User blog comment:Cheesemuffin8/John Wick Vs. Max Payne/@comment-4661256-20180728224641

El Alamein's "Yhe" Edges:

 Handgun: Glock 34 vs. M1911:  The Glock's got a higher magazine capacity and a higher muzzle velocity, as Wass noted below. The M1911's .45 ACP is a larger caliber round than the Glock's 9mm, but I would actually say that the 9mm is probably better at penetrating armor because of the shape of the actual bullet. Yeah, the .45 does more damage to an unarmored target, but since both are wearing armor the Glock might have a better chance at getting through to the wearer underneath.

Edge: John Wick

 Rifle: AR-15 vs. AK-47:  I'm giving it to the AK-47, actually. I know that I usually champion the AR series over the Kalashnikov, but there are a couple of factors that give the AK some situational advantages. Both warriors are obviously skilled with their firearms, so I'm not particularly concerned about accuracy. The fact that the AK-47 can fire fully-automatic means that Max Payne can fire short bursts to suppress John Wick or potentially nail him a couple of times in rapid succession. The AR-15 being semi-automatic makes it better at longer ranges but doesn't do it too many favors as the fight closes in. Plus, the AK-47's 7.62mm round is a bigger bullet than the AR-15's 5.56mm round.

Edge: Max Payne

 Close Range: Benelli M4 vs. Mini Uzi:  I'm going to give it to the submachine gun. The shotgun will knock Max Payne on his ass if John Wick can get a good shot out, but I don't see him getting that close. Most of the weapons present in this fight outrange the shotgun, including the Uzi, and even if Wick gets close enough to use it, the M4 is a big long weapon that will be far less maneuverable than the Mini Uzi. Finally, the fact that the Uzi can lay down fully-automatic fire to suppress or riddle Wick means that Max Payne has a lot of options that aren't available to his opponent.

Edge: Max Payne

 Armor: Suit vs. Vest:  Well, the suit covers more of the body than the vest does, and since it's a tailored set of clothes it's probably not restrictive when it comes to moving about in combat. But the fact that it has an opening in the upper chest area (where most soldiers are trained to aim anyway) is a pretty big design flaw in my opinion, something that the Kevlar vest doesn't have to worry about, even if it doesn't cover as much of the body. I'm going to call it a draw.

Edge: Even

WINNER: MAX PAYNE

I'm giving it to Max Payne because he's got fully automatic weaponry, which Wick lacks. This is a pretty significant advantage in a gunfight that is hard to overemphasize. This means that Payne can more easily suppress his opponent while maneuvering to a more advantageous position, and if he does land a hit on Wick it'll probably be with several rounds in rapid succession. They are, more or less, equally skilled with firearm use, sure, but Payne's firearms are just better. Throw the glaring weakness of Wick's suit and Payne's greater experience into the mix and I think that it will be a tough victory, but one that Payne is properly equipped to pull off.