User blog comment:Richard Starkey/Jack Marston Vs. Colton "Cole" White/@comment-143604-20110605193526

Close Range- Colton White. The tomahawk has more reach and can be thrown as well, giving it more versitality and making it a better weapon from a tactical standpoint.

Medium Range- Colton White. I'm not going to lie, I'm kind of biased here, because I don't know much about western weapons, but I love revolvers.

Long Range- Jack Marston. The Winchester is the gun that won the West for a reason. In fact, the Winchester could easily change the whole course of the battle in Jack's favor.

Explosives- Colton White. The Molotov is deadlier and more reliable, at least in comparison to the Dynamite available during the time period. Plus, the molotov can spread and turn the battlefield into living hell.

Special- TIE. I honostly can't figure this one out.

EDGE- While my weapon choices would say Colton White, I'm giving the overall to Jack. Jack has training from one of the single most bada*s cowboys from the West, plus he has Dead Eye. Unless Dead Eye is negated for this battle, as it's a gameplay element, not a story element. Please note whether or not Dead Eye is applicable here or not, thank you.