User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 3 Episode 1: Frank West vs Rick Grimes/@comment-181289-20130331224459

Okay in terms of weapons these two come in fairly even, Rick gets a slight edge in my opinion in melee and Hand gun. His Melee weapon is more likely to get a kill than the bat and his hand gun has more rounds. The other weapons in my opinion are fairly even.

The X-factors, are also fairly even in my opinion. Rick has better Training and is more brutal but Frank is less likely to snap in a psychotic episode. However going nuts isn't necessarily bad, it can make you more willing to kill, or it could cripple him and render hims helpless, it's sort of a double edge sword.

So in my opinion it comes down to who is going to get the kill first. In my opinion that would be Rick. He's training and brutality mean that he is more likely to get the kill first. Neither of these guys are really soldiers in the traditional sense, but Rick past life as a police officer I think gives him the training and slight mentality edge that will give him a narrow win in my opinion, he may have a poorer state of mind but if he ends the fight quick enough he can win.