User blog comment:Goddess of Despair/Season 5 battle 2 Comanche vs Aztec Jaguar/@comment-5795750-20130531003045

BG1's "EA should've covered this in the Native America Battle Royale" Edges:

Short Range: Iron Blade > Obsidian Blade in terms of durability, Obsidian Shards > Iron Blade in terms of killing potential but the Maquahitl is longer than the war hawk giving it a range advantage

EDGE: Even (slight lean towards Aztec)

Medium Range: The war lance gets the edge here since it has a range advantage

EDGE: Comanche

Long Range: Both weapons can easily be reloaded and while the Tlacochtli and Atlatl is longer than the bow and arrow, it might not be thrown as far as it plus it is much heavier

EDGE: Comanche

Special: Similar to the Short Range edge

EDGE: Even (slight lean towards Aztec)

Overall Edge: Hmmm... this is tricky considering that the Jaguar knows how to fight in the jungle, is a trained soldier and has at least some form of armour and shield; the Comanche is one of those examples of prime ancient guerrila fighters. I can't really decide - I'll have to say Even.