User blog comment:Lasifer/Welcome to Rapture: Booker DeWitt vs. Jack Ryan/@comment-181289-20140204011035

This vote will deal more with the warrior themselves rather than the weapons and abilities they both bring, as I feel they overall come out pretty even, Jack having a slight edge over all, but not enough to swing it one way or another when dealing with the mentality if these warriors.

In terms of who is the better warrior overall, I'd give my edge to Booker, Jack wins in terms of pure physicality but Booker is much more intelligent, and has significant edge in experience and training. If the fight comes to close quarters Jack would most likely win, But I don't see Booker letting that happen if he can help. His weapons may not be as good ever all, but they aren't really significantly inferior either. Booker's intelligence, Training and Experience make up for the short comings in his arsenal. But it's the experience I feel is Booker's greatest asset. His experience gives him and edge in being mentally prepared for battle more so than Jack, while Jack can handle it perfectly fine, Booker is gonna be more in "tune" with the feeling and situations combat brings because he's got more experience in this type of situation. Jack is sorta learning as he goes, Booker knows how to handle battle because he's experience it before. Jack does fine for someone who just kinda finds himself in a situation, but Booker has real battle experience coming into this fight and that is invaluable.

Jack may have the Brutality edge, but Booker's score is quiet high as well, so when it comes to a willingness to kill, While Jack has an edge, they both score so high that it probably won't matter much in this fight, neither will hesitate to kill.