User blog comment:Kazanshin/Calusa Warrior vs Mata Toa Warrior/@comment-28716800-20180914124048

Battlefan237's edges

Short:Easy win for the Mata Toa, because it can deliver much more devastating damage than the makeshift seashell war club, simply due to its larger head. Edge: Rapa Nui

Mid:The golden rule of DF doesn't apply here for the reasons below: The shark teeth, unlike actual blades, are not powerful enough to cause major damage and the fact that they're simply fixed on the club with improvised ropes and stuff makes them highly unreliable, prone to fall off. The hand club, while also being improvised, is at least stable and has the potential to deliver severe damage.Edge: Rapa Nui

Long:As thoroughly stated by everyone below, arrow wins due to its range. Edge: Rapa Nui

Special:The Calusa knife actually has a blade and a handle, while the Easter Island dagger is barely a weapon - just a slightly sharpened stone piece. EDGE: Calusa Warriors

Overall:Easy win for the Rapa Nui. Their better weapons, better training, greater experience and better physicality will allow them to outmaneuver their American foe with ease.

P.S.: For unspecified reasons my computer doesn't allow me to write the winners in bold.