User blog comment:Lasifer/Welcome to Rapture: Booker DeWitt vs. Jack Ryan/@comment-5538194-20140129002534

Ethan's "Shocking" Edges:

Melee: Booker's Sky Hook is a mean weapon, and is multi-purposed, being made for attacks as well as transportation. The pipe wrench, on the other hand, is an improvised and unaffective blunt instrument.

EDGE: BOOKER DEWITT

Handgun: The Mauser holds more rounds, and has a higher rate of fire, making it superior to the Webley. These factors, who can get the shot out faster, or has more bullets, will be a determining factor in a tightly contested battle.

EDGE: BOOKER DEWITT

Shotgun: The Spencer's rate of fire and easier reloads is what makes this shotgun superior to Booker's. Jack's shotgun is better equipped for up-close combat, which is what the shotgun should be used for.

EDGE: JACK RYAN

SMG: Jack's SMG has a bit more ammo, but Booker's has better accuracy and has around the same rate of fire.

 EDGE: EVEN

Long Range: It's simple here, a long range sniper that can pick off a target from hundreds of yards away, versur a weapon used since medieval times. Easy victory here for Booker, as his sniper clearly trumps his adversarie's bow.

EDGE: BOOKER DEWITT

Launcher: Jack's grenade launcher has more rounds, and is an earier reload than the bulky rocket launcher.

EDGE: JACK RYAN

Vigors/Plasmids

Shock Power: Booker has the better power here, shock damage, stunning the target, and 2x damage increase.

EDGE: Booker Dewitt

Fire Power: Jack's fire power is slightly better, as it is more immediate and deals damage over time.

EDGE: JACK RYAN

Ice Power: These powers are very, very similar, and for that reason, it is even.

EDGE: EVEN

Telekenetic Power: Booker's power provides an extremely effective shield, pretty much destroying the notion of bullet damage when it is cast. Jack's telekenetic power just can't compare.

EDGE: BOOKER DEWITT

Swarming Power: These powers are pretty much the same, both damaging and distracting their enemy.

EDGE: EVEN

Assist Power: Jack's enrage power might backfire on him, sending Booker to attack him even more vigorously. Booker's power with the automatons, and Jack's backfire power add upp to a DeWitt victory.

EDGE: BOOKER DEWITT

Forceful Power: These powers are very similar, and that's why this one is even.

EDGE: EVEN

Trap Power: Both these powers are very similar, and that's why this one is close to even. However, I feel that Booker's powers pack more of a punch than Jack's traps, and that's why booker gets the slight edge.

EDGE: BOOKER DEWITT

X-Factors: Jack's complete and total lacking of experience, training, and intelligence, give Booker the edge in the X-Factors.

EDGE: BOOKER DEWITT

WINNER: BOOKER DEWITT!​