User blog comment:Geekboy27/Duke Nukem vs Postal Dude/@comment-5795750-20130223080755

BG1's "Come Get Some Mail!" Edges

Melee: Here we see Duke with two weapons in the extremities in terms of range - the fists are reallt good up close but they wouldn't stand up to a shovel or a baton. The throwing knives are not really melee weapons but since you put them in melee, I guess that means that they will also act as ordinary knives which means that the knives have an advantage in versatility and range.

EDGE: Duke Nukem

Short: Well... this is kinda tricky to choose. In combat, I guess it is important to have less of recoil in order to land a perfect shot and in this battle, because both warriors are going to be moving fast they'll be firing their guns quickly. The M1911 is not as powerful as the Deagle but the Deagle is heavy and has one heck of a kickback that can spoil accuracy big time hence it will take Postal Dude quite a while to get his shots lined up by which time Duke will have already landed a few killshots at him.

EDGE: Duke Nukem

Medium: If you're gonna have the SPAS-12 be using pump action then this comparison is dead even but since the SPAS-12 also has a semi-automatic option, then it is very versatile. But then again, the range on the Mossberg aint that bad; its the range on the SPAS-12 that worries me and what might tip the scales one way or another. Since there is no specifics on the SPAS-12 i may have to call this even

EDGE: Even

Long: Dual SMGs are great when it comes to delivering devastating damage but it is horrid with accuracy and range; the M16 is a good rifle but it is plagued with unreliability issues. In the end here I may have to give it to dual MP5s here since it can land put more rounds into someone before that other person can return fire quickly; also Duke will charging head-long into Postal Dude so thats the range advantage gone.

EDGE: Duke Nukem

Special/Explosives: The Molotov cocktails are very good at dealing psychological blows to an enemy but at the end of the day, the fire they spread may not be enough to damage someone unless the throw is very accurate and it hits the person directly. Otherwise, the grenade launcher has the ability to cause extensive and collateral damage with a far greater range.

EDGE: Duke Nukem

Honestly I don't think I need to go through X-Factors here because we know that...

Overall Winner: Duke Nukem by a longshot - Duke packs the more devastating weaponry that will simply Postal Dude away; Duke may not be bright but at least he knows where to point a gun and fire it; also, Duke has faced off against numerous aliens standing in his way and won. There's no way this Main Man will lose to some anti-heroic psychotic vigilante