User blog comment:Ethandabomb/Aztec Jaguar vs. Abenaki Warrior/@comment-122.57.201.242-20130121060358

Edges

Short Range: Despite the speed and versatility of the Tecpatl I have to go with the War Club as it is the larger weapon and is the more powerful of the two

Edge: Abenaki

Mid-Range: Im going with the Maquahuitl fo its power and for the fact that the obsidian blades inflict tearing wounds which cause the target to bleed out quicker than slashing wounds. A spear is a spear.

Edge: Aztec

Long Range: While the Bow & Arrow can be fired quicker and more accurately the Aztec's cotton armour is designed to keep light projectiles like arrows out and the Atlatl & Tlacochtli has more stopping power due to the size of the projectile so...

Edge: Even

Special Weapon: The Knife has more killing power and can be thrown but the Tematlatl has the range of a football field and the hardened clay balls that the Aztecs used (they did use stones but clay balls were deemed more effective) could as you said could crack a mans skull but could also destroy a mans face. Also again there is the matter of the Aztecs armour: if it can stop an arrow then it can stop a Knife.

Edge: Aztec

Armour: Light Armour > No Armour

Edge: Aztec

Overall: the Aztec Takes this due to the fact that he has armour but is still incredibly fast and agile, the killing power of his Maquahuitl and the dire wounds it will leave if not an instant kill and the fact that the Aztec has TWO long range weapons which gives him more chances to kill the Abenaki before he can close the distance.

Winner: AZTEC JAGUAR WARRIOR