User blog comment:Elgb333/A Grim Fairy Tale: Jack Horner vs Blue Fairy/@comment-3189283-20190705104829

Let's see shall we

Powers 

The Blue Fairy has based her entire power set on incapacitating and while this can sometimes be a disadvantage in a fight in this particular battle it's actually a massive boost. Jack can't really be harmed by any sort of magical attack so trying to hurt him his futile however knocking him out is a viable option and with the Blue Fairy having an entire arsenal of magic spells designed to do just that. Jack meanwhile doesn't really have a set of powers he uses what he can do in combat is limited only by his imagination due to his reality bending powers allowing him to conjure up whatever he wants.

However there are two things which put this massively in Jack's favour; The Pathetic Fallacy and Devil's Burlap Sack. By summoning Gary, Jack can create a whole horde of anthropomorphic objects to act as distractions to stop the Blue Fairy from being able to solely focus on him and more importantly he can turn the Blue Fairy's wand into an enemy itself, depriving her of the main thing she uses to cast her spells. The Burlap Sack is also incredibly OP because once Jack whips it out then it's basically all over for the Blue Fairy as she will be unable to escape it's vortex. Without this two particular facets of Jack's power I probably would've sided with the Blue Fairy but with them he takes the edge.

Edge: Jack Horner 

X Factors 

Both are skilled strategists and manipulators but Jack has the advantage of having outsmarted about five different versions of the devil as well as literal gods which is much more impressive than Rumplestiltskin and an evil queen. Combat skill also goes to Jack for being much more physically capable and having more experience in that area. And seeing as how these are the only two X Factors and Jack wins them both well obviously he gets the edge here as well.

Edge: Jack Horner

Weaknesses

Honestly Jack's weaknesses aren't even that much of of a weakness. Yeah sure he can be knocked out and incapacitated but that's a weakness the Blue Fairy herself also shares and losing his invulnerability in his dragon form doesn't matter because she won't be trying to kill him anyway. The Blue Fairy's weaknesses are much more damaging, her powers are reliant on her magic wand and fairy dust, the former Jack can get rid of with the Pathetic Fallacy which leaves her with a finite amount of fairy dust to use all her powers. Granted she probably won't run out quickly but it is still a limitation and one Jack doesn't share. Her gullibility is also a big problem considering Jack is a master manipulator and trickster so she could easily be tricked or baited into a trap. In essence Jack's weaknesses are just weaknesses that almost any other person would have whereas the Blue Fairy's are ones that specifically cause he problems in this match.

Edge: Jack Horner 

Final Verdict 

Let's just get it out of the way and say that I'm casting my vote for Jack. It should be obvious from my edges why but I'd like to say that while I have given him all the edges and spent most of my vote dunking on the Blue Fairy I don't think this battle is as onesided as it may seem. Blue is bringing some very effective incapacitating spells to this battle and even one of them hitting Jack would basically win her the match and with her own agility and speed it'll be hard for him to hit her, meaning she has a much better chance of ending the battle quickly. However I feel if the battle drags on she'll start to struggle as her fairy dust runs out and the longer it goes on the more it falls in Jack's favour. He's got the two most potent abilities in the Pathetic Fallacy and Devil's Burlap Sack and his greater cunning means he'll be able to think rings around Blue and her slightly gullible nature. It won't be easy but I think Jack has the less limiting set of powers and less exploitable weaknesses and will come out on top.

Jack Horner: 2,600

The Blue Fairy: 2,400