User blog comment:Alockwood1/Walking Dead Survivors Versus Perfection Nevada Citizens/@comment-5522042-20131119032450

Utter noob's "Because Daryl Dixon is Hot" edges:

Sniper-Even. Whilst the Barret is powerful and has a larger magazine, the issue of manuverability is too great to overcome the Winchester. Edge even

Assault Rifle-The M4A1 by far is the better weapon. Lighter weight, better muzzle velocity, and much, much more reliable. Not surprising considering that the M4 is an improved version of the M16. Edge  Survivors

Shotgun-The Mossberg has a larger magazine and is lighter. Edge Survivors

Pistol-The Desert Eagle has much more recoil and is more likely to jam than the revolver. Edge Survivors

Explosives-Toy car bomb vs grenade? What is this, Call of Duty? Anyways, the grenade is better since it can be used in a greater varity of scenarios. Edge Survivors

Non-Lethal-Going blind and deaf is much worse than just deaf. Edge Survivors

Melee-Range, power, and practicality for all these weapons goes to the Survivors. Edge Survivors

Special-Rifle > crossbow. Simple as that. Edge Citizens

X-factors-To long, didn't read. Edge even

Winner-Walking Dead Survivors. More experience fighting humans, better weapons, and Daryl Dixon is pretty. I'm fairly sure the last one is the biggest issue for the Citizens.