User blog comment:Weew1213/Dementor vs Ringwraith "Soul Sucking Demons" (Season 1 Finale and Halloween Special)/@comment-17814994-20151015110507

Elgb's "Foul Creatures of the Night" EDGES!!!

Offensive: The dementor's kiss is a powerful attack but it can only be effective against someone whose still alive, and the Nazgul is already dead so it won't do shit. But wait Elgb? Doesn't the dementor's kiss suck one's soul? And the Nazgul are basically ghost so they can be sucked as well? Well no. There's a clear difference to what a Nazgul and a ghost in LotR mythos are. The Nazgul aren't entirely spirits, they are spectral, but are shadows able to do magic. Aside from their kisses, the dementors have nothing else to give, though they can fly. The Nazgul on the other hand, have magic and their dark spectral powers with them. And I'm gonna disagree with your stats Weew, the Nazgul's weapons aren't normal in my opinion. In Desolation of Smaug, they look and feel spectral as themselves, and were magically powerful enough to take on Galadriel. EDGE: Nazgul

Defensive: Both these beings are powerful. The Nazgul in particular can only be killed or driven off by magic, fire and "Prophesy". Dementor's on the other hand are virtually unkillable, with no mortal weapons or magic that can kill them. However, they have one clear weakness. And that's their relaince on their victim's positive emotion to survive. Without it they become weak and useless. The Nazgul have no positive emotions for the dementors to feed to. EDGE: Nazgul

X-Factors: The Dementors are nothing more than ghouls. They don't think, or have any clear goals in mind. So they're basically animals in nature. The Nazgul can think and strategize for they were great tactical men at their time. They too have more experience in fights and wars to combat the more instict-based Dementors. EDGE: Nazgul

Deadliest Warrior?

Although the Dementors are more faster and durable (and unkillable) but they have nothing to attack the Nazgul with because their main and only weapon of the kiss won't affect them. And the Nazgul's powers of Black Breath won't do shit as well, they do have their more powerful magic to help them. The Nazgul too are stronger and smarter than the dementors. And if the battle lasts too long, the dementors would have starved to keep them going due to the lack of emotion and fear to power them.