User blog comment:Pygmy Hippo 2/Miyo Takano (Higurashi When They Cry Kai) vs. Edward Richtofen (Call of Duty:World at War)/@comment-3189283-20190117093853

Let’s see shall we Short Range  Yeah, no contest the Bowie Knife wins out. A scalpel is sharp yes but it’s also very flimsy and has an incredibly short range making it a poor melee choice. The Bowie Knife meanwhile was created with use as a weapon in mind and so naturally is better suited for the job.

Edge: Edward Richtofen  Mid Range  The Colt outclasses the Luger with the further effective range and the larger and more damaging round. The Luger does have an extra round, but it won’t make a whole lot of difference in the way the extra range and more powerful round will.

Edge: Miyo Takano  Long Range  Again, the MP5SD outclasses the MP-40 by having the higher rate of fire in a comparison of very fine margins. The silencer does reduce the muzzle velocity a bit, but it also gives it a stealthier tactical usage than the MP-40.

Edge: Miyo Takano  Special Weapon 

The Wunderwaffe wins so easily it’s not even funny. First off it carries three rounds in comparison to the RPG’s one so can cause more damage. Secondly it fires much faster than the RPG, if my Nazi Zombies memory holds true you reload and fire it much quicker than the same time it would take to load and fire and RPG. Thirdly it’s more effective at hitting multiple targets because the electricity will travel between multiple targets in the same vicinity. Really what it boils down to the fact that the Wunderwaffe is made to be anti-infantry and the RPG is made to be anti-vehicle and as there are no vehicles involved it’s out of its element.

Edge: Edward Richtofen Final Verdict  I’m going to go against the grain here and side with Miyo Takano here. In terms of firearms she takes the advantage with her superior pistol and SMG and while the RPG loses horribly to the Wunderwaffe I still think overall her firearms are better overall. In terms of experience yes, I concede she personally lacks the same experience as Richtofen due to her having only one real engagement whereas Richtofen has faced zombies numerous times. However, what wins this battle isn’t the weapons or the personal experience but who they’re bringing to assist them. Miyo is bringing a highly trained counter-intelligence group and Richtofen is bringing some recent recruits to the Wehrmacht. It doesn’t take a genius to see the vast gulf in quality in that short description and ultimately, it’s what gets her the victory.

Miyo Takano: 3,000   Edward Richtofen: 2,000