User blog comment:Elgb333/Jason Voorhees vs Casey Jones/@comment-4552610-20141216043428

Undead RVD's "Hockey Masks: A gift from Canada" Edges
Weapons: This one is interesting. Each weapon is unique and useful in their own ways. Comparing them in a simple A1 vs A2, B1 vs B1, etc; will not do. This will be a comparison of pros and cons: Between the two, Casey's weapons come with more advantages. Also, Casey's training and natural adept nature allows him to use his weapons with more effectiveness and versatility, unlike Jason who simply uses them as weapons.
 * Lets start with Jason: his Machete, wood axe and harpoon gun (which is NOT actually pictured, as the image is of a spiked pole pulled from the fence that Jason uses as a spear) are the capable weapons he has; The machete is sharp, the wood axe is heavy and powerful with good reach, and the harpoon gun has decent range. On the other hand, the cleaver is severely limited in use as it can't be used for stabbing like most other knives and it has little reach. The woodcutter is simply too big and unwieldy. The ice pick has no reach what so ever, requiring Jason to get a hold of Casey up close, which will be hard.
 * Now on to Casey: The baseball bat is actually quite effective as its modifications will heavily increase the physical damage dealt to Jason. The hockey stick is also useful as it is capable of full-decapitation; I don't know it this is do to the "blade" of the stick is sharpened for cutting or if it is shear-superhuman strength behind it. Either way, another good tool to take down the slasher. The Sledgehammer is VERY helpful as it is among the closest to being a real weapon; it it much like war-mauls, heavy war hammers made for blunt damage. The power in it is immense and should be able to crack Jason's skull. Lastly, the pipe bomb is DEVISTATING. A good hit from this will at least cripple Jason, if not completely blow him to bits. As for the other weapons.... meh. The Golfclub can be deadly when used as it has quite allot of force behind it. However, its handle is weak and will be prone to bending. The Cricket Bat is not as tricked out as the bat and thus won't have the same destructive power to harm Jason.

Special/X-Factors: This one is hard; Jason is an undead monster capable of surviving immense harm but Casey has fought mutants, robots and supernatural monsters in the past. Jason has superior strength, endurance, brutality and stealth but Casey has vastly superior speed, agility, reflexes, and intelligence. Between the two, Casey's combat experience, reflexes and intellect would allow him to overcome Jason's stealth and his speed and agility would help him overcome Jason's strength and speed. I'd say Casey just barely edge out.
 * Slight EDGE: Casey Jones

Overall: I feel that Casey may just BARELY beat Jason. Where Jason is vastly stronger, tougher and more brutal, Casey is faster, smarter and packing superior combat skills thanks to his versatility in martial arts.