User blog comment:JGM007/S1, E1: Alexander the Great VS Publius Cornelius Scipio Africanus/@comment-24180428-20121227023646

Pointy edges:

Tale of the tape-Alexander is lighter and younger. Edge Alex

Long-Alex has this, javelins are crap for long range as seen on deadliest warrior.

Mid-Alexander's spear is longer.Edge Alex

Short-Alex's sword is lighter and longer. Edge Alex

Armor-Alexander's armor is lighter. Edge Alex

Tactics-Agree with you.

Winner Alexander the great.