User blog comment:Goddess of Despair/Season 6 Battle 2 Nazi Werwolfs vs Alamo Scouts/@comment-5795750-20130830034648

BG1's "WWII Again; and Not Enough Weapons!" Edges:

Close Range: I'm torn here - the Luger is the lighter and more powerful pistol with a bigger magazine but the M1911 fires the larger rounds and is very reliable...

EDGE: Even

Mid Range: Same as edge above - the MP40 is the lighter and more powerful gun with a big magazine while the Thompson fires the larger rounds, has a reliable feed system and sprays more lead... I actually might have to give this to the Thompson despite the good features of the MP40

EDGE: Alamo Scouts

Long Range: Even though the Gewehr is lighter than the M1 and it can be reloaded in the middle of a battle compared to the M1 Garand's "en bloc" clip magazine, I have to give this to the Garand for having a larger range and a higher muzzle velocity behind each shot; did I also mention the Garand is also reliable (I mean it has worked on the wet and muddy grounds of France, the blistering cold of Belgium and the hot steamy islands of the Pacific during the war so that should account for something)?

EDGE: Alamo Scouts

Overall Winner: So here we have two sets of battle-hardened commandos packing very powerful weaponry. At the end of the day, I will have to give this to the Alamo Scouts plainly because of their greater ordeal in the Pacific, the greater reliability of their weaponry and their better organization/teamwork; the Werewolves were formed by the war's end when Germany was losing badly so you could look at the Werewolves as a patchily-made war unit that was doomed to fail from the start