User blog comment:Tybaltcapulet/Geronimo vs Theodore Roosevelt/@comment-3189283-20181023121730

Let's see shall we

Melee

The Tomahawk does exactly what the Bowie Knife does except it has a further reach and a greater weight to give it more punch behind it's blows.

Edge: Geronimo

Sidearms 

The Single Action is rocking the larger round and greater muzzle velocity which would be great if not for the fact neither are really wearing much armour so having greater stopping power isn't as much of an advantage as it could be. What is a considerable advantage meanwhile is having a double-action mechanism instead of a single-action one as you can pump out your rounds much faster.

Edge: Theodore Roosevelt 

Rifles

It's the same weapon so there isn't really any comparison to be made and I couldn't find anything to suggest either Roosevelt or Geronimo being amazingly skilled riflemen or anything. I normally associate Roosevelt with the Krag so why that wasn't used I don't know but whatever.

Edge: Even

Final Verdict 

In terms of weapons Roosevelt has a slight edge owing to him having the better sidearm (Melee won't play much of a part and won't be a deciding factor) but it's not enough to give any big advantage or anything. So this battle comes down to X Factors and in that regard it's a clear victory for Geronimo. He has far more experience both as a warrior and a leader and was much more successful to boot, both against the US army and Mexican tribes. Everybody else has already shit on Roosevelt's cavalier attitude to combat so I won't go to much into that but I will defend him a little bit by saying the open desert suits him better because Geronimo's skirmishing tactics won't be quite as effective. Nevertheless I still think Geronimo is just the better tactician overall and that will carry him to victory in this battle of small margins.

Geronimo: 2,800

Theodore Roosevelt: 2,200