User blog comment:JGM007/Robert E Lee VS Napoleon Bonaparte/@comment-379205-20121216003422

119's "Is this fight even fair" Edges


 * Long Guns: The Richmond rifle is a rifled weapon firing a conical round, outranging the Charleville, and is much more accurate. There's a reason why rifles replaced smoothbore muskets. Edge: Lee


 * Pistols: Lee's Colt fires six shots, Napoleon's flintlock only has one. Edge: Lee


 * Swords: The Sabre and longer than the Model 1850. Edge: Napoleon.


 * Overall Winner: Robert E. Lee takes this easily. In fact, I almost wonder if this shouldn't be deemed an unfair battle, giving how much firearms advanced in the 50 years from the Napoleonic Wars to the Civil War.