User blog comment:Jackythejack/No Normal World Anymore: Katniss vs Rick Grimes/@comment-379205-20191215004421

'''119s's "This is the Future, Get a Gun!" Edges'''


 * Ranged: The bow and arrow is certainly a powerful weapon in the hands of a skilled user, as is the Colt Python. In terms of effective range, the bow might have at least a slight edge, depending on the environment, but the revolver take the edge in terms of rate of fire, muzzle velocity (it is possible to dodge an arrow, but not a bullet), stopping power, and ease of use. In the arena, I see situations where both the bow and the revolver might have the advantage arising. For this reason, I call this one Edge: Even- Situation Dependent


 * Melee: The axe has more weight and is slightly longer than the knife, while still be relatively light, giving it an advantage over the knife. Edge: Rick Grimes


 * X-Factors: With the training from the rebellion, Katniss takes training, however Rick takes experience as he has been fighting and surviving for longer against a wide variety of foes. In terms of physicality, Katniss may be more agile, but Rick is physically stronger and has a decent pain tolerance and endurance given that he has survived injuries such as being sent flying from an explosion. As for marksmanship, this one is more difficult, as Katniss has fired further, but Rick has some extremely impressive precision shots, like blowing off a man's finger. Overall though, I'll give training and marksmanship to Katniss, and experience and physicality to Rick Edge: Even


 * Overall Winner: Rick Grimes scrapes out a narrow victory against Katniss thanks to the higher muzzle velocity and rate of fire of his gun, as well as he greater combat experience and physicality.