User blog comment:MilenHD/Guan Yu vs Miyamoto Musashi/@comment-28716800-20160924134241

Battlefan's 'The Romance of two deadliest fictions' Edge !

Short Range: As I have mentioned before in many other battles corresponded to the use of Dao in China, Chinese are masters of using this dull but yet fearsome weapon. However the effect of this weapon wields when it comes to a comparison between Katana, a more flexible weapon that functions in a great variety of ways to attack such as waving style and stabbing rather than Dao's simple cutting and slashing, I'm giving this edge to Musashi.

Middle Range: The Green Crescent Blade is Guan Yu's iconic trademark. While Musashi maybe a master of using his Bokken, the wooden weapon is just no match with a steel-intensified Blade. Also, I find it hard not to mention that the Green Crescent Blade accompanied Guan from the very begining of his military career till his tragic end, Guan regarded it as a certian part of his life but not a simple killing tool, which suggests that Guan injected his own emotion into this weapon that had become a fraction of his motivation, making it more deadly for Guan to use in combats. Edge: Guan Yu.

Long Range: Guan's bow has a pretty primitive design comparing to Musashi's, but Guan's brilliant skills of using it really make sense in this one-one battle. So it's pretty hard for me to decide this one, so I put an end to this tough pair by setting down an edge.

Special : The Wakizashi is in fact a minimaking of Katana, but this doesn't mean that it's as deadly as its prototype due to the fact that it's a pretty normal form of weapon while its opponents Yin-Yang Daggers are more unexpected and creative weapon which are very easy to operate a sudden close range stab or slash. Edge: Guan Yu.

X factors: While Musashi is a more disciplined warrior who had received better training, Guan had fought in more significant wars, and he actually led a gigantic group of soldiers to secure many victories agianst sophisticated millitary artist Cao Cao and Sun Quan the Warlord of Southern China. He'd also had a record of killing leading generals in Cao Cao's and Yuan Shao's teams. Edge: Guan Yu.

Overall: I really respect Musashi and consider him as one of my favorite warriors, but toady I have to give this to Guan because his just more experienced and brilliant for Musashi to deal with. Winner: Guan Yu !