User blog comment:RSV 123/Chatrapati Shivaji vs. Attila the Hun/@comment-5232784-20120804032536

At first, it seems that Atila has the advantage in projectiles: he has more of them (throwing spear, bo and arrow, axe that can be thrown), and though the Brown Bess Musket will have more power and (perhaps?) more range, it will not have the fast reload time that a bow and arrow has. However, Shivaji is better armored, and the power and noise of the Musket should serve as a powerful psychological weapon. Plus, some musket balls could produce some grevious wounds (some musket balls from the civil war, for example, when hitting an arm bone, could turn up into the bone instelf and be impossible to pull out, hence many amputations).

My edge: Shivaji (but by a narrow margin, due to longer sword, better armor, and powerful and psychological power of the Musket)