashashin