User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 2 Episode 8: Mohawk Warrior vs Germanic Warrior/@comment-422690-20130303001757

So...

Close range: Fire-Hardened Club wins. While I like knives, they fall short in the reach category. The club will give both nice reach and a good bit of blunt trauma. Edge: Germanic Warrior.

Mid Range: Tomahawk wins. Sure, the shortsword is longer. However, the Tomahawk can be thrown, and its design also allows it to trap an opponent's weapon and disarm them. It's more versatile, and a better defensive weapon. Edge: Mohawk Warrior

Long Range: Bow and Arrow wins, hands-down. This one is all about range, range, and more range. Edge: Mohawk Warrior.

Special: Shield wins. It'll neutralize all of the Apache's weaponry, and that nice Steel Boss can be used as a bashing weapon. Edge: Germanic Warrior.

Overall: Germanic Warrior wins. Despite having better designed weaponry, the Mohawk Warrior loses here because of two crippling aspects: He is unable to neutralize the shield and has mostly stone-age weapons (save the randomly steel Tomahawk) while the Germanic Warrior has iron and steel weaponry.