User blog comment:Bl02PIE/Robocop vs Judge Dredd/@comment-35680048-20200104170620

Tybaltcapulet's "Time to shoot bullets out of the air guys" Edges:

Primary: No shit the Lawgiver wins. The Auto-9 is a fine pistol, and Murphy is certainly very skilled with it, but the Lawgiver is just better. It's more ammo, and has a shit ton of options at its disposal. The Auto-9 is just a regular pistol modified to fire in three eound bursts with 50 rounds.Edge:Judge Dredd

Secondary: I don't understand how you couldn't give the edge to Robocop's assortment of secondary weapons. I think Bulls is taking the whole switching weaons problem Murphy has a bit too seriously. It's not like Dredd can just automatically switch the type of rounds he's using either. And you can't ignore the pure mobility the flightpack gives, the pure power and variety of the Gunarms, and the glorious Cobra Assault Cannon which fires, and then there's no more anything.The Arbitrator is literally just a shotgun version of the Lawgiver, with nothing really special to provide outside of that.Edge:Robocop

Melee: The terminal strip isnt even really designed to be a weapon, so it loses out here pretty easily. At least the daystick and Boot Knife will get more action in combat, but even then, none of thesr melee weapons will really be all that useful so it's a moot point.Edge:Judge Dredd

Armor: Do I even need to explain this? The Titanium alloy armor that Robocop has is just better at tanking damage in general, with large explosions and high powered rounds being basically useless against it.Dredd's uniform has been comprimised by similar things in the past. It just isn't as good.Edge:Robocop

Physicality: In terms of speed and agility, Dredd will win every time. There's simply no doubt about that. But Murphy has certainly shown better feats of strength in his time. He also can easily compete with the reflexes of Dredd, being able to catch and even shoot bullets out of the air with ease. And like Laqy I want to also draw attention to the fact that Murphy h iij himself isn't take damage, it's his body. Dredd on the other hand, still has human limitations and is tanking all damage onto himself. With the power of Murphy's weapons, this will eventually take a toll on him, unlike Robocop who can keep going.Edge:Robocop

Overall/X-factors: I'm coming in with a tiebreaker and it's in favor of Alex Murphy/Robocop.

TBC