User blog comment:Elgb333/Iron Men Challenge: Ned Kelly vs Jim Miller/@comment-3189283-20160724081757

Let's see shall we

Short Range

I'm torn with this one. The Beaumont-Adams has the quicker and easier firing system due to it being double-action and also has a significantly longer range but the Peacemaker has that all important extra round and it's higher muzzle velocity gives it a more powerful shot which is especially important considering both are wearing armour.

Edge: Even 

Mid Range 

Obviously the Colt Revolving Rifle gets the edge due to a faster rate of fire, further range and larger magazine size but I would still like to give some credit to the Coachgun. While it is purely a close quarters weapon (with an even shorter range than the handguns) the sheer penetration power of the shot will more than likely get through Ned Kelly's armour with only a couple of shots and Miller's skill with said weapon only make it all the more deadly.

Edge: Ned Kelly

Long Range 

Really not very impressed with the Spencer Rifle if i'm honest. Sure it has a much longer range but other than that it gets outclassed in every other area. The Winchester has the rate of fire, magazine size, packs a bigger punch and judging by the descriptions of both rifles it also seems far less complex to fire.

Edge: Jim Miller

TBC