User blog comment:Cheesemuffin8/John Wick Vs. Max Payne/@comment-36053634-20180803152448

Guitarcar's "/k/ is a real Payne!!" Edges

Handgun:

I thought this was just like the Jungle Jim match I made. The Glock is fast sure, but both warriors has put in bullets in targets at amazing speed in near impossible scenarios. The Glock would have faired better at this scenario for me still because Max is less armored. The M1911 might have been powerful but aiming for that torso still takes more time than just shoot the head, limbs, legs and etc.

Edge: John Wick

Assault Rifles:

The AR-15 despite being a superior combat rifle did not have the automatic fire the AK-47 had. When I heard that this would be an urban scenario, I waved bye to the AR-15. Semi-auto was what got multiple US army units defeated by come close combat Taliban attacks who were using the AK-47.

Major Edge: Max Payne

Close range:

The Shotgun was often deployed as a support weapon by SWAT units. The shotgun alone was very vulnerable to counterattacks without other friendly units. The speed of both warriors would make the shotgun cumbersome in accuracy while the UZI's close combat fire rate would pin the shotgun easily.

Edge: Max Payne

Body armor:

What people get so wrong here is that they glare on the weakspot like its the most fatal flaw in all body armors. This instance is a lot like Gothic plate armor, The groin is so exposed yet the combat style of the weapons they used often blocked the Groin. Not to show any bias but John Wick wouldnt be that much of an idiot to expose his torso either.

Edge: John Wick

X-factors:

The X factors are reasonable to me but they still ended up in a tie. So....its tie for me then.

Edge: Tie

Summarry:

Its time to choose wether handguns and body armors could hold up against what seems to be a duo between a UZI and an AK-47.

And the answer is no.

Despite being a tie here it seems that John Wick's advantage arent the best suited for this combat.

He could hold up for long but Max Payne together with superior firepower will bring the definition of "Payne" train towards John Wick.

Winner: Max Payne