User blog comment:Elgb333/I Will Survive! Hugh Glass vs Alexander Selkirk/@comment-3189283-20160907092010

Let's see shall we

Main Weapon

The Hawken Rifle has the more modern design and over four times the range of the Brown Bess which will be particularily helpful for Glass to snipe Selkirk from a distance, possibly before he even notices him. However if the range is closed or Selkirk spots Glass first then the Brown Bess' faster rate of fire will take the advantage as Selkirk can just pepper his opponent with Bullets while he desperately tries to reload his rifle. This comparison is highly effected by how the battle plays out and I can't really give an edge to either as both excel in a particular scenario.

Edge: Even

TBC