User blog comment:Battlefan237/Tony Montana vs, The Penguin ( comics)/@comment-5795750-20170906235353

BG1's "Say Hello to My Little Friend!" Edges:

Melee: Yeah this is pretty much a standard knife vs spear/ballistic knife/throwing knife/knife comparison - Penguin's knife is definitely the more versatile one though I must say that once you throw that knife you have to be sure you can get it back (pretty much the downside of all throwing weapons really)

EDGE: Penguin

Pistol: Well the Beretta has more rounds in the magazine but... *EA's voice whispers in my head* the M1911's larger and deadlier bullet cancels this out. DAMN YOU EA!

EDGE: Even

SMG: Tommy gun wins out there. Hear me out, yes the MAC-10 may be the more modern and compact gun which can definitely bring out a degree of surprise on the field but the Tommy gun is definitely more controllable (since Tony and his men will be more trigger-happy and thus more likely to waste bullets) and it has the bigger magazine.

EDGE: Penguin

Assault Rifle: More modern, more controllable rate of fire, greater range and bigger magazine... Penguin's AK-74 definitely has the better stats and quality over Tony's 1970s-era relic.

EDGE: Penguin

Special: Shield vs grenades, hmm? Well for all the benefits that Penguin's gadget-laden umbrellas have, using a grenade launcher means you can launch explosives from a further distance than the flamethrower or shotgun can reach, plus the grenades can be launched at a place beside or around the shield to deal the Penguin some indirect/collateral damage. Yes I will admit that the reload time for Tony will be a pain but at least the M203 is attached to the assault rifle meaning he has two weapons in one while Penguin needs to switch umbrellas

EDGE: Tony

X-Factors: Average of 87.6 for Tony; Average of 81.9 for the Penguin

EDGE: Tony

Overall Winner: Here's the problem with most battles involving the Penguin - as evidenced by other battles featuring him (as well as looking at his track record in the comics), the Penguin is more of a planner than an actual fighter... except you actually managed to find some scans that shows how Penguin is proficient with his weapons so I'll grant you that. Given this and given how Scarface portrayed the combat finesse (or lack thereof) of Tony Montana, I will have to give this match to the Penguin. Did I also mention that Cobblepot's gang are more loyal, more clear-headed and more skilled on the gun that Tony's drug-addicted cronies?