User blog comment:Marcus Forelli/Harry Dresden vs John Constantine/@comment-5465602-20130212151632

BeastMan14's "Magic Noir" edges

Magic: I like Dresdens spells, but Harry has the advantage of a larger variety of spells that might pack more power. Edge: John Constantine

Magic Items: Harry has got good weapons here, but many of John's weapons are far more powerful, capable of killing a target instantly. Edge: Constantine

Weapons: John despises using guns, while Harry always uses one as backup. As said in Skullduggery Pleasent, "Only an idiot would bring a sword to a gunfight." Edge: Harry Dresden

X-Factors: Harry has an X-Factors score of 77.15, while John has a score of 77.50. John narrowly takes this due to his greater intelligence and experience. Edge: John Constantine

Overall Winner: I really went into this rooting for Harry, but John wins it. He's more experienced, got a larger variety of attacks, and is smarter than Harry.