User blog comment:GSFB/Gollum vs Sir Didymus/@comment-17814994-20150912142114

Elgb's "Samll but... not terrible. Just Terrifying" EDGES!!!

Short: Obvious win for Sir Didymus. Gollum's missing some teeth, and their fragility will be a big downer for Gollum. SD's teetha re sharper and designed to kill like a fox. EDGE: SD

Mid: Are you kidding me? The mace takes this in a sexy and curby landslide. It's longer and is deadlier with every swing. Rocks are rocks, and throwing it will not automatically kill a person. EDGE: SD

Long: Well it's not really obvious. I'll probably pissing my pants more when I see someone charging towards me with a mace than another sissilly throwing rocks at me. Going up close and personal would probably remove any lethality or range advantage of a rock. EDGE: SD

Special: I like Gollum and all, but I think that ring took more from him that it gives. He's physically frail, taht even untrained hobbits can take him on with a few sweats dropped. The only thing going for him is his stealth, but against someone whose well-trained, wearing armor,and ahs heightened senses. Well it's a no brainer. EDGE: SD

Deadliest Warrior?

Though being the cutest of the two, I still give the deadliest edge to Sir Didymus. Gollum isn't really the ebst fighter around. he loves to flail and ambush, but he lacks any combat training and experience. He's beat in weapons too. SD not only has the more fearsome weapons, he's also got the better physicality. If Gollum was given the One Ring well he may have stood a chance, but today he's pretty beat.