User blog comment:Thornclaw Braveheart/Thorin Oakenshield vs. Roran Stronghammer/@comment-5465602-20130220010509

BeastMan14's "Good with a Hammer vs Has a shield of timber" edges

Close-Range: Roran is a goddamn beast with his hammer. He's killed dozens of Imperials with it, but Thorin's axe can kill a lost faster and its a dwarf weapon of choice. Edge: Thorin

Mid-Range: Ocrist is Thorin's primary weapon and he is incredibly skilled with it. The spear is pretty much a liability if it misses when thrown. Edge: Thorin

Long-Range: Thorin has the better bow, but he rarely uses it and is likely not very skilled. Roran is a farmer, and he happens to be brother to one of the best archers out there, who likely taught him some skills. Edge: Roran

Special Weapon: I have to give to the Oakshield, its stronger and can be used more offensively. edge: Thorin

Deadliest Warrior: This is close, but Thorin wins out. He's stronger, better trained, and brings the better weapons.