User blog comment:Lasifer/Welcome to Rapture: Booker DeWitt vs. Jack Ryan/@comment-13937974-20140214195010

Melee- While it may not kill you the pipe could still deal some damage but the roating skyhook is just a much more effective weapon. Edge-Booker DeWitt.

Handgun-The Broadsider is a much more effective weapon due to its faster rate of fire and larger ammo capacity. While the revolver is probably a little more powerful, it lacks the qualities of a modern pistol. Edge-Booker DeWitt

Shotgun-I have always liked the 1887 but I feel that the shotgun slugs would be more effective in a close quarters engagement even if it lacks the stopping power of the 1887. Edge-Jack Ryan.

Submachine gun-The Thompson takes this based purely on its larger ammo capacity. Edge-Jack Ryan

Long Range-I can see why the crossbow is an obvious choice but I think that the Springfield is a more superior weapon because of its power and modern design. Edge-Booker DeWitt

Special weapons-The grenade launcher is just clearly the superior weapon with 6 grenades at a high rate of fire. No contest. Edge-Jack Ryan.

I would vote on magic and henchmen but this is the first time i've heard of these characters

Based on weapons I think that Jack Ryan takes this. While Bookers skyhook does impress me I think that Jack has more practical weapons and wins were it counts. Deadliest Warrior-Jack Ryan