User blog comment:LB&SCR/GWM Episode 6: Albert Mayer v Henry Gunther/@comment-35549375-20190503013322

Necron Jesus's "Sad But True" Edges:

Melee: Honestly, an actual cavalry saber is easily the better weapon against a bayonet. The saber has better reach and is definetly a more effective weapon to stab someone with, compared to a small and short knife that just doesn't have enough area to kill a person like a saber does. Edge: Albert Mayer

Pistols: Going to agree with Tybalt here and give it to the Mauser. While the Colt has .45 ACP, the Mauser will be able fire for a much longer period of time and will be the more reliable weapon of the two. Edge: Albert Mayer

Rifles: Both the Enfield and Gewehr are quite similar rifle, however the Enfield does have far better range than the Gewehr, overall both weapons are pretty similar when it comes down to it, but overall I give it to the M1917 Enfield here. Edge: Henry Gunther

Overall: Ultimately despite the year gap, I'll be giving this to Albert Mayer. While Gunther did get the rifle advantage, it was really only due to the range of the Enfield. The melee and pistol edges both went to Mayer, so he seems to have the more reliable weapons of the two. I'd also give a slight physical edge to Mayer due to him being a cavalryman. Mayer himself seems to be more highly trained due to him being a Lieutenant, and depending on whether or not he's mounted can change the outcome of the battle, but either way I see Mayer defeating Gunther here.