User blog comment:Cosmo6252/Judges vs Mandalorians/@comment-5559147-20140825102728

Beginning with weapons edges

Close Range

Vibroblade ( knife ) vs Daystick

When clubs face blades, the blades normally win, even more so in this case because of the vibrobladed added ability to cut.

Edge: Mandalorians

It should how ever be noted that Judges almost always carry a boot knife as well as their daystick.

Mid Range

CR-1 Blast ( er ) Cannon vs Widowmaker 2000 Shotgun

The CR-1 is likely going to have the edge in spread and maybe power, on the other hand the Widowmaker seems to have the better ammo capacity.

Edge: Even, their are just to many unknowns.

Long Range

E-11 vs Lawgiver

It seems the E-11 might have small edge in "ammo" capacity, but other then that it is completly outclassed. It may have vairable powe settings, but doesn't offer the options the lawgiver does nor is it essentially tossing out mini-grenades, like the lawgiver. It range is measures in meters where as the lawgivers is measured in miles and has heatseeking/tracking ammo, where as the E-11's is all dumb fired. The lawgiver is probably even the lighter weapon.

Edge: Judges

Special

Stub-Gun vs Light Repeating Blaster ( I believe a T-21 is pictured )

While stub-gun is a very powerful weapon. Which has been used to cut apart large structures, the LRB is more reliable and better in a suppressive fire role. Which is more important then raw power in this kind of engagment. Though it still has plenty of power, being able to tear apart light vehicles and all.

Edge: Mandalorians

Equipment

Flame thrower and fiber cord whip vs gas and stun grenade

The flamethrowe is the only one of the bunch that intended to cause serious injury and the fibercord whip is the most reusable. On the other hand the grenade are the better area effect weapons which is important in a small unit skirmish. Still being wrist mounted the flamethrower/fibercord whip are more accessable.

Edge: Mandalorians

Armor

Mandalorian Duraplast armor vs Judge armor

The Mandalorians armor has better coverage, is more practical ( allowing for better range of motion ), and is likely tougher.

Edge: Mandalorians

While the Judges only recieved one edge, its really the only one they need as the lawgiver can essentially do everything the mandolorians entire arsenal can. This combined with combined with the toughness and determination of the Judges themselves. Leaves only one conclusion.

DEADLIEST WARRIOR: Judges.