User blog comment:WraithOfWaffle/Season One: Battle Four: Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop) vs. Nathan Drake (Uncharted)/@comment-4552610-20131127000032

Undead RVD's "Not staying long but I have some time to make one vote" Edges:
Melee: While Nathan is handy with his fists, Spike's hand-to-hand combat skills surpass ANYTHING Nathan can muster. What is worse for Nathan, Spike is also good at disarming people so hand-to-hand is inevidable.
 * EDGE: Spike

Shotguns: While the SPAS-12 is semi-auto, Nathan's SPAS-12, called the SAS-12, is pump-action only. This means the advantage the SPAS-12 has over the Remington doesn't applie here. I say it is even as the range of the two guns are pretty even while the Rate of fire equal out.
 * EDGE: Even]

Pistols: Both guns have the same range and mag size but the Jericho is a tiny bit more accurate. For that, it gets a slight edge.
 * EDGE: Spike

Automatic: The SAKS-74U is a shortened assault rifle, meaning it has the superior range and power. The MP5 is nice and all but the Assault Rifle has the superiority all around.
 * EDGE: Nathan

Grenades: Grenades are Grenades. However, Spike uses his grenades a tad bit more creativly but that is more of use and not the weapons themselves.
 * EDGE: Even

X-Factors: While Nathan is more expereinced (debatable), more mentaly sound and a little smarter (again, debatable), Spike is better trained, more accurate and is WAY better in hand-to-hand combat. I feel these will make more of a difference. Spike is also more stealthy, better at combating people one-on-one and his mastery of slide-of-hand will allow him pull of some stuff Nathan would not see coming, such as attaching a live grenade on the back of Nathan's belt.
 * EDGE: Spike

Overall: Nathan may have the better long arm but Spike has the supierior hand-to-hand combat skills, handgun and x-factors. He will likely work to disarm Nathan and fight him in hand-to-hand combat, which will allow Spike to take an easy win. Overall, Spike should have the skills and luck to take the victory.

 VOTE: SPIKE SPIEGLE