User blog comment:Sppople/Aragorn vs Jack Sparrow/@comment-4392864-20150815135706

To be honest, I have to go with Jack Sparrow on this one. In a straight up fight, Aragorn would easily defeat him. That being said, Sparrow never fights fairly. To paraphrase what he once said, if fighting fair resulted in him being defeated, then there'd be no incentive for him to do so. Aragorn's a good fighter, but Jack uses his wits to plan his fights, and he'll use his environment to his advantage. In a way, I can see Aragorn walk past an object that Jack was hiding behind, only for Jack to stick his pistol into the back of Aragorn's head and say "Pirate."

Deadliest Warrior: Captain Jack Sparrow