User blog comment:Samurai234/The Baldwin–Felts Detective Agency vs. The Untouchables/@comment-3239346-20110617204643

The Deadliest Warrior, Jr.'s Jr. Edges:

For close range the Remington holds a larger caliber bullet, and with two similar pistols stopping power matters, so edge Baldwin-fetts.

Mid Range I don't care about sharp-shooting bullcrap or whatever because the thompson holds way more rounds and has a faster rate of fire as well as greater range so Edge Untouchables

In shotgun mid-range it's even both are good shotguns and it's really no difference between the two.

In long range I give the edge to the springfield. It's the more modern gun with better upgrades and designs, and it has a far longer range than the winchester. Edge: Untouchables

For close range the Maxam Knife gets the Edge it has the longer blade than the Knuckle Duster and even punching won't help in a knife fight. Edge: Baldwin-Fetts

In explosives the Pineaple Grenade gets the edge it might not have as big a boom but it's more portable, and you can hold multiple grenades on you at once much easier than carrying multiple TNT charges on you at once. Edge: untouchable.

Overall Winner: The Untouchables

They're bringing the better weaponry range-for-range, sans close, but that won't matter because the Baldwin-Fetts won't ever get that close. This is not sharpshooting vs. spray-and-pray. This is people who are accurate with six-shooters vs. peole who are accurate with tommy guns. That's right people, TOMMY GUN DOES NOT EQUAL NO AIMING! So basically, better guns in a gunfight equals a win.