User blog comment:The Deadliest Warrior/Pirate vs. Ninja/@comment-2187516-20110709004557

Samurai234's spectacular speculations

Cutlass Sword vs. Wakizashi Sword: The Cutlass (I think) has a longer reach.

Edge: Pirate

Boarding Ax vs. Poisoned Daggers: The axe has a longer reach, but is slower to swing. The Daggers have a shorter reach, but if hit in the right spot, instant kill.

Edge: Even

Boarding Pike vs. Kusarigama: The Kusarigama has more uses hand and can be used to disarm.

Edge: Ninja

Stinkpot vs. Metsubushi: The stinkbomb may smell bad, but the effect goes away. The Metsubushi is besically glass in the eye.

Edge: Ninja

30-pounder Long Cannon vs. Shurikens: The Shuriken can't really kill. The Cannon is overkill.

Edge: Pirate

Flintlock Pistol vs. Fukiya: The blowgun has a slow killing time. The pistol has better killing power.

Edge: Pirate

Grenado vs. Tessen: A metal fan vs a grenade?

Edge: Pirate

The Deadliest Warrior: Pirates

The ninjas may be sneaky, but they are bad in "in your face" fights. The Pirates' gunpowder weapons will give them a huge edge at a distance.