User blog comment:GothamCityRiddler/Silas (The Da Vinci Code) vs The Assassin (Angels & Demons)/@comment-8012490-20130817231610

Weapon 1: The ice pick was used as an ambush weapon. It would not be very useful in an actuall fight. Edge: Silas.

Melee 2: The leather flail is not as long as or as accurate as the branding iron. Neither of them are designed to kill, though. Edge: The Assassin.

Firearm: The Glock has less of a punch and less ammo than the USP. Edge: Silas.

X-Factors: The assassin is more intelligent and agile as well as having illuminati training. I believe that that speaks for itself. Edge: The assassin.

My vote goes to the assassin.