User blog comment:Wassboss/Rebel Scum Empirical Gains and a Cunning Plan: Captain Blackadder's Men vs Dutch's Gang./@comment-17814994-20160401172458

Elgb's "Mr. Bean had a mustahce? WOAH!" EDGES!!!

Melee: I can't say which one is better. The bowie knife does have the larger blade and that nasty clip point to do more damage, and it can be thrown too. The bayonet on the other hand is longer, more versatile and has the range advantage. EA did once said that a bayonet wasn't the best weapon for trench warfare at taht time. But I don't know, seems both weapons were effective at their respective timelines. EDGE: Even

Sidearm: I have to disagree with Milen on this one. Power maybe essential but you have to remember that the Colt Peacemaker is ganrly a big obsolete weapon even for early 20th century standards. It takes a frigging minute to reload, is single-action, and is so bastardly unreliable that cowboys actually only load 5 bullets instead of 6 to prevent it from suddenly firing out of nowhere. The Webley revolver only has a mint of difference in terms of pwoer, and it also have the more advanced top-break mechanism that allows it to eject spent casing faster and reload it quicker. Basically, if Dutch empties his pistol he absically loses it, while Blackadder can just eject his casings and relaod quickly to get back in the fight. EDGE: Blackadder

Rifle: No contest. While the WInchester can fire faster, the Enfield has over twice the range, twice the pwoer and can be reloaded faster. EDGE: Blackadder

Machine Guns: While the Maxim Gun has the advantage in range, the Browning trumps it at everything else. The american machine gun itself was designed to be successor to the old maxim. The Browning is water cooled to prevent overheating of the barrel so Blackadder doesn't need to chang ebarrels everytime, it has the bigger caliber and muzzle velocity, and for me its open bolt is better than the maxim's swinging bolt because it doesn't pick up much grit, making the browning undoubtedly more reliable. EDGE: Blackadder

Deadliest Warrior?

Inconclusive for now. I'm still not sure which warrior will trump the other. Blackadder team seem to have the better and more advanced weapons and training while Dutch has the edge in brutality, experience and marksmanship skills. I'll edit this as soon as others put their own opinions.