User blog comment:LB&SCR/Combat-Happy Joes and Amphibians: Easy Company vs. Roebuck's Squad/@comment-17814994-20160415110722

Elgb's "Almost Forgot To Vote" EDGES!!!

I'm gonna skip the comparisons and go straight to my vote. As what I know about these two characters, I'm gonna have to give the edge to Easy Company because of some very "easy" reasons. The thing about Easy Company is that they were written as full-blown action heroes. While it doens't make them superhuman, it does give them some feats that made everything Roebuck did look like a frigging kindergarden play. Where talking about guys who can take on a friggin Wermacht army and panzer divisions by themselves, shoot down enemy airplanes like they were made out of carton boxes, and infiltrate Nazi bases like it was going out of style. Roebuck and his squad were pretty badass themselves, but they seem to always lose a great number of men and time doing so. Besides, the Easy Company work better as a team. Roebuck's squad depends too much on Miller to get them through tough challenges.

In terms of x-factors, the Easy Company has this in the bag too. They are soldiers after all while Roebuck's squad were marines who were less equipped and had "to do more with less." Easy Company fought a more ferocious enemy and each of their memebers' specialization work so well for the team.