User blog comment:WanderingSkull/The Road Less Traveled: Doomguy vs. Master Chief/@comment-5931345-20140727114932

Melee: Chainsaw no doubt. The knife has its advantages like its lightweight, concealment, and throwability. But its too small against a frigging chainsaw that is powerful enought to penetrate a high ranking demon's hide with ease. Forget the fist, chainsaw gets the edge. Doomguy can pin Chief and rip him to shreds. Edge: Doomguy

Sidearms: I HATE THE 9mm. I've never been impressed by it. It has such weak penetration, weak muzzle velocity, and weak mass body. I give the edge to the magnum because of its bigger size, and in a battle of body armor, power is more important than numbers when trying to penetrate. 9mm ain't gonna do shit against Chief armor. Chief's magnum too (believe or not) can actually be used to snipe using Chief's zoom in capability. Edge: MC

Shotgun: ITS NO CONTEST HERE. 9 gauge gets curbstomp x10000 by the solekraft (wrong spelling I know). I've seen what the solekraft ,38 ammunation can do. That thing is strong enough to blow a man's torso in half, and can rip a cocunut tree in two. Edge: MC

Automatic: LIKE I SAID THE 9MM IS A PIECE OF SHIT. I've never been impressed by it. Its so frigging weak. I've seen a present day Type 2 body armor able to tank a 9mm MP5 full auto with little damage. The only thing that's goo about the 9mm nowadays is its ergonomics and cheapness. Shit, I hardly doubt a 9mm will penetrate Chief's armor, EVEN IF ITS IN A FRIGGING CHAIN GUN. I myself hate the MA5C, but its no doubt has the longer range, better accuracy, and more powerful damage and penetration DUE TO USING RIFLE ARMOR THAN A BS 9mm PISTOL AMMO. Edge: MC

Ubers: Although Chief has tanked some powerful energy weapons, I have to go with the BFG. That thing is a monster, and has a faster rate of fire. Edge: Doomguy

Explosives: I have to go with CHief on this one. MC's rocket launcher has a scope for targetting and has a faster rate of firing. Doomguy's rocket launcher is slow, he can outrun his rockets like a chump. Chief's launcher is also more accurate. Edge: Chief

X-Factors:  In terms of strength I'm divided. Doomguy is strong enough to rip humans apart and kill the devil by punching it in the balls (HEHE). In terms of speed, Doomguy somehow is faster, but in agility, Chief has it due to jumping high and doing effective combat rolls. But in terms of experience and intelligence on the other hand, Chief gets it. I resepct Doomguy for destroying Hell a couple of times and killing its master, but most of the time he kills melee using (and sometime) unarmed demons and weakling. Chief on the other hand, is far smarter due to ACTUALLY planning than just rushing in like Doomguy. He also has faster reflexes due to his supersoldier augmentation, and has durability too boot where his bones are superhumanly strong. Chief also has the advantages of fighting smart and capable alien warriors like the Covenant and Didact, fight off mindless universe-destroying flood, and even fightng his own kind during the ressurection. Edge: Chief

Winner: Master Chief. Although Doomguy is a strong person, and has the better melee and uber weapons. He flunks out due to using outdated and low penetration weapons (9 gauge and 9mm are weak in Chief's universe). While Chief uses far more technologically weapons and armor. His armor has shields, something Doomguy hasn't and will take some time to get through.Top of that, Chief's got the better training, better augmentation, smarter. All Doomguy does is rush in and go rambo and everything and everyone. Though it works well in his unvierse, I believe CHief can outwit, outmaneuver, outsmart, and outgun Doomguy's berserkeness.