User blog comment:El Alamein/The Screaming Eagles vs. The Lusthog Squad/@comment-5495321-20121205025716

I am going with the Screaming Eagles on this one.

Here's why:

Weaponry:

Close range: Luthog squad: It apears that the M1911A1 handgun is obviously on both sides, but in terms of blades, the bowie and combat kinfe are pretty evenly matched, but the Machete over the spike bayonet is way really gives it to the Lusthog squad.

EDGE: Lusthog Squad

Mid range: Screaming Eagles: The M16A1 was both unreliable and unpowerful in its time. The M14 and the AK are going to be the more effective weapons for the battlefield. Their reliability and caliber are even, but the AK gets the edge in rate of fire and magazine capacity.

EDGE: Screaming Eagles

Long: Even, they bring the same weapons.

EDGE: Even

Special: Even: The squads each bring a LAW, M79, frag grenade and a non lethal weapon. The Red Ryder BB gun is only supplied to one warrior, but in all honsety, has less effectiveness in combat compared to that of the smoke grenade. But I'm going to call this one even.

EDGE: Even

Leadership: Lusthog: The Eagles' leader depends on someone else in the squad on their decisions in combat. Lusthog's leader, while a rebel, would, in my opinion, lead his troops more effectively in combat.

Morale: Even: Both groups of soldiers had outsanding morale for their situations in combat.

Combat Experience: Eagles: The soldiers of the Screaming Eagles received more in combat experience than the Lusthog.

tactics: Eagles: After three days of combat, the Eagles managed to take Hamburger hill. This would be exhausting and have taken much planning and tactics.

Teamwork: Even: I would say that both teams worked together in combat fairly well together.

Training: Eagles: As 101st airborne members, they received greater training.

Supplies: Eagles: Like Beast said, the Eagles sruvived for three days on a hill. They may not have the supplies, but they used them better.

Calm under fire: Eagles: Again, surviving for three days while under constant fire is big in this category.

Success: Even: Both were successful in their missions.

WINNER: SCREAMING EAGLES