User blog comment:LB&SCR/Wander Alone: Jack Reacher vs. Rama/@comment-3189283-20160622112221

Let's see shall we

Melee

Forget about the hand to hand combat styles for a minute and just consider this. Rama has fought his way through entire buildings of highly trained criminals and take down a criminal empire pretty much exclusively with his bare hands. I'm not familiar the Jack Reacher series but I somehow highly doubt that Jack is anywhere near as a accomplised and that's without mentioning that pencak silat is much more refined and versatile than the kensi system that Jack uses.

Edge: Rama 

Pistol 

It's pretty obvious that the Glock takes the advantage here. There the fairly noticable magazine difference in favour of the Glock but it's lighter weight and higher muzzle velocity give it less recoil and therefore greater accuracy when shooting.

Edge: Jack Reacher 

Carbine

Despite being used as a replacement for the M4, the HK416 is severely lacking in range, rate of fire and muzzle velocity when compared to the modified M4A1. I guess in a jungle enviroment the lighter weight of the HK416 could be an advantage but it doesn't make up for the sheer domination the M4A1 has in every other area.

Edge: Jack Reacher 

Lel Randomze Wpns

I'm inclined to agree with Elgb on this one. The Shotgun is far better suited to the close quarters combat needed in a jungle enviroment and the Jack will struggle to get a clear shot with all that vegetation around. Furthermore the Remington is much to bulky to carry around which restricts Jack to being in one spot in order to maximise its effectiveness, leaving him vulnerable to an ambush.

Edge: Rama 

X Factors 

Jack Reacher has an average of 82.2 whereas Rama has an average of 78.6.

Edge: Jack Reacher 

Final Verdict 

TBC