User blog comment:Leolab/User Siege Tourney, Round 24 of 63: Redkite (Markus) v Leolab (Lloyd)/@comment-181289-20130816023642

Edges

Attacker

Over Run: Possible, but not extremely likely. While he does bring decent siege weapons to the fight, Leo's counter measures should more than off set this. Lacking versatility, means that even if the situation changes to need a new approach, it will be near impossible to adapt.

Force Surrender: Not gonna happen, Leo's to good at this and his men are to loyal.

Defender

Force Surrender: No gonna happen, Like Lloyd, high loyalty will prevent this from happening, and similarly, he is good at what he does, he won't give up.

Destroy Attacker: Fairly possible, Lloyd forces are well trained and can hammer the attackers from a distance and even if they get in the defending forces are not gonna be push overs.

Hold out: Highly likely, Markus is gonna have a hard time getting in, and will take high casualties even trying. Llyod should be able to hold out.

Single Combat

long Range: Lloyd, both are bows but his is armor penetrating and have a toxic aspect.

Mid Range: Loyd the pike doesn't offer the versatility of a halberd and isn't as conducive to single combat.

mainhand/ off hand: Markus Markus wins this one becasue his shield will give a defense that will be a change for the Talwar and axe to get around.

Single Combat over all winner:Lloyd while having issues up close, his long range and mid range off set this, giving him a win in single combat

Overall Score

Attacker: 1

Defender: 3

Tie: 0

While Lloud wins in several category and the battle over all, it will be close.