User blog comment:Atila the hutt/Batman vs Captain America/@comment-4552610-20130709012821

Undead RVD's "Why Not" Edges:
Short: Batman has this. While Captain America is stronger, Batman has beaten foes stronger and Batman is trained in multiple martial arts. Cap is a brawler compared to Bats.
 * EDGE: Batman

Mid Range: Cap's shield is an amazing weapons but it has one fatal flaw: He only has one. If Batman is able to catch it (with his immense strength and agility), he will disarm Captain America. Batman has many batarangs, including multiple types with different functions. He will be able to outmatch Cap at a range.
 * EDGE: Batman

Long Range: This is stupid. The bonoculars only gives him greater range... and that is it. Plus, it would be useless against Batman. He is a master of stealth and would be out of Cap's sight. The bolos will be able to trip him and make him an easier target.
 * EDGE: Batman

Special: This one is a tough one. The Gas Pelets will give Batman greater stealth abilities and allow him sneak up on Cap. However, Cap can hit Batman with enhanced strength (He doesn't have true superhuman strength as his strength is only slightly greater than Batman's) and can hit people harder. I am going to give this one a tie.
 * EDGE: Even

Vote: This one is an easy one. The Movie-verse Captain America is no where near as impressive as his comic counterpart while Arkham-verse Batman is not much different from his Comic-book counterpart. He has the better hand-to-hand combat abilites, throwing weapons and is a master of stealth, allowing him to hit Cap without him knowing. Overall, Arkham City Batman is more than a match for Movie Captain America. ===VOTE: BATMAN (ARKHAM CITY)