User blog comment:BeastMan14/Judge Dredd vs The Predator/@comment-5232784-20121130020621

1. Strength

Judge Dredd is a powerful dude, but against a Predator, he's not even on wuss level. Predators can grab your spine and rip it, your skull and pelvis out of your body, no problem. If Judge Dredd strength rating is 85, then the Pred's should be perhaps 20 times that number (they can go toe-to-toe with Xenomorphs, and in the novel Predator:Turnabout, they can withstand the paw swipe of a Alaskan Brown Bear (they get 1200 lbs. However, the Preds were not as strong as the bear, only able to withstand the blow and subsequent flight through the air without suffering severe damage).

EDGE: Predator

2. Brutality

Judge Dredd, like Dirty Harry, kills a heck of a lot of crooks. And he's brutal in his quick judgments, no mercy.

Predators, however, will kill even children or grannies wielding real weapons, and either remove their skulls or even their spines and pelvises as well (pelvis is a rarer part of the body for them to take, but as shown in Predator 2, it can and does happen). In the Batman-Pred crossovers, this brutality can even extend to dogs that try to protect their masters from Predators (the dogs are strung up like their masters).

Edge: Predators

3. Killer instinct

Though Dredd is a killer, he's also a Lawman, not a soldier. He's a peacekeeper, not a peacemaker.

Predators have a warrior society, and are hunters, striving for the perfect kill.

Edge: Predators

4. Experience

Both Judge Dredd and the Predators are experienced fighters, but Dredd has never, ever fought a Pred. Predators, however, are more than experienced fighting humans: while Dredd wont know what he's fighting, the Predator shall.

Edge: Predator

I VOTE PREDATORS