User blog comment:Pygmy Hippo 2/Ancient Terror Part 1:William Afton (Five Nights at Freddy's) vs. Alfred Drevis (Mad Father)/@comment-3189283-20191002104016

Let’s see shall we

Leader

In terms of the weapons they are carrying I’m giving the edge to William. A scalpel is a poor weapon and I don’t think it will make it through William’s costume and while the Chainsaw is better in that regard it’s loud noise and need for gas to be effective are real drawbacks especially since Alfred doesn’t seem sane enough to use it conservatively to save ammo. The Kitchen Knife is not a great weapon by any means but it has a further reach than the Scalpel at least and doesn’t rely on gas to be used like the Chainsaw. The Springbonnie Suit William is wearing appears to give him a big boost to his physical capabilities and this helps make his kitchen knife all the more effective.

Edge: William Afton

Minions

Pretty obvious edge for the Animatronics. They tower over the normal human sized dolls and are physically stronger and more durable as well owing to them being made of metal rather than sown together human body parts and plastic. The Dolls do have weapons to deal damage with but this still requires them getting up close to use them, right within range of the sharp teeth and spikes of the animatronics. The impassable invisible barrier one of them can create could help protect Alfred or themselves but it doesn’t really help them offensively as again they need to get close to be able to damage them.

Edge: William Afton

Final Verdict 

William Afton should win this pretty easily. Looking at the X Factors it’s clear we’re not looking at two highly skilled warriors here, just a pair of lunatics with a love of creating a bunch of fucked up minions. Neither have much experience outside of murdering innocent people and while both are clearly intelligent this doesn’t translate into their fighting style. That leaves physicality which as I’ve discussed I think William has the advantage in because of his Springbonnie Suit. His minions are also much better because they were designed to be used in a combat role (well to stalk and kill people but you get the idea) whereas the Dolls were created mainly for Alfred’s obsession with beauty and so are unsuited for an actual fight. William has the better minions and the better weapon so logically he wins this fight.

William Afton: 4,500

Alfred Drevis: 500