User blog comment:MilenHD/Visigoth vs Celt/@comment-17814994-20150711115030

Elgb's "Rome's Classical Roge Gallery" EDGES!!!

Short: Both swords are deadly weapons of antiquity and these two gave Rome a run for its money. But in comparison, the migration sword takes the edge due to it's longer blade and lethality. And even though it's longer, it's also the lighter weapon. EDGE: Visigoth

Mid: There's no way the scythe is going to win against any well-crafted weapon. Heck, if there's a rating for the "improvised" weapons category, the scythe would have been in the lowest of the bottom pit. Not only is it unweildy and hard to use, but it also wastes a lot more energy than using a simple axe. The Lancea is accurate, longer, and can be weilded with ease and proficiency. EDGE: Celt

Long: The javelin easily takes the edge. It's lighter, takes less energy touse, and penetrates deeper than the sling which is only deadly if it hits the enemy in the head (IF it hits). EDGE: Visigoth

Special: Though the burda may seem to be the more primitively designed tool here, it's actually the more practical weapon than the flail. Flail weapons are like nunchucks; it takes time and effort to learn how to use them without hurting yourself in the process, while giving half the damage of a baseball bat. The burda is simple and can produce more damage in one hit than a flail. EDGE: Visigoth

Deadliest Warrior: Visigoth

Not only do they take the edge in close and long range weaponry, they also have armor to protect them from some of the Celtic weapons. While almost all of the Visigoth weapons would surely kill a naked Celt with no armor. The Visigoth were also more successul in their military campaigns against Rome, while the Celt's disorganized structure led to their defeat from that same opponent.