User blog comment:CuchulainSetanta/Sinbad vs. Tarzan/@comment-4803039-20120910195442

The biggest issue I see with Tarzan is that his mid and long range weapons are wood...and can easily be burnt by the fire siphon, and the major legnth difference between Sinbad's sword and Tarzan's dagger is another. There comes a point where a longer blade is better than a shorter one, and this is it. I would rather make sure that I can slash while not having to worry about the dagger getting near me.

So unless Tarzan uses his animal friends to distract Sinbad, the Sailor of the Seven Seas has it in my opinion.