User blog comment:MilenHD/Alaric I vs Arminius/@comment-3189283-20171011125334

Let's see shall we

Close Range

Well seeing as how the Migration Period Sword was based off the Spartha it stands to reason that they'll function very much the same.

Edge: Even

Mid Range

The Boar Spear is a good weapon for keeping someone at a distance and those little hooks on the side can be used to pull away someone's shield giving it extra utility. The Framea on the other hand has a more compact and manoeuvrable size, a big bonus in the close confines of a forest and itself has an extra utility in that it can be used as a projectile as well. Both have their uses and both achieve these uses well so there isn't really an edge to be given.

Edge: Even

Long Range

I hate the Javelin with a burning passion but as a ranged weapon the Francisca Axe isn't any better. However it does at least serve some use as a melee weapon which is more than can be said for the flimsy shitty Javelin.

Edge: Alaric I

Special Weapon

I think people are too quick to dismiss the Club here. Sure the Seax has good cutting power and a blade is generally more lethal than blunt trauma, but Arminius's chainmail will nullify any slashing attacks. The club's blunt force trauma bypasses the protection provided by chainmail making it more effective at dealing damage.

Edge: Arminius 

Final Verdict

This is a very tough one to call. The two are roughly even in weaponry and while Alaric has a slight edge in terms of armour because of his helmet it's not a huge advantage. I think people are overrating Arminius a bit here, yes he did cause a crushing defeat to the Romans in Teutoburg Forest but that was his only victory of note and he was soundly defeated once the Romans got their act together. Alaric on the other hand not only sacked Rome but also served in many more battles and he also served in the Roman Army at one point, so his tactical knowledge is just as good as Arminius' is. Ultimately that's the only thing to separate the two, Alaric is just the more experienced and successful warrior.

Alaric I: 2,550

Arminius: 2,450