User blog comment:MilitaryBrat/The Phantasm vs Rorschach/@comment-11993014-20130714220614

Apoc's Anti-Hero weapons edges

Short: Claw on hand vs Meat cleaver

The claw is readily avalible, but the cleaver seems more powerful. Rorschach can just cut off the hand Phantasm has her claw on and call it a day.

Edge:  Rorschach

Mid: Hand to hand vs hand to hand

Both characters seem to be very good at hand to hand combat IMO. They are equals

Edge: Even

Long: Smoke from gauntlet vs Grappling hook

The smoke may give the illusion of teleportation, but the hook has the capacity to kill, giving it the edge

Edge:  Rorschach

Special: Mask vs mask

Phantasm's mask has night vison, can be used as a gas mask, and changes her voice, all of which Rorschach's mask cannot do.

 Edge: Phantasm

 Overall winner:  Rorschach. He lives to kill killers. He is also way more brutal than Phantasm. My vote goes to  Rorschach.