User blog comment:Pygmy Hippo 2/Pier Gerlofs Donia vs. Zhu Yuanzhang/@comment-35680048-20190102034757

V]

Tybaltcapulet's " What the Hell? This isn't God Emperor Sun Tzu" Edges:

Short Range: Like BF, i'm going to give an even rating here. The Katzbalger may be shorter but it's double-edged, making it a sword with more versatility to it. The Dao on the other hand provides a lighter and longer blade better for standard combat and dueling. Edge: Even

Medium Range: The pike may be big, beautiful and super scary, but it's designed for formations and larger scale conflict. The Qiang is still pretty damn long and has a nice addition of the tassel to screw with an opponents vision and take advantage of distraction.Edge: 朱元璋

Long Range: The 3-barrel matchlock is frankly utter trash in a battle compared to the Arquebus, a weapon literally designed to replace such a heavy pile. The Arquebus is much more accurate and much lighter and will be a much better source of gunfire than the primitive Pole Matchlock.Edge: Pier Gerlofs Donia

Special: The Zweihander is a beauty of a blade. A rather light blade for being a whole 7ft long, Pier could easily decapitate an enemy with this massive piece of steel. But what about the landmine? Well it's not really that useful at all. I don't think that Pier and his men are really that stupid or desperate to get weapons in a 5v5 where they need to take weapon from the enemy. And the trip wire? That all comes down to dumb luck. Great in a large engagement with a horde of enemies, but virtually useless against a small squad. Major Edge: Pier Gerlofs Donia 

X-factors/Overall: Easy win for the Frisian hero Pier Gerlofs Donia.This all comes down to the type of battle being fought here. Pier was completely used this sort of skirmish, being a pirate and all and thus would be very suited to this fight. Zhu Yuan Zhang on the other hand, while he was a much better overall success, relied heavily on large scale battle tactics, and therefore is at a disadvantage here. As Pier and his Frisian friends are equipped with more practical and superior weaponry, and the better armor to stand up to gunfire and blade damage. He may have lost his own war, but here the Frisian hero claims victory against the Emperor.

Pier Gerlofs Donia: 3500 

朱元璋: 1500