User blog comment:Thornclaw Braveheart/Thorin Oakenshield vs. Roran Stronghammer/@comment-24180428-20130219234320

Utter noob's "Noob sword" edges:

Short range-I'm gonna go with the axe due to better killing abilitiy. Edge Thorin

Medium range-The spear has a range advantage over the sword, allowing it to kill without putting the user at risk. Edge Roran

Long range-Since Thorin hardly uses his bow, I am giving Roran the edge thanks to better bow experiance. Edge Roran

SPecial-Steel/iron is more powerful then a wooden shield. Edge Roran

Winner-I say Roran wins due to better ranged weapons and a more powerful shield.