User blog comment:Lachlan Blake/Magic vs Bullets: Dr. Facilier Vs Captain Hook/@comment-2016768-20110625004641

THE DEADLIET WARRIOR'S DEADLIETS EDGES:

Hook Hand vs. Voodoo Staff: The Voodoo Staff has magical properties and pure bludgeoning power as well as a reach advantage over Captain Hook's souvenir from the crocodile's mouth.

EDGE: DR. FACILIER

Rapier vs. Smoke & Illusions: The Illusions can be a good distraction for a follow-up kill but can't kill itself. The rapier will slice and dice the Voodoo man up and down before he even knows what happens. A weapon that distracts will always lose to a weapon that kills.

EDGE: CAPTAIN HOOK

Flintlock Pistols vs. Voodoo Dolls: The good doctor could stick Hook's voodoo doll full of pins before Hook can even pull the trigger. One needle to the heart and Hook falls dead even on the other side of the world.

EDGE: DR. FACILIER

Blunderbuss vs. own Shadow: Facilier's shadow can distact Hook and trip him up but it won't be as effective at killin as Facilier himself will be. The Blunderbuss might misfire but when it goes off it takes anyone down with it.

EDGE: CAPTAIN HOOK

Overall Winner: Dr. Facilier

Magic beats early gunpowder and Hook's crew is incompetent anyway - screw Smee! He's gonna be the first to die! He can't fight to save his life, much less Hook's! A much more combat ready Dr. Facilier will tear incompetent Hook to pieces, with a good 650 kills to his credit.