User blog comment:Pygmy Hippo 2/Ancient Terror Part 3:Dead By Daylight Killers vs. Hide or Die Hunters/@comment-35680048-20191028144630

Tybaltcapulet's "Horror Battle: # 21535" Edges:

The Electric Psycho: Both of these two use electricity and both aren't right in the head. But in terms of who beats the other here, I think I prefer the kit The Scientist has to offer over The Doctor. In weapons, the Electric Bat is superior since it provides a shock to every hit, and isn't blocked by the multiple spikes on the spiked bat which while threatening, make it harder to actually kill. I'm not a massive fan of Carter's Spark either which does what the Electric Bat does better, but at a shorter range, and it's effects are basically useless against The Scientist, who is already psychotic, and as a result won't be very much affected by the intense shocking. The Holodromes provide a way for TS to trap TD and put the beating on him. The Radar also provides a quick way of tracking down anyone he goes against. And as for perks, TS again slams with perks that are much more practical to his equipment than TD's fear based perks. And TD relying on his fear based abilities really is his downfall, while TS is much better at actual practical combat. Edge: HDH 

The Ranged Hunter: To me, the Fisherman is easily the most competent and sane warrior here, and is quite efficient here, unlike the Huntress who essentially behaves like an animal. As for main weapons, I prefer the spear, as I believe it is likely larger, and still most likely light, and on top of that has the addition of barbs that will cause even more damage. The Broad Axe is just a simple axe that is highly telegraphed and easy to avoid in my opinion. Then for their ranged weapons one may say that the hatchet easily take it, since there's at least five available to Anna and the Harpoon is a single shot weapon and a pain in the ass to reload, but it's actually pretty even to me. The Hatchets seem to require a wind up/charge, while the Harpoon fires instantly, and I would say hits much harder than the hatchets. Range really doesn't matter here as this is a pretty small space for them to be fighting in. I also prefer the Sonar, which like The Scientist, provides The Fisherman with  a constant visual on Anna no matter what. The Coarse Stone only really seems to waste time, as TF should be able to tank hatchet shots, even if he's bleeding(and even then he has his ghost mode which makes him untouchable). And Anna's perks are basically useless, reliant on an unsuspecting victim, while the Fisherman can improve the functionality of his Sonar.Edge:HDH 

TBC