User blog comment:Swg66/AnnhilationNation vs. Facetheslayer/@comment-422690-20110712010744

Close range: Draw. Though I'm tempted to disqualify Uruk-Hai scimitar and Scutum as the Uruk-Hai's scimitar's design isn't found anywhere in ancient culture. The Suctum is a nicely massive shield, which will protect from a lot. However, it impairs mobility in a one-on-one situation, as we've seen in Rajput vs Centurion, and the thing the Targe and Tomahawk gives is mobility. Edge: Even.

Mid range: Polish War Scythe wins. That thing's a fearsome weapon. While Halberd's options are a factor, the War Scythe has a good deal more cutting power. I think. Edge: AN.

Special: Wind and Fire Wheels win. I'm going with range on this one. Edge: AN.

Overall: Facetheslayer wins. AN's weapons, while handy, are difficult to use with his biggest advantage: the Scutum. Plus, his arms and armor restricts mobility, giving FTS room to run circles around him.