User blog comment:Elgb333/Miyamoto Musashi vs Julie D'Aubigny/@comment-24180428-20130908134906

Utter noob's "I still only consider one bad*ss" edges:

Primary-The Rapier is a terrible weapon. It's much weaker,  restricts you to stabbing, and can't do any harm to your opponent unless you hit their eye. The Katana on the other hand will be able to slice a person in two no problem and is more durable. Edge Miyamoto

Secondary-These two may be the same length, but the Jutte was made of iron and the dagger was made of steel. Common sense says steel>iron. Edge Julie

Special-Wood vs steel? Come on, this is obvious. The Bokken is a training sword and wont be lethal unless you hit someone over and over on the head. The Arming sword on the other hand....Edge Julie

X-factors-Julie is a alchoholic. Miyamoto was a very good tactition, going into two duels late to anger his foe, and a third duel early to surprise them. Edge Miyamoto

Winner-Miyamoto Musashi. I doubt the fight would be long enough for Miyamoto to resort to his other weaponry, the Katana should be enough. Lets not forget that he has armor, training, experience, and tactics on his side.