User blog comment:Goddess of Despair/Season 3 battle 7 Horror Movie warriors vs Creepypasta warriors/@comment-5795750-20130208121357

BG1's "Ultimate Horror Battle Ever" Edges:

I'll go fro

m easiest to hardest here.

1. Jeff the Killer vs Michael Myers

Jeff and Michael are evenly matched in weapons but what this really comes down to is the ability to fight relentlessly. Sure Jeff has the touch of insanity and unpredictability about him but Michael knows that feeling and thus would smartly be able to counteract the attacks Jeff swings.

EDGE: Horror Movie Warriors

2. The Rake vs Freddy Kreuger

The Rake's claws are considerably longer than Freddy's when I look at the picture but I reckon Freddy has got this since he also has telekinetic control and the ability to create and spread fire that would certainly put off The Rake's ability to attack properly (since the intense amount of light coming in from the fire would render night-vision useless).

EDGE: Horror Movie Warriors

3. Leatherface vs Goatman

Looking at Goatman's weapon - the Axe - it would make mince meat of the sledgehammer and I doubt the chainsaw will have any effect on it. However, the chainsaw is more technologically sophisticated and I bet Goatman as a human will be completely terrified of it since the sound it makes its roaringly scary and it won't be long before Leatherface will lop off the clawed hands that hold the axe.

EDGE: Horror Movie Warriors

4. The Snow Monster vs Jason Voorhees

This will probably end up close but Jason has weapons that give him superior ranged attacks over the Snow Monster. Also the machete would be useful though I'm not sure how tough the Snow Monster: if his skin is thick, then it would mean that Jason wouldn't be able to cut deep into it and thus Jason has lost his edge. I'm going to assume though that the Snow Monster's skin isn't like an animal's

EDGE: Horror Movie Warriors

5. Slenderman vs Pinhead

Probably this is gonna be the trickiest pairing I've had to deal with. Slender does have the advantage of time travel meaning he'll be able to fight Pinhead with multiple versions of him, but given the limits of time travel (in which if you do aid your past self, to preserve the timeline, the past self has to go back), Slender's attack may not go far...

I see his attack on Pinhead go like this: Pinhead creates multiple illusory images of himself, Slender and his time travelling selves try to find the real one, however in doing this, Slender will have to go back in time again and again, meaning his 'help' will diminish in numbers as he progresses in his attacks until he finds the real Pinhead. Even then, his tentacles, while numerous, may not be enough to counteract the chains.

Another thing I want to point out is which version of Pinhead are you using? If you're using the normal Pinhead then it would be difficult but not impossible for Slender to use his static attacks to weaken Pinhead (Pinhead does know the meaning of pain, right?). However if it is the Pinhead from Hellraiser III, then Slender's aforementioned attacks will be useless since Pinhead then has no humanity about him and thus nothing for Slender to use his attacks upon.

I agree Slender will not be easy to beat since he too has no humanity about him but Pinhead has all the smarts, plus I doubt Slenderman will know what it is like to be in the world of the Lament Configuration/Hell and go through a LOT of pain and suffering to be as wilful as Pinhead.

EDGE: Horror Movie Warriors (but only just)

Given my edges above, the Horror Movie Warriors stand out as the ultimate monsters. None of that Creepypasta BS will ever be around for long on this world and they wouldn't know what it is like to be in a dimension like Hell.