User blog comment:JGM007/S1, E1: French Knight VS Scottish Highlander/@comment-5078776-20120927000258

Cfp3157's "This is just.....unfair" edges:

Close: The Broadsword has range, speed, and versatility under its belt, which gives it the edge over the short, restricted War Hammer. Edge: Knight

Mid Range: The Claymore is a devastating weapon, but its great size makes it slow and unworthy to wield when the Knight closes the distance with his Broadsword. The Halberd may be smaller, but it has an advantage in speed by being made of more wood than steel. Edge: Knight

Long Range: The Crossbow has range and accuracy. Edge: Knight

Special: Both weapons have problems. The Morningstar is a heavy, slow, and can cause damage to the user, while the Targe and Dirk can't get past the plate armor of the Knight. Edge: Even

Armor: The plate armor may be heavy, but it is like Spartan armor on steroids. It can protect from slashes, thusts, and pierces. The chainmail just can't compete. Edge: Knight

Winner: Do I even need to say this? The Knight is better protected, has better weapons, and has better training. The French Knight will kill the Highlander and make him Haggus.