User blog comment:Tomahawk23/John Marston VS Cole Phelps/@comment-1017446-20110808021939

Omnicube1's Cubeliest Edges

Close Range: For the revolvers, my edge goes to Phelps' M1917 Detective. It may fire a smaller round, but its double action. The Schofield revolver does pack that power, but it's slow firing rate makes it the weaker revolver. For the semi-automatic pistols, edge to the Colt M1911 for firing the larger .45 ACP. Also, this pistol is pretty much an upgrade to the M1903. Edge: Cole Phelps

Mid Range: The Browning Auto-5 may be semi-auto, but it lacks the range to beat the pump-action Ithaca 37. Well Phelps is carrying a semi-automatic submachine gun....and Marston still has that shotgun. Edge: Phelps

Long Range: The Carcano is pretty much Marston's only effective long range weapon that still falls short to the M1 Garand and the BAR. For two reasons: 1.) it's a bolt action so it's easily outclassed by the semi-auto capabilities of both the M1 and the BAR, which can also fire in full-automatic; 2.) The round fired by the Carcano is notorious for its lack of killing power. The bullet was so slender, the wound it inflicts is just a clean through, no major tears or anything. It wounded more soldiers than it killed. The Henry rifle is a joke compared to the big boys Phelps is carrying. It fires such a small round and it lacks the rate of fire. Edge: Cole Phelps

Special: Baton can't kill in one blow, unless you're really lucky and place one hard blow across the middle of the forehead or on the top of the spine. The tomahawk and the bowie knife will easily kill at a faster rate. Edge: John Marston

Explosive weapons: Hmmm....Phelps doesn't have any in this category. So I guess...Edge: John Marston

The Deadliest Warrior: Cole Phelps, his weapons are much to advanced for Marston. The cowboy's only weapons that will harm the cop is the Carcano rifle and the high-powered pistol. All of Phelps' weapons will dominate over Marston's, except for the baton. 800-200