User blog comment:Pygmy Hippo 2/Rorschach (Watchmen) vs. James Earl Cash (Manhunt)/@comment-27334870-20180330172653

Dargoo Faust's [REDACTED] EDGES: "Smooth Criminal"

I'm going to skip edges and cut straight to the chase; Cash wins this off of his arsenal alone. If this was Comics Rorschach, I would have argued that this is actually very close, but movies and game Rorschach is notably less intelligent than he was in the comics, or at least had less time to show exactly how intelligent he was. To be fair, Rorschach in any instance is smart as living hell, but comics blows any other interpretation of him out of the water; he was hailed as the best detective and one of the smartest minds on the planet, and if this was comics rorschach I would have doubted of Cash would have been able to pull the trigger on him once, since the moment Rorschach notices him, he'll take to cover and take him down before he can even retalitate.

However, since this is movie!Rorshach, his stealth abilities and detective skills are less notable, meaning that the gap in arsenal is now too large to ignore. That said, he physically outclasses Cash, but a single shotgun blast to the chest will likely be enough to put him down, something I doubt this version of Rorschach will likely avoid. I vote for James Earl Cash, then.