User blog comment:FEARTHEWAFFLE/Indiana Jones vs Vigilante/@comment-5795750-20131218235700

BG1's "Alright, if you want" Edges:

Close: Machete gets the edge here since it has a large blade and thus grants more room for a kill than simply waving the butt of your gun around

EDGE: Indy

Medium: Hmmm... this is quite an interesting matchup since Indy with his bullwhip can disarm foes and so can Vigilante with the lasso. I'd say its even here since both can do almost the same job

EDGE: Even

Long: 1 double action revolver vs two single shots? I'd actually have to go with the single shooters here since they bring twice the amount of ammo and perhaps twice the firepower

EDGE: Vigilante

X-Factors: Average of 86.2 for Indy, Average of 86.6 for Vigilante

EDGE: Vigilante

Overall Winner: I would pretty much say that Vigilante wins out here althought it will be close; the only way for Indy to win is if he can close the distance between him and his opponent and disarm him of the lasso and revolvers, however Vigilante's sharpshooting skills here will aid him immensely in keeping Indy away from a close range fight - add to that Vigilante's experience fighting alongside superheros against some superheroic threats (who might as well have weapons that are like Indy's) and you got yourself one ass-kicking street-smart cowboy