User blog comment:JGM007/S1, E2: Edward the Black Prince VS William the Conqueror/@comment-5078776-20130103033206

Cfp3157's "TALLY HO!" edges:

Close Range: The Broadsword is lighter and will work better with William's lighter armor. So with swords...Edge: William the Conqueror

Mid Range: The longbow may be faster and go farther, but the crossbow has a lighter draw weight and can be used by anyone. Edge: Even

Long Range: The thing with siege weapons is that they're not meant to be light. They're meant to hit hard and far. The trebuchet simply does this better. Edge: The Black Prince

Armor: The plate armor protects the user better than the chainmail hauberk. Edge: The Black Prince

Tactics: While the Feigned Retreat is good, it's too situational. If Edward doesn't pursue, William will fall victim to the surrounding archers that the Black Prince will place around him. Edge: The Black Prince

WINNER: The Black Prince. This is just a rematch of William's fight against Joan of Arc. And it'll end in the same way. The Black Prince is not only bringing the better armor and long range weapon, but he also bringing the better tactics and a faster mid range weapon. These factors will let the Black Prince win, and not as barely as Joan.