User blog comment:Cfp3157/Connor vs. Captain Jack Sparrow/@comment-3189283-20150830092144

Lets see shall we

Melee

The Cutlass clearly has the range advantage over the tomahawk and hidden blades and in the hands of a skilled swordsman like Jack Sparrow should be enough to keep Connor from getting close enough to use his melee weapons. The tomahawk can be thrown but Connor never does this in the game and he's unlikely to throw away a melee weapon when he has only one other close range option. The hidden blade and tomahawk are also more fragile than the cutlass and could easily snap or break in combat.

Edge: Jack Sparrow 

Mid Range

Both of these weapons are basically the same thing, the only difference is that while Jack has 3 shots, Connor only has two and while he can fire his shots off quicker this is offset by the fact that Connor is not a skilled firearms user. Jack not only has more shots but he's also a much better marksman and is more likey to get a lethal shot with his pistols.

Edge: Jack Sparrow 

Long Range

The Indian Bow gives Connor more shots at than the Brown Bess and in the hands of a talented archer like Connor, it shouldn't be too hard for him to get a lethal shot. That being said Jack is an equally skilled marskman with the Brown Bess and he also has the range and stopping power advantage. Tough call so I'm going to call it even.

Edge: Even 

Special

The Blunderbuss wins out here not question. The Rope dart is more of a distraction tool than anything and takes a lot of effort to use effectively whereas the Blunderbuss is just 'point at the thing you want dead and fire' simple.

Edge: Jack Sparrow 

TBC