User blog comment:Lasifer/Fallout User Tourney: Arrow vs. Ethank/@comment-26074921-20120722024227

Alright battle one-I realize that I am a competitor in this one and Las has no restrictions on competitors voting, but I will do my best to be as fair as possible in my vote. So lets begin


 * Melee-Even This is an interesting match-up here. The Proton inversal axe has much greater length giving it an initial edge. It also has carries more weight behind each swing dealing more damage, especially when in Koyoto hands with the higher strength. It also carries the added electrical damage affect. However Jack is neither in power armor or a robot negating most of that advantage. The axe is heaver and hits harder, but that advantage is also its disadvantage. The Katana is far lighter, faster, and can attack far more quickly, meaning that between swings or after dodging attacks (note Jack has higher agility) more attacks with the katana can be dealt. The axe’s speed, weight and shape also limit its options, while the katana carries more speed and variety.
 * With Jack’s increased agility and a lighter more varied weapon, and Koyoto’s higher strength and a more devastating weapon this easily comes out even-Even


 * Close-Jack Cobb When it comes to the two side arms the Plasma Defender takes an immediate edge in clip/energy cell size, holding a whopping 7 times as many shots as the Sequoia. However, the Sequoia’s shots themselves are more penetrating and deal twice the overall damage. The Sequoia is no real slouch to reload as well (taking little time) and can fire a lot faster than the Defender. The Sequoia also easily takes accuracy and range over the defender.
 * While it’s a very close call with the plasma defender’s greater number of shots, the Sequoia does higher damage faster and more accurately as well. Its close but-Jack Cobb


 * Medium-Jack Cobb The LAER deals higher damage and is much lighter, however the advantages seem to end there. The Marksman Carbine holds an equal number of shots in a clip and reloads just as fast. However, it has a greater rate of fire (over twice as high) and is the more versatile of the two weapons. The Marksman Carbine easily has the range advantage with the scope, or without it-being far more accurate. Both the Warriors have used these weapons for a long time, however I believe that Jack is carrying the better gun and it fits his fighting style perfectly.
 * Despite the higher damage of the LAER, the Carbine takes this due to longer range, faster rate and more versatility Jack Cobb


 * Long-Koyoto The .308 sniper is a deadly accurate weapon and easily takes range and accuracy, however it is outclassed in this fight (especially since Jack already has the Marksman carbine which really fills a similar role). The Bozar deals more Damage per second and holds 6 times the capacity. Jack is coming in with a similar weapon as his mid-range whereas Koyoto has brought in a light machine gun that doubles as a sniper rifle. The Bozar may deal less damage per shot….but well it fires a hell of a lot more shots in quick succession. Even if the Sniper rfile is more accurate, the Bozar over comes its slight lagging with sheer firepower (maybe Koyto’s Luck could help out with the spread even).
 * Basically the Range, power and accuracy of the .308 don’t stack up against the power of the Bozar Koyoto


 * Explosive-Jack Cobb The Nuka Grenades are extremely powerful explosives, more powerful than the individual MFC grenades in the cluster. It also has the additional effect of the irradiation, both during the explosion and lingering. However the MCF cluster grenade has higher output all together (assuming all grenades detonate simultaneously) and has additional benefits as well. The MCF cluster covers a larger area and doubles as small mines. If doing the battle Cobb throws out one or more, the battle field has become a dangerous place for Koyoto and Steve (Though Jack may have tactics as to how to throw them, it still poses a danger to him as well.
 * In the end the Cluster grenades have much wider use and more tactical options than the sheer Force of the Nuka grenades. Jack Cobb


 * Armor-Koyoto-TBW


 * Companion-Even While they are both nightstalkers, Cobb has had his since he hatched it early in his career, meaning that it is incredibly loyal to him. Koyoto also has traveled extensively with his, making both creatures great for combat alongside their masters. (whether or not Steve has steath)

Deadliest warrior-TBD