User blog comment:RSV 123/Chatrapati Shivaji vs. Attila the Hun/@comment-5195329-20120804034541

Sword: I'll give the edge to the Talwar due to the horses and the heavier armor on Shivaji. I think it will simply be able to do more and make a control of the field. It also has a length advantage. EDGE-SHIVAJI

Mid Range: The throwing spear should be easier to land and will just be more manueverable/effective. I feel the pata wil be hard to stab with and awkward to cut with, too limiting. EDGE-ATTILA

Long Range: The musket (while being better at piercing) wont be as easily to shoot and move like the horsebacked hun bow. Bow also is much faster at firing and less smoke roaring from the weapon. I think the bow will be the most effective of all the weapons here. EDGE-ATTILA

Close Quaters: The Katar is probably great for stabbing the Hun's armor while the sagaris (which is the same axe as the scythian, fun fact) isn't as likely to be able to cut in to the meat. While I like the sagaris, I think the kata fights the other aspects of the fight better. EDGE-SHIVAJI

OVERALL: Winner - Attila the Hun, I think that the bow and the spear will be dominating enough to overpass the lack of armor quality.