User blog comment:Appelmonkey/Anime Season, Epsiode 2 Fantasy/Gilgamesh (Fate/stay night) vs. Loki (Marvel Comics)/@comment-5795750-20150830235314

BG1's "...And I Will Not Be Bullied By-" Edges:

Offensive Powers: Both of them may have superhuman strength on their side but while Loki's all about that magic and stuff, Gilgamesh (as far as I can see) has that and a lot more - sure Loki may be wielding Surtr which is powerful enough to match Thor's own godly strength, but Gilgamesh has a lot more weaponry on his side especially because of the Gates of Babylon. In short, Loki may be strong, but Gilgamesh packs a more versatile offensive arsenal.

EDGE: Gilgamesh

Defensive: Gil's got armour, Loki hasn't - that's one thing going for him. Even so, Loki - being an Asgardian - has the same level of durability, healing, stamina and speed as Thor and other Asgardian gods, as well as the Frost Giants. Also, being the cunning trickster he is, Loki can take advantage of Gil's low magical resistance when Loki unleashes his magic in ways Gil may not expect (no matter how knowledgeable Gil is in the arcane) especially through the use of illusions. That being said though, I have to call this even.

EDGE: Even

Weaknesses: If you want me to see who would be the lesser weakling of the two, then I would have to say that IMO Loki is the less weak of the two. As far as I see it, Gil's overinflated ego and tendency to think of others as lesser beings than he is going to hold him back somewhat from using his powers and weapons to their fullest extent (again something Loki may take advantage of) but Loki's arrogance isn't that detrimental.

EDGE: Loki

Before I go on any further with my vote I would actually like to ask two things that may affect the outcome of my vote: 1. Where's this battle taking place? As you said so rightly in Loki's weaknesses, Loki's magic is less powerful on Earth than in Asgard so battlefield location may make the difference 2. At what point in Loki's timeline is this happening? IIRC Loki died during the events of Siege, was reincarnated as a young boy and goes off fighting with the Young Avengers as a slightly less older version of his former self (up until Secret Wars/Battleworld)