User blog comment:BeastMan14/Why So Serious, My Beautiful Snowflake? Tyler Durden vs The Joker/@comment-5795750-20130302004020

BG1's "Brad Pitt vs Heath Ledger - Battle of the Teenage Hearthrobs" Edges:

Melee: The baseball bat has the range to hit someone but it isn't as powerful as a switchblade knife. Both weapons are easily avoidable though and since Tyler has the greater physicality and has been doing non-stop fighting, he should know how to avoid a swing with the knife.

EDGE: Tyler

Short Range: The Glock may carry more rounds but it doesn't have quite the large range the 4506 has - also in the time it may take for the person carrying the Glock to close the gap, the person holding the 4506 will have reloaded and begun shooting again

EDGE: Tyler

Medium Range: The MAC-10 is the more devastating weapon here with a higher rate of fire but at the end of the day, the MP5 has the far superior muzzle velocity, larger range and ammo clip.

EDGE: Tyler

Explosive: The nitro-glycerin bomb is great for ambush attacks but otherwise, it is useless as a direct assault weapon. The M67 however can be thrown and has a large explosive blast radius (though not as large as Tyler's bomb since the latter can 'level buildings' meaning it contains a higher explosive payload)

EDGE: Joker

Special: The RPG has a big warhead and a large range of attack but if someone with brass knuckles can close the gap, then the person holding the RPG will have no other choice but to fistfight back because of the risk of firing an RPG at close range.

EDGE: Even (Slight lean towards Tyler)

X-Factors: Project Mayhem is a very very dangerous gang with a lot of influence over the US meaning that they have had to face almost every single US Special Force and Army and Police unit available. Also they work better as a team and have great tactics. However, the thing that may tip this match-up in the Joker's favour is that the Joker has faced off against Batman - THE SMARTEST MAN IN ALL OF THE DC UNIVERSE (save for John Constantine, but I digress). Plus he is very unpredictable and scary. If the battle is set in Gotham City (which is most likely the case), then Joker has the homefield advantage. But I think Tyler and Project Mayhem are not going to be THAT easily manipulable mentally (Tyler MIGHT be but I can't really say for sure now)

EDGE: Even (Slight lean towards Tyler)

Overall Winner: Tyler Durden and his Project Mayhem gang will be able to destroy The Prince of Darkness since they have the teamwork, tactics, physicality and mentality to counteract the Joker's unpredictability and cunning.