User blog comment:Necron Jesus/4th of July Special!: Alvin C. York vs Audie L. Murphy/@comment-35617681-20190706033825

Kriller99's "The Real Life Captain Americas!" Edges

Rifle: Audie Murphy. While York's Enfield has a greater range by 160 yards, the M1 Garand fires in semi-auto and has 3 more rounds. In addition, while the Enfield is a better sniper rifle, the M1 will prove more effective when the distance closes between the two combatants. I will admit, it is really a preference thing, whether or not you prefer speed or range, but I just figure that the M1 is more well-equipped in a fight at different ranges.

Machine Gun: Edge goes to the M2 Browning. While (if I'm remembering corractly) it's a stationary weapon, it holds the advantages in all the important stats. It possessed greater range, has more stopping power, the greater capacity, and a higher rate of fire. Not to mention armies still have it in active service.

Handguns: Literally the same weapon, so I would make it even, but York did show off impressive precision and ferocity when facing off against those Germans who attacked him that one time, so I give him the slightest of edges here, if only for skill alone.

Winner: Audie Murphy! He possesses newer and more improved firearms, and takes the edge in all of the x-factors. Alvin York was a great soldier, but he isn't as well-equipped or as tough as Murphy.