User blog comment:Lasifer/All-Stars vs. Smash Bros. 1: Big Daddy vs. Bowser/@comment-5232784-20130207034701

Okay lets have a gander

1. melee weaponry

Bowser has claws, fists, spiked shell, and teeth, while Big Daddy has a metal head, a huge fist, and a drill hand. Both have lethal weapons here, but Big Daddy has a major advantage with his drill hand, which can be turned on and cause grusome injury and death. I give this to Big Daddy.

EDGE: Big Daddy

2. Unconventional attacks

Bower's fire breathe and Giga Bowser capabilities are formidable. The latter in my opinion may be big Daddy's undoing. However, Big Daddy can fire back with freezing, cyclone fire, electric and flood attacks, and has a sister ready to drain the life from his enemies. Also, his Frenzy state and drill fowards eject are good counters to the latter capability. Due to the greater variety of unconventional strikes, I'd say Big Daddy wins here

EDGE: Big Daddy

3. X-Factors

Bowser wins in the strength and intelligence department, while Big Daddy wins in the durability, brutality, and speed department. However, the lack of intelligence on Big Daddy's part is not such a disadvantage when we remember that little Sistr Gather, which is as far as I can tell intelligent, is with him in this fight, and may talk to him, guide him during combat. And we have to rememer the speed advantage and combine it with the lethal drill hand.

EDGE: Big Daddy

I give this to Big Daddy, due to more lethal weaponry, more unconventional attacks, and a commanding lead in X-Factors

BIG DADDY WINS