User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 3 Episode 1: Frank West vs Rick Grimes/@comment-5495321-20130401034339

Alright, let's get something straight: Frank has the experience. He's covered wars dammit. Rick is a poor leader who is screwing up one time after another. IE: The comics when he essentially drove the group into a hoard of zombies (Yes, we're talking the TV show version, but I'm just giving a decent example as I have stopped watching the show).

WEAPONS EDGES'N'SHIZZZ

Melee: West: The bat, if it's momentum gets going, will end with a brutal and bloody kill. But the machete is a bladed weapon which is always helpful. However the reach of the bat and it's solid material will provide an edge over Grimes. Even if the bat breaks, it becomes a deadly stake.

EDGE: West

Revolvers: Grimes: Double action, lighter weight. It's all there for an edge to the Python. Real simple.

EDGE: Grimes

Handguns: West: The reliable design of the 1911 will allow it to work in any condition. A 9mm isn't even that effective. The .45 will rip through Grimes.

EDGE: West

Shotgun: Even: They're just too similar to call. A half pound isn't going to make much of a difference.

EDGE: Even

AR: Even: Yet again, they're just too similar. No real differences.

EDGE: Even

Rifle: West: This is too close. But just close enough to call. The minimum weight of West's rifle will make it easier to maneuver in combat.

EDGE: West

I've stated my reasons above, this is a win for FRANK WEST>