User blog comment:BeastMan14/Help Me Doktor! The Medic vs Edward Richtofen/@comment-4803039-20130409023339

Affectos's Emotions: "Screw Health Insurance!"

Close: As much as I want to vote for the Syringe Gun, the depth of penetration just doesn't compare to that of a bullet. Edge: MP40

Mid: Main note, the Bowie Knife is never thrown in Nazi Zombies. Taking that into account, I have to go with the longer reaching weapon with the serrated edge. Edge: Bonesaw

Long: Sadly, while the Crusader's Crossbow gains more damage the further it flies, the Ray Gun is shown to have an infinite range. Edge: Ray Gun

While I like the concept of the match-up, I think that the Medic could've had some stronger weapons. In the end, Richtofen's greater brutality will earn him the victory.