User blog comment:El Alamein/The Malmedy Survivors vs. the Dunkirk Evacuees/@comment-4541447-20160302085351

So-Pro's "When DF makes Allies Fight each other" Edges

Close/Mid Range-Dunkirk Evacuees: Yes I'm doing both Close and Mid Range here but that is one because they both have to do with bladed weapons and two because they both go to the Evacuees of Dunkirk. Both of their blades have the length advantage over the American's Knife/Bayonet meaning they would have to get in closer if they have a chance of striking and killing them.

Long Range-Malmedy Survivors: Nothing can beat the power of the .45 ACP of the Colt M1911, that coupled with that one extra bullet, better muzzle velocity, and the quicker reload speed of the magazine to the cylinder give the edge to the Colt once again.

X-Factors-Malmedy Survivors: While both tie out in the Factors, the Survivors get it due to taking some important ones such as Stealth, and Combat Experience. For Stealth this could be helpful and even balance things out at close range as it means the Americans could attempt and even succeed in sneaking up on the British soldiers and taking them out before they can even draw their knife/bayonet. As Deathblade pointed out the survivors had to deal with escaping from the feared SS Panzer Divisions who if I remember correctly were some of the elite soldiers of the German Army and then of course some probaby soldiers have probably been fighting since the US entered the war.

The Deadliest Survivors: The Malmedy Survivors

While the Dunkirk Evacuees have the better close range weapons and I doubt the pistols are going to make much of a difference, like Deathblade said, the fact that the Malmedy Survivors had to contend with the elite Nazi SS Panzer Divisions and with what little they had still make it back to the allied lines means that they had to deal with a lot more. The Dunkirk survivors had huge numbers at least when they were holding off the Germans but the Malmedy survivors was composed of very little due to all of their friends being massacred and as such were use to working in a small group of five compared to the Evacuees.