User blog comment:Leolab/Mami Tomoe (Puella Magi Madoka Magica) v Mimori Togo (Yuki Yuna is a Hero)/@comment-5795750-20160417234304

BG1's "I Have No Knowledge of Either Two But I'm Voting Anyway" Edge:

Based on what I've seen in this blog, I am actually convinced that Mami Tomoe actually wins this by a hair ribbon. I believe this is the case because Mami is actually bringing in the more versatile set of weapons - sure Mimori has more up her sleeve and brings in more actual weapons such as pistols, a sniper rifle and drones but methinks that switching between these weapons will actually cost Mimori time that Mami can easily exploit. Furthermore, Mami's ribbons are not only offensive in capability but also defensive and sure they may not stop a giant four-legged mech in its tracks completely but they will slow it down. The giant muskets with its variety of ammunition and amazing accuracy will also catch Mimori off guard as will the Tiro Finale.

Regarding X-Factors, I'm inclined to believe that Mami is definitely the more experience and battle-hardened of the two. Sure both combatants have suffered crippling mental and emotional blows but as you mentioned in Mami's bio these have been erased post-Rebellion leaving only her memories of fighting wicket witches and other such creatures within her magical realm. Mimori's PTSD however remains permanently etched into her mind and thus, as Cfp states, this will definitely hamper her in combat.

As a final note, I would like to say that I am under the presumption that Mimori, knowing full well about the effects of the Sange, will not push herself to the limit to see that Mami gets knocked out whereas Mami will not be quite so lax on Mimori (if that makes sense).