User blog comment:123chaseyoung/Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson vs Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday/@comment-14624336-20140405075722

this is hard and my brain hurts

sherlok lacks long range weapons but he is intelligent and cunning enough to make it a game of hide and seek                                                                                                                                    but it should be noted that these guys use extreamly powerful weapons that only needs one accurate shot to end someone

Melee-sherloks riding crop is not going to workd against knives but his martial arts can allow him to disarm opponents.watsons cane sword is longer than the knife

EDGE-Sherlok and watson

Side arm- This is a matter of who shoots first and who can shoot faster.Sherlok's webley lacks those abilities.Watson has a decent fire arm and Wyatts one is decent too but it is single action.

EDGE-Doc gets this one for having two pistols with diffrent abilities giving him more options and rounds

Main-pepper box is powerful at extreamly close ranges but still it can't match rifles or shotguns

EDGE-gewerh 1888 is more accurate and easier to reload giving watson the edge

I give my vote to sherlok and watson.with sherloks intelligence and overpowerd short range pistols with watsons military experiance,training and decent weapons they can win