User blog comment:Affectos/Survival of the Living: Night of the Living Dead vs. The Walking Dead Gang (Telltale Games)/@comment-4661256-20130103201410

El Alamein's "They're Coming to Get You, Barbara" Edges:

 Close Range: Claw Hammer & Spiked Wooden Boards vs. Fire Axe & Hatchet:  The axe and hatchet are very similar weapons that are sharp and heavy, which is great in a close-quarters fight if you want to inflict gory damage like the severing of limbs. The claw hammer is a very decent improvised weapon (givent that the hammerhead can inflict blunt trauma while the pointed claw end can inflict puncture wounds), but the NotLD gang suffers with the wooden boards - it's not a great weapon, not even against zombies, for crying out loud! The fire axe and hatchet, in combination, are the superior weapons.

Edge: Walking Dead Gang

 Mid Range: Colt Model 10 vs. Beretta:  A semi-automatic pistol beats a six-shooter - faster rate of fire, larger magazine capacity, quicker reload, lighter... blah, blah, blah. You all know why the Beretta is superior - it's more modern. And modern weapons beat their older counterparts nine times outta ten.

Edge: Walking Dead Gang

 Long Range: Winchester vs. WInchester:  It's the same weapon. Unlike what Mr. Anon says below, they're the same damn thing.

Edge: Even

 Special Weapons: Molotov Cocktails vs. Butcher Cleaver:  The Butcher Cleaver is a clumsy melee weapon while the Molotov Cocktails have the potential to inflict collateral damage - they're a freakin' firebomb for cryin' out loud.

Edge: Night of the Living Dead Gang

WINNER: THE WALKING DEAD GANG

I really, really, really wanted to vote for the NotLD gang... but I don't see it happening. Their weapons are inferior on nearly every level, and they failed in their attempt to hold off the undead - I doubt they can hold off competent enemies who can fight back from a distance. It's a shame too, because Ben is such an effective leader. Oh, well.