User blog comment:Ekreture/Roger's Rangers vs. Dahomey Amazons/@comment-5538194-20140823010342

'Ethan's "You wassup DaHOMEY?" Edges'

Melee-The tomahawk is multi-purposed, being used for hacking and throwing, making it a more valuable asset to the pinned down warrior. The throwing use of the tomahawk could be crucial while the ranger's gun needs to be reloaded.

EDGE: Roger's Rangers

Mid Range-While you could argue the flintlock takes a long time to reload, it's killing power and range outmatch it's primitive counterpart. Black powder will ususally outdo wood and steel.

EDGE: Roger's Rangers

Musket-These weapons are pretty similar. Both take a substancial time to reload, and have relativively similar effective ranges. It comes down to skill here, and I personally believe the Amazons to be better sharpshooters due to their training in the jungle and using the terrin as an advantage.

EDGE: Amazons

Special-The club is a versatile weapon. It can be thrown and used to bludgeon, but the bayonet just has more killing potential. Its also used on the end of a lethal firearm, so it can be used in between shots, making it easily accessible.

EDGE: Roger's Rangers

WINNER: ROGER'S RANGERS!