User blog comment:Greenberet69/Last Battle 2 of 9: Alvin York vs. John Marston/@comment-5195329-20120823001309

+Pistol: The 1911 is semi-auto (the S&W M3 is single action), uses box mags, and has 1 more round. York also got famous for being able to defend so well with the 1911. So ya... EDGE-YORK.

+Rifle: This is pretty close, the enflied and the winchester have about the same round capacity. Winchester is faster but the enfield has a rifle round and larger range. The flater round of the winchester might help close up though, it could help. I'll say EDGE-EVENish.

+Mach: The BAR can be carried easily, fired from the shoulder and uses box mags. The gatling is gonna be hard to operate and move one person and too big to really get a lock on one person. EDGE-YORK.

+X-Factors: York is a trained soldier and was able to keep insanely smart under fire. In this case I think terrain will be outdone. EDGE-YORK.

+OVERALL: Winner-York, x-factors and weapons, York should take this.