User blog comment:Couldnotthinkofagoodname/Shion Sonozaki vs Hannibal Lecter/@comment-379205-20140222033757

119's "Stopping in Hinamizawa for Dinner" Edges:

Weapon 1: The hunting knife, while not designed for combat per-se, still have a blade more similar to that of a combat knife, while a meat cleaver is nothing like a purpose-built weapon. The meat cleaver is heavy, with a formidable chopping ability, but it lacks a point, meaning it can't thrust. On the other hand, the hunting knife can be used both the slash and thrust, and can be deadly in either a hammer or icepick grip, making it much more versatile. Edge Shion

Weapon 2: While Shion's sledgehammer is shorter than the one pictured, it still has a longer handle than the meat mallet. The meat tenderizer does have some spikes on the end, which may help with focusing the impact, however, Shion's hammer is heavier, and in the end, takes my edge.

Weapon 3: This one is more difficult. The kitchen knife is a more straight forward weapon, and more likely to kill, while the spiked whip is capable of ripping off chunks of skin and flesh with each strike, but in the end, is intended to torture, rather than kill. Hannibal is known to be a skilled combatant with his knives, and if he is wearing the suit in the first picture, the relatively thick jacket would likely minimize the impact of strikes to the torso- as the relatively short spikes would not be able to cause significant damage after first having the pierce the jacket. That, along with the fact that whip could get caught on something or even go out of control and hit Shion as it swings back gives Hannibal the edge.

Weapon 4: Shion's stun gun takes this easily being able to stun a target with an electric shock. Shion's is illegally modified to the point where it can knock at least someone the size of Keiichi Maebara unconcious. While Hannibal is much larger than Keiichi and may better handle the shock, it should still create an opening for Shion to finish the job with her hunting knife. Edge: Shion

Special Weapons: This one is more complicated. The Syringe would be debilitating and eventually lethal. However, in my opinion, Hannibal's martial arts training takes this, as the syringe could be shattered by a strike from a knife or mallet, and Hannibal's martial arts training can be used with his weapons to make them more effective, for instance, allow him to gain the upper hand in a grapple and then finish off a downed opponent with his knife.

X-Factors: Hannibal takes the majority of the important X-Factors, including strength, skill, and experience. Shion takes agility, as well as the less important brutality and insanity, the latter of which may be detrimental, causing her to make a fatal mistake. Edge: Hannibal.

Overall Winner: As formidable and downright terrifying as Shion Sonozaki is, she is not at the same level as Hannibal. She has only been killing a relatively short time, while Hannibal is an experienced killer. Hannibal is also train in combat, probably to a better level than Shion, and has unquestionable superior intelligence. This will enable Hannibal to overcome Shion's weapons and eat her for dinner.... literally...