User blog comment:JWarrior89/Jack Sparrow vs Zorro (Campellverse)/@comment-8012490-20130901140956

Melee: The rapier is a very thin and medium-length sword, wheras the hangar is a somewhat short but curved sword. The cutlass and rapier each have their own advantages. The cutlass is better for use on ships and in crowded conditions and the rapier is better overall for close quarters combat. I cannot give an edge without more information.

Ranged: The bullwhip can be used for disarming and is versitile; however, it is not very lethal or very long ranged. The pistols have a huge range advantage and are more deadly. Plus, Sparrow can just pull out another once he used one. Edge: Sparrow.

X-Factors: I agree with Bulls on the training aspect. The experience, health, and intelligence are the same as they are in the x-factor description. Overall, Sparrow has better X-Factors. Edge: Sparrow.

My vote goes to Sparrow.