User blog comment:Guitarcar/Sheriff Hoyt vs Gunnery sergeant Hartman/@comment-27043000-20180907184752

Pygmy Hippo's "Will TCM finally stop losing?" Edges

Melee:The Baton is longer and lighter than the KA-BAR Knife but is less lethal. Edge:Hoyt

Sidearm:I would like to say that the revolver Hoyt uses is a Ruger Vaquero and that is what I will be comparing to Hartman's Colt M1911. The revolver has a more powerful round but it's got less rounds and is slower than the pistol. Edge:Hartman

Primary:The shotgun that Hoyt uses is actually a Winchester Model 1912 and that's what I will be comparing to the M14. The shotgun has more power but the rifle has more rounds, a longer range, and is faster to fire. Edge:Hartman

X-Factors:Sheriff Hoyt takes Experience, Speed, and Intellect while Sergeant Hartman takes Training along with Strength and Endurance. Edge:Hoyt. Edge:Hoyt

Final Verdict:A Texas Chainsaw Massacre character actually wins a fight for once? And it's not Leatherface vs. Sun Tzu? Yep, Sheriff Hoyt may have the worse firearms but his cunning intellect and constantly hunting for victims make him more prepared for a new fight than Sergeant Hartman who spends his days yelling at recruits. It also doesn't hurt that he has a better melee weapon and he's been shown to shoot people if he has to rather than just anger them.

Winner:Sheriff Hoyt