User blog comment:ZombiRoll270/John Marston vs Zombies/@comment-4392864-20131226153904

Originally, I probably would have declared this to not be a fair fight, due to Undead Nightmare. However, since Nightmare is non-cannon, well, you know.

Needless to say, I think that John and the four men with him could take on 60 zombies with relative ease, especially if they were of the Romero-type. I mean, if they were smart, they'd take on the undead from the second story window of the hotel/brothel/whatever, even if their long range was just some pistols. Reason is, between the five men there, they'd have at least a hundred rounds of ammunition, altogether, if not more.

To make this more of a challenge, make the number of zombies like 120, that way there's a guarantee that John and his posse would run out of ammo before they ran out of zombies.

As it is, Winner: John Marston