User blog comment:Urbancommando77/Theodore Roosevelt VS Pancho Villa/@comment-4661256-20120301040928

Let's look at the warriors and see who would win:

Looking at the Bolo Knife and the Bowie Knife, the Bolo Knife is basically a machete and the Bowie Knife, is just a big nasty knife. The machete is longer and has a greater psychological effect especially if you're charging a machete-wielder with a smaller blade. Edge: Pancho Villa

When you're talking about the rifles it's looking at a bolt-action vs. a lever-action, but I like the lever-action's faster rate of fire. But, it can only hold 7 rounds and I think the stripper clip puts in 10, and the stripper clip is way faster to reload. Accuracy seems greater with the bolt-action rifle, but it's too close to call looking at these predecessors to the semi-automatic gun. Edge: Even

For the machine guns/long range, both of these guns require a four-man crew and that's gonna eat up manpower, but both of the sides will have this disadvantage. According to Wikipedia, they are the exact same size, which I don't really buy but they're both on wheels so mobility must be around equal. Still, the Maxim is the more modern system and I think that the Gatling gun vs. the Vickers was bullcrap. The more modern gun wins here because it's got improvements that the Gatling gun lacks. The Gatling gun is the forerunner to the machine gun. The Maxim IS a machine gun. Edge: Pancho Villa

Medical supply is useless in a six-on-six, whoever's injured is gonna die because Pancho or Teddy isn't gonna let the other walk over to camp to patch up a friend.

Teddy Roosevelt gets my vote - even though I hate the Gatling Gun, it comes down to true military experience, and Teddy is a general and a politician while Pancho is just a rebel. He takes his experience from true combat, while Teddy has actual combat plus formal training to back him and his men up. They won't back down under Teddy's ferociously inspiring leadership whereas Villa's men might break and run. I think our former president Theodore Roosevelt has this in the bag.