User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 3 Episode 1: Frank West vs Rick Grimes/@comment-5043545-20130330211731

WanderingSkull's "Officer Friendly" Edges

Melee: This a close one, the Bat has the advantage in length not to mention the blunt trauma this weapon can cause, but I have to give this one to the Gator Machete. Although, shorter this weapon is meant for killing and cuttting things apart. Plus, Rick can probably manage to cut the bat in half once he gets close enough... or one West's hands. EDGE: RICK GRIMES

Revolvers: Colt Python vs. Broken Butterfly. Another, close category, but the greater fire rate for the Python narrowly wins this for Grimes. Since, both aren't wearing any type of body armor the gun that can do more damage in less time gets the edge. EDGE: Rick Grimes

Handguns: This is familiar of something and I just can't put my finger on it. Well, let's see the Colt M1911 is a legendary handgun that is still amazing to this day for it's great power and accuracy. Ultimately, it can't compare to the MUCH greater magazine size of the Glock 17 which has 10 more rounds than the M1911. EDGE: Rick Grimes.

Shotguns: Both are shotguns that have proven to be amazing killing machines. So this is ultimatly a tie. The buttstock on the Reminton allows for West to steady his shots better, but the Mossberg a buttstock and a pistol grip so I can't reallt decide on a victor here. EDGE: Draw

To Be Written....