User blog comment:Leolab/Ancient User Tourney, Round 2: Oliver Moreau (Winter) v Sir Bors of Newcastle (Elgb)/@comment-25242759-20160529014809

Deathblade's "Time to repay the favour" edges

Okay,

Primary: Sir Bors. While the Naginata may be the longer of the two and more damaging in terms of power, the longsword is considerably lighter and much more mobile. Even though the Naginata is the better of the two weapons in terms of reach, but once Oliver loses that range advantage then Bors can deal damage with his shorter longsword and Targe. In short, while the Naginata has the range advantage, the longsword is just the more versatile weapon for the close quarters battle and coupled with the Targe allows for an extra bit of defence as well as another weapon.

Secondary: Sir Bors. TBC