User blog comment:Kaiser of Metcalfer99/Frank Castle vs Rukh/@comment-27043000-20190223184952

Pygmy Hippo's "I didn't know the hairless chimpanzee from that one Creepypasta was in Star Wars" Edges

Close Range:The Sledgehammer is completely outclassed by the Electrostaff which is not only longer and lighter but can stun people with its attacks as well and as the image shows, it can take a lightsaber hitting it so its more durable. Edge:Rukh

Mid Range:The EC-17 Hold-Out Blaster is lighter and has modifications for better accuracy and a flashbang effect but the Heckler & Koch MP7 is longer, has more range, and fires much faster. However blaster shots are more lethal than bullets and faster as well making me give a slight edge to the more versatile EC-17. Edge:Rukh

Long Range:The Heckler & Koch HK416 is longer, possibly has more range, a faster firing rate, and can be fired with more accuracy while the Blaster Rifle Staff is lighter, has devastating blaster shots, and is a combination weapon. Overall, I still give a slight edge to the Heckler as I'm not sure how effective the Blaster will be at this distance and it does take a moment to change from the Electrostaff anyways. Edge:Frank

Special:The Class A Thermal Detonator is lighter but the AG-C/EGLM Grenade Launcher is longer, has more range, and can be used multiple times with a variety of ammunition. Just like before, the more versatile weapon wins and it's the AG-C/EGLM this time. Edge:Frank

Aid:The M84 Stun Grenade is great for disorienting an opponent to go in for the kill but the Sinrich Optical Dephaser makes sure that whoever uses it isn't getting seen first and with these two's powerful weapons, that might be the deciding factor. Edge:Rukh

X-Factors:Frank Castle takes Brutality, Endurance, and Audacity while Rukh takes Unarmed Combat. They tie in Experience. Edge:Frank

Final Verdict:This was a difficult decision but ultimately I had to go with the more advanced warrior, Rukh, who despite losing out in the X-Factors has far more instant kill weapons and has a huge advantage in his Dephaser. Frank Castle does have a great advantage at long range with his assault rifle/grenade launcher combo made for that but his X-Factors aren't perfect. Brutality is as useless as ever if both fighters are killers, I doubt Frank's tanked anything like a blaster shot before, and Audacity can backfire horribly especially when your foe can turn invisible. Overall I see Rukh getting in a crippling blow in the beginning and punishing Castle for his lack of caution later in this fight by clobbering him at close range.

Winner:Rukh