User blog comment:MilitaryBrat/Batman (Nolanverse) vs Red Skull (MCU)/@comment-8012490-20130621120853

Short Range: Batman's bladed gauntlets are not as ranged as the knife at first; however, Batman can shoot them out and Red Skull would not expect them. Edge: Batman.

Mid Range: The Luger is more lethal than the batarangs are. Edge: Red Skull.

Long Range: Batman's EMP gun should shut down much of Red Skull's weaponry. Edge: Batman.

Special: Batman has better armor and more of a variaty of grenades than Red Skull. That would allow him to be more versitile. Edge: Batman.

Other Equiptment: The pulse rifle is better than the grappling pod; however, the Red Skull has nothing like the batpod. Edge: Batman.

X-Factors: Batman is more stealthy and has better training than Red Skull does. The intelligence is close, like the training, but the brutality is much lower than the difference between stealth. Edge: Batman.

My vote goes to Batman.