User blog comment:Greenberet69/Greenberet's Final Battle: Captain George Stacy vs. Lieutenant James Gordon/@comment-3127606-20121012001301

My vote goes to Gordon. He has experience fighting men with more training than Stacey (Joker/Bane gang). Also, he lives in Gotham. One of the most brutal cities in the world and he lives and works to fight the crime in it. This meanshe has to be a damn good which will mean more of his bullets will land on target which means he will win the fight. New York doesnt have quite the crime rate as Gotham, so Stacey would have less experience dealing with armed criminals than Jim Gordon.