User blog comment:El Alamein/Denham's Expedition vs. the Monuments Men/@comment-26865010-20151201180703

Snigel's Nameless edges!

Long Range: The M1 wins due to its larger magazine and RoF. The Mauser makes it possible for the Expedition crew to pick off targets at a longer range, but M1's edges trump the Maucer's range.

Edge: MM

SMG: Its almost the same gun, with some minor differences. M1928 has the obvious advantage in magazine size. And also note the grip, allowing it to spew lead at the opposing force with accuracy.

Edge: DE

Pistol: This is pretty close to me. Despite 1911's larger cartridge, the Luger's one extra bullet takes the win. Luger may have the weaker bullet, but no-one is using bulletproof vests.

Edge: DE

Melee: Another battle that has a Machete vs KA-BAR in it. The Machete wins due to its longer range and cutting power. One good swing and somebody's missing a hand. Or a leg.

Edge: MM

WINNERS: Denham's Expedition!

Despite having inferior training and technology, the men of Denham's Expedition have the experience, killing instinct and physicality to win this fight. The Thompson is a major edge Denham's Expedition has, due to its rate of fire and magazine size (especially if the battle takes place at the Melee-Mid range).