User blog comment:GSFB/Gollum vs Sir Didymus/@comment-3189283-20150912101608

Lets see shall we

Short Range 

Both have the same short range attack but I have to give it to Sir Didymus. Gollum's teeth may be horribly deformed and sharp but they are still human teeth and are not going to be as damaging as Sir Didymus's bite as his teeth are better desgined for doing damage.

Edge: Sir Didymus 

Mid Range 

A rock is going to do jack shit in this fight as Gollum is not going to get close enough to actually use it especially with Didymus swinging his mace about. The Mace is more lethal, has a longer reach and as it's an actual crafted weapon as opposed to improvised is also more durable.

Edge: Sir Didymus 

Long Range 

I know I just said that the rock is going to do jack shit in this battle but I was referring to it's usage as a melee weapon. When used as a projectile it's not much better but it is at least a ranged option and if Gollum can throw it hard enough it could do some serious damage. The Knightly Charge does give Didymus more momentum behind his mace swing but his mount Ambrosious is cowardly and is likely to panic and run once it gets sight of Gollum's hideous apperance.

Edge: Gollum 

Special

Gollum clearly has the physiological advantage with his larger size and greater strength but he also brings a great deal of agility to fighting style. Didymus's advantages are more to do with the equiptment he carries, namely his armour which gives him protection against Gollum's primitive weapons. Didymus is also the more disciplined of the two with his knight training and this also makes him better prepared for battle than Gollum.

Edge: Sir Didymus

Final Verdict 

This should be a comfortable win for Sir Didymus. Gollum is just too insane and is overly reliant on his own physical abilities in combat. The only weapon he has is a rock (if you can call it a weapon) and I doubt it will be very effective. Didymus comes armed with an actual weapon (the mace) and also comes well equipted with armour and his knightly training which make him not only better prepared physically for Gollum it also gives him the better mental preperation as well.

Sir Didymus: 4,500

Gollum: 500