User blog comment:El Alamein/Centurion vs. Hersir/@comment-26032472-20160128102618

MilenHD's"Boss"edges

Sidearms:Edge Hersir:Both of these weapons will not be very effective,but the seax is longer,plus is sharper and probably made of better matterials,while the pugio will pass through the chainmail,the seax's superior sharpness and material will prove too much for the Centurion.

Swords:Edge Hersir:This was sawn before in this wiki,in Viking vs Centurion.The longsword is longer,more powerful,made of better materials,plus can be used as blunt tool.All this factors combined and you have the perfect way to slice and dice you're opponent,yeah the scutum might be a challenge but after all longer and stronger is better.

Spears:Edge Centurion:Although the pilum bends,is actually the better sppear his harpoon head is better for piercing armor,plus is little bit more accurate unlike the Viking Spear which is created for melee and not so much for throwing,plus I don't think it will be able to pierce the centurion's armor.So after all it's one big victory for the pilum.

Long:Edge Hersir:While the plumbata is accurate,it has the mobility,it has range,but lacks the power and the damaging power of the francisca axe,plus it has more piercing power and the other barbarians used it and beated the Romans,so not much of competition,edge throwing axe.

Shiled:Edge Centurion:TBC