User blog comment:CrystalScorpion96/Thalmor(Skyrim) VS Noldor(Prophesy of Pendor)/@comment-5795750-20131126065602

BG1's "Here's your first vote, even though I don't know much about these guys" Edges:

Melee: The Noldor Rune sword gets this no question since it is light and very powerful according to your description of its capabilities

EDGE: Noldor

Ranged: I find it hard to believe that there are arrows that weigh 0 lbs but anyway... I got to give my edge to the Noldor Composite Bow since it can hit more accurately and you can manoeuvre with it more quickly; also the Noldor are carrying more arrows

EDGE: Noldor

Armour: Armour that is stronger than steel yet light enough for the person to move about makes for great use in combat and that is what the Thalmor elves bring to the table

EDGE: Thalmor

Shield: In comparison with Earth shields I say we have a targe vs a scutum since one is made of a more durable and stronger material but the other is lightweight and can be used offensively; and in this instance I have to go with the one that has more options i.e. used for both defence and offence quite well-roundedly

EDGE: Thalmor

Special: So I take it then that the Thalmor magic has a very long range attached to it then, which means the edge here is even since with the horse, it is manoeuvrable and agile meaning it can dodge whatever attack the Thalmor throw at it but I guess the Thalmor are sometimes lucky shots/very precise in their magic casting

EDGE: Even

X-Factors: Average of 72 for Noldor; Average of 82 for Thalmor

EDGE: Thalmor

Overall Winner: Gosh this is like comparing Genghis Khan and his Mongols to King Leonidas and his Spartans... I will have to concede that the question asked here is if the lightweight yet tough armour can withstand the onslaught brought by the Noldor's weaponry. My answer to that is simply no seeing as how the Noldor pack a very strong sword, a very accurate bow which can simply target anywhere that isn't armoured and the important X-Factors of Stealth, Cunning and Terrain Advantage which could make for a very fast-paced fight the Thalmor simply cannot keep up with despite their magic. In the end, the Noldor win this battle of the Elves. What next? The Noldor vs the LotR Elven Army?