User blog comment:LB&SCR/Unknown Tales of Private Investigations: Pinkerton National Detective Agency vs. Baldwin-Felts Detective Agency/@comment-3189283-20150816192500

Lets see shall we

Melee 

The Clip Point Knife not only has a much longer reach, hell the blade is almost the length of the entire Maxam Knife, but it's also lighter, making it quicker to swing and use.

Edge: Pinkerton National Detective Agency 

Sidearm 

Both are quite simular but the Smith & Wesson has the larger bullet, making it the more powerful due to it's superior stopping power.

Edge: Baldwin-Felts Detective Agency 

Primary Rifle 

The Henry has significantly more rounds, allowing the Pinkerton agency to get off more shots before having to reload, allowing the agents to take more risks with their shots. The Winchester is the more modern and likely more reliable and it also has almost double the effective range of the Henry. This offsets the larger clip size of the Henry as the Baldwin-Felts agents can simply stay out of range and pick off the Pinkerton agents from a safe distance.

Edge: Baldwin-Felts Detective Agency 

Secondary Rifle 

Simular to the above, the Spencer Rifle has many more rounds and will easily allow the Pinkertons to overwhelm the single shot Sharps rifle, which would seem to easily give it the edge. However the Sharps has a much further effective range and is renowned for it's greater accuracy than other rifles and to top it off it also has the more powerful shot. Unlike the Winchester above though the single shot mechanism of the Sharps, gives it such a slow rate of fire that I don't think the Baldwin-Felts agents will be able to get off more than a few shots before the Pinkerton agents get close enough to pepper them with shots, giving the Spencer the edge.

Edge: Pinkerton National Detective Agency