User blog comment:Leolab/User Siege Tourney, Round 5 of 91: Utter Noob (Celina) v Redkite (Markus)/@comment-422690-20130326172842

I've finally created a set format for how I'm going to vote on these. Feel free to copy it if you want; it's pretty much guaranteed a full vote, unless your explanation sucks.

Attacker Victory Conditions:

1) Overrun Castle: Condition failed. Not only does Celina have no siege weaponry, Markus can keep her out. There will also be no deserters for her to take advantage of, while she will have trouble keeping her own army together to be able to mass an attack.

2) Force Surrender: Condition failed. Since she hasn't got a strategy for her cavalry, which utilized properly could cut off supply lines. On top of that, she will face a massive deserter problem - something that won't be a problem for Markus.

3) Win Single Combat: Condition failed. Single combat will not be possible with Celina.

Defender Victory Conditions:

1) Force Surrender: Condition achieved. Celina's deserter problem, along with the devastating trebuchet, can easily force her to surrender. She won't have a choice.

2) Annihilate attacker: Condition achieved. That tesudo formation will make her men easy pickings for the catapult. And yet again with the deserter problem - she won't be able to keep up an attack for long.

3) Survive: Condition achieved. Markus can easily withstand Celina's attacks.

4) Single Combat: Condition failed. No single combat in this match.

Tie Conditions:

1) Win, but loses general: Condition failed. Markus is not going to die, and Celina is not going to win. Not by a long shot.

2) Double kill: Condition failed. Markus is pretty much untouchable for this fight.

Overall tally:

Attacker: 0

Defender: 3

Tie: 0

Markus wins.