User blog comment:Killermoves/Billy the Kid vs Henry Lightfoot/@comment-4454770-20191101051645

Here’s my predictions:

Melee: The bowie knife is designed to be a brutal weapon, and no improvised weapon, especially pieces of clothing, can match hat. The only advantage Henry’s melee weapons has is suprise, but after the initial attack these wold falter.

Edge: Billy the Kid

Pistol: Uh yeah, the Webley is double action and can be reloaded faster. Seriously, the Colt Peacemaker may have the larger round, but it can only be reloaded wih 5 rounda, and takes a whole minute to be reloaded properly.

Edge: Henry Lightfoot

Shotgun: Billy’s coach gun is shorter but can still pack a nasty punch. The fact that you dont need to pull down the hammer makes it he faster gun. The hunting shotgun may have advantage in range but its slower, and when reloaded with bird shot, not really tha lethal as well. The only realy disadvantage he coach gun has is the fact that Billy only used this weapon once in his life so he’s not that experienced with it, but when he used it he was deadly.

Edge: Billy the Kid

Rifle: The Lee Metford all the way for its stronger round and farther eange. Its bolt action and carbine model makes it more maneuverable and easier to use in the close knit battlefield such as a town (cause with a lever action, there is sometimes little room to cock the lever compared to the bolt action). Granted some of the younger Peaky Blinders may not be knowledgeable with it, but many of them were veterans too like Lightfoot.

Edge: Henry Lightfoot

X-Factor: I have to give this one to Henry Lightfoot. He went to war for crying out loud, which gives him way more experience than the tiny insurrection that Billy fought in. There is also a lot of myth to dispel about Billy, for one he is NOT the charismatic leader that everyone believes. He was just a kid who got entabgled in a feud and has been trying to escape his life of crime ever since. He’s led his gang only once in the war during the Battle of Lincoln. Henry Lightfoot on the other hand is way more vicious and would chase down and destroy Billy as he tries to escape like he always does.

Edge: Henry Lightfoot

Deadliest Warrior: Henry Lightfoot is the victor here. While weapons and x-factors are tied, the peaky blinder has the better rifle and training, as well as he fact that he fought in a war. Billy is just a kid who lacks training and mostly tries to run away, and in the end that’s ehat got him cornered and killed by better trained men. Unlike Billy, Henry Lightfoot has survived every combat he’s gotten himself into with better confidence, grit and training.