User blog comment:BeastMan14/Spoilers Ahoy! The Arkham Knight vs The Winter Soldier!/@comment-21025171-20150914220542

WraithOfWaffle's "Who the Hell is Bucky?" Edges

Weaponry: The weapons I'll be comparing are the Grapple Gun and Custom Dual Pistols versus the Gerber Knife and Skorpion. This is an easy edge in favor of the Arkham Knight, as the grapple gun can stun the Winter Soldier or allow the Knight to take evasive action and the Pistols are powerful as all hell so they may at least distract the Winter Soldier. Although the Winter Soldier's Skorpion is a decent weapon and his knife fighting skills are impressive they simply don't pack enough of a punch compared to his opponent's weaponry.

Edge: The Arkham Knight

Equipment: The Poor-Man's Batsuit and Helmet will be going against the Metal Arm. As much as I like the Batsuit's capabilities and the helmet maybe giving the Arkham Knight some sort of edge in battle the Metal Arm on top of Winter Soldier's superhuman abilities even out the versatility factor.

Edge: The Winter Soldier

X-Factors: The Arkham Knight gets an average of 77 to the Winter Soldier's average of 83. The Arkham Knight is more mobile and better trained but the Winter Soldier is stronger, more experienced, and more mentally clear.

Edge: The Winter Soldier

Overall: These two sidekicks who've joined the dark side of justice are two tough bastards who are serious thorns on the sides of Captain America and Batman. Although the Arkham Knight has more of the fancy toys and equipment he's only a man going up against a superhuman foe in the Winter Soldier. The Winter Soldier is simply tougher and more experienced in combat and when the battle does enter a hand-to-hand fight the Winter Soldier is going to get the upper hand. The last nail in the coffin is the mental state of the Arkham Knight possibly overpowering him and possibly costing him the fight.

Edge: The Winter Soldier