User blog comment:SPARTAN 119/Rena Ryuguu (Higurashi) vs Kusaka Tatsuhiko (Kara No Shoujo)/@comment-5795750-20130122140604

BG1's "Do we have a psycho in the house?" Edges

Primary: As much as I want to go for the Nata since it has the larger blade, I may have to go with the hatchet on this one since the hatchet can also be made into a thrown weapon, giving it a slightly greater range... unless Kusaka doesn't know how to throw a hatchet.

EDGE: Kusaka

Secondary: The pipe like you said is of a greater length but it is heavy compared to the scalpel, and besides, while the pipe can guarantee blunt force trauma, Kusaka's scalpel is a double-edged weapon. If the scalpel cut don't kill you, then the infection will.

EDGE: Kusaka

Special: I'm gonna call this even because Kusaka's awl is presumably not used for combat purposes but what are the chances Rena is going to find a glass window in the battlefield and break it so she can use a glass shard?

EDGE: Even (slight edge to Rena)

Overall Winner: As much as I want Rena to win this, I think Kusaka Tatsuhiko takes this battle since he is older and thus has more experience in dealing with (insert word) like Rena, plus with his brutality, he would seem more intimidating than Rena could imagine. If this battle were to end in a draw, may I suggest that a slash from Rena's nata kills Kasuka but the infection from the scalpel spreads and causes Rena to collapse and die.