User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 2 Episode 8: Mohawk Warrior vs Germanic Warrior/@comment-24180428-20130303004200

Utter noob's "Barbarian" edges:

Short range-The club stats are unkown, but judging by the picture, the club is longer then the knife. Longer=better range. Edge Germanic Warrior

Medium range-The tomahawk is a nice weapon and can be thrown effectivly, however when you throw the tomahawk you lose the weapon. The Germanic warrior just needs to raise his shield and then the Mohawk warrior has wasted his tomahawk. The sword has the range advantage in hand to hand combat and will not be thrown. Edge Germanic warrior

Long range-The spear can be used for both short and long range but when thrown you lose the spear. The bow and arrow allows you to fire faster, making this comparison like comparing a musket to a modern day pistol. Edge Mohawk

Special-The shield can be used to defend from arrows and tomahawks, and of course the club. The shield is very large and covers a majority of the Germanic warrior's body were as te club can't even defend whatsoever. Edge Germanic warrior

X-factors-Mohawk has an average of 80.25 to the Germanic warrior's 76. Edge Mohawk

Winner-I think this would be semi close, but the germanic warrior should win. He has better matierial (steel) and fights better in close-medium range. The Mohawk warrior will get crushed up close.