User blog comment:Goddess of Despair/The "pro" season battle 2 Jesse James vs Crazy Horse/@comment-4661256-20121216203817

'El Alamein's "You Can Run Faster Than a Horse? I Didn't Think You Could RUN!" Edges:'

 Close Range: Bowie Knife vs. Tomahawk:  Both of these weapons are brutally efficient in close combat, and both can be thrown. However, the steel blade of the Bowie Knife will prove sharper and more durable than the iron or even bone head of the tomahawk.

Edge: Jesse James

 Mid Range: Colt 1851 Navy vs. Colt Single-Action Army:  The Single-Action Colt has a higher caliber round, so it'll put down somebody with less rounds thanks to a more powerful punch.

Edge: Crazy Horse

 Long Range: Winchester vs. Henry:  The Winchester is by far the superior weapon - longer range and more reliable, plus it's being used by a cowboy (used to fighting with guns) while the Henry, in Crazy Horse's hands, will be less effective as the Natives are more used to fighting with bows and knives.

Edge: Jesse James

 Special Weapons: Pistol Whip vs. Inyankapemni:  Well, lots of people are claiming that the Pistol Whip damages the revolver, but I doubt it's going to make the gun fall apart right away - maybe SUSTAINED damage might occur over a long period of time, but it's not a super-detrimental impact on the gun. The Inyankapemni, however, breaks and has a long bendy stick that you can easily duck under and close the distance to bludgeon your enemy with any part of the pistol. The Pistol Whip gets the edge because it doesn't break as easily and it's got a larger surface area with which to attack.

Edge: Jesse James

Winner: Jesse James

Let me just say, I don't like Crazy Horse as a warrior, but I almost voted for him. Lots of people are saying he has more combat experience than James, but that's just not true. James fought in the Civil War as a guerrilla bushwhacker, and he continued to fight as an outlaw. His more reliable long-ranged weapons (as well as being more accustomed to fighting with firearms), sharper and stronger close-ranged weapons, and calm collected approach to combat will leave him unfazed by Crazy Horse's "psychologically terrifying" war whoops and have him carve up the Chief worse than Pancho Villa had done.