User blog comment:So-Pro Warrior/Season 1-Battle 14: Jake Lonergan vs. John Marston/@comment-5465602-20150123003553

Beastman14's "I've buried more of my children than I've raised em" Edges

Revolver: John Marston. Jake's Model 1860, while effective, is rather dated, nor is it packing quite as much punch as John's New Service. Another advantage is that John is renowned for his quickdraw skill, while Jake has never shown any evidence of that level of skill with a revolver.

Shotguns: John Marston. Its an unspoken rule that pump-action shotguns are just all-around better weapons than their sawed-off brethren, for numerous reasons.

Rifles: Even. While Marston's rifle is lighter and likely easier to use in a gunfight, Jake's rifle packs the more powerful round to make up for being slower and clunkier.

Special: Even. While Jake's bracelet is certainly an incredibly deadly weapon, there's one problem. Its completely alien to Jake, and he doesn't seem to entirely understand what it's capable of or how it works, meaning he might not use be able to use it quite as effectively as John will be able to use his devastating one-shot kill of an anti-tank rifle.

Deadliest Warrior: John Marston. Ultimately, Jake is no much for a true legend of the west. Marston simply brings better weapons and backup, alongside being a far more experienced and intelligent warrior. Looks like John will tame one more bandito and ride off into the sunset. Overall Score: 575-425