User blog comment:Bl02PIE/Robocop vs Judge Dredd/@comment-25253035-20200104154311

Lawmaker vs Auto-9: Okay, I give this one easily to the lawmaker. The Auto-9 is just a simple machine pistol, while the Lawmaker is a machine pistol and a whole myrad of other weapons. It can be used to fire explosives, heat-seeking rounds, gas rounds etc. It also has an auto-targetting system, making it more accurate, and a tremendous advantage in magazine count.

Edge: Judge Dredd

Secondary: This is an interesting comparison. There's no doubt that Judge Dredd gets the edge in versatility since he has like a ton of different ammo he can use. The only problem is that, unlike the lawgiver, he can't just switch to each ammo with a switch or voice recognition. He still has to pump those rounds in the barrel manually. Robocop also needs to manually switch weapons, but his weapons seems to be more versatile (that frag-firing sniper rifle would do so well against Judge Dredd).

Edge: Robocop

Melee: Each of these melee weapons have its strengths. The terminal strip is no doubt the nastier weapon with more killing potential than the mostly less-lethal combat stick. However, unlike Robocop, Dredd is better trained in martial arts and hand to hand combat, and can use that stick with better efficiency to attack Robocop with multiple strikes. To be honest, I doubt each weapons would be that lethal unless they hit a weakness. So I give them neither the edge.

Edge: Even

Armor: Robocop's armor is made up of titatnium alloy and protects his body as a whole. Judge Dredd's uniform is weaker and doesn't protect him that well.

Edge: Robocop

Powers and Final Verdict: This may sound crazy, but I am going with Judge Dredd. Robocop has everything going for him such as being stronger (is a casual wall-level combatant), tougher (he can survive a warehouse explosion and a rocket launcher) and has a computer-assited brain for better combat cognition. But Dredd has the advantage in the superior priamry weapon, and his secondary weapon isn't really that bad either. He's also faster that Robocop. Even if Robocop can fly around and launch fire after fire against Judge Dredd, the latter is a bullet timer who can easily dodge Robocop's attack, before unleashing his armor piercing and frag rounds to take Robocop down (his lawmaker is strong enough to destroy tanks with frags and heatseeking rounds).

But what really gives the victory for Judge Dredd for me is his experience. Seriosuly, msot of Robocop's enemies are thugs who are weaker than him. He did fought a few robots like the ED-209, the cyborg Cain, and that robotic ninja guy. But Dredd on the other hand? The dude fought mutants, superhumans, cyborgs, monsters, psychics, and even Death itself. The fact that he's defeated these rogue gallery gave him enough expeirence to defeat Robocop. He's fought robots and cyborgs that are more advanced than Robocop and won. Hell, Dredd proved hismelf to be faster than a computer robot in a shootout. So Robocop won't be a problem.

Winner: Judge Dredd