User blog comment:Couldnotthinkofagoodname/Elliot Salem and Tyson Rios vs Soap MacTavish and John Price/@comment-26150944-20140219001704

TheWetWaffle's "This Means War" Edges

Eliot Salem Vs. John "Soap" MacTavish

Short Range: The P99 and Beretta 92FS both shoot the 9x19 Parabellum round but for this comparison, the P99 will chamber the 40 S&W round as in Modern Warfare 3. The P99 is superior in this comparison due to it being the lighter gun with more range and a stronger round. While the 92FS has a higher muzzle velocity, the P99 is just better.

Edge: John "Soap" MacTavish

Mid Range: One could argue that the lighter weight, faster rate of fire, and better concelability of the Vector can make it better but I disagree. The G36C has a stronger round, has a better range, and larger magazine. It's a pretty easy edge for Eliot Salem.

Edge: Eliot Salem

Long Range: Now through my research team of crackpot scientists aka Google and the Army of Two Wiki, there isn't a sniper called the MVD in either games. So I'll go with Skully and basically do a Dragunov SVD vs. RSASS comparison. The RSASS boasts a longer range, more ammo per clip, lighter weight, and stronger round. The Dragunov may be Old Reliable but the RSASS is the new kid in town and takes the edge.

Edge: John "Soap" MacTavish

Explosives: This comparison is hard but it's even for me. The AT4 has a larger warhead, longer range, and bigger boom in general. On the other hand, the grenades are lighter, have more portability, and give Salem a second chance since the AT4 is a one use weapon. There are downsides as the AT4 can kill Soap due to the huge explosion and the grenades don't pack as big of a boom as the AT4 and can also kill Salem if someone throws a grenade back at him.

Edge: Even

Melee: I find that the Tatang is a bit longer with it's 8.6 inch blade vs. the KA-BAR's 7 inch blade. The Tatang's larger blade easily makes it the better bladed weapon.

Edge: John "Soap" MacTavish

TBF