User blog comment:WanderingSkull/The Road Less Traveled: Doomguy vs. Master Chief/@comment-4392864-20140806004211

Best of the Best! I's been a while since I've played these games, but let's see who I think would win.

Melee - A puny knife, versus a Big Huge Chainsaw - I'm going to surprise people, and pick the knife - you miss with a chainsaw, you'd best move quickly. A knife, easier to recover from. Edge - MC

Sidearm - A few big bullets, versus a bunch of small bullets. 50 bullets has to do something. Edge - Doomguy

Shotguns Unless one has more bullets, or faster firing, I don't see an edge. Edge - Even

Automatic a Gatling gun that fires 9mm, or an Assault riffle. I'm looking at lots of rounds from the Chaingun. Doomguy

Uber - Both are deadly, but both take time. BFG though can take on multiple targets though. Edge - Doomguy

Explosives I'm just calling it Even. Both give you a bad day. Edge - Even

Deadliest Warrior Both of these guys are tough hombres, seen a lot of things, killed a lot of things, but I think that Doomguy might win. That being said, it will be one Hell of a battle. Edge - Doomguy