User blog comment:WraithOfWaffle/Battle Eight: Carnegie (The Book of Eli) vs. The Governor (AMC's The Walking Dead)/@comment-5043545-20140213035245

WanderingSkull's GraveDigging Tunes "Church Of The Children Of Atom"

Melee: While I personally think the Machete is a superior melee weapon overall, I have to give it to the Governor. What tips it in his favor is the superior training of his men who are likely more skilled in melee combat as they've become used to it under his orders. Combine that with the fact the Governor is strong as hell he can probably deal some painful stab wounds with that knife of his. EDGE: The Governor

Pistol #1: Both weapons are similar and both supply the same 9mm round but the Beretta is simply more effective. It packs 2 additional round allowing it to outlast the Browning-Hi Power before it needs to reload. Coupled with superior training and muzzle velocity gives it the edge between the two. EDGE: The Governor

Pistol #2: When comparing weapons it simply comes down to the fact that the Beretta is packing a larger clip size at hand. The higher muzzle velocity of the Beretta also helps deal some extra damage despite the weaker 9mm. The .45 although stronger and more reliable simply loses out due to a smaller clip. EDGE: Carnegie

Shotgun: The newer, more efficent design of the UTA5 is simply better than the classic shotgun known as the Mossberg 500. The UTA5 simply has a way larger mag and can lay down some serious fire without having to reload as often. EDGE: The Governor

TBF