User blog comment:El Alamein/Highlander vs. Huskarl/@comment-5257934-20120809025036

Right time for edges,

Close Range: The longsword is longer and more powerful, edge Saxon

Mid Range: The Claymore is much longer, and its shown some serious kill ability, edge Highlander

Special: I don't know how to compare the knives, so their even

Armor, the chainmail and shields are the same, but the saxon has a helmet

The Saxon would win due to their better close range, and a helmet, coupled with even knives