User blog comment:Tomahawk23/John Marston VS Cole Phelps/@comment-889585-20110808015846

Sith-venator Wavingstrider's Edges!


 * For Close range It's a tie as the Smith and Wesson Model 3 beats the Colt Detective Special but the M1911A1 beats the FN M1903. EDGE: Tie


 * For Mid Range the Browning Auto 5 beats the Ithaca 37 but the Thompson is a wild card, assuming the Browning Auto-5 has a range of about 20 meters the Thompson trumps it with 50 meters and a larger magazine size. Overall I'm giving the edge to Cole as he has two mid range weapons as compared to one. EDGE: Cole


 * For Long Range the M1 Garand is a great semi-auto rifle, 8 .30-06 (7.62x63mm) round en bloc clip with a range of 402 meters. The Carcono rifle has a 6 6.5x52mm round en bloc clip with a range of 600 meters, however unlike the M1 Garand it is Bolt-Action. The Henry rifle has a 16 .44 rimfire clip but is lever action slowing down the firerate and although has more rounds in a clip it will take longer to reload the the clip of the M1 Garand. Overall I am giving it to the M1 Garand, being semi-automatic and having a quick reload will be a huge advantage in the fight. EDGE: Cole


 * For Special obviously a bowie knife and tomahawk beats a baton. EDGE: Marston


 * For Explosives ummm <.< edge Marston? EDGE: Marston

OVERALL WINNER: Cole Phelps-John Marston is a great fighter, but Cole Phelps is a great fighter with better weapons. Using the M1 Garand, Thompson, and M1911 he will dominate over Marston's slower-firing weapons. 2,560-2440