User blog comment:Richard Starkey/Jesse James Vs. John Marston/@comment-4265204-20110809151806

I'm going to have to go with John Marston. He is more skilled of a fighter than Jesse overall (he fought in Mexico against the Federale Army, for one...). Weapon wise, the Evans and the Tomahawk will give Marston a well-rounded edge, while Jesse will have the advantage in mid and close range combat.