User blog comment:Lasifer/Fallout User Tourney: Arrow vs. Sabre/@comment-4541447-20120810204654

So-Pro THE WARRIOR's Edges

Melee Jack Cobb (Arrow)-The Katana has a longer reach then the Death Claw.

Close Range James (Saybee)- The Colt M1911 has a larger round and can reload faster.

Mid Range Jack Cobb (Arrow)- Let's see an old cowboy era Carbine or a more modern firearm? Yeah the more modern weapon can can fire faster, and reload faster gets this.

Long Range Even- Same gun same everything

Explosive James (Saybee)- Grenade Launcher barely gets this against the powerful blast that all of those explosives combined will do.

The Deadliest Warrior: Jack Cobb- He takes the important edges in Melee and Long Range as he has the more modern Long Range Gun and the longer reaching Melee weapon.