User blog comment:WanderingSkull/Jason Voorhees vs. Michael Myers/@comment-5078776-20130820225623

CFP3157'S EDGES OF MASSIVE DESTRUCTION AND UNDEAD CHEESY SLASHER FILMS!

Iconic: Jason Voorhees 

The fact that the machete alone is over double the size of the kitchen knife gets the edge, but with Jason's near-superhuman durability and strength makes his strikes more powerful and let him take Michael's toothpick onslaught.

Secondary: Even 

Each weapon has its ups and downs. When it comes to the weight and length of the weapon, the pitchfork takes it. However, in terms of the one wielding it Jason is easily the stronger of the two warriors here, making the much more focused area of attack for the axe hit harder.

Special: Jason Voorhees

The Meat Cleaver makes the much more practical weapon, as it has a much larger attack surface. The claw hammer is only slightly longer (literally an inch), and the claw isn't that good of a weapon. The hammer is too small for much damage as well.

WINNER: Jason Voorhees 

Jason can take this without any doubt in my mind. Not only does Jason take the much better and more practical weapons, he is much stronger and only slightly more durable.