User blog comment:Affectos/The Vigilante: Travers Lysander (Affectos) vs. Ellis Jackson (MilitaryBrat)/@comment-24180428-20130830142931

Utter noob's "Horses are Weird" edges:

Melee-The Tomahawk is going to perform better as a melee weapon and will do more damage as a projectile. Edge Ellis

Revolver-The LeMat has ammo on its side, but the Colt has power. So I'm going to call it even.

Shotgun-The pump action will make Ellis be able to fire a bit faster. Edge Ellis

Rifle-The Henry may be heavier, but it is more powerful with a higher ammo count to add to that. Edge Lysander

Special-The Bow has a much longer bow, and since Ellis was trained by Apaches he is likely a great archer. Edge Ellis

Pros/Cons-Ellis has training, Lysander doesn't. However Lysander doesn't really have a con that will affect this matchup, whilst Ellis has to worry about his familly. So edge even.

Winner-This will be a close fight, but I have to give it to Lysander. Whilst Ellis is skilled archer and possess greater short ranged weaponry and a greater special weapon, the Henry rifle outranges alll of those. Consdiering Lysander is a great marksmen with said rifle, he may be able to pick off Ellis before he gets in range to use his Tomahawk or Shotgun. Though if Ellis does get up close he could best Lysander with his superior short ranged weapons.

=Deadliest Warrior-Lysander=