User blog comment:LB&SCR/Unknown Tales of Private Investigations: Pinkerton National Detective Agency vs. Baldwin-Felts Detective Agency/@comment-4392864-20150816164624

Detective Stories Melee: Clip Point Knife Versus Maxam Knife. Knives are usually the same. I don't see any real difference. However, the Clip Point has an extra few inches, meaning it will get in quicker. Edge: Pinkerton

Sidearm: Colt Model 1851 Navy Revolver versus Smith & Wesson Model 3. The S&W carries a bigger round than the Colt. Edge: Baldwin-Felts

Rifle 1: Henry Repeating Rifle versus Winchester Model 1886. While the '86 is a newer model than the Henry, the Henry carries more rounds. Edge: Pinkerton

Rifle 2: Spencer Rifle versus Sharps Rifle. Sharps rifle usually only has one shot, compared to the seven from the Spencer. Edge: Pinkerton

Shotgun: Coach Gun versus Colt Model 1878. Both are basically the same. Edge: Even

Deadliest Warrior: Over all, I feel that the Pinkertons will beat the Baldwin-Felts. They have the experience, and intimidation needed to get the other group to "back down from the Job". Winner: Pinkerton National Detective Agency