User blog comment:Facetheslayer/Richard Harrow (Boardwalk Empire) v. John Marston (Red Dead Redemption)/@comment-5465602-20160115221118

BeastMan14's "" Edges

Melee: Even. I think both these weapons have interesting advantages to them. While Richard's is certainly more versatile in an actual melee fight, being capable of both stabbing and punching, John's Tomahawk could be a devastating one-hit kill that Harrow might not expect, assuming he can land the hit.

TBF