User blog comment:Lasifer/Welcome to Rapture: Booker DeWitt vs. Jack Ryan/@comment-2149911-20140128041554

Pach is gonna vote and  "If There's a Hell Down Below, We're All Gonna Go."

Weapons: Both Warrior are packing some heavy heat in this battle, especially against the creatures that dwell within the Fort and each other. However, it seems that Booker's weapons will do him more good in this grim situation compared to his opponent. To me he takes the most important edges in the weapons compartment, which are Melee, Pistol, Mid, and Long Range. Each weapon he has contains more ammo, fast fire rate, more damage, and can be used at a much longer distance. Overall, it seems Booker carry on this round. Edge: Booker DeWitt.

Vigors vs. Plasmids: Okay this is where shit gets real son. Check it, these are the abilities that will help the two wanderers survive in this desolate hellhole, but also give them a unique advantage against each other. Booker's Vigors give him a good blend of  Offense (such as Devil's Kiss and Murder of Crows), Defense ( Return to Sender), and Knockback ( Bucking Bronco). Jack, on the other hand, has a nice mix of Offense (Incinerate and Shock Blast), Variety (Plasmid traps), and Trickery ( Attack Dummy and Hypnosis). Let's not forget that both of them can control other individuals and machines to do their bidding, but in my personal opinion I think Jack narrowly takes this round. The variety of the plasmid traps have more destructive damage that could damage any wanderless individuals that would activate them and the ability to have a Big Daddy protect him temporarily will be a very significant danger to Booker. Edge: Jack Ryan and his Plasmid ability.

Gears vs. Tonic: This is a close one. Each power up gives an advantage against their opponent, however the ability to turn invisible when standing still gives Jack a slight lead in the round. Edge: Jack Ryan.

X-Factors: Again another close one here. Booker takes the edges in Intelligence, Training, and Experience, which to me, in my opinion,  makes him a more rounded and balanced fighter who knows how it is to be in the midst of war and to take charge when needed. Jack, however, gets the edges in Strength, Durability, Brutality, and Creativity. To me, this makes Jack a physically intimidating person in battle, who will do anything for his own survival, and know how to use his powers and the enviornment to his advantage. It's hard for me to take a side, each X-Factor give a warrior a unique advantage in battle, so I will give this a tie. Edge: Tie.

Overall Winner: Jack Ryan. It's gonna be tough and brutal battle to the death, where the winner is gonna be bloody, empty and barely and inch of his life in him. In the end Jack Ryan takes this battle for several reasons. His enchancements will prolong his survival much longer than his opponent, which is very damn important advantage in any fight. His plasmids and Tonics provide much better maneuverability and have contain more damage compared to the Bookers' Vigors. Also, to me, it seems that Jack would be in Rapture long before Booker and Elizabeth ever arrive, which means he will know the place more and use it to his advantage. Also being a damn survivor is a good boot too.