User blog comment:Alockwood1/The Fellowship of the Ring Versus The Dragon Knight Companions/@comment-5078776-20130920014050

Honestly, while it's certainly not unfair it's an easy win for the Fellowship. When it comes to the mages, Gandalf and Carolinus are actually pretty even in terms of magical skills and abilties. However, Gandalf can also fight up close with his staff and sword Glamdring to combat him up close. Between Aragorn and Brian, Aragorn seems to have the superiority in terms of experience, mental health, and teh actual blade. Anduril cannot break, while Brian wields a normal sword.

Despite his great skill, Dayffd gets beaten by Legolas because he lacks the precision and experience that Legolas has with him. Plus, his bow is much less cumbersome if it comes to melee, so Legolas near-superhuman agility allows him to do some crazy bow fu fighting.

Gimili and Aargh are both the brutes of their teams. However, I feel as if Aargh could beat Gimili because of his agility, senses, and stealth abilitiy. Even though Gimili has a true weapon and armor, Aargh can get past it all.

Frodo and James, though i feel, won't even meet in combat. Frodo will wear the One Ring and just run around as a skirmisher with the others of the Companions. James, however, can serve as a much more direct and useful combat option for the others.

In the end, it's Gandalf, Aragorn, and Legolas confronting Carolinus, Aargh, and James. Aargh will get pelted with arrows by Aragorn and Legolas, and those combined three have teh experience, tactical and combat skills to beat Carolinus up close. James, without hi fellows, will easily fall to the three remaining Fellowship members.

WINNERS: FELLOWSHIP OF THE RING!!!!