User blog comment:El Alamein/Isaac Darkstone vs. Finn Müller. Day Four: Hunger Games Tournament Redux/@comment-422690-20160729232612

So...

Close Range: Katar wins. They're the same weapon, so not much to say weapon-wise. Finn, however, will likely use his better, thanks to that "Bladed Weapons Expert" trait, something that Isaac lacks.

Mid Range: Glaive wins. One is due to reach, two is due to the "Skilled staff fighter" trait for Isaac. While the length of the spear can work against it in a small space, people seem to be underestimating how much damage a shaft can do. Even if it doesn't kill, it can break bones and disable with a solid hit.

Long Range: Throwing knives win. While the previous sim establishes that they won't get through that polymer clothing, they're still more useful than the crossbow in a small arena. Isaac's going to have a hard time loading, drawing, aiming, and firing while avoiding Finn's blows.

Special: Black Eggs win. Using a spear against a staff expert is not going to get you very far. The Black Eggs are a potent disabling weapon; simply getting hit with it is enough to cause an instinctive flinch, even if it doesn't get in the eyes. This creates an opportunity for a skilled combatant to close in and face-stab the shit out of a dude.

Overall: Isaac Darkstone wins. Finn is a good fighter, but he's not used to targets that fight back. Isaac can - and will - strike back at him, and will likely wear Finn down, ultimately disabling him with the Black Eggs long enough for a kill.