User blog comment:Leolab/User Siege Tourney, Round 8 of 91: Utter Noob (Celina) v Cfp3157 (Tian/Christian)/@comment-5465602-20130415194055

BeastMan and the edges live!

Attack Conditions:

Overrun Castle: Not Likely. Cfp's defenses are thick, making it difficult for Celina to close the distance.

Force Defender to surrender: Not Likely. Again, Cfp's defenses are thick, and he keeps morale high, likely keeping his men from wanting to surrender.

Win Single Combat: Impossible. Celina does not accept single combat.

Defender Condtions:

Force Attacker to Surrender: Possible. Celina's poor troop loyalty and difficulty getting last the defense could cause a rebellion.

Annihilate Attacker: Possible. Celina could not get last the defenses at all, and eventually get worn down to nothing.

Survive for 4 months: Possible. Celina's bombardment could go on a while, and if the assaults don't succeed, Tian's defensive may hold a while.

Win Single Combat: Not Possible due to Celina's refusal of single combat.

Tie Conditions:

One Side Meets Victory Conditions but loses their general: Not possible. Kenway won't die in defense of the fort due to how well defended it is, while Celina could die leading her assaults.

Both sides lose general: Not possible. See above.

Overall:

Kenway should win this. He's far more organzied, alongside having a more loyal army with extremely tight defenses.