User blog comment:Battlefan237/When Skull Island meets Jurassic Park ! Preston Packard vs. Robert Muldoon/@comment-3189283-20170406184237

Let's see shall we

Pistol 

Interesting comparison seeing as how both are from the same line of handgun. The M1911 is newer and so I assume better designed but I couldn't find much on how it would've been better. The M1902 has one more round though so I guess I'll call it even.

Edge: Even

Rifles

Since the majority of the men on both sides are using M16's there's not much point analysing that and the AK-47 and H&K 91A2 are only being carried by one guy each which makes their impact on the battle minimal. Ultimately it comes down to Packard and Muldoon's respective induvidual weapons and in that regard it's a clear edge for the M14. The Remington is a bolt action meaning it can't fire as fast and it also has a much smaller magazine meaning Muldoon has to be much more careful and precise. It'd be the superior weapon if he could get to a good sniping position but in standard combat the M14 is more practical.

Edge: Preston Packard

Shotgun

The Ithaca has one extra round but being a pump action can't spit out it's rounds as quickly as the semi-automatic Spas-12 which will be more important in the close confines of a forest.

Edge: Robert Muldoon

TBC