User blog comment:Leolab/User Siege Tourney, Round 16 of 75: Beastman14 (Ryan) v MilitaryBrat (Evans)/@comment-4552610-20130622134833

General
Main Melee: The Cutlass is a fast little sword but it is not as long, as powerful or as destructive as the Claymore. Also comes to the fact that blocking or even surviving a hit from it will end up bad.
 * EDGE: James

Offhand Melee: The War Hammer is a powerful little weapon but is it not as versatile or as long ranged as the throwing knife.
 * EDGE: Ryan

Polearm: The Boarding Pike is a low-quality spear meant for simplicity. The Alabarda is essentially a Halabard. Halabard beats spear any day.
 * EDGE: James

TO BE CONTINUE...