User blog comment:GSFB/Night of the Living Dead Survivors vs Mughal War Elephants/@comment-4661256-20121212220630/@comment-5232784-20121212222611

Okay, we got another vote for the NOTLDS. 2 to 3, in the Mughal's favor.

I doubt that several bullets from a Winchester would cause these elephants to panic, but perhaps if enough of them and the revolver bullets can get past their armor (plate and chain mail combo) then they might do this. However, they have to do it a lot to panic a well trained war elephant. I think they have a better chance if they hit an eye or two, which would make it much easier for them. And I think they will have better success getting them to panic with a well tossed Molotov cocktail.