Board Thread:Warrior's Pub/@comment-4661256-20181227160325

I would like to request a rematch for Manofgod's recent Bernard Montgomery vs. Douglas MacArthur battle for a few important reasons:

1) Some of the weapons chosen (i.e. the PIAT, and even the Sten/Bren) are not necessarily the best choices, while others which would make sense (i.e. the Grease gun, which even makes an appearance in the written simulation) are omitted. 2) The x-factors are not very detailed and often inaccurate (to give one example, Dunkirk has very little to do with Montgomery, who was not in control of the strategic decisions being made and should have no impact on his score in logistics). 3) The biographies are incredibly lacking and there is no information beyond surface knowledge. 4) Not enough emphasis is placed on the tactical/strategic capabilities of the respective commanders, who are certainly more famous for tactics, strategies, and leadership than personal combat and should thus factor in to the blog.

Link to the blog: https://deadliestfiction.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Manofgod/Bernard_Montgomery_vs_Douglas_McArthur 