User blog comment:Goddess of Despair/Utter noob's Halloween Special/@comment-5795750-20131103040715

BG1's "You most certainly will die" Edges

6th Place: Zombies

I actually see the horde coming down first even though they have superiority in numbers. While they are numerous and can endure pain greatly, they are slow and more up close; Jason and the Bogeyman can get past them quite easily with their weapons, Gill-Man can just drag them underwater and feast on them from there, the Jersey Devil can kill them from the air and the Rake, with a much faster speed and long claws can strike at and kill the zombies from a distance before rushing away for the next strike

 5th Place: Rake 

Compared to the Bogeyman and Jason, the Rake's natural weapons lack range and (in the case of the teeth) penetrating power, and against Gill-Man and Jersey Devil, the Rake is not too aggressive a creature and is one that relies on stealth and speed a little too often (even with its nightvision)

 4th Place: Bogeyman 

The Bogeyman may be intimidating with that hammer but at the end of the day, it will fall prey to the swifter attacks of the other three horror combatants. The shockwave attack might do well against Jason but that's it - Gill-Man and Jersey Devil can't be affected due to their primary location (water and air, respectively)

 3rd Place: Gill-Man 

As much as I agree on the fact he has the homefield advantage and it is more intelligent than both Jason and the Jersey Devil, the fact is that his weapons lack the range of Jason's machete and while he is safe underwater, he won't be once he is on land - falling prey to the flying Jersey Devil; and sure he might have superhuman strength and a healing factor but that isn't probably going to be enough against Jason; also while Jason is afraid of water, he isn't afraid to pursue Gill-Man into it (because his retarded mind can't seem to process the risk involved)

 2nd Place: Jason Voorhees 

Jason may be a supernatural creature of force but at the end of the day, I see his experience fighting Freddy Krueger as being not enough to counter something the winner of this battle has on it; Jason's only real edge here is his machete which will fare well against all the other creatures except for...

 Winner: Jersey Devil 

While the Jersey Devil has thin wings and short claws that pale in comparison to Jason's machete, its high mobility means it can strike from the air and get out before Jason has time to react; oh sure Jason can regenerate from the scratches but I think that with enough force (either by attacking him with wings, tail and claws rapidly or using the scream like a shockwave effect akin to the Bogeyman's hammer or perhaps both), the Jersey Devil can knock Jason into the lagoon to his watery grave; after all, it is said that total victory on land can be achieved from total control of the skies