User blog comment:Leolab/User Siege Tourney, round 45 of 50: Beastman14 (Ryan) v Leolab (Lloyd)/@comment-5795750-20140503023104

BG1's "Pirates vs Indians... sounds like another movie in the making" Edges:

Attacker Overruns the Castle: Yeah....... no. I can't see the reckless running strategy (if it even is one) working here. At all. Lloyd has relatively come up with the perfect countermeasures to stop the charge from working.

Attacker Forces the Defender to Surrender: Not a chance here. Lloyd's men are very loyal to him and will never desert their post unless all hope is lost which is very unlikely given Ryan's lazy and predictable strategy

Attacker Wins Single Combat: Not that it is going to get to that stage but if it does then I don't see Ryan coming out on top here since he is packing a not-so-balanced set of weapons. That crossbow might actually weigh him down here and his armour is not as strong as Lloyd's.

Defender Forces Attacker to Surrender: Certainly Ryan's men will desert or even kill him after seeing the fruitless carnage wrought by Lloyd's defences. Heck I don't think it will take him that long to see Ryan's men come to the door with the terms of surrender.

Defender Annihilates Attacker: If Ryan lets loose all his men, then surely all of them will go down in flames and dirt and whatever else there is because the troops seem unarmoured and thus are more susceptible to arrows and fire and cannons and whatever else Lloyd's men have up their sleeves.

Defender Survives for 4 Months: Since Ryan's men will always be ordered to charge the castle and not the supply lines that Lloyd's men will get their supplies from, I think Lloyd and his men are able to survive for that long but then again the battle will be over within a matter of days or weeks so...

Defender Wins Single Combat: See above.

Either Side Meets the Victory Conditions but loses their Commander: Well... I don't see either side win AND lose their commander because no matter how you look at it Lloyd and his men win and he doesn't lose his head (and Ryan will lose his head and the battle)

Both Sides lose their Commander: See above.

Winner: Lloyd Kumar wins this easily since he and his men are packing the superior weapons and armour over Ryan's little band of pirates. Whatever little psych warfare Ryan tries to achieve against Lloyd will be useless since in their eyes, the Pirates will seem to look and act stupid.