User blog comment:El Alamein/French Revolutionary Militia vs. American Minutemen/@comment-5078776-20120820231928

Cfp3157's "SO PISSED THAT I LOST!!" edges:

Close Range #1: Bayonet vs Crude Club- The Bayonet get s the edge to me because of the fact that, while the club can provide lethal damage, the bayonet can be used in mid range by attaching it to the Bess and close range as an improvised knife. Edge: Minutemen

Close Range #2: Fish Hook vs Tomahawk- Let's see. A tiny little hook that can abrely reach out in front of you versus a lethal hand-held axe that can hack and be thrown. Obvious. Edge: Minutemen

Close Range #3: Dagger vs Iroqoius knife- I can't give an edge because I don't know the Dagger's potential, so even. Edge: Even

Mid Range: I like the Colichmarde because it was built to counter calvary sabers and has a nasty thrust, but the Cutlass isn't a calvary saber and can slash and thrust. Edge: Militia

Long Range: Both are extremely inaccurate muskets, but the slightly bigger musket ball of the Bess and the slightly faster rate of fire, (depends on the user. Average 3 to 4 ompared to the 1777's regular 3.) wins the edge to me. Edge: Minutemen

Special: I am unsure if scattershot is involved. I will not vote on this category.

Overall Edge: The Minutemen fought a well-supplied army of British Redcoats, compared to the French Militia's poorly equiped French Army, who had spent more money helping the Americans and were ill prepared for French Militia. This makes my edge lean over to the Minutemen slightly. Winner: American Minutemen