User blog comment:Facetheslayer/Richard Harrow (Boardwalk Empire) v. John Marston (Red Dead Redemption)/@comment-5043545-20160114003257

WanderingSkull's GraveDigging Tunes "Cowboy Capone"

Revolvers: The M1892 is going to pull through with a narrow edge, but as expected its reasonably close and for good reason. The Webley has the larger rounds, albeit not by much, but it comes down to Marston's amazing quick draw and reaction time with sidearms. I mean have you seen Marston take out entire groups of troops before they can even raise their firearms? EDGE: John Marston

Handgun: Now, this is a bit more difficult since Marston is still good on the draw, but revolvers are more his thing when it comes to sidearms. In terms of design both are pretty good, but the Model 51 is designed with the intention of being a pocket pistol rather than full-out combat. Still the issue with the whole left flank perception takes a small hit here. Still, I'm going to have to call this even with neither having a very clear edge over the other. EDGE: Even

Shotgun: Pump action is just awesome considering it allows you to plot your shots better and you are less likely to waste ammo. But the semi-auto nature of the Auto-5, which is not auto as the name implies, but close enough. Semi-auto is a great way to still maintain accuracy, but be able to pump out rounds at a quicker pace to compete with your foes. But wait, what is this? The auto-5 isn't taking edge? How can this be? Well, simply put the extra round of the 1897 makes it eve. EDGE: Even

Rifles: Well, Marston is an excellent shot with rifles as seen in game where he basically destroys enemies from a range, but I'm a bit lost as what Enfield this is. Since I searched up the gun and had idea if it was the Lee-Enfield or American Enfield. Still, I guess I'm going to give it to the American Enfield since it might have one more round than the Krag. EDGE: Richard Harrow

TBF