User blog comment:Weew1213/The Man with no Name vs Rooster Cogburn (1969) "Gunslingers in 60's"/@comment-3189283-20160308182655

Let's see shall we

Melee

Both of them are bringing the exact same weapon and I don't recall either one being particularily skilled with blades so I can't really give one an edge over the other.

Edge: Even

Handgun

Once again both of these two have pretty much the same weapon but this time I do know that the Man is the more skilled quick draw specialist and while both are likely equally skilled marksmen with their pistols the Man can draw and fire his quicker. However Rooster does have two revolvers to the Man's one and this gives him double to ammo capacity and more chances to get that winning shot.

Edge: Even

Shotgun

Again both of these weapons are eerily simular with the same ammo capacity and feed system but the Double Barrel has a much shorter range due to it being sawn-off and it's more difficult to reload, which makes it pretty much a one shot weapon.

Edge: Rooster Cogburn 

Rifles

If the Winchester was compared to either the Sharps or the Henry but combined they cover each others weaknesses well. The Winchester is more reliable and has a further range than the Henry and has a faster rate of fire than the Sharps but importantly the Sharp's longer effective range allows The Man to pick of Rooster from a distance and if the gap closes the superior firing rate of the Henry allows him to compete against the Winchester in closer proximity.

Edge: The Man with no Name

X Factors

The Man has an average of 86.5 whereas Rooster has an average of 80.25.

Edge: The Man with no Name

Final Verdict 

In a battle between these two legendary actors greatest roles The Man wins out here. Let's not beat around the bush here, Rooster is completely outclassed here and while he things would seem equal in terms of weaponry The Man brings the superior long range options which is easily the most important catagory. However it's the men behind the weapons that actually counts and The Man with no Name is clearly the better combatant. Rooster is a skilled marksman sure but only with his pistols and the fact that he's in a drunken stupor most of the time it greatly reduces his reaction time and speed which is a recipe for disaster in a firefight, let alone against a skilled quickdrawer like the Man. The Man has the calm compsure to not do anything rash and he's easily be able to manipulate Rooster into doing something stupid and and leave him open to that finishing blow.

The Man with no Name: 4,000

Rooster Cogburn: 1,000