User blog comment:Killermoves/Terrors of the Old West: Chief Joseph vs Clay Allison/@comment-39845974-20191207144934

Spontoon Tomahawk vs. Bowie Knife: This is an interesting comparison. the Bowie takes a large advantage when in close combat engagements like grapples, it having a greater blade length to handle ratio. The Tomahawk can do a lot of damage in combat, but the Bowie still can easily kill an enemy in single combat. So it goes down to who has more advantages. Both have 2 methods of attack. The Bowie can stab and slash, but the Tomhawk can chop and bludgeon. The Tomahawk has more range, but the Bowie then is a far superior weapon in a grapple due to its shorter length and longer blade. In the end, I'm just slightly gonna side with the Tomhawk. Edge: Chief.

Nez Perce short bow vs Colt frontier six shooter: Is a less difficult edge to call. The Short bow and The revolver potentially have a similar range, the Revolvers range going up to 50 yards and the Short bow average a similar range. When looking at their advantage, the Revolver generally takes the cake. The Revolver does more damage, it only requires the usage of 1 hand to use, it's user can potentially carry more rounds since bullets are a good deal less bulky then arrows, its doesn't require the need to reload and not aim after every single shot, and its also a much more effective weapon in melee. The Bow is light weight, has a faster loading speed and doesn't make sounds when you shoot it. To me, the Revolver is able to over take the bow here.