User blog comment:Appelmonkey/Anime Season, Epsiode 5 Superheros/Saitama (One Punch Man) vs. Superman (DC Comics)/@comment-5795750-20160215124937

BG1's "Appel you really need to fix your spelling errors" Edges:

Powers: Superman's powers cover all ranges and is versatile in both offensive and passive capabilities which is a good plus for him but I cannot ignore the idea of Saitama possessing superhuman speed, reflexes, agility and senses (including his sixth sense) to the point he can dodge attacks easily without seeing them coming. Furthermore, as Elgb points out, both characters possess great degrees of invulnerability but of course you have to remember that: a) Superman has been one-upped a bunch of times by people as strong as him (e.g. Darkseid, Doomsday) as well as those who had access to kryptonite (e.g. Lex Luthor) or magic (e.g. Mr Mxyzpltk); and 2) he has to have his power source of the sun so of course Saitama could take Supes to the far reaches of space or deep underground where no sunlight could come in

EDGE: Even

X-Factors: Both guys have been fighting a large variety of heroes throughout their respective franchises but since this is Pre-New 52 Supes we are talking about here, he's been doing this for a very long time (like 40 years or so). That being said, I could say that the moment Saitama actually meets Superman then his pessimistic attitude he's been harbouring throughout his life finally disappears but this could possibly mean his decision-making capabilities decrease (methinks since his apathy has led him to be able to make better decisions). You know what? I'm just gonna leave my explanation there and...

EDGE: Superman (barely)

Overall Winner: Yeah hopefully the One Punch fandom don't come here and ruin this beautiful battles of yours... anyway this is definitely close and Supes will definitely give Saitama a run for his money as his long-awaited worthy opponent and yes I can see the argument that Saitama can "one punch" his way to victory... but Superman can still give Saitama a hammering without even getting close to punching range - furthermore I tend to think that even though Saitama is said to see attacks coming without really seeing them, Superman can at least get the sense of Saitama coming towards him or running away to somewhere (since he has dealt with superhumanly fast people such as Barry Allen, Wally West, Wonder Woman, etc.) and thus he can formulate a plan on the fly; a thing I'd like to point out here is that Saitama is the "One PUNCH Man" so I guess if Saitama did some kicking or elbowing it would be strong enough to hurt but not fatal so I guess there's one way of besting him (grab him by the legs or any part of the arm that's not the hand) and I guess Superman could potentially do that...

You know what? Having gone through this in my mind, I can see this being a really really close match but in the end, with a greater degree of fighting superheroes that are just as strong and fast as Saitama (plus what's to stop Supes as Clark Kent find out about Saitama from his journalist contacts?), Superman might just win this match