User blog comment:Alockwood1/Sir Daniel Fortesque Versus Samurai Jack/@comment-5795750-20150724030910

BG1's "Knight vs Samurai but with a twist" Edges:

Unarmed: This one definitely goes to Jack since martial arts trumps any other form of unarmed melee combat such as the one Daniel brings to the table

EDGE: Jack

Melee: Will have to call this even considering how sword and shield > simple sword but upon looking at the swords simply for what they are (a katana and a broadsword) the katana is the superior sword over the broadsword

EDGE: Even

Range: Crossbow vs bow, eh? Well after actually looking at how Dan's crossbow works (in that it has a rapid rate of fire) I will have to call this even - I'm slightly leaning towards the yumi given that it can be fired more accurately and has the same amount of power behind it as the crossbow but you can't deny that having a crossbow with a fast rate of fire and one-handed capability is a good perk for Dan to have

EDGE: Even (slight lean towards Jack)

Secondary: Definitely the axe wins here since the spear has a smaller blade and yes it may have range as both a melee and ranged weapon but essentially as a throwing weapon it becomes useless and as a melee weapon... see reason above

EDGE: Dan

Special X-Factor: Undead durability vs photographic memory (Hulk vs Taskmaster, anyone?)... I will actually have to say that Jack wins out here because his ability potentially allows him to use Dan's weapons and fighting style as his own

EDGE: Jack

X-Factors: Wow you did the calculations ahead of me...

EDGE: Jack

Overall Winner: I will have to go with the others here and say that Samurai Jack is the main winner here simply because he packs in the greater set of weaponry where it counts, the greater set of skills and a very decent amount of experience; as Skull and Elgb have implied in their votes, Jack has very good swordsmanship skills as well as the superhuman reflexes and speed necessary to dodge and counterattack weapons both futuristic and ancient. And for that misspelling troll of an anon's information, the battle isn't necessarily one to the death - what Skull, Elgb and I are trying to get at is that Jack may not want to kill Dan but he will certainly not be the first one to give up; also, your example of Aku using the katana and not hurting Jack is clearly an example of not what you are trying to prove but what Alock has said in the blog: "this sword can only be used for good, and, in the hands of Evil, cannot harm the Innocent" - Jack isn't evil so technically, in his hands, he could use the katana to shatter Dan into pieces and even if he cannot do that, Jack can simply use his martial arts, yumi or even Dan's own weapons to do the job instead if he so inclines

PS Misspelling troll of an anon, I'm sure Skull and Elgb have played the MediEvil game and watched enough of Samurai Jack to know what they are talking about so don't lecture them about any missing points