User blog comment:Jackythejack/Island Residence: Purna Jackson vs. Sheva Alomar/@comment-27043000-20181225010656

Pygmy Hippo's "Error:Title Not Found" Edges

Close Range:The Stun Baton is just as powerful as the Torch Cudgel but it's shorter and lacks an additional killing factor with its secondary function. The Sig P226 has more ammo and a faster reload but Purna's Magnum has the more powerful round. Edge:Tie

Medium Range:The Short Shotgun has more ammo but the M3 Shotgun has a faster reload. They both use the same rounds so again... Edge:Tie

Long Range:The SIG 556 completely dominates the AK-47 with more ammo, deadlier rounds, a greater rate of fire, a faster muzzle velocity, and longer range. Edge:Sheva

Special:Actual military explosive>improvised explosive. Edge:Sheva

X-Factors:Sheva Alomar takes Experience and Physicality while Purna Jackson ties in Quick Thinking. Edge:Sheva

Final Verdict:Aside from being in unfamiliar territory and having her shorter ranged weapons be equal to Purna Jackson's, Sheva Alomar has all of the advantages here. She has a huge edge at long range and an actually decent explosive along with dominating the X-Factors. While Sheva takes all the edges in this duel, Purna has to settle for ties.

Winner:Sheva Alomar