User blog comment:Urbancommando77/John Marston V.S. Ned Kelly/@comment-3127606-20130528004130

MB's "Seriously, WTF is that on my wall?" edges:

Close range: Edge Marston-The hunting knife is a much larger piece of death. The blade can penetrate far deeper and inflict much more savage wounds.

Mid Range: Edge Marston-The Lemat has the option of utilizing a shotgun attachment, in addition to the actual pistol. When you have options, you can be more effective on the battlefield.

Long Range: Edge Marston- The Winchester has more than double the amount of rounds than the Spencer, it has a more effective reload system, and is double action.

Special: Edge Marston- The shotgun gets the edge here because despite having a shorter range and less ammo, it was far more reliable a weapon to use.

Special 2: Edge Ned-The snyder is an actual weapon. That's all that needs to be said here bub.

Winner: John Marston-He has the superior weaponry, the terrain advantage, and the will to get past this obstacle.