User blog comment:MilitaryBrat/The Phantasm vs Rorschach/@comment-4978251-20130715032315

Melee Weapon- The claw is versitile, but the cleaver hits harder, with a longer reach. Edge- Even

H2H Skills- Rorshach takes this as he is likely stronger, his combat style is unpredictable, and he is amazing at improvising weapons in the heat of combat. Edge- Rorshach

Distance- Smoke pellets are nice for distractions and such, but the grappling hook is better. It can strike harder, the hooks can pierce flesh, has longer range and can be used for better movement. And Rorshach can't be scared easy. Edge- Rorshach

Masks- This is ridiculous, but the Phantasm mask can do things, useless as they may be in the heat of combat. Edge- Phantasm

Overall- Rorshach easily. He is stronger, has better weapons and such. They both have fear, but Rorshach's fear is better. Phantasm fear is just because she appears and acts otehrwordly, but Rorshach is feared for his reputation which is more genuine, especially considering how skilled a detective he could probably figure out she is just a normal person using tricks. He also more brutal then Phantasm.

Overall- Rorshach