User blog comment:Leolab/Irving Morrell (TL-191) v Welkin Gunther (Valkyria Chronicles)/@comment-5795750-20160830033922

BG1's "Flight of the Valkyries" Edges:

Cannon Fodder Infantry: Now that I think about it, I agree with what everyone is saying here - because the Gallian A is the more sophisticated gun in terms of performance (given its higher rate of fire, magazine size and reload time than the Springfield), they will of much better use to the Scouts in the battlefield; in terms of grenades, it might appear that both are your standard stick grenades but if you look again, the B-Type grenade's head is more rounded at the top meaning it may have a tendency to roll when it lands making the potato masher grenade the superior of the two - still that does not make up for the disadvantage of the rifles

EDGE: Welkin

Anti-Tank Infantry - Immediately after seeing the two weapons, it is clear that the Lancers have this one in the bag with their superior warhead creating a much bigger blast than that which is launched from the Anti-Barrel Rocket

EDGE: Welkin

Rushers - As a weapon constructed for war, I will have to side with the M1 Thompson here considering that: a) it has the larger bullet; b) it has a high rate of fire; c) it can be used automatically and semi-automatically as one pleases; and d) the Thompson line of guns are tried and true with their a-OK reliability. Attaching a water-cooling system to a gun isn't really saying good things about your gun's reliability - it's blatantly advertising that the gun is defective because it overheats too easily

EDGE: Morrell

TBF