User blog comment:WanderingSkull/Jack vs. Frank West/@comment-4497328-20120916173734

Chainsaw < Baseball Bat

G17 > M1911A1

Mossberg 500 = Remington 870

UMP 45 > Micro-Uzi

AK-47 > M4A1

Traps > Reaper

That being said, I think Frank will take this despite having inferior weapons. He has experience fighting other humans. Jack does not.