User blog comment:FEARTHEWAFFLE/Indiana Jones vs Vigilante/@comment-5559147-20131220024147

Well assuming this battle is still going I'll vote.

Begining with weapons edges.

Machete vs Pistol whip - Lets be honest I can't see a way to give this to the pistol whip, even if I wanted. The machete is bladed, longer, and heavier. Not to mention nothing stopping Indy from pistol whiping as too, in other words The Vigilante basically doesn't have a close range weapon. EDGE: Indiana Jones.

Bullwhip vs Lasso - While both can be used to ensnare and disarm only the whip can be used as an actual offensive striking weapon. EDGE: Indiana Jones.

Colt Official Police vs twin six shooters (1851-1860 Remingtons maybe?) - The six shooter, their being two of them do have the edge in capacity. 12 rounds vs 6 for the Colt, but they are slower to fire and likely releod. So ROF favors Colt. On the other hand two weapons does increase reliability in a manner of speaking in so much as even if one breaks you can still use( rely ) on the other. EDGE: EVEN.

As for the warriors themselves while The Vigilante has faced some incredible odds, he tends to do it with full blown super heroes at his back. Its tad bit easier to face galactic threats when you've got the full might of earth's greatest heroes backing you up. The Vigilante was also an adult when he began his "career" where as Indy has faced supernatural and impossible odds sense childhood with not much more then whip and wit. In this case where the Vigilante doesn't have the JLA backing him up, thats what matters. What the warrior can and have done on their own.

DEADLIEST WARRIOR

INDIANA JONES