User blog comment:Drayco90/Marvel vs. DC- Hawkeye vs. Green Arrow/@comment-26074921-20120410014330

Both the Archers have impresive arsenals suited for different tactics. Hawkeys for lethality, and Green Arrow for incapacitation. Given that information one might be inclined to vote for Hawkeye, but it matters how they use their arsenal, and Green Arrow knows how to use his arsenal alright. Couple his tatics that play to his non-lethal (for the most part) arrows and his Inteligence and Creativity x-factors and he is easily a match for the highly trained SHEILD Hawkeye.

So with the two rather closely matched, Green Arrow narrowly beats out Hawkeye for the same reason many voted for Joker over Red Skull. Combined Intelligence and Creativity outclasses training. By themselves neither are a better asset than training, but together (at least in this situation) They give Green Arrow the edge.