User blog comment:BeastMan14/Video Games vs Comics: SHIELD vs Umbrella/@comment-4552610-20130404005103

Undead RVD's "More Info, Please" Edges
Melee: Knife vs Knife.
 * EDGE: Even

Pistol: The Glock 19 does not have the crazy-ass mag size its past forms have. I'm going with the Beretta do to having more rounds.
 * EDGE: UMBRELLA

SMG: The two have around the same mag size and rate of fire but the Steyr TMP has the superior muzzle velocity.
 * EDGE: UMBRELLA

Rifle: The M4A1 has the greater range and superior rate of fire. It lacks in Muzzle Velocity but it it will hit better and with greater accuracy.
 * EDGE: UMBRELLA

Explosive: The hand grenade has versatility but the M203 Grenade Launcher is faster and has a greater range.
 * EDGE: UMBRELLA

Shotguns: The AA-12 has more rounds, mag fed and automatic.
 * EDGE: SHIELD

Gear: The Camo is nice but the Thermal Vision sights should debunc that.
 * EDGE: SHIELD

Overall: I wish there was x-factors or stuff like that but I'll go with the guns. Here, UMBRELLA has superior better guns. They lose in shotguns and gear but they have the better pistols, SMGs, rifles and explosives.