User blog comment:Lasifer/Professor Pyg vs The Riddler/@comment-26074921-20120331031742

I have to vote Riddler, though not much can be said that hasn't been already, Riddler may not always ssem like a straight up fighter, but when you dominate Inetelligence, Creativity, Speed, and Experience, you have some attributes that cannot be ignored.

Pyg may have a better iconic weapon (The Riddler's staff not bringing anything lethal to the fight) but the Riddler's question marks easily outclass another set of melee weapons, especially considering how he'll more than likely use them (lol I really hope you don't just have him chuck them at pyg).