User blog comment:Urbancommando77/Noble Six vs Courier Six/@comment-889585-20111206220824

Sith-venator Wavingstrider's Conservative Edges!


 * For Melee, and  are essentially the same thing, both are bowie knives. EDGE: Tie


 * For Pistols the M6G fires a 12.7x40mm round compared to the .45-70 of the Magnum Research BFR. I can't seem to find much information on the metric conversion of the .45-70 other than that it is 11mm, but there is an easier way to give an edge rather than round size. Magazine Fed Magnum>Hunting Revolver, faster reload and a larger magazine. EDGE: SPARTAN-B312


 * For Rifles 1 the MA37 Individual Combat Weapon System is pretty much the UNSC Army designation of the MA5C Individual Combat Weapon System, which has much more information available. The MA37/MA5C has a 32 7.62x51mm round magazine with a muzzle velocity of 905 m/s (2970 ft/s), a barrel length of 24 inches, a fire rate of 750-900 RPM, a weight of 3.8 Kilograms (4.1 Kilograms Loaded), and a range of 300 meters (WTF? A 24 inch barrel using a .308 and only has 300 meters in range, should have like 800 meters in range at least) vs the Colt Model 733's 30 5.56x45mm round magazine with a muzzle velocity of 2,611 ft/s (796 m/s), a barrel length of 11.5 inches, a fire rate of 700-900 RPM, a weight of 2.44 Kilograms (loaded weigh probably about 2.74 Kilograms), and a range of 300 meters. So for my gun gurus out there, really which would you prefer? A little carbine with no stopping power at all, or a Bullpup Battle Rifle with an ammo counter that has a larger magazine, more muzzle velocity, and is renown for it's reliability. EDGE: SPARTAN-B312


 * For Rifles 2 the M392 Designated Marksman Rifle easily outclasses the Colt Model 933 for the same reasons as the MA37 beats the Colt Model 733. EDGE: SPARTAN-B312


 * For Sniper Rifles the Sniper Rifle System 99 Anti-Matériel easily beats out the PGM Hécate II due to the larger 14.5x114mm round compared to the PGM's 12.7x99mm, and is semi-automatic compared to the PGM being bolt-action. EDGE: SPARTAN-B312


 * For Shotguns the M45 Tactical Shotgun fires the larger 8 gauge, but is pump action and clip fed compared to the Hawk Semi-Auto Tactical being magazine fed and obviously being semi-automatic, but it fires the smaller 12 gauge. Stopping Power vs Fire rate and reload speed, gonna go with the same way I went with pistols, magazine fed wins. EDGE: Courier Six


 * For Grenades I have to go with the M9 Frag Grenade, it's shrapnel has more range than the Incendiary grenade. EDGE: SPARTAN-B312


 * For Extra I have to go with the M41, that 102mm rocket is devastating especially in two barrels. EDGE: SPARTAN-B312


 * For Vehicles Falcon>Vertibird EDGE: SPARTAN-B312


 * For Armor while the MJOLNIR Mark V may not be that strong, but it has rechargable shields and gives the user much more strength and speed, not to mention the HUD. EDGE: SPARTAN-B312

OVERALL WINNER: SPARTAN-B312-It's no real contest, not really.