User blog comment:SPARTAN 119/Mitsuko Souma (Battle Royale) vs Rena Ryuguu (Higurashi)/@comment-8012490-20130928122546

Firearms: Mitsuko has a pistol vs. Rena's bolt-action rifle. The bolt-action rifle has more range and does more damage, despite the firing rate; however, the pistol is more concealable than the rifle is and easier to use in close-quarters. But there is a reason why pistols aren't used as main battle weapon. As in, they lack in range and power. Edge: Rena.

Edged Weapons: The nata is heavier than the Kama is and it may be longer as well. Straight up edged weapons tend to be better than weapons of similar length on poles. Edge: Rena.

Close Ranged Weapons: The metal pipe is longer than the knife is and the broken glass is more lethal than the stun gun is, but the stun gun can stun Rena long enough for Souma to get he with the knife. Edge: Souma.

X-Factors: The only x-factor Rena loses in is firearms and she has the better gun to make up for it. Edge: Rena.

My vote goes to Rana.

My location vote goes to the Battleship Island.