User blog comment:Kaiser of Metcalfer99/Tlingit Warrior vs Kiribati Warrior/@comment-35680048-20180805045624

Tybaltcapulet's" I am the Sand Guardian" Edges: Close Range: I have to agree with Pygmy on this one. The sword club may be longer but that also makes it unwieldy and is doesn't actually have a blade compared to the double sword which has two blades making it more versatile and more deadly. Edge: Tlingit. Medium Range: You would think a massive 12 foot spear Vs a club would win but to me their both pretty bad weapons. Their both way too big for their purposes and will both take a lot of dedication to each blow. I really have to give this an even. Edge:Even. Long Range: A bow ALWAYS beats the sling. The bow is simply more accurate and will be effective more of the time. Edge: Tlingit

Special: The shark tooth club is just simply longer and the teeth will be more effective than the jade of the pick.Edge: Kiribati

Aid:The shield is much more practical than a lasso and a stick. This also benefits the Tlingit's superior armor which wills certainly be more useful... Edge:Tlingit

Armor: Speaking of armor, the Tlingit's protects more of him and therefore will be more effective. The Kiribati's head is exposed making is much easier to club, shoot him with an arrow or use the double sword on him. The Tlingit will be much more protected from the Kiribati's spear, clubs,and sling, which will me relatively ineffective overall. Edge:Tlingit

X-factors: I would argue based on your description that the Tlingit had more experience than the Kiribati warrior easily, and since he wins in Audacity and Intimidation and ties in experience you can obviously see where I'm going with this. Edge:Tlingit

Overall:The Tlingit  is clearly the deadliest warrior. His double sword is more effective than the Kiribati's club. He may have an ineffective club himself but the spear isn't much more useful. His long range capabilities are much better with his bow stomping the sling. His shield is massively more useful than a lasso and a freaking stick. And yes the shark tooth club is superior to the pick, the Tlingit's armor will easily cover for that. Take that with equal training, arguably more experience, more audacity and intimidation and the Tlingit will curbstomp the Kiribati warrior.

Tlingit:4000

Kiribati:1000