User blog comment:BeastMan14/Why So Serious, My Beautiful Snowflake? Tyler Durden vs The Joker/@comment-4552610-20130225161458

Undead RVD's "YOU DON'T KNOW WHERE I'VE BEEN, JOE! YOU DON'T KNOW WHERE I'VE BEEN!" Edges:
Close: I would have gone with the Filleting knife as they seem to use that more often in the movie, but I digress. I'm going with the Baseball Bat. It has enough reach to keep the knife at bay AND it can knock the knife away with the right hit.
 * EDGE: Durden

Mid: You sure you got the right guns? The Smith and Wesson 4506 only carries 8 .45 ACP rounds. With that said, The Glock is the actual winner as it has more rounds in it.
 * EDGE: Joker

Long: I would say something about the MP5 having a mag size of 100 but they do make a 100 round Drum mag for it. Comparing the guns, the MP5 wins by a long shot do to its longer range (200m vs 50m), muzzle velocity (400m/s vs 288m/s) and mag size (100 rounds vs 30). The MAC-10 loses hard.
 * EDGE: Durden

Explosive: The M67 is very reliable but the Nitro-Glycerin remote bombs packs much more of an explosion and has far greater killing potential.
 * EDGE: Durden


 * Special: I find it unfair to compare a pare of brass knuckles against a F--KING ROCKET LAUNCHER. The rocket launcher has the superior range and killing ability. BIG win to the Joker
 * EDGE: Joker

Overall: This might surprise many of you but I'm backing Tyler Durden on this one. They are both very intelligent and fight to bring anarchy upon the world, and while the Joker is far Brutal, Tyler is physically superior and his men are far more loyal. Best of all, Tyler has a far larger influence across the States as their is a Fight Club and Project Mayhem in nearly every state. The Joker was attacking Gothem but Tyler was attacking the whole United States. Overall, Tyler's Physicality, Team Loyalty and larger effect on the states should be what gives him the win.