User blog comment:Greenberet69/Last Battle 2 of 9: Alvin York vs. John Marston/@comment-379205-20120821021058

119's Edge: X-Factors: Alvin York takes all of the X-Factors, including training, combat experience, and calm under fire. Overall Winner: Alvin York takes this one easily. Marston was no doubt a skilled marksman, but he never really took on opponents on the level of the German Army, and had no formal military training.
 * Pistols: The Colt M-1911 is a semi automatic pistol with an extra round in the magazine, meaning a faster reload and higher rate of fire. Edge: Alvin York
 * Rifles: The M1917 Enfield has a smaller magazine than the Winchester, however, it more than makes up for this with its much greater range and higher muzzle velocity. Edge: Alvin York
 * Machine Guns: The M1917 is a fully automatic machine gun, whereas the Gatling must be cranked by hand. Edge: Alvin York.