User blog comment:Thornclaw Braveheart/Witch-king of Angmar vs. Eragon Bromsson/@comment-1728211-20111129205855

Close range: Obviously the flail. Edge: Witch-king. Mid range: Here, speed gives Brisingr an edge. Broadswords are awkward things to lift and swing while being comparatively no good for thrusting. Edge: Eragon (only just). Magic 1: Telekinesis is reasonably good but Eragon didn't stand up to well to the screech in the first chapter of Inheritance. Edge: draw Magic 2: Not sure how "wardless" Angmar's weapons are, but they were probably imbued with fell magic. However, Black Breath is universally harmful. Edge: Witch-king. Magic 3: Advice on mental duelling: don't. Yes, Eragon would probably survive this. Edge: Eragon. Mount: I would estimate the Fell beast as roughly equivalent to a Lethrblaka, so while this is a fight Saphira would probably win in time, it could keep her occupied for long for enough for Angmar to get the edge over Eragon. Edge: draw. Special: Again, the Morgul knife is a superior weapon. Edge: Witch-king. (Thorn, I would have had Aren instead of the bow.)

One final note: Eragon could kill Angmar, as Glorfindel's prophecy mentioned a "mortal man" while Eragon is a half-elven Dragon Rider.

Advantage: Witch-king.