User blog comment:Goddess of Despair/Season 5 battle 2 Comanche vs Aztec Jaguar/@comment-3189283-20130604164358

Lets see shall we

Short range: 

The Maquahitl is longer and those obsidion shards will do massive damage to the unarmoured commanche whereas the war hawk won't be as effective against the aztec's cotton armour and helmet.

Edge Aztec Jaguar 

Mid range: 

Sure the War Lance is longer and that tip will be very damaging against the aztec armour but it is also a horseback weapon and it won't hold up as well on foot where it will be much clumsier to wield. The Tepoztopilli is shorter sure, but it is much easier to use and obsidion shard head will do alot of damage to the unarmoured commanche. However the lack of range is a big disadvantage and it lacks the power of the Maquahitl. Tough call and I'm going to have to call it even.

Edge Even 

Long range: 

The commanche bow seems like it would win out in this matchup and normally it would. It has the range, the rate of fire and isn't a one shot weapon. However it will be stopped dead in it's tracks by the cotten armour of the aztec; It was desgined to stop arrows. The Tlacochtli and Atlatl may not be as effective but once again against the unarmoured commanche it will do more damage than the bow will, giving it more killing potentional. Again i'm going to have give this one a tie.

Edge Even 

Special Weapon

The Tecpatl is longer and it has the deadlier blade in the context of this battle. For the fourth time in the vote I have to point out that the cotten armour will do a good job of preventing the blade from doing as much damage as it would have done if the aztec was unarmoured. That obsidian blade will wreak havoc on the unarmoured commanche.

Edge Aztec Jaguar 

Final Verdict

This battle really comes down to one simple factor: Armour. The Aztec's armour is good enough to prevent most of the Commanche's weapons from doing the damage they are capable of. The War Lance is the only thing that can really get through the Aztec Armour easily and it's too clumsy to use all that effectivly in combat. On top of that the Aztec's obsidan weaponry will wreak havoc on the unarmoured Commanche, culminating in a landslide victory for the Aztec.

Aztec Jaguar: 4,000

Commancher: 1,000