User blog comment:So-Pro Warrior/Season 1-Battle 1:Battle of the Galaxy Savers: Commander Shepard vs. Luke Skywalker/@comment-4248317-20121120075259

Close - Luke. As Las said, this is a pretty obvious choice. The Lightsaber is far more damaging, versatile, and can be continually activated.

Mid - Shepard. While Luke's pistol has more rounds and more accurate, Luke isn't as experienced with it as Shepard is with his gun. In addition, Luke has no armor, whereas Shepard has both kinetic barriers and N7 armor, providing double defense against blaster shots.

Long - Shepard. Like So-Pro said, the Avenger is more accurate, reliable, and easy to use. Add to that Shepard's superior training, as well as the fact that, again, Luke has no armor, means the Avenger will do far more damage in this fight.

Abilities - Even. This one is too close for me to call; Shepard's biotics are better for offense, and can even freeze Luke in place, but Luke's Force powers can do similar things, as well as increase his speed and heal himself.

X-factors - Shepard. Shepard has far more training than Luke which helps him immensly. In adition, I personally feel he should get a slight edge in experience, as he has been fighting for longer than Luke has.

Winner - COMMANDER SHEPARD'''. '''Shepard wins due to superior training and experience, as well as better overall weapons. In addition, a number of Luke's force powers are either reduced or nullified against Shepard; his lack of scars (as So-Pro has stated) means that Shatterpoint has less to target, and I believe Force Persuasion will not work either, as Shepard has been shown to have an incredibly strong will, having resisted so much exposure to Reaper Indoctrination. Luke's only chance is in close combat, and while Shepard's armor will be shredded by the lightsaber, I'm not sure how effective the kinetic barriers will be. If they can block the lightsaber even once, that gives Shepard a prime opportunity to stab Luke with his Omni-tool.