User blog comment:CuchulainSetanta/Sinbad vs. Tarzan/@comment-5931345-20130606165420

Short range: The shamshir is longer and is more deadly than the knife so it gets the edge. But be warned Tarzan has fought other swordsman before and he knows how to counter them. Edge: Sinbad

Mid range: The Wooden spear gets the edge becasue it is longer and can distance the opponent. Not to mention that Tarzan throws hat thing with aacuracy from time to time. Edge: Tarzan

Long range: Although the Siphon can do more damage, and can burn the jungle Tarzan is in. The bow has the longer range and is pin point accurate: Edge: Tarzan

X-factors: Hard to say on this one. Sinbad has more experience fighting in his many advnetures, while Tarzan is physicall superior than Sinbad. Sinbad seems to be a little bit cunning becasue of his feats of survival, while Tarzan can improvise and has tactics he can use. But I have to go with Tarzan becasue in a battle physicality is much important. Edge: Tarzan

Winner: Tarzan would win simply becasue he has the btter weapons that would dominate in range and becasue og his physical superiority. Sinbad is a great warrior but he's more of a simple merchant, and many of his adventures were more about luck than combat.