User blog comment:SPARTAN 119/Pancho Villa vs Mikhail Tukhachevsky/@comment-5078776-20121009193030

Cfp3157's "Mexicans vs Russians...interesting." edges:

Melee: The Machete has this. It may not hav ethe range of the spike bayonet, but that's why it shines. pancho can easily close the distance with his shorter blade and use it where the bayonet is ineffectie. Edge: PANCHO VILLA

Pistols: I agree with everyone here. The Nagant is double-action, has one more round in the cylinder, and has a slightly longer barrel. Pancho loses the edge of RoF, accuracy, and ammo. Edge: MIKHAIL TUKHACHEVSKY

Rifles: These rifles are pretty much the same. Edge: Even

Automatic Rifles: THe Mondragon has a faster RoF and bigger muzzle velocity. These are automatic rifles, so the edge Mikhail has in magazine ammo loses its edge. Edge: PANCHO VILLA

Explosive: The Grenade is more portable and causes less damage to the user. Edge: MIKHAIL TUKHACHEVSKY

X-factors:

Villa/X-factors/Mikhail

61 Training 78

84 Combat Experience 80

58 Health 78

87 Tactics 69

90 Leadership 76

67 Brutality 89

Winner: PANCHO VILLA

Villa dominates at long range with his superior automatic rifle and his lighter bolt-action rifle. His revolver only falls slightly, and his Machete deciminates the bayonet. He also is a better leader, is a master of guerilla tactics, and is more experienced in actual combat. This why the Mexican will be the Russian in this Red Dawn enemy civil war.