User blog comment:Postapocfan1999/Season 1 Ep 3 Rick Grimes vs Max Rockatansky/@comment-5559147-20130802181845/@comment-5559147-20130804182926

In that case

REVOLVER

Colt Python vs Smith and Wesson 28. Same caliber, same capacity, very close by the numbers in general and while the 28 likely to be considered the more reliable/durable weapon, as the Python suffered aa number of mechanical issues/critisizms during its run, the Python is Rick's carry peice, like Max's shotgun its his go to weapon. His first, last, and often only line of defense. So he is going to know it well and keep it well maintained, so also like Max's shotgun.

EDGE - Rick.

Okay, so now Rick has taken 3 weapons edges to Max's 2. How ever outside of the weapons on a personal level its Max's game. He's got the experience, the skills, the toughness, adaptability etc. In the end Rick's arsenal allows him to do way better then he would other wise, but....

Max Rockatansky is the..

DEADLIEST WARRIOR.