User blog comment:MilenHD/Pier Gerlofs Donia vs Michael An Gof/@comment-4454770-20150225154441

Let's end this once and for all!!!

Short range: Meat cleaver is a kitchen tool, not a weapon of war. Even though it's big, it's not designed to be a balanced weapon. The longsword is tailored to kill people more efficiently.

edge: Piers

Mid: I'm going with the pike. Yeah sure people point out about how the pike is too big, but Piers is  a big man, so that weapon is perfect for him. The billhook is actually designed more as an anti-cavalry weapon with its hook, and because of that hook, it won't have the same penetration as the pike. The pike will keep Michael off fom a distance.

edge: Piers

Long: Same weapon, same results. But I'm giving a slight edge to Piers because he dwarfs Michael and his size allows him to use the weapon more efficiently and accurately.

edge: Piers

Special: This is a big stomp for Piers here. Michael is carrying a heavy and weildy weapon, and so his advantage of speed against Piers strength is hugely nullified. Pier won't be having the same problem with his zeihander.

edge: Piers

Winner: Pier Gerlofs Donia

An easy win for this giant. Michael is a poor tactician, he's rather more of a speaker than a warrior. His only battle, the battle of Deptford Bridge, ended quickly and humiliatingly for him. After that he got captured and quartered. Piers was more successful in the war he fought and obviously lasted longer. He also has the advantage in size and strength, and he's probably superhuman too.