User blog comment:Greenberet5/George Custer vs.George Pickett/@comment-162.204.29.43-20140807171403

Men: Pickett because while the 7th had better training, the Confeferacy had numbers and expeince.

Edge: Pickett

Carbines: Pickett because the Sharps is more modern and holds more rounds.

Edge: Pickett

Revolver: The SAA is modern and lengendary

Edge: Custer

Special: The Arkansas toothpick is badass

Edge: Pickett

Rifles: the Springfield is newer, and therefore better

Edge: Custer

Swords: The officers sword can be used on both foot and horseback.

Edge: Pickett

Winner: Pickett because he had numbers and training at West Point