User blog comment:Greenberet69/Altair vs Aragorn/@comment-5078776-20120506025017

For close range, I have to vote for Aragorn's dagger. It seems more versatile than Altair's Short Blade. However, in the movies I rarely saw him using it. So it gets a 67 to the Short Blade's 33.

For mid range, the edge goes to Aragorn again because his sword is simply longer and just as quick as the Sword of Altair. So it gets 89 to the Sword of Altair's 11.

For long range, come on. A bow vs some knives. Aragorn edge with a 95 to the throwing knives 5.

For special weapons, the edge goes to the hiddnen blade. It may not be as versatile, Altair has more expierience with his weapon compared to the throwing dagger. So the edge is Hidden Blade 79 to the Throwing Dagger's 21.

I agree with most ex-factors but the swordsman skills. Aragorn's blade is heavier but he wields just as fast as Altair's. He gets a 94 while Altair gets a 95.

My edge still goes to Altair. He is slightly more skilled and versatile, while Aragorn is mainly a swordsman.