User blog comment:So-Pro Warrior/Aragorn II Elessar vs. Leonidas I/@comment-3189283-20160203114534

Let's see shall we

Primary Weapon

The Dory Spear clearly has the reach advantage and works well in tendon with the Aspis within a defensive formation. Anduril (and by extension the other Longswords) on the other hand has greater versatility and both can be used to render the Dory useless by chopping off the spear end. This really depends on how much Leonidas and his men can stay in formation because as long as they maintain a shield wall then Aragorn and the Gondor Soldiers will have a hard time getting at them with their swords. That being said if Leonidas and his Spartans do break formation (more on that later) then the Longsword's greater versatility should win it out.

Edge: Even

Secondary Weapon

From what I've read up on the Dagger it has a blade length of about 15 inches which is slightly shorter than that of the Kopis at 18 inches. More importantly than the size difference though is that the Kopis's design makes it hit a lot harder although I don't think it'll be that effective against the chainmail that Aragorn and company are wearing. Still it'll be more useful that the dagger which has to get past the Aspis which was can stand up to much tougher punishment than what the dagger can provide and I'm not even going to entertain the ridiculous notion that Aragorn and the Gondorians would throw the dagger.

Edge: Leonidas

Long Range

Man fuck the Javelin. I will note that the Bow's effectiveness is going to be severely hampered by the Aspis and the fact that only one guy can use it but it's still a much better option than the Javelin.

Edge: Aragorn

TBC