User blog comment:Alockwood1/Night of the Living Dead Survivors (1968) Versus Q's Gang (Gangsters, Guns, and Zombies)/@comment-25242759-20141007203348

Well for starters,

Long Range edge- NotLD survivors. Why? The Winchester rifle has more ammunition capacity (8 rounds compared to two), and is a proper long range weapon while the shotgun is really more mid or close range.

Mid range edge- Q's gang. It's simply because the Barretta is holding up to 15 rounds and is magazine fed while the S&W is a six shot revolver, meaninig it takes longer to reload.

Special edge- NotLD survivors. While the chainsaw is an effective close range weapon, the Molotov is a ranged weapon and is an incendiary weapon.

Melee edge- NotLD survivors. A shoe? Seriously? While the 2x4 is an effective close range weapon, the tire iron is usually made of metal and can cause serious damage. Same with the shoe and the claw hammer.

Overall- While Q's gang has got the majority of the critical X-factors, NotLD survivors just have better weapons.