User blog comment:Pygmy Hippo 2/Dan the Decapitator (Elgb333) vs. Kyle Dash the Owner (Pygmy Hippo 2)/@comment-35617681-20181023031540

Kriller99's "Dead By District" Edges:

Close - Edge to the Katana. The ice axe wasn't intended as a weapon, and while it has a greater length and the knife attached to the bottom, the signature weapon of the Samurai has more blade.

Mid - Tie. The macuahuitl, while considerably more fragile, will have a slightly larger chance to harm Dan because all the armor he has is a shield, whereas Kyle's armor could be able to protect him from the spear. In addition, the spear can be cut in half, lowering its' usefullness. However, the spear has the metallurgy advantage and doesn't require as much strength to use in a sunstained fight.

Long: Pistol Crossbow. It's likely lighter than the spear gun, has more ammo, won't allow your opponent to know where you are (the rope will be a dead giveaway if you miss with the spear gun) and it has a red dot sight to improve accuracy.

Special: Both are more unorthodox "weapons" (Rose is the more so), but overall I'd give Rose the edge. The molotovs could literally backfire, fire spreads after all. In addition, Kyle's seal could distract Dan for long enough for him to sneak up on him.

Armor: Hard decision for me to make, but I surprisingly give the edge to Kyle's scrap armor. While it is pretty shoddy, the tactical shield just seems like it wouldn't be able to protect Dan against Kyle's weapons. The ice ax could disarm him, Rose would require him to move it in her direction, and the macuahuitl could bash it out of Dan's arms. The Iron armor, while nowhere near as durable, at least be an afterthought rather than a priority you have to keep track of.

Winner: Dan the Decapitator. While he's not as supernatural (though I don't think that'll be a factor in this fight to keep things even), he's way more experienced and cunning, not to mention that he has the better weaponry. The biggest issue, however, is that Kyle hasn't fought against someone who can fight back.

Ps, what are the rules on making a user-submitted warrior? What limitations should I make sure to include (I assume this means early gunpowder weapons at best, which I'm fine with)?