User blog comment:Omnicube1/MACV-SOG vs. DGSE/@comment-2016768-20110130175440

THE DEADLIEST WARRIOR'S DEADLIEST EDGES:

Hsuh Puppy (Smith & Wesson Model 39) vs. Walther PP: Whenever I give an Edge to a firearm I base it on facts. The PP snd the Hush Puppy are quite similar but the PP has a kick-back while the Hush Puppy doesn't. Other than that, the differences are too miniscule to differentiate, but based on that, the MACV-SOG gets the Edge.

EDGE: MACV-SOG

Mac-10 vs. TMP: The Mac-10 has a faster rate of fire (1,090 rounds per minute to the TMP's 850-900 rounds per minute) and, while it's a bit heavier, it's because it has a suppressor, which makes it even deadlier.

EDGE: MACV-SOG

CAR-15 vs. FAMAS F1 FELIN: The F1 has a faster rate of fire and has a very high effective range (3200 meters) and that alone is a huge advantage. The CAR-15 is slightly outdated and when you compare it to a more modern weapon like the FAMAS F1 there's no contest.

EDGE: DGSE

China Lake NATIC vs. HK69A1: Both grenade launchers have a range of 350 meters, but the NATIC can hold three grenades in its magazine while the HK69A1 is single shot.

EDGE: MACV-SOG

Overall Winner: MACV-SOG

The DGSE are slightlymore modern but not modern enough to make a difference and their weapons, while good, don't stack up to the great weapons of the MACV-SOG.