User blog comment:WraithOfWaffle/Season One: Battle Three: Cole Phelps (LA Noire) vs. Eliot Ness (The Untouchables)/@comment-3127606-20131030211053

MB's "Man of Steel" edges

Short range 1: Edge Phelps-The M1911A1 was a groundbreaking sidearm worldwide, and wasn't replaced for close to 70-80 years and is still being used today on the frontlines by special forces. That means a well made design.

Short range 2: Edge Ness- The Model 10 has a slightly longer barrel meaning better accuracy.

Mid range: Edge even- Same weapon pretty much.

Long range: Edge Phelps-The M1 Garand was designed to replace the Springfield for the US Military post WWI. It has semi automatic fire instead of bolt action, it carries more rounds, and it's also a bit more accurate. Depending on the shooter of course.

Special: Edge Even-They both have their advantages and disadvantages as far as killing potential goes.

Winner: Cole Phelps.