User blog comment:Tomahawk23/John Marston VS Cole Phelps/@comment-3166030-20110803012251/@comment-3166030-20110805203551

I'm actually a girl. But with the weapons edited, I give the edge to Marston, because the Henry holds more rounds than the M1 Garand, and can hit outside of the M1A1's effective range (which is equal to an average pistol)