Board Thread:Warrior's Pub/@comment-27334870-20180404225417

Beggining my tyranny of the wiki, where I upheave the old and bring in the new now.

This is on the general chat because I feel like all wiki members should be able to give an opinion here.

Something that usually bothered me is that the Ancient and Modern categories were really vague, and users might not have a specific idea as to where to place warriors from overalapping time periods, or even base the category on weaponry, such as calling Incan Soldiers in the Exploration Period "ancient".

I propose that we decide on what the heck the categories mean.

I've prepared two options, one that I prefer and one that the wiki seems to normally use, and propose the expantion/creation of two new categories.

A) Make new Categories and Divide the existing ones by time period

In short:


 * Fictional Warriors are a case-by-case basis (such as Future Warriors)


 * Ancient Warriors will be defined as warriors from before the 5th Century AD.


 * Medeival Warriors will be 5th Century to 15th Century.


 * (New Category) Renaissance Warriors will be 15th Century to 17th Century.

I also propose we add a new category to Battle of the Year, regarding battles with Medeival and Renaissance warriors.
 * Modern will be 17th Century and onwards.

B) Keep old categories, just clarify that we define them by arsenal.


 * Ancient Warriors are those without firearms.


 * Modern Warriors use firearms.

C) Make it case-by-case for every warrior, even those in real life.
 * Medeival Warriors define those inbetween these two definitions.

I need sysops to state their support of A or B, or propose new ideas for discourse. Other users may also state their opinion, but don't push it.

My postions are  A,  B, and C. 