User blog comment:SPARTAN 119/Yuuji Kazami (Grisaia) VS Kasumi Route Shirou Yusa (Dies Irae)/@comment-35680048-20180827222942

Tybaltcapulet's " Don't know these two but i'll try"Edges:

Handguns: I'm actually going to give this an Even rating. While Shirou's elevated strength will help him out with ease of use, I believe this is countered by the pronlonged support, Yuuji's glock will give him. Both are entirely different handguns and will be useful for different purposes.Edge: Even

Explosives: I would have to agree with the author here and give this to Yuuji's IED.An assassin like Yuuji Kazami will easily be able to trap Shirou, who thrives off of a " go in guns blazing" tactic. This will enable the greater power of the IED to be more useful and catch Yusa off guard at the least. The grenade would be great for foes who aren't near Shirou's level but Yuuji can avoid much more than your standard human.Edge:Yuuji

Melee: The cross won't be nearly as effective on Yuuji, who is not a vampire and can take serious punishment. Shirou can take just as much and more, but the bayonet is an actual weapon and will be great to boost Yuuji's advanced close combat techniques. Better user, better weapon, better material, the choice is clear.Edge: Yuuji

Last Ditch: Both are pretty hard weapons to use but since again Yuuji has techniques and skill with melee and close combat he will be able to use the ballpoint pen in a much more advanced way than Shirou can use his necklace.Edge: Yuuji

X-factors: I'm going to cut to the chase and give this to Yuuji, just to start. Shirou may take the majority of the x-factors but Yuuji is not far behind him whatsoever. Shirou has more experience in general but Yuuji also has had his fair share of tussles and battles. This trend continues in Physical Strength, endurance, Intelligence, and Agility. But in places like training, close combat, Stealth, marksmanship, Shirou is quite lacking compared to Yuuji. And in this fight these x-factors (with the exception of stealth maybe) will be very important for Yuuji, giving him the tactical and skill edge.Edge: Yuuji

Overall: TBW