User blog comment:El Alamein/Lewis and Clark vs. Paul Revere/@comment-5078776-20120925230053

Cfp3157's "THE EXPLORERS ARE COMING! THE EXPLORERS ARE COMING!" edges:

Close Range #1: The Cavalry Saber has a longer reach than the the Iroqoius and Hunting Knife combined. Plus it's thrust and slashes are more likely to kill. Edge: Paul Revere

Close Range #2: The Colichmarde and Axe are both great at parrying the other weapon. What it comes down to is the fact that the Colichmarde is faster and more versatile gives it the edge to me. Edge: Paul Revere

Overall Edge in Close Range: PAUL REVERE

Mid Range: The Brown Bess has a slightly faster rate of fire with 3-4 rpm to the Springfield's 2-3 rpm. Edge: PAUL REVERE

Long Range: I won't give an edge because the 1792 Contract Rifle is a Pennsylvania Long Rifle. So until I get more info.....Edge: Even

Special: The Pipe Tomahawks are gonna be useless if you get the 6 Pound cannonball in your stomach. Even when Lewis and Clark close the distance, Paul Revere has a sword comapred to the tiny axe. Edge: Paul Revere

X-factors: Will add later.

Current Edge: Paul Revere. He is a master of guerilla tactics and did actual fighting compared to Lewis and Clark who hired Native American mercenaries to do their main fighting. The two had experience, but this is nothing compared to Revere.