User blog comment:Leolab/User Siege Tourney, Round 40 of 50: Redkite (Markus) v Cfp3157 (Shengway)/@comment-422690-20140214210758

Attacker:
Overrun: Easily. Shengway's simply not prepared to hold off a competent fighting force. (10-yard distance between spikes for a barricade? Only someone too smashed to stand would think that's an adequate defense.)

Force Surrender: Very likely. Shengway's terrible loyalty score against Markus's massive one is going to make a difference here.

Single Combat: Very likely. Markus is simply better equipped to fight one-on-one than Shengway is; he's got lighter equipment but better defenses.

Points: 3

Likely victory: yes.

Defender
Annihilate: Not likely. Shengway's not even prepared enough to repel Markus, let alone kill his men.

Force surrender: Lolno.

Survive: Also not happening.

Single Combat: Nope. Too much equipment weighing him down.

Points: 0

Likely victory: Nope.

Tie:
I'll save some space and say that neither condition is happening. Markus isn't dying, and Shengway sure as hell ain't living.

Overall
Markus wins hands down.