User blog comment:Goddess of Despair/The "pro" season battle 2 Jesse James vs Crazy Horse/@comment-5232784-20121215225342

Very interesting, this is more in the tradition of the DW tv show than most fights here.

Lets have a look, shall we?

1. Short range

A Bowie Knife can be considered by some as a short sword, a very effectiv3e short range weapon, more so in close quarter combat than the tomahawk, in my opinion. However, to throw a knife you have to move your hand from the handle to the blade, while with the tomahawk you dont have to do this: you throw a Tomahawk by its handle instead. Therefore, one can throw a tomahawk in quicker time than you could a knife, because while one is flipping his knife around for a throw, the other is already aiming and throwing a tomahawk. Due to these advantages and disadvantages of both weapons, I call this even

Edge: Dead Even

2. Mid range

Both of these revolvers are quite similar, so there is not much of a difference here to make a big advantage of one over the other. However, Jesse Jame's revolver has a bit faster muzzle velocity, and I think it tends to be a slight advantage here.

Edge: Jesse James

3. Long range.

Crazy Horse's Henry has less weight (slightly) and an extra bullet, but James' Winchester has twice the range. The Winchester wins out over the Henry due to the awesome range superiority.

Edge: Jesse James

4. Special

The pistol whip is a effective way to knock a guy out, but the Inyankeapi war club is designed to kill with one swat; unlike the pistol whip, the Club here is a lethal weapon

Edge: Crazy Horse

5. Tactical advantage

This is where Craz Horse is weak: leading his men into a battle means that he will most likely be the first person picked off by the winchester rifle, and in many battles, when the leader is killed, his army panics and retreats.

Plus, while Cazy Horse and his men have revolvers, Jesse and his goons will be quicker draws...

Edge: Jesse James

Verdict: Jesse James wins this

JESSE JAMES WILL WIN!!!