User blog comment:SPARTAN 119/Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson vs John Nicholson/@comment-5078776-20121219214140

Cfp3157's "For the GLory of the South!" edges:

(PS I love this match. I'm from Clarksburg, WV, and that's where he was born. I take great pride in the fact that I live in the birthplace of such a great commander.)

Knives: The Biwie Knife isn't as long as the Kukri, nor is it as versatile. The Bowie Kinfe is...well a knife. The Kukri is a f**king machete. Edge: Nicholson

Other Melee: While the Club packs a bigger punch, the Toothpick is longer and more versatile. Edge: Stonewall

Revolvers: The LeMat has more ammo in the primary gun and a shotgun "attachment". Edge: Stonewall

Swords: I like the fact that the Gothic Sword has a basket hilt, which protects Nicholeson's hand better than 1850. Edge: Nicholeson

Musket: Their the same. Edge: Even

WINNER: Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson. I tried to keep it as un-biased as possible, but I still believe Jackson will win. He has two knies as oppsoe to one, a better revolver, and he has the edges in training, tactics, and leadership.