User blog:Greenberet5/George Custer vs.George Pickett

GEORGE CUSTER: Cavalry general famous for his last stand

VS

GEORGE PICKETT: Confederate general who led the I'll fated charge at Gettysburg

WHO....IS....DEADLIEST?!!!

Custers Men and Weapons
Men: 7th Cavalry

Carbine: 1855 Colt Revolving Rifle

Special Weapons: Derringer

Revolver: Colt Single Action Army

Rifle: 1873 Trapdoor Springfield w. bayonet

Sword: Calvary Saber







Pickett's Men & Weapons
Men: Confederate Army

Carbine: Sharps Carbine

Special Weapons: Arkansas Toothpick

Revolver: 1858 New Army Revolver

Rifle: 1853 Enfield Rifle Musket w. bayonet

Sword: Officers Sword







X-Factors
George Custer           George Pickett

83 Tactics 89

Edge: Pickett; while both lost their most famous battle, there is one different; Pickett came out alive, and Custer did not.



84 Troops 62


 * Edge: Custer; the Confederates are a rag tag group, while the 7th were trained professionals.

82 Calm Under Fire 75

Again with their troops. The Rebels could retreat with notthing Pickett can do to stop it

Battle Notes

 * Two genrals leading 9 men ( 2 horseback/ 7 infantry).
 * Will take place in a grassland area ( Very similar to the setting in Pancho Villa vs. Crazy Horse.
 * Sides have unlimited ammo
 * Indians will be involved

Voting
Vote on the weapons and who would win. Saturday I will tally the votes and on Sunday I shall finish the battle.

Personal Edge
My personal edge goes to Custer for having more experince and better weapons