User blog:Greenberet69/Last Battle 2 of 9: Alvin York vs. John Marston

''' Alvin York: The Famous World War I American Soldier from Tennessee who single handedly took out Machin Gun nests, and captured 132 German Soldiers using his amazing Sharpshooting skills. '''

 VS. 

 John Marston: 

'''The Wild West outlaw who hunted down his former gang members in order to resue his family from the Governement. '''

When these two Legendary Sharpshooters go head to head only one will come out and emerge as THE DEADLIEST WARRIOR!



We have Reality vs. Fiction

Both operated back in the early 20th Century and both are famous Sharpshooters.

Battle Notes
5 vs. 5

York and 4 Fellow American Soldiers vs. Marston and 4 other Outlaws.

Following the failed attempt of killing John Marston the Governemnt sends Alvin York and 4 other American Soldiers returning from World War I to take out Marston and 4 outlaws who have befriended him.

Battleground

 * Thieves Landing (Red Dead Redemption)

X-Factors
York-Marston

93 Training 85

Edge Alvin York: York received US Army training where as Marston didin't have any sort of training

95 Combat Experience 94

Edge Alvin York: York was fighting against the well trained, and more brutal and powerful German Armies in the First World War where as Marston while he fought the Mexican army in the revolution are nowhere near as tough as the Germn armies and mostly fought outlaws, and bandits.

94 Calm Under Fire 86

Edge Alvin York: Being able to take out Machine Gun nests, and capture 132 German's single handedly was not and easy task and yet York got it done.

Personal Opinion:

I have to give this Battle to Alvin York. He is legendary for what he did during World War I being able to single handedly take out MG nests, and capturing 132 German prisoners by himself. Not to mention he fought against the well trained are deadly German Army where as Marston mostly fought against other Outlaws.