User blog comment:El Alamein/Landsknecht vs. Samurai/@comment-422690-20120725042121

Close 1: Zweihander wins. Despite the fact that the Katana has a more mobile style, the Zweihander is far longer, over twice its length as a standard, which gives the Ladsknecht an edge here. In addition, the Zweihander has more mass, giving the resulting swing a much higher energy and better impact. Edge: Landsknecht.

Close 2: Wakizashi wins. Both are specialized slashing swords, but the Wakizashi has an advantage with its shape. The curved design gives an increased cutting power on the edge it hits on. Plus, the guard on the Katzbalger will let in a thrust, which is possible with a Wakizashi. Edge: Samurai.

Mid: Yari wins. The Pike was meant ot stop a massive charge; in a 1-on-1 fight, it will be too unwieldy to do any good. The Yari, on the other hand, is a spear – and depending on the variant, can double as a longer Naginata. In essence, the Pike is overspecialized, while the Yari provides more options. Edge: Samurai.

Long Range: Even. Both are only going to give one shot, and the Matchlock ignition system is less than reliable. All in all, I’m going to give this even. Edge: None.

Armor: Burgonet and Munition wnins. Simply put, it has greater coverage.

Overall: Samurai get this for their superior dagger and spear.