User blog comment:AgentXA564/Syndicate Agents (X-Files) vs. Cultists of the Old Ones (Cthulhu Mythos)/@comment-4978251-20130423025753

Now I am going to vote, though I still think you should use the Tommy Gun instead. Oh, and it is a rule you can't limit a magic users abilities to just a few.

Melee- I like the stilleto, but the dagger is larger. It can make wider cuts, plus it has magic so there is no telling what is to be expected, especially since this is Old One magic. Edge- Worshippers

Handgun- The revolver dose have power, but the SIG has more rounds and possibly more range. Edge- Agents

Long Range- You can't limit the magic of one warrior, as I mentioned before. You should list other spells as examples of what they typically do. You can't line up a shot when you have gone mad, you could probably shoot you allies in the process, plus the Cults other spells help out. Edge- Worshippers

Assualt Weapons- This is even for a few reasons. Again I recommend replacing the shotgun, but the MP5 could work against the Agents. If an Agent has one and is driven mad, then he could spray and hurt his teammates. But the shotgun still lacks the range or capacity to take the edge. Edge- Even

Overall- I have to say Cultists. They have more powerful weapons up close, while their magic can probably cover greater distance then the rifle. The Agents could shoot eachother as they are driven mad. Again, there is no telling what spells the cult has, they might even be able to make their daggers light up with fire or even summon very minor creatures. We just don't know what to expect. Plus, the Cultists have a (assumly) homefield advantage.

Overall- The Cult of The Old Ones