User blog comment:Weew1213/John McClane (Die Hard 1) vs John Shaw "2 Cops, 12 Rounds"/@comment-5795750-20160707011545

BG1's "Final Round... FIGHT!" Edges:

Melee: Basically, it comes down to who has the better H2H skill and... well basically I will echo what the others have said below and give the edge to Shaw. McClane in the first movie was more preferential to shooting his enemies or at the very least using the environment around him as an aid to his pathetic H2H skills; since Shaw is, at least according to the movie, more experienced in the police force, it can be presumed that he has had his fair share of H2H training and experience (and while I haven't seen the movie, it can be assumed that his H2H skills are shown in whatever glory it holds and are better than McClane's). Oh note that I didn't take into account the riot shield which will be extremely helpful in a melee situation (as EA told me long time in one of my battles)

EDGE: Shaw

Pistol: TBF