User blog comment:MilitaryBrat/Batman (Nolanverse) vs Red Skull (MCU)/@comment-4552610-20130621214942

Undead RVD's "Detective Ninja vs Red Nazi" Edges
Short Range: The Red Skull is stronger so his punches will hit harder. However, he is pretty sluggish and sloppy with his attacks while Batman is faster and has a vastly better fighting style. As for the blades, the wrist blades should be able to catch the dagger and snap it in two. They can also spring out for a surprise.
 * EDGE: Batman

Mid Range: The Lugar is a classic Nazi weapon with a lethal shot but Batman's bataranges can disarm Red Skull. Lethality vs Versatility. I say even.
 * EDGE: Even

Long Range: While the Death Ray Pistol can kill in one hit, the EMP gun gets my edge as while it won't kill, it will cause the high-tech Death Ray to stop working.
 * EDGE: Batman

Special: Batman has protection and a wide array of grenades, Red Skull has physical enhancements, an SMG and a grenade.
 * EDGE: Even

Other Gear: Not sure what the Pulse Rifle does (can't remember it that well from the movie) but Batman has a powerful flying vehicles with mobility and the ever classic Grappling Hook. He should be able to get Red on his toes.
 * EDGE: Batman

Overall: Weapons are great but Batman is physically and mentally inferior to the Red Skull. However, his tenacity, superior skills and somewhat more intact mind (Batman dresses up as a bat fighting crime but the Red Skull is a full pledge, elitist, homicidal maniac) should push him to victory. Red may have destructive power in both his weapons, build and mind but Batman has a more versatile arsenal and a more calculating (and less insane) mind.

VOTE: BATMAN

 * Note: The Nolanverse Batman is vastly weaker than the Comic version but the same goes for the Movieverse Red Skull to his Comic counterpart.