User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 3 Episode 1: Frank West vs Rick Grimes/@comment-5795750-20130324054251

BG1's "I Sold it, Now I'll Vote on it" Edges:

Melee: The baseball bat has a larger reach compared to the machete, even though the machete has a blade that could result in an insta-kill.

EDGE: Frank

Revolvers: The Colt Python can be fired faster thanks to its double action plus it is lighter.

EDGE: Rick

Pistols: The Glock is lighter plus it fires more rounds and it also has a higher muzzle velocity

EDGE: Rick

Shotguns: Both have similar stats concerning killing potential but weight is key and the Mossberg is that bit lighter and thus is more compact

EDGE: Rick

Assault Rifles: Much like the Shotguns they almost have the same stats; this time, the key difference in both guns is that the M4A1 has the higher RoF and muzzle velocity and a greater range than the SG 552

EDGE: Rick

Snipers: While the Winchester is more built for hunting/sport, it is lighter than the Remington thereby giving the weapon the edge

EDGE: Frank

X-Factors: Average of 66 for Frank, Average of 70 for Rick

EDGE: Rick

Overall Winner: Hmmm... all the edges are telling me that Rick wins. But I disagree with it. Frank West as I look at him is better in physicality, creativity, experience and mental health which I guess is enough to cancel out Rick's brutality and training. Sure Rick might get an advantage in a firefight with his weapons, but since Frank has been in wars (ya know?) he would know how to dodge guns and stuff. The only thing that would tip the battle in Rick's favour would be something similar - he fought against the Woodbury Army who are comprised of military veterans...

This is tricky so I'll probs say this ends in a Draw