User blog comment:Goddess of Despair/Frank West vs Ash Williams/@comment-4552610-20130329022344

Undead RVD's "Zombie Killer vs Deadite Killer" Edges:
Melee: This is one hell of a choice but I feel the Primary weapons that will do the most damage is the Broad Sword and Chainsaw. The Chainsaw will be easier to use than the Circular Saw and the Broad Sword will overpower the Machete. Everything will even out. Mid Range: One would go with the Pump-Action Shotgun but Ash's gun has one very powerful aspect: Movie Magic. He can fire the thing lord knows how many times WITHOUT the need of reloading. He will throw out more shots Frank can react to. Long Range: I'm going to say the Uzi will get the in. The Lever Action Rifle doesn't have the Movie Magic the Boomstick has. The Uzi will overwhelm the Lever-Action Shotgun Special: I'm going with Dynamite. The Molotov will do overall less damage and harder to control. Worse yet, If frank drops his Molotov, he will be on fire. If Ash drops his Stick, he can just pick it back up and throw it right. Overall: I feel Ash will win this. He is smarter (Can craft mechanical wonders like a working metal hand and working black-powder before it was made) and has the better overall weapon. I do hope Ash comes up on top.
 * EDGE: Ash
 * EDGE: Ash
 * EDGE: Frank
 * EDGE: Ash