User blog comment:WinterSpider/William Munny vs Rooster Cogburn/@comment-3189283-20191007171848

Let's see shall we

Handgun 

The Revolvers are all pretty equal with roughly the same calibre and the same number of shots. However as others have pointed out below me the Starr Revolver is double action which gives it an easier reload and a much faster firing speed.

Edge: William Munny 

Rifle

The Winchester takes the edge here almost entirely because of it having over double the ammo capacity of the Spencer. The Spencer does have a slightly more powerful round but it's negligible in comparison to the massive gap in terms of ammo count.

Edge: Rooster Cogburn

Final Verdict

I'm siding with the bold talking one eyed fat man, Rooster Cogburn. Having the better rifle really helps him in the early stages of this battle where combined with his much greater marksmanship he'll be able to at the very least injure Munny if not kill him outright. Munny has to rely on closing the distance where he has the faster firing revolver but even then he's still lacking in experience and overall firearm skill when compared to Rooster. His only hope is that Rooster is so drunk off his ass that he just keeps missing which granted is a fairly likely proposition but nevertheless Rooster should have enough about him to make it out victorious.

Rooster Cogburn: 2,900

William Munny: 2,100