User blog comment:Elgb333/Undead John Marston vs Gabriel van Helsing/@comment-25699251-20141111150531

Melee

I am calling even on this one, the tomahawk is going to be a very effective CQC weapon in this fight. While the stakes will not be very useful. But in exchange neither will the torch. So then it comes down to the tomahawk vs saws. In this match up I would vote for even. They are both very effective weapons. While the sawblades will deal more damage up close and personal the tomahawk can be thrown.