User blog comment:JWarrior89/Jack Sparrow vs Zorro (Campellverse)/@comment-5931345-20130901115530

Melee: Both are excellent one handed swords. But I have to give the edge to Jack Sparrow because the hanger is both great thrusting and slashing weapons and it has a far longer blade and reach. Edge: Sparrow

Range: If Zorro can get a jump on Sparrow he might disarm him before Jack can aim and fire one pistol. But Jack has two pistols. Even if Zorro can disarm one Jack still have one more pistol to fire. And Jack is a very very deadly marksman, able to fire while on the move. Edge: Sparrow

X-Factors: Sorry JW, but in Training I have to disagree with you. Jack Sparrow did recieve training from an Italian fencer, he also recieve combat training from his father, and he was already an excellent swordsman in his youth. Zorro only recieved his training in his adulthood. In intelligent, I have to go with Sparrow, because he not only tricked authority, he also tricked supernatural training. In physicality, I have to go with Zorro since he is more athletic. But note both characters aren't really keen on killing. Both never try to kill their opponents unless completely necessary and has done them harm. I have to give most of the x factors to Sparrow. Edge: Sparrow

Winner: CAPTAIN Jack Sparrow. He is smarter and has better weapons. Though Zorro is born in a more modern time, Sparrow is better equipped, and has the combat experience that outclasses those of Zorro's.