User blog comment:Lachlan Blake/Shaun (of the Dead) vs Columbus/@comment-3166030-20110901060458

Neither of them were particularly great with firearms, to be honest. If it weren't for Tallahassee and Wichita (I think that was her name), he wouldn't have lasted.

Anyway, I'm going for Shaun, because the mallet is slow and cumbersome, while the Cricket bat can be armed, and swung in a fluid motion.

I'll also go for Shaun in the fact that his firearm holds more than two shots.