User blog comment:El Alamein/Annie Wilkes vs. Jack Torrance/@comment-3189283-20150706210732

Let's see shall we

Primary Weapon

Both of these weapons are of a simular length and weight but the Axe wins out here simply because it's more pratical in the situation. The Axe is already more mobile and easier to wield than the sledgehammer and when you add in Jack's superior strength it makes it even easier to wield, giving it more killing potentional.

Edge: Jack Torrance 

Secondary Weapon

Normally I'd give this edge to the kitchen knife as despite it's much shorter range it's more likely to land a lethal blow but in this particular case I'm actually going to go against the grain and give the edge to the Croquet Mallet. We've seen Jack shrug off knife wounds before and while he can't exactly shrug off a knife in the neck I seriously doubt that Annie is going to be able to achieve that precisionwith Jack right up in her face. The croquet mallet is less lethal but I have little doubt that Jack could easily beat Annie to death with it and the range advantage coupled with his axe is going to make it very hard for Annie to get close enough to even use the kitchen knife.

Edge: Jack Torrance 

Special Weapon