User blog comment:SPARTAN 119/Nanoha Takamachi (Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha) vs Akemi Homura (Puella Magi Madoka Magica)/@comment-99.246.172.232-20120103150211

I'll have to say Nanoha will win the battle. without the Time manipulation magic, Homura will be in a hell of disadvantage. She has less agility and just uses conventional weapon. While Nanoha will have access to extreme powered magic. All the time hit and run, surprise attack tactics of Homura are done with time manipulation. I don't really think she can drag Nanoha into her trap too (like what she did with Walpurgis). Without that she might resort to hiding and shooting from afar with rifles, which is easy enough for Nanoha to reflect with Protection Magic. Rocket spam pretty much can't happen without time manipulation. Remember that rocket launchers can only be shot once each. So rate of fire is considered low enough. The moment the rocket missed Nanoha, Nanoha could just go 'Divine Buster' and blow Homura away. Even if Nanoha lacks killing intent, she'll just incapacitate Homura easily. Not to mention that Raising Heart is an intelligent device that protects Nanoha too.