User blog comment:MilitaryBrat/The Phantasm vs Rorschach/@comment-4248317-20130715021437

JWarrior89's "I'm BATMAAAAAAAAN" Edges

Short: The Meat Cleaver is powerful, but carries the possibility of being knocked from Rorschach's hands. The Phantasm's claw, on the other hand, is attached to her arm, meaning Rorschach would have to cut her arm off to get rid of it. In addition, the extra point on the claw makes it more versatile.

EDGE: Phantasm.

Mid: While both fighters are skilled hand-to-hand combatants, as MilitaryBrat stated, Phantasm was able to fight off not only the Joker, but also Batman, who knows over 120 different Martial Arts.

EDGE: Phantasm.

Long: The Grappling Hook, unlike the smoke from the gauntlet, is capable of killing. However, it was not designed with combat in mind. The Phantasm's smoke, on the other hand, while not lethal in itself,  enables the Phantasm to hide from Rorschach, setting herself up for a surprise attack. In addition, it makes the Phantasm appear to teleport, which could be used to unnerve Rorscharch.

EDGE: Phantasm.

Special: The Phantasm's mask, unlike Rorschach's, has multiple benefits; disguising her voice (psychological warfare), gas mask (protecting her from coughing/choking in the smoke clouds from her gauntler), and night vision, which will allow her to see Rorscharch when he can't see her.

EDGE: Phantasm.

OVERALL: THE PHANTASM. While I admit I don't know a lot about either warrior, the Phantasm takes this in my opinion. Her weapons and abilities seem far more versatile than Rorschach's.