User blog comment:Leolab/Ancient User Tourney, Round 2: Oliver Moreau (Winter) v Sir Bors of Newcastle (Elgb)/@comment-28394113-20160526232827/@comment-5043545-20160531032111

There are several key sissues with this vote that I feel need to be addressed that make this vote kind of bad.


 * Yes, Sir Bors has more armor, everyone seems to make that obvious, the problem is that he's roughly carrying 90 pounds of gear coming into this match before he even gets his other weapons. He'll be slower than his target whose wearing a comfortable armor. Something that covers the torso is enough protection. He's wearing a full set of knight's armor against someone whose tools are more effective against hitting this tank of a target who won't be moving around comfortable due to the amount of weight on him. 60-70 pounds of starting choices should be the max, anymore and you'll be slow and open.


 * Next, you completely ignored anything said in the bios to describe the warriors and instead focused purely on weapon edges to determine a vote. Not exactly the best way to have a vote. As you didn't examine the warriors and the conflicts they might have fought in. This is a usual pitfall for many as focusing only on weapons is never a good idea when comparing warriors. We've had matches on this wiki before where warriors with worse weapons win because of x-factors and skills.