User blog comment:Dargoo Faust/Mid-Season Special! Geralt of Rivia vs. Talion/@comment-83.10.3.2-20160305133728

Ok, so:

Primary Weapon

Geralt's sword is longer and heavier. This allows him to strike stronger blows from loger distance. Talion's blade is slightly lighter, allowing him to strike a little bit faster. Witchers sword is made with special technique, making it much more durable and sharper than regular sword, that Talion beras. According to books, witcher's swords can cut through such swords with no problem.

Edge: Geralt

Secondary Weapon

Geralt's silver sword is much longer and heavier than Talion's broken sword, allowing witcher to strike more devastating blows from longer distance.

Edge: Geralt

Long Range Weapon

Talion's bow has better rate of fire than Geralt's crossbow and due to Elven Shots packs a punch. Although long range weapons are useless in this fight as both warriors can avoid it.

Edge: Talion

Magic/Extra

Most of Talion's magic are useless against Geralt, as the witcher can block them with Quen sign and is highly resistant to potions. On the other hand, Talion lacks defensive magic. Also, Geralt's boms pack a lot of power, that can be devastating against almost unarmored Talion. Even Talion's Invicibility is wouldn't help him, because of GEralt's enhanced senses, mainly hear and smell.

Edge: Geralt

Armor

Geralt's armor is more protective and durable than Talion's leather armor, due to witcher's chainmall elements.

Edge: Geralt

X-factor:

Geralt's 86 vs Talion's 85,2. Close on, but goes to Geralt.

Edge: Geralt

Overall

Talion holds a long range advantage, but Geralt holds everything else. He has more destructive short-range weapons, better armor and more balanced spells. On the other hand, Talion has lighter, but smaller and less durable short-range weaponary, only ofensive spells and almost no armor. Also, Geralt is fast enough to dodge  point-blink bow shot. Geralt wins, mostly due to his better defence, capable of stopping everything, that Talion can throw against him.

WINNER: GERALT