User blog comment:Leolab/Ancient User Tourney, Round 10: Tiberius Proditus (EA) v Sir Bors of Newcastle (Elgb)/@comment-5078776-20160728032711

ROYAL BOWL 2016!!! While the broadsword on its own is a slightly superior sword to thespatha, the added shields of both warriors throw it heavily in Tiberius' favor. Not only does the scutum offer decent protection, it's also less cumbersome than Bors' heavier targe mixed with his plate. It perfectly compliments itself as a weapon set, while the targe and longsword weighs Bors down significantly. While the Pilum's additional effect as a projectile may be useful, that's a slim to none chance against a smaller target like the targe, or a heavily armored one like Bors. The halberd is much more versatile, and can easily damage both the scutum and rip through the Lorica Hamata easily with the hook or axe. Simply put, while the pilum is a nice little option, the Halberd is simply bringing more of them. The crossbow is too complicated and slow to utilize in such a close-confined battle space. The plumbata is a perfect choice, though, since it requires little to no prep outside throwing it. While I doubt it can pierce Bors' armor, it should provide a nifty distraction for Tiberius to take the kill. To be perfectly honest, I can't expect any of these weapons to be used. The mantrap takes far more time to setup and prepare than even possible in this fight. The Pugio is a toothpick- it's not getting past that armor unless Bors stands there and does nothing. The only reason the Pugio even gets an edge is that it can, ultimately, be used- the same cannot be said for the mantrap. Sir Bors is the more well-rounded combatant, but that also means he has no specialty. In reality, he is actually minimally trained in so much- and his arsenal reflects that. He has a mismatch of weapons that just look cool, while Tiberius' is consistent and compliments itself magnificently. Although he may have to spend some time getting through the armor, Tiberius Proditus will prevail...eventually.
 * Iconic: Tiberius Proditus''
 * Mid Range: Sir Bors of Newcastle
 * Long Range: Tiberius Proditus
 * Special: Tiberius Proditus
 * WINNER: Tiberius Proditus