User blog comment:Thornclaw Braveheart/Witch-king of Angmar vs. Eragon Bromsson/@comment-3361508-20111129000438

Must not get spoilers <_<

Close Range: Knife < Flail. EDGE: Witch-King

Mid Range: Haven't read that far into the book yet <_<

Magic 1: Telekinesis pl0x. EDGE: Eragon

Magic 2: Per Thornclaw. EDGE: WK

Magic 3: Black Shadow... basically like a disease that withers you down? Pshh... Eragon's gone through much worse, aka when fighting Durza. EDGE: Eragon

Mount: Dragon > Weird Pterodacyl looking thing. Plus, Eragon has quite the tight bond with Saphira, something that would be a huge advantage. EDGE: Eragon

Special: So, coming from what you said... the arrows can't kill the Witch-King. If it can't kill, I would at least think stun. But if not, Eragon's screwed in this category. EDGE: Witch-King

Overall Edge: Eragon. He's fought against worse foes than this.