User blog comment:Drayco90/Marvel vs. DC- Captain America vs. Batman/@comment-4497328-20111029061403

This is very close, and my gut instinct is to vote for Cap'n, but I have to give this one to Batman. He has devoted his life to fighting. In straight out hand to hand combat, Capt. won't last a second. With his shield, he'll last longer, but Batman also has his hook, which helps and augments his strategic skills.