User blog comment:SPARTAN 119/Pirate vs Ninja Rematch/@comment-122.32.123.7-20130608110243

Daggers: Both have same length. Dirk can't be used in slashing but tanto can be used in slashing/stabbing.

Edge: Ninja

Swords: I agree with your opinion.

Edge: Even

Other melee: None of the blunt weapons(including axes) could kill more than bladed weapon in deadliest warrior.

Edge: Ninja

Mid Range: Fukiya and shuriken need some time to kill their enemy. Also, shuriken is more effective in close range and it gives a chance for pirates to kill ninjas with their pike.

Edge: Pirate

Pistol: Flintlock is easier/faster to reload.

Edge: Pirate

Shotguns: Flintlock is better than matchlock as pistols.

Edge: Pirate

Rifles: Same as pistols and shutguns.

Edge: Pirate

Xfactors: Many pirates were veteran navy and military training is much more harsh then ninja's martial arts training.

Edge: Pirate

I'll vote on pirates. Ninja's main weapon is their stealth ability. If pirates found them. They'll be killed easily.