User blog comment:GothamCityRiddler/The Governor vs Negan (Walking Dead Comic Series)/@comment-4392864-20140709020709

Crazy Dangerous To be honest, I haven't read anything past Volume 5 in the Comics - thank God for the Wikia. I'll do what I can, to figure out which psycho would kill the other.

Melee: Normally, I'd go with the machete, as it has a nice blade. However, when your main arm is lopped off, you can't get in a good swing. Negan has two good arms to swing his baseball bat with, smashing in the Governor's skull. Edge Negan.

Secondary Weapon - As the saying goes, you don't bring a knife to a gunfight, unless it's a ballistic knife. That being said, the Governor is missing his main arm. This will be very close. Edge Even

Assault Rifle - Old Debate, of sorts. Kalashnikov family versus the M16 family. However, in this case, M4A1 is more advanced than the AK-47, although comics aren't the best source to get exact firearms from. Edge Negan

Vehicles - A tank without Ammo versus a truck that can haul the squad. Umm, I don't see any real edges here, especially since a tank without rounds is not helpful in a fight. Edge Even

Better Leader - Both men scare me, but I think that Negan is even scarier, stronger, and physically more fit than the Governor. Edge Negan.

Better Men - To be honest, this will depend on the composition of the troops. Some are good, others aren't. Edge Even.

Winner - I got to go with Negan. He scares me more than the Governor, and that's just going by the Wikia description of him. I mean, he killed Glenn, just to terrorize Rick, while Rick was tied up. I mean, while the Governor killed several of Rick's people, Rick wasn't helpless at the time, meaning that the fight occurred practically right then, unless I'm confusing the TV with the Comic. But still, the guy's more scarier. Edge Negan