User blog comment:MilitaryBrat/Major Richard "Dick" Winters vs Fidel Castro/@comment-379205-20110923000510

119's Edges: Garand vs SKS: The SKS has a larger magazine and longer range: Edge Castro

M1911 vs Tokarev: The M1911 fires a much more powerful round, edge Winters

Bayonets: The two weapons are so similar, I call this even.

MkII vs RGD-33: The RGD-33 is complicated to use, while that Mk II was quick and simple to use, meaning Winters can throw it faster, Edge Winters.

X-factors (Training, experience, etc): Winters takes the x-factors easily, being a skilled frontline soldier likely with more combat experience than Castro.

Overall Winner: Winter's superior training, experience, and weapons mean give him the victory.