User blog comment:Marcus Forelli/Batman (Nolanverse) vs Sherlock Holmes/@comment-24.6.166.58-20130331192655

All right, let's take a look at our fine combatants, shall we?

Short Range: Batman's iconic Batarangs have proven to be invaluable tools, allowing him to quickly dispatch enemies nonlethally, as well as silently. The Caped Crusader is a master with these weapons, as he can throw them with superb accuracy, even if he is one of the weakest incarnations of Batman. Despite all this, Sherlock's revolver has a killing edge, which will help, even in a fight like this, which isn't a battle to the death. Firearms are more easy to use then thrown weapons, and the bullets are smaller than Batman's Batarangs, which are a few inches in length, if I recall correctly, and thereore, Sherlock can carry more ammunition. The power of the bullets will slow Batman down, and could even hurt him, so this one goes to Holmes. Edge: Sherloch Holmes.

Medium Range: Sherlock's gun is very deadly, and useful, but unfortunately for him, a 10-round magazine will not help against Batman, who, on the other hand, has multiple explosives that are more versatile. The smoke bombs provide a way to hide. The tear gas can be used to disorientate and stun Sherlock. The explosive gel can easily knock him back a few feet. Edge: Batman.

Long Range: Sherlock's rifle is extremely deadly, powerful, and accurate, which will give him an advantage. Still, Batman has the swarm of bats, and when he calls in a swam of bats, you know that sh*t is about to get serious. If Holmes can land a shot on Batman, the Dark Knight will be critically injured, but he can use the bats to distrac Holmes. Also, bats can bite. And since the gun is bolt-action, it may be a little slow. Edge: Even.

Martial Arts: Oh man, this one is way too easy. Sherlock is a proficient fighter, and there's no doubt about it. Just look at what he did to Professor Moriarty and to the boxer. He's quick and shrewd, as he can anticipate his opponents' moves. However, he's only been in one-on-one fights, whereas Batman can easily take out multiple opponents at once, and he's done it many times. In a fight, astuteness can only get you so far. Batman uses many different martial arts, a definite advantage. Sherlock is more of a quick jab and knockout guy, using counters and strong blows. Batman uses takedowns, counters, knees, kicks, punches, bone-snapping moves, and many others. Also, Batman is stronger, since he broke a brick wall with a kick, and his foes are more dangerous and skilled than Sherlock's. Has Mr. Holmes ever faced an entire S.W.A.T team or a group of ninjas by himself? No. Edge: Batman.

Melee: This is a very close one. Batman's sharp gauntlet spikes can be deadly, and they are very painful when used on a foe. They can be used for blocking, and they can catch bladed weapons between them, allowing for a disarm. This doesn't just apply in the Nolan films, but also in other Batman-related media, like Arkham City. Also, they are titanium-dipped, and can be shot out. But then again, Sherlock's cane is both a bladed and blunt weapon, and has a longer reach. He can employ it in a way akin to a sword and baseball bat, both of which are deadly. Batman may be able to catch the blade, but the blunt end can whack him across the face, and he can't really shoot out the spikes until his opponent gets up close and personal. Edge: Sherlock.

Tools and Gadgets: Easily Batman, who is the king of gadgets. The whip won't be effective against Batman, due to his Kevlar suit, and his concealed weapons. The Pepperbox might give him a surprise advantage, but again, Kevlar suit. Plus, he'll have to wear it out with his revolver first. Chemical weapons won't work, since Batman can avoid it, and he already has gas weapons of his own. Furthermore, the sonar vision is a boon, allowing Batman to see where Sherlock is at all times. The Batsuit an shock Sherlock, should he attempt to grab the cowl, and Batman can use his cape to swoop in behind him. Edge: Batman.

Stealth: Batman easily. He's a master at stealth, and can blend in with the shadows, utilizing darkness to jump his foes. Also he can hang upside down behind enemies, and when they turn around........you know what happens next. I don't see how a disguise will help Sherlock in the heat of combat. Edge: Batman.

Intellect: Sherlock, but barely. He's a genius, but Batman is also one, even in Nolan's films. Still, he can't really adapt to his situation, and usually gets caught in an inescapable predicament. Shelock always finds egress out of a tight space, and is a master of adaptation. Edge: Sherlock.

Overall Victor: Batman. By a hair. Bruce is far more advance, and can be very cunning. Sherlock barely beats him in the intelligence category. His guns and blades can be more powerful than Batman's weapons, but Batman is no stranger to deadly firearms and blades, now is he? He dominates in martial arts, and is just better physically. He wins this battle by the skin of his teeth. The two great detectives would make good friends, though. I think they'll just agree to cross paths on good terms the next time they meet.