User blog comment:GSFB/Vasco Nunez de Balboa vs Vlad the Impaler/@comment-422690-20150203164938

So...

Melee: Kilij wins. This is honestly due to personal preference here, as the Espada Ropera is an excellently designed stabbing weapon. The Kilij is an excellently designed slashing weapon. Both can chop, and both can do what the other is designed for with less efficiency. I just like the Kilij better, since it's easier to let the weapon do what it wants to. Edge: Vlad.

Mid: Tie. Considering there's no information given on the actual blades on either halberd (Alabarda just means Halberd, not denoting any style), I can't give an edge.

Crossbows: Tie. Considering there's no information given on Balboa's crossbow, I can't give an edge.

Firearms: Arquebus wins. It's more accurate, and will typically have a larger range than the far more primitive hand cannon.

Special:Balboa wins. Since the war dogs nearly triple his numbers, this is a no-brainer.

Overall: Balboa wins. I'm almost tempted to call a fairness challenge based on how much he outnumbers Vlad thanks to those war dogs, but I'll pass for now.