User blog comment:LB&SCR/Unknown Tales of Private Investigations: Pinkerton National Detective Agency vs. Baldwin-Felts Detective Agency/@comment-17814994-20150819101250

Elgb's '"We Serve and Protect, For the Right Price. We are... Police of Fortune!" 'EDGES!!!

Melee: The clip point knife wins this quite easily. Not only is it the longer weapon in this cateogory, but that actual "clip point" in the end of the blade would have dealt more damage the moment it digs inside flesh. EDGE: Pinkies

Sidearm: I'll have to disagree with most of the voters below me. Both weapons are NOT the same as they have said (just one look and you'll see how obvious the difference actually is). Colt 1851 Navy (cap and ball or coartridge converted) is a slow, heavy, and very innacurate pistol with its lack of top strap. The Smith and Wesson Model 3 is a lighter and more accurate sidearm, with its top break system allowing it to eject spent cartridges and reload waaaaaaaaaaay faster than the fixed cylinder Colt. EDGE: BF

Primary: This is a tough one right here. The Henry rifle is a puny rifle that fires baby bullets but having a larger magazine, while the Winchester 1886 is a monster elephant gun with beastly recoil. In the end I'm siding with the Henry. The M1886 is a big game hunting gun not quite suited for combat due to its small magazine and heavy recoil. The Henry may lack damage, but at least you can fire almost twice the ammo. EDGE: Pinkies

Secondary: Both are the same guns. All questions are answered. EDGE: Even

Shotguns: ???????????????????????????????????????????????????

Deadliest Warrior?

The Pinkertons get this even due to sheer power of their weapons. The Baldwin Felts were nothing more than mean thugs whose only good at shooting unarmed laborers trying to make their American Dreams a reality (they make me sick). The Pinkertons were jerks too, but at least they were a more organized unit who fought far more dangerous opponents such as Jesse James and the Wild Bunch.

'P.S. I think you got the weapons wrong here. The Baldwin Felts were an early 20th Century unit whose probably armed with bolt action rifles (Mausers or M1903 Springfields to be exact) and pump action shotguns. And it sure was very innacurate to give em a Smith and Wesson Model 3 as a sidearm because from what I've read, they've carried the more periodic Colt Official Police or Smith and Wesson .38 Military.'

'And what Colt Model 1878 shotgun are you taking about? The Colt M1878 was a revolver, NOT a shotgun.'