User blog comment:Greenberet69/Boromir vs Carver Hawke/@comment-422690-20120217213431

Close range: Lineage Maul wins. Sure, a sword and shield is good, but mauls are designed to break those. Edge: Carver Hawke.

Long Range: Even. Despite a bow being better than throwing knives, Carver can't equip a bow. :P.

In all honesty, despite the fact that the Fellowship (with the exception of Gimli) has been shown to be pretty adept at throwing weapons, the Grey Warden archers that Carver will likely bring have far more range. Edge: Carver Hawke.

Overall: Carver wins. Despite his whiny mage-hating personality, he has better armor and weapons.