User blog comment:Tomahawk23/Anton Chigurth Vs. Cousins/@comment-4661256-20140424015228

El Alamein's "Hold Still... Please" Edges:

 Close Range: Remington vs, M1911:  I really love the M1911 for its merits, especially in the Second World War, but it's simply outclassed against a bigger, badder weapon. The Remington packs a major punch at close and even mid range, and doesn't require the user to aim to such an extent as they would need to with the M1911. Plus, its silencer will give Anton an operational advantage should he need to get the drop on one of the Cousins without alerting the other. Yeah, the M1911 will likely be easier to reload, but the shotgun can be reloaded before all eight rounds have been expended. The same can't be done with the handgun. Overall, I'm giving the edge to the Remington for its silencer, longer range, and greater stopping power.

Edge: Anton Chigurh

 Mid Range vs. Armor: Tec-9 vs. Kevlar:  Yeah, sorry Cousins, but Kevlar won't do you jack-squat against Anton Chigurh. It'll stop some shots, sure, and I guess the 9mm rounds of the Tec-9 won't be especially effective against their torso regions, but they're still vulnerable to head and limb shots. Also, even if you're shot with Kevlar on, it's still going to hurt - something just slammed into you at speeds upwards of 2,000 feet per second. So to me, that extra gun gives Anton greater versatility at range whereas the Kevlar only offers marginal (and situational) defense at best.

Edge: Anton Chigurh

 Special Weapons: Captive Bolt Pistol vs. Axe:  Yeah, it's been stated a bunch of times below. Chigurh makes that weapon deadly, but mostly against unsuspecting victims (like that guy who he pulled over with the cop car). The axe doesn't require an element of surprise, it doesn't require the user to be directly adjacent to the victim, and it doesn't need to be targeted on the forehead. It can hack off limbs.

Edge: The Cousins

WINNER: ANTON CHIGURH

Not only does Chigurh bring more raw firepower to this fight with a shotgun and a submachine gun, but he's a tough bastard - point in case, when he patches himself up after that car accident and high-tails it out of there. So even if the Cousins shoot him once or twice with their pistols, it won't really make much of a difference unless it's a killshot. I don't see the fight moving in up-close or anything simply because Chigurh's shotgun really nullifies any close-ranged advantages the axe has, while at a distance the suppressive abilities of the Tec-9 more than outclass the M1911. Not an easy win for Chigurh, per se, but not impossible for him either. The Cousins are outmatched, plain and simple.