User blog comment:El Alamein/Farkas vs. Fenrir Greyback/@comment-379205-20160321054327

119's "Its' 12:27, Not sure if this still counts, but what the hell" Edges


 * Weapons: This one is easy. Even if Fenrir prefers to rip his enemies apart and refrains from using the Avada Kedavra curse or other potentially lethal spells, i.e. Sectumsempra or any of the multiple explosion spells, he could still disarm, stun or incapacitate Farkas, allowing him to freely tear him apart. Edge: Fenrir


 * Armor: Steel beats cloth robes- even if it won't block magic, it would probably work against claws. Edge: Farkas


 * Werewolf Form: As much as Farkas hates it, he would use it if he has no other options to defend himself. Now Fenrir's werewolf form may be resistant to spells, but is smaller, and cannot be controlled- Fenrir probably isn't bright enough to make a Wolfsbane Potion, and/or is ethically opposed to it. Farkas, on the other hand, can transform at will, can control his form, and is larger and thus probably stronger. Edge: Farkas


 * X-Factors: In terms of experience, Fenrir has presumably killed average wizards, as well as Muggles, however he was easily beat back by Hogwarts students, let alone the Order of the Phoenix, and it's probably safe to say any Muggles he's killed were unarmed at the time, and lacked any military training. So yeah, Farkas probably has fought more enemies actually trained in combat, and is more trained in battle himself. Fenrir, however takes brutality and werewolf experience. Still, I give the edge to Farkas.


 * Overall Winner: Farkas takes this one in a close fight thanks to his better combat experience, including some experience fighting magic (albeit a different kind of magic), as well as his stronger, more controllable werewolf form.