User blog comment:Cfp3157/Frank West vs. Nathan Drake/@comment-21025171-20161012022322

Waffle's "I Punched a Chicken" Edges

Melee: Frank gets the edge despite Drake's capability as a hand-to-hand combatant. However, Frank has a bat from the start plus can use whatever weapon he has to his advantage. He can get something really nasty like a machete or saw, or something to annoy Drake like a glass bottle or brick. It should be mentioned that Drake can use the same stuff West can pick up but Frank is more accustomed to using outlandish weapons and with a higher X-Factor rating in creativity he can find new ways to use them while Drake would fumble.

Edge: Frank West

Pistol: Same old comparision and the Beretta wins it. The 92FS has way more ammo to overwhelm Frank and can deliver more suppressing fire. Also assuming zombies are present then Drake can hold both them and Frank off while Frank has a chance of running a clip dry trying to hold off an enemy, living or dead.

Edge: Nathan Drake

Mid Range: Interesting comparison Cfp. The bold decision to give Frank a non-firearm weapon here does spark some debate considering how ineffective it is in sheer killing power, whereas a shotgun will simply blast a fucker to hell. But I'll actually call this even, as Drake's SAS has greater power but only has 16 shots so he'll need to make his shots count. On the other hand Frank's gun has more ammo and can hold off zombies more but doesn't bring as much raw damage.

Edge: Even

Long Range: I was going to give it to the AK at first but considering the sheer volume of the Mega Buster's ammo, it stacks up well against the Kalashnikov. The AK's fire travels faster but the Mega Buster is an energy weapon that'll destroy limbs from bodies while the AK will just pierce skin. Plus, I doubt Drake will expect Frank to bust out a weapon that fires that type of shot when it looks like a toy, so there's a surprise factor.

Edge: Frank West

Explosive: Grenades are actual explosives meant for combat while molotovs are improvised weaponry made on the fly. Yes the molotov can spread fire that'll distract and annoy Nate but the grenade kills much faster and does much more damage in a shorter time.

Edge: Nathan Drake

Special: Oh lord the Boomstick blows the WES out of the water. It's much more versatile with a bayonet in the form of a pitchfork and a much more powerful ammo as 12 gauge smashes .44 Magnum despite what Dirty Harry would say. Sully's iconic revolver is smaller and easier to hold but in the end it can't hold a candle to a shotgun.

Edge: Frank West

X-Factors: Frank West gets an average of 80 to Nathan's average of 83. Frank is more creative and more brutal, Drake is smarter and better physically, and both are evenly experienced.

Edge: Nathan Drake

Overall: TBD