User blog comment:The Deadliest Warrior, Jr./French Cavalryman vs. British Sailor/@comment-422690-20110111223220

Cavalryman. Three guns vs two guns, three guns win.

And you do know that a Carbine is a type of rifle and not a make, right? Or were you just being redundant like the DW hosts are (Stiletto knife, anyone? A STILETTO IS A TYPE OF BLEEDING KNIFE, FFS