User blog comment:Cfp3157/Percy Jackson vs. Harry Potter/@comment-5465602-20131029003716

BeastMan14's "Mysterious Ticking Noise/As typed by Dionysus" edges

Primary Weapon: Percy. Harry's wand gives him a lot of crazy cool and amazing abilities, sure, but it can easily be knocked away from him when Percy closes the distance and engages in close combat, and without it, he's an entirely useless fighter who can barely hold his own against a mean-spirited cousin, let alone a demigod who trained most of his teenage life in swordsmanship with a devastating surprise weapon and could go toe-to-toe with Ares (though it did come back to bite him in the ass later). Riptide is a pen, but Percy can draw it in an instant, making it much more discreet than Harry's wand when he whips it out and points it at someone, shouting magic words as he does so. Push comes to shove comes to sword being drawn comes to spell being fired, Percy is simply wielding a better weapon with far more skill than ever seen before in the Potter-verse. Edge: Peter Johnson

Abilities/Magic: I was even when I first thought about it, but then I pondered a bit more, and realized Percy has what is needed to win. Harry has spells that he can use to dominate at range, but Percy can easily use his own powers as well. Percy is strong enough to manipulate and move water from incredibly far distances, and with a massive lake just a sprint away, this will will "swamp" Harry down a bit in terms of casting spells when you're thrown away by a tidal wave. This will contribute a bit towards Percy's abilities as well, because even an ankle-deep pool of water can instantly heal his wounds, make him faster and stronger, and much smarter and more focused on his foe. Percy brings much more in terms of raw combat abilities that will contribute much more to the battle. Edge: Perry Johanssen

Deadliest Warrior: Isn't it obvious? Percy Jackson should take this without too much difficulty because he's the overall superior warrior. He's much more experienced, he's stronger and faster, he's much better trained, and he brings far better weapons and abilities for this fight. Harry's an impressive wizard, no doubt, but Percy is one of the greatest demigod's since the time of the Greeks. Score: 625-375