User blog comment:WraithOfWaffle/Battle Fifteen: Walter White (Breaking Bad) vs. Frank Murdoch (God Bless America)/@comment-25242759-20150108091022

'''Deathblade's "Nobody stops this train!" edges:'''

Ok we have a cancer stricken man vs a man who isn't affected by cancer. Let's get started.

Assault Rifle: Walter White. Ahhh, the typical AK-47 vs M4A1 face off. The Norinco is effectively a Chinese copy of the AK-series, so it shares the same flaws: accuracy, etc. The M4A1 is more accurate and has a stock on it. The downside is it has a smaller round, but I don't think it matters here.

Revolvers: Frank Murdoch. A five round revolver vs a six round revolver? The Ruger LCR is a good weapon in Walt's hands in terms of quick drawing, but one extra bullet is all Frank needs to take Walt down.

Pistol #1: Walter White. The Smith and Wesson 4506 is an updated M1911, so it fires a similar round. However, the S&W has got one more bullet than Frank, which could be life or death for Walter.

Pistol #2: Frank Murdoch. The pebble like 9mm is almost useless compared to the .45 ACP. However, the larger magazine of the Browning Hi-Power is a definite game changer.

Melee: Frank Murdoch. Despite them being the same weapon, I have to give the edge to Frank Murdoch; he's healthier and more sane than Walter.

Explosive: Walter White. The exploding car is just a 10-90 chance weapon. It may work 10% of the time but isn't all that good due to getting the fuel/oxygen mix right. However, Walter's pipe bomb is actually decent. He can detonate it at a distance and kill Frank without closing the gap.

X-factors: Walter White. Walt takes the critical intelligence, experience and tactics factors which ultimately hands him the win here.

Winner: Walter Hartwell White. Walt is more intelligent, experienced and tactically superior to Frank, having faced people like Gus Fring, Tuco and his Cousins and Jack Welker and his white supremist gang who are a lot worse than Frank.