User blog comment:WraithOfWaffle/Battle Eight: Carnegie (The Book of Eli) vs. The Governor (AMC's The Walking Dead)/@comment-4392864-20140213212248

They never get what they want!

Melee- The machete is a very nice blade, but the Bowie, now that's made for killing- the stabbing is more deadly than a slash. Edge- Governor

Handgun 1: Both of these are nice guns. However, both the Browning and the Beretta are much the same. Overall though, I'm giving this to the Beretta, but only because of higher muzzle velocity. Edge- Governor

Handgun 2- Again, both are good guns, with the Colt 70 being the great-grandson of the Colt 1911, but I have to go with the Beretta for having twice the ammo. Edge- Carnegie

Shotgun The Moss 500 is a nice gun, but 14 shots are better than 9, in favor of the UTAS. Edge Governor

Rifle 1- The Ak-47 in your classic Bad Guy Weapon, but the AUG is a newer weapon, and is a little bit better. Edge Governor

Rifle 2: Again- old versus New- have to go with the FAL for being improved. Edge Carnegie

Explosive Type 69 versus AT4- both of these are 1-shot weapons that blow things up. I have to go with the AT4- it's newer, and has some improvements over the 69. Edge- Governor

Heavy Machine Guns- both of these are battlefield changers. Now, while the Browning is a newer gun,it's a little prone to jamming. The Gattling gun though- get a jam in one barrel, you still have seven more to use.. Edge- Carnegie

Deadliest Warrior- I have seen The Book of Eli, and while I can say that Carnegie can be terrifying, the Governor just scares the Hell out of me- the guy would cut your head off and stick it in a fish tank! Winner- Governor