User blog comment:Kaiser of Metcalfer99/Tlingit Warrior vs Kiribati Warrior/@comment-27358240-20180808070810

'''Kazanshin's "YOU  PICKED THE WRONG LANDS, FOOL!" edges'''

Close Range: The sword club is longer, but that's where the advantages end. The tlingit dagger is more durable, sharper and can be swung or thrusted faster. Edge: Tlingit

Mid Range: The shark tooth spear is longer and is probably superior at damaging flesh. However, against the wooden armor of the tlingit, I fail to see it causing significant damage. The club, on the other hand, will give no quarter to the Kiribati's armor and will cause blunt trauma. Edge: Tlingit

Long range: Bow>Sling. Nuff said. Edge: Tlingit

Special: The pick is going to have no problem punching through the armor of the kiribati, especially with the jade blade, while the sword suffers from the same disadvantages as the spear: shark tooth just don't do well against wood. Edge: Tlingit

Defense: The lasso is a versatile weapon, but it won't be effective against an opponent with a shield, especially not one that big. Edge: Tlingit

Armor: I'll actually give this one to the Kiribati. The wooden armor of the tlingit is indeed much tougher, but I see it being a huge nuisance for mobility. Edge: Kiribati

X-Factors: Tlingit via higher average.

'''Deadliest Warrior? I give it to the Tlingit. '''I may be a little biased since the Tlingit are one of my favorite Native American tribes, and since I'm probably partially Tlingit, with some other indigeneous american blood, but the Tlingit has all the weapon advantages it needs to dominate the Kiribati, while the latter can't really do anything against that thick wood armor.