User blog comment:Alockwood1/Jericho Cross Versus John Marston (Undead Nightmare)/@comment-17814994-20150919125642

Elgb's "Red Dead... Dead Again" EDGES!!!

Melee: I can't say which weapon is better. The scepter was definately designed as a weapon, and its longer too. But it's all blunt force and nothing else. The torch is shorter, but it both offers blunt and fire damage. But still, a torch isn't really the best weapon to use because it can also catch you on fire with every sloppy swing. The scepter, being shaped as a mace, probably has more power and damage potential. EDGE: Jericho

Melee #2: Both are pistol whips and butttrokes, but Jericho's weapons are designed to cause more damage with each attack as opposed to John's mediocre strokes. EDGE: Jericho

Pistol: The Mauser pistol is the one that is designed as an actual machine pistol. The Mauser's bootleneck cartridge allows it to have almost the same veloctiy as a semi-auto pistol. The Redeemer may have 24 rounds but it's not actually "automatic" in a sense. You still need to fan the hammer in order to create an illusion that it is automatic but not in ana ctual sense. What you're doing when you're fanning the revolver is firing it fast semi-automatically... not automatically. It's like firing your Glock so fast that it looks like it's automatic but isn't. In te case of a single-action revolver it's also the same thing. however fanning revolvers is not adviceable due to being so innacurate. EDGE: John

Pistol #2: The Lemat revolver is a great revolver but is an antique one. The Warmongers is the more advanced revolver which can be fired and reloaded faster, as well as being a pair. EDGE: Jericho

Rifle: Evans repeater easy. It's got the bigger magazine and faster rate of fire. EDGE: John

Sniper: The carcano rifle may have one more bulllet but the Carson is semi-auto which makes the the faster rifle. EDGE: Jericho

Thrown #1: The boom bait is only good against zombies. The splitter has both explosive and fragmental damages. EDGE: Jericho

Special Weapon #1: The blunderbuss is slow and consuming weapon. It's only effective against zombies but less damaging against anything else. The crossbow has the farther range and explosive potential. EDGE: Jericho

Special Weapon #2: This I gotta give to the explosive rifle. I actually made a battle long ago with the rifle against Nemesis T-Type's rocket launcher. While the launcher gives off the bigger boom, many still agreed that the explosive rifle is better because it can be aimed more accurately, straight and reloaded quicker. EDGE: John

Eye power: Although Jericho's Vision looks very useful in targetting enemies, John's dead eye can also do this as well as slow down time. EDGE: John

Deadliest Warrior?

Although it's sad for me to vote against my all-time favorite VG character, still I'm not going to drown in bias, and proclaim Jericho Cross as the winner. He's got the better weapons, as well as being stronger, faster and tougher than the zombie Jack.