Talk:Darth Vader (Legends)/@comment-85.76.48.34-20140502205117/@comment-4484220-20140503005536

Expert's opinions are predominantly written by the author of its respective battle, although if they don't provide one then any user is allowed to offer up one to go on the warrior's page. The term "expert's opinion" is a metaphor to represent the general populous of voters on each battle. I realize that this is often times a very arrogant and inaccurate description of the demographic of users who voted, becasue there are some battles that have received very few, very poor, and very ill-informed votes, as well as battles that have very poorly written "expert's opinion"s themselves. About this time 2 years ago, there was a subtle (unintentional?) attempt by a few users to try to change the convention to "winner's argument," which I admit is a bit more accurate and respecful of a term, but it ultimately failed to overturn such an established practice.

If expert's opinions tried to assert themselves as not just opinions, but as objective fact, then that would be even more arrogant. Losing faith in a statement just because it's an opinion is plain silly, this entire site is just our opinions. It's fan-fiction, so there was a lot of speculation on our parts about how to different types of abilities and skillsets would mesh with each other, and deeming it as anything other than an opinion would be both foolish and egotistical.

Judging by your comment on Jetstream Sam's page and this one, it seems you've been exposed to a lot of the poor quality content on this site. I agree, there are a lot of bad battles and expert's opinions here, and I'm sorry that you've seen the bad parts. If you're still interested in this site, I suggest you take some time to look through the blog posts and battles of these users and reconsider your opinion on this wiki:

http://deadliestfiction.wikia.com/wiki/User_blog:Drayco90

http://deadliestfiction.wikia.com/wiki/User_blog:MrPacheco101

http://deadliestfiction.wikia.com/wiki/User_blog:JWarrior89

http://deadliestfiction.wikia.com/wiki/User:So-Pro_Warrior

http://deadliestfiction.wikia.com/wiki/User_blog:El_Alamein

http://deadliestfiction.wikia.com/wiki/User:Bulls12345