User blog comment:Snigel/Surgeon Smackdown - Dr. Steinman vs The Medic/@comment-4476906-20150913210805

Urban EDGES

Melee: '''Scalpel VS Bonesaw. '''This easily goes to The Bonesaw. The Scalpel is a surgical tool invented to make fine incisions through 1 or 2 layers of skin or muscle. The most it'll do is cause minor damage to The Medic's skin, but nothing else in the long run. However, the Bonesaw gets it's name for being able to cut through bone for amputation purposes. It's a lot more effective than the scalpel.

EDGE: The Medic

'Ranged: ''Thompson M1921 VS Syringe Gun. '''This one goes to the Thompson simply due to its larger magazine and it's high rate of fire. The Syringe Gun won't stand up to it.

EDGE: Dr. Steinman

'Special: ''Crusader Crossbow VS Improvised Bomb. '''This one goes to the Improvised Bomb. It's radius and it's effectiveness won't stand up to a single-shot crossbow. The bomb will be able to do a lot more damage than that of the Crusader Crossbow.

EDGE: Dr. Steinman

'X-Factors:'' Crazy on Crazy Action. '''The insanity and brutality make Dr. Steinman a better fighter than the much more sane Medic. Sure, Steinman is a woman-maiming, Aphrodite-worshipping nutjob, but he does know his way around a Thomspon as much as he knows his way around the female anatomy (which he knows pretty damn well by now).

EDGE: Dr. Steinman

Overall: Dr. Steinman

Steinman dominates in both Weapons and X-Factors, not to mention that his purpose in Bioshock is to actually fight Jack and be seen as a maiming maniac, while The Medic acts more as the support class to the nine mercenaries. In a battle of two crazy men of the medical profession, Steinman wins.