User blog comment:ILoveBattles/ILoveBattles (Collab with WanderingSkull) - Season 1 - Episode 4 - James Gang vs Dutch's Gang/@comment-5795750-20160224031536/@comment-4661256-20160224035034

Mid Range: The .45 Colt is a larger round than the 7.65mm Borchardt (which is .454 inches vs. .309 inches). Also, the two round advantage of the semi-auto pistol is pretty negligible when you factor in the extreme level of skill the James Gang possesses with their handguns. Now I'm not implying that Dutch's Gang isn't skilled with their guns but I don't think they can beat firing in a quarter of a second--on Deadliest Warrior they even said that's faster than human perception can register, so Dutch's Gang won't even know what hit them, quite literally.

You claim Dutch's Gang has superior weaponry but the only edges you even gave them was pistols (which is very debatable, per my above paragraph) and the shotgun (the impact of which is going to be limited in a long-ranged quickdraw of a firefight). If anything the rifle is going to be the most important factor here due to range and accuracy and the Evans is just so terrible that it renders the weapon effectively impractical in a combat situation. That's why I think your vote is substantially flawed.