User blog comment:Lasifer/No Hope for Mother Earth: The Reapers vs. Giygas (Collab w/ Beast)/@comment-26150944-20140103230318

TheWetWaffle's "Neither of these series have a fourth game" Edges

Leaders: Sovereign vs. Giygas

Giygas is manages to get the edge due to the fact that Soveriegn has never fought a psychic opponent so this will be a tough challenge. Giygas has a lot of raw power, tougher attacks, and more moves than his opponent, giving him more choices. The Devils Machine and Apple of Enlightenment also give Giygas a huge boost since he can send the an attack back to Sovereign or predict Sovereign's next move with the Apple of Enlightenment. In terms of X Factors, Sovereign has an average of 88 while Giygas also has an average of 88 but Giygas takes the edges of brutality and strength and Sovereign takes experience and intelligence while tie for tactics. Overall, Giygas is the superior leader, he has the Devils Machine, Apple of Enlightenment, is more brutal, and is a lot stronger than Sovereign.

Edge: Giygas

Right Hand Man...Er...Alien...Mech...Thing: Saren Arterius vs. Porky Minch

While Porky is a really strong opponent, Saren is the more portable and experienced warrior. Porky has some pretty devastating attacks but Saren could dodge those attacks and hit him back. Porky also has to worry about Saren's biotic abilities and attacks since they could hit him pretty hard. In X Factors, Saren has an average of 87.5 while Porky takes an average of 86.666. Saren takes experience, intelligence, and strategy while Porky takes strength and brutality while both tie for loyalty to their leader. Overall, Saren takes the edge of superior general, Porky is bulky in his mech so he is open to fast attacks from Saren and that could be the thing that kills him.

Edge: The Reapers

Army Units: Geth vs. Starmen

This one goes is a tie, as the Starmen's PSI powers can definitley do some damage to the Geth but their superior armor can help them take hits from the PSI powers. When the Starmen do find a weak point in the Geth, they could do some serious damage and take them out but as they're doing that the Geth are going to be killing them off.

Edge: Even

Expendable Units: Husks vs. Mushrooms, Reptiles, and Tentacle...Things

This is going to be another tie, as the Husks are a lot more brutal and can do a lot of damage but Giygas's expendable units have better attacks. While the PSI attacks of Giygas's expendable units can do a pretty good amount of damage, the Husks have more diversity which can be a good tool in this scenario.

Edge: Even

Overall: The Reapers vs. Giygas

While Porky may be a problem in this battle for his team, I'll give my vote to Giygas and his team of Porky, Starmen, and mushroom... things. Giygas is the better leader but The Reaper's general Saren can beat Porky which can hinder Giygas but not give The Reapers the win. Giygas is called the "Embodiment of Evil" for a reason, he's a pretty tough guy to beat and The Reapers will soon learn that.

OVERALL WINNERS: GIYGAS