User blog comment:Elgb333/Post-Halloween Historical Horrorshow! Pirate Girls vs Harpe Brothers/@comment-5078776-20151106042021

PIRATES OF MISSISSIPPI!!! The tomahawks are handy weapons, capable of delivering devastating hacking attacks and chops. Considering their native training, the Harpe brothers were also likely skilled at using these axes as improvised throwing projectiles. That being said, the cutlass' versatility and larger surface area make it a more lethal weapon in comparison. Both weapons are relatively short, so the agile advantages a tomahawk typically has against swords is negated here. This is an incredibly interesting comparison. The pistols are instantly more lethal, capable of sending a decent-sized hole through your chest. In addition, there are six of them each; that's two dozen shots, so it's not like their options are limited. That bejng said, the bow's reliability and range give it an edge over the sidearms. I doubt the Harpe brothers were incredibly proficient with their bows though, so the maximum advantage that could be gained is sort of negated here. Overall, both weapons have advantages and dosadvantages that even the playing field.
 * Melee: Pirate Girls
 * Mid Range: Even
 * Long Range: TBA
 * X-Factors: TBA
 * WINNER: TBA