User blog comment:Ethandabomb/Spock vs. Han Solo/@comment-8012490-20130419114005

Star wars vs. Star trek, who will win?

Close ranged weapons: viroblade vs. ahn-woo. Though the ahn-woo is a pretty stealthy weapon like a garrot, it is not designed for straight-up combat. The viroblade, on the other hand, is much better for this type of combat. Edge: Han Solo.

Next it is the blasters vs. phasers. I'm condensing it into one comment because my reasons to giving Spock the edge are the same with both: accuracy. The blaster users fire constantly with their weapons and rarely seem to hit anything. On the other hand, the phaser users fire only once and always hit their target. They both take out their enemy in one hit, but the phasers are simply more accurate. EdgeX2: Spock.

Hand to hand has boxing/wrestling vs. nerve pinch and vulcan martial arts. Spock wins with this one instantainiously. Vulcans are physically stronger then humans by far. Spock has been able to knock around multiple humans and it takes more then 2 people to restrain him. The nerve pinch also is able to take out people in one hit wheras Han needs more then one to take anyone out. Edge: Spock.

Then there are the x-factors. I believe spock wins here as well. He is simply too smart and logical for Han to be able to deal with. Sure Han is more bold; however, that may cause him to make rash decisions or run into unnecesary trouble. Wheras Spock's discipline will keep him calm and coordinated. Edge: Spock.

My vote goes to Spock for this one. He is an experienced military commander with more accurate weapons going up against a smuggler. In addition, he is physically and mentally stronger then humans, including Han Solo.

Finally, I believe that the battle should take place on the enterprise. The situation is that Han is traveling on the millenium falcon when he comes across the ship. He flies into the shuttle bay to investigate. Kirk, meanwhile, has also noticed the millenium falcon and Spock goes down to investigate. When they go down, either Han mistakes Spock for someone working for the empire or Spock attempts to arrest Han for smuggling. Then the fight starts.