User blog comment:Alockwood1/Sir Daniel Fortesque Versus The Scotsman/@comment-5795750-20160416141650

BG1's "Dan's Journey Prequel... right?" Edges:

Unarmed - I think its pretty obvious that if you have both arms AND superhuman strength then you definitely can with ease defeat an opponent whose only party quirk in a CQC fight is merely taking his arm out and whacking you with it

EDGE: The Scotsman

Main Weapon - Well at least this one isn't hampered by any magical BS that could prevent it from being a lethal killing machine and IIRC a Scottish claymore sword is two-handed meaning the Scotsman will definitely have some power behind each swing; however it is just a sword and it essentially will falter when compared to a sword-and-shield combo that actually may do Dan wonders

EDGE: Even

Long Range - Easy edge to the Scotsman's machinegun leg which apparently reminds me of Rose McGowan's M16 leg... oh yeah, the reasons why the edge is given? Well its more modern than Dan's anachronistic Gatling and thus packs a much better performance and to practically top it all off, its attached to the Scotsman via his leg and thus is not as easy to lose in the middle of combat as the portable Gatling

EDGE: Scotsman

Explosives - Dan's Bomb Grenados are simply ancient versions of the modern/futuristic grenade of our era and that of the era of Samurai Jack. Need I say more?

EDGE: Scotsman

Psychological - Well this is an interesting comparison you are having us make here Alock... anyway I have to give this to the bagpipes since his playing of them could cause a great deal of trauma and pain to Dan who, despite being undead, is capable of hearing and thus also capable of using both his hands to try to block out the noise leaving him vulnerable (if the Scotsman is quick enough to drop the bagpipes and then strike down Dan while he still has his ears covered)

EDGE: Scotsman

X-Factors - You've done it already and I'm proud of you

EDGE: Scotsman

Overall Winner: Although he may appear to be a dumb brute, I don't think that The Scotsman will lose out in this fight to the undead Dan - I mean his weapons are more advanced than Dan's given that he has a machine gun and a grenade compared to Dan's grenado and Gatling; furthermore, if he is able to go toe-to-toe with the skilled Samurai Jack with his great strength in CQC and expert skill with his weapons (and I think the Scotsman will comically find a way to turn his bagpipes into a weapon) then taking down the undead and not-so-well trained or experienced knight shouldn't be that much of a difficulty.