User blog comment:Jackythejack/Robin vs. Elodie: Royal Smackdown/@comment-35680048-20190822044938

Tybaltcapulet's "I'm absolutely winging it here" Edges:

Magic: In all honesty i'm not too impressed with Robin's magic, besides Rexcalibur. They all consist of basic elemental spells which really don't do much more than shock, burn and/or blow people away. It doesn't leave much to the imagination and is lacking in versatility. Sure they have some decent power, but they're pretty basic spells that Elodie can counter quite easily.

Then you look at Elodie's magical capabilities. And let's just say they blow Robin's magic out of the water. Elodie can easily detect every important detail about Robin and her spells, giving her extremely valuable information throughout the battle itself. On to her defenses, which are nigh impossible for Robin to fully get through. Elodie can resist all kinds of magical attacks, including fire based spells, and can even counter Rexcalibur with her resistance to extreme cold. Her shields also provide protection against all of Robin's other spells. Then finally moving on to Elodie's offense, which is also quite versatile.She has various light attacks to blind enemies,create discs to harm opponents, become invisble,cause illusions that can throw off even tbe best of magicians, and even incinerate people with basically no effort. Yeah, Elodie takes this category no problem.Edge:Elodie

Magical Weapon:This is pretty even to me. Both of these swords have their own advantages to help them in battle. The Leven Sword has a powerful ranged attack in the form of lightning that extends Robin's reach. The Light Sword on the other hand appears to be a summoned weapon instead of a regular physical one(which even if she lost it means she can just bring it back again and again), and the Light Sword appears to be the more powerful close-range sword. Edge:Even

Extra Weapon: A regular ass sword vs a scepter that can incinerate fools whenever Elodie feels like it. I mean she likes her sword better, but does it really matter when the scepter can dish out a hell of a lot more punishment than the Silver Sword. The Silver Sword isn't even that durable as the author has stated in its description.Edge:Elodie

Overall/X-Factors:From an outsider to both of the respective universes of these two warriors, it seems that this is a stomp for Elodie. Sure Robin is older and more level-headed, but honestly this doesn't really upset all the other advantages Elodie has over her.

Elodie can counter literally anything that Robin throws at her with the sheer scope of her magical abilities. She can discern vital info on her spells quickly, defend against them reliably with her shields, and can hit back with her OP light based spells. She's simply the more well-rounded magical fighter.

On top of this, despite Elodie's young age, she is quite intelligent, and a very fast learner, picking up most of her skills within a few weeks, and being able to understand warfare deeply. And she has faced foes such as Togami, who are techincally much more experienced opponents, and are incredibly powerful, and still came out on top.

With far superior magic, and a history of defeating more experienced and powerful foes, Elodie should be able to wipe the floor with Robin

Elodie:3500

Robin:1500