User blog comment:Thornclaw Braveheart/Aragorn vs. Jon Snow/@comment-422690-20111007154801

Close Range: Dirk wins. A Dirk, which is a dagger, is longer than the knife, giving Snow the reach advantage. Edge: Jon Snow

Mid Range: Longclaw wins. Valyrian Steel is unbreakable. Anduril was reforged from a broken sword. Reusing bad materials does not improve it. Edge: Jon Snow.

Long Range: Draw. They're both longbows. Edge: Even.

Table X-Factor: Ghost wins. Sure, sure, experience. Having a vicious and superbly stealthy Direwolf to back you up wins every time. Edge: Jon Snow.

Numerical X-Factors: Aragorn wins. Despite these two having some of the highest ratings I've seen on this wiki (seriously, re-evaluate your decision process. One warrior shouldn't be in all high 90s), Aragorn has a 4-point lead in the average. Edge: Aragorn.

Overall: Jon Snow wins. If this was purely Snow vs Aragorn, Aragorn would take it. But it's Snow and Ghost vs Aragorn. The addition of Ghost gives Snow an easy win, no matter how much backup Aragorn has.