User blog comment:Samurai234/Minutemen vs. Jacobite Rebels/@comment-3189283-20110723200424

Lets see

Close range: The broadsword is just better in my opinion. Edge Jacobite Rebels

Mid range (Polearms): The axe looks more devastating and the pike is not as effective on foot. Edge Jacobite rebels

Mid range (Pistols): The blunderbuss pistol is basicly a shotgun pistol. Much better than a normal pistol. Edge Minutemen

Long range: The kentucky rifle is way more accurate than the musket. Edge Minutemen

Special weapons: The dirk looks like it has a longer blade so i will go with that. Edge Minutemen

Overall its the firearms that will win this match and based on that the Minutemen win this. Even though the Jacobite rebels have the better swords and polearms if they can't get close enough to use them then they are screwed. The Minute men win 550-450.