User blog comment:Geekboy27/Jonah Hex vs John Marston vs Silas Greaves/@comment-17814994-20140709065528

Elgb's "Clint Eastwood wannabes" edges

Melee: No contest here. The tomahawk is superior than the knife and the pistol whip. The axe has a farther reach, throwable, and deals more damage. Next is the knife. Edge: Hex, Marston, and Silas

Pistol: John is no doubt in a big disadvantage since he only carries one pistol. Jonah comes second because his Dragoon revolver are inferior than the Rangers and has the lowest caliber of the three. Silas comes on top with his ranger pistols having larger caliber and more reliable firing. Edge: Silas, Hex, Marston

Mid: Marston's Henry rifle may have the bigger tubular magazine, but its no doubt slower in firing rate because of its inferior lever, and its slow and cumbersome reloading. Jonah and Silas have the same weapons, but I have to go with Jonas on this one, seeing him gundown a whole army of KKK's in the first arc of all-star Western.Edge: Hex, SIlas, Marston

Deadliest Warrior:

3rd: Silas Greaves. I have respect for Silas in terms of his accuracy and ability to dodge bullets when the time is right, and he himself has some good weapons in him, but of all the three he has less skill in terms of close quarters and in quick draw skill. Don't get me wrong Silas has been in duels with historical people like Jesse James, but those guys, especially James, have no records of participating in any quickdraw duels and gunfights. Silas just doesn't have the experience Marston and Hex have.

2nd: John Marston. Although Marston has the inferior weapons, he does have one advantage in that category; smokeless gunpowder. Having fought in the early 20th Century, John would have carried smokeless gunpowder which is better than blackpowder Hex and Silas may be using. These powder has more poer in it, and is more accurate. John himself has been to numerous gunfights and duels, and can gun down multiple enemies at once with a draw.

1st: Jonah Hex. Hex wins easily. His undeniable experience stomps the other two. Hex has fought against supernatural creatures and even been transported to the future (even gunning futuristic gangs with only his Ruger blackhawks). But his winning factor is his almost superhuman quickdraw speed. Hex has outdrawn a zombie Wild Bill Hickok (one of the few historical gunfighters who has been in a real quickdraw duel), and even outdrawn the g*ddamn Batman himself. In the end, hex would outgun the two, killing them and getting drunk after.