User blog comment:Richard Starkey/Jesse James Vs. John Marston/@comment-143604-20110810165401

Ask and ye shall receive-uh. I don't know enough about guns to do edges, but I give the close range edge to James. The Saw-Blade can be a liability if Marston isn't careful with how he uses it, and not only could he lose his weapon, he could lose the whole fight if he hits something minor with it and can't pull it out before taking a bullet. That said, the Tomahawk coupled with a revolver and rifle that can go toe to toe with the Colt Revolver and Winchester, and James still using the Pistol Whip in lieu of a real weapon, I'm giving the edge to Marston. Plus his experience with the Mexican Army, his gang which ran similar to the Jesse James gang, and his government work, he beats out.