User blog comment:Alockwood1/Sir Daniel Fortesque Versus The Scotsman/@comment-4661256-20160410030818

El Alamein's Edges:

 Unarmed: Left Arm vs. Brute Strength:  Well, while the arm does offer a surprise factor (since the Scotsman won't likely be expecting his opponent to start swinging his own body parts around) and superior range and reach (whether used in a melee fashion or thrown, it still has a greater range than a regular fist), it's still the inferior weapon. Versatility will only take you so far, and the Scotman's much simpler and harder-hitting brute force will be able to inflict far more severe trauma on Sir Daniel than Daniel's arm will be able to do on the Scotsman.

Edge: The Scotsman

 Main: Magic Sword & Gold Shield vs. Magic Claymore:  While I think that the claymore, especially in the hands of the Scotsman, is going to be a formidable weapon, and it does have the advantage of reach and power, it's more or less balanced out by Sir Daniel's sword-and-shield combo. The broadsword is certainly more versatile and will be more useful as the two warriors get close-up and personal, and the shield's magical potency will hold up to the punishing blows of the claymore. In my opinion, it's a tough call, but even--the Scotsman can hit harder and from a greater distance, while Sir Daniel can defend better and fight more comfortably in closer quarters.

Edge: Even

 Long Range: Gatling Gun vs. Machinegun Leg:  The Gatling Gun is portable, but it has a slower rate of fire and is less accurate by design when compared to the Scotsman's more modern machinegun leg. Not only that, but while Cfp claims that the weapon being on his leg is a hindrance, after a quick Google image search it appears that somehow the Scotsman defies logic and is proficient and accurate with that gun--and it's always on him, no matter what. Easy edge for the Scotsman.

Edge: The Scotsman

 Explosives: Bombs vs. Grenades:  Easy win for the grenade. Cartoon physics aside, the grenade is more reliable, lighter, easier to throw, and overall the superior weapon.

Edge: The Scotsman

 Psychological: Being Undead vs. Bagpipes:  Yeah, while neither of these will factor in very prominently to the overall outcome, at least the fact that Sir Dan being undead is passive and doesn't hinder his capacity to fight. The bagpipes effectively make the Scotsman unable to fight.

Edge: Sir Daniel Forteque

WINNER: THE SCOTSMAN

I came in sympathetic to Cfp's underdog vote, but I'm afraid I disagree with him here. The Scotsman wins because of his bigger, badder, harder-hitting arsenal. The machinegun leg is ridiculous in both how practically he manages to use an impractical weapon and also how much more technologically advanced it is over a gatling gun. When it comes to raw strength the Scotsman again takes a huge edge--the fact that his fists alone are weapons means that when you put a magically-enhanced claymore sword in his hands, you really need something like Sir Dan's magical shield to have a chance at holding out against it. Combine this with higher levels of training, combat experience, and physical strength, and it's clear that the Scotsman wins.