User blog comment:Lasifer/1001 Days: Merle Dixon vs. Trevor Philips/@comment-24905168-20140509153207

Melee: I'm giving this to the baseball bat. Its longer and more useful in combat. Although it isn't as lethal the bat can cause more lasting damage than the Knife. With a blow to the head it can make your vision blurry and if you are bleeding the blood will get in your eyes making it harder to see making you vulnerable to another attack.

Pistol 1: Merle gets this one, although the weapons are very similar his pistol just has one more bullet it can spare in the fight. Even though it's just one bullet, that one bullet could be the one to end your life.

Pistol 2: Have to give it to the M1911, though it has lower capacity than the H&K, it has far greater stopping power and range.

Assult rifle: Giving this one to Trevor, though it lacks the capacity it needs to keep up with Merle, it has a far larger capacity making it to were he can spare more ammo than Merle.

X-factors: Merle, his X- factors are overall higher than Trevors.

DW: Trevor, though it was a 2:3 Trevor's weapons have more capacity except the taurus and a better close range weapon. He can spare more bullets and I don't see this battle being fought from long distance so I doubt Merle's advantage on range would come on top of Trevor's capacity. Even though Merle had the better X-factors Trevor has fought people with more experience and training than he has.