User blog comment:Aaron Siegel/SCP-049 vs. Frankenstein's Monster/@comment-5795750-20150614092141

BG1's "The Horrors of Science and Superstition" Edges:

Weapons: Like you said, SCP-049's lethal touch isn't going to work on "Adam" because he is essentially an undead creature so that's the SCP's most valuable assets gone. His scalpel isn't going to do much damage either since the monster is very durable and a stab or swipe isn't going to make the monster flinch. The zombie companions of his won't do much damage either since they are dealing with something that ain't human and thus their full force blows won't do much damage to them

EDGE: Frankenstein's Monster/"Adam"

X-Factors: Average of 56.25 for Frankenstein's Monster/"Adam"; Average of 33.13 for SCP-049 and SCP-049-2 together; Average of 27.5 for SCP-049 by itself; Average of 38.75 for SCP-049-2

EDGE: Frankenstein's Monster/"Adam"

Winner: You know what? I actually agree with what Pach is saying and I too think that Frankenstein's Monster/"Adam" may actually win this but it will be quite a struggle - you point out how both monsters have had no battle experience but as Pach points out, the SCP is not really much of a combat-oriented warrior whereas "Adam" was built like one even if his creator had no intentions of making one so even if both are that inexperienced fighting others like their opponents, at least one is built to deal with such problems