User blog comment:Lasifer/Fallout User Tourney: Drayco vs. Sabrecrusader/@comment-5232784-20120804183011

Okay here we go:

Shishcabob beats deathclaw due to longer range, fire ability, capability for poisons

Colt .45 beats flare gun, due to more ammo and actually being designed for combat

Trail Carbine beats Heavy Incinerator due to lasting longer before breaking

Sniper rifle has more range than K9000, but the latter has a brain (smart gun) and far more ammo: Dead even

25mm Grenade APW beats firebombs, due to have far more explosive projectiles at the ready (the latter consists of only six bombs)

NCR Ranger combat armor beats fedora, because, well, its a fedora!

Fire Gecko beats Yao Guai, due to fire ability (animals are instinctually afraid of fire)

The Combatants: Austin the Wizard is equal in intelligence to James the walrus, but has more luck and more perception. I give him the edge in this

Mental health: Austin the Wizard is a lunatic. James has the edge

My Vote, due to most edges: James the Walrus!