User blog comment:GSFB/Rephaim Giants vs Sumerian Wild Ass Chariots/@comment-4844014-20121230011247/@comment-5232784-20121230011647

Alright, we have our first vote: 1 to nothing in the Sumerian Wild Ass Chariot's favor!

I agree that speed will be a crucial factor here. Though Onagers/wild asses are not as fast as horses, and though the Sumerian chariots were bulky, I think the speed advantage speaks for itself. Still, ground troops that are disciplined and stand together can defeat mounted warriors, such as occured at the Battle of Gaugamela (the Phalanx trumping the Persian scythed chariots, which were designed to destroy Phalanxes) and the first battle of Poitiers (when Charlse Martel/ Charlse the hammer, lead the Frank infantry to triumph over the Moorish Cavalry), but they do not always win...