User blog comment:SPARTAN 119/Lisbeth Salander (The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo) vs Shion Sonozaki (Higurashi)/@comment-4552610-20120819041751

I'll throw in a vote for ya.

Undead RVD's Edges of....... Stuff:

Short Melee: I got to go with the Bowie knife. It may lack the reach of the hammer but it is faster and can be thrown. EDGE: Shion

Mid Melee: I can't pick one. The bladed whip lacks the power of the golf club but it can be used to trip or disarm. EDGE: Even

Heavy Melee: The katana wins hands down. It's sharper, lighter and faster. The ax may have weight but it's slow and much more unwieldy. EDGE: Shoin

Taser: Both have the same weapon but Shoin's is illegally modified to give out more of a punch. EDGE: Shoin

Pistol: Shoin's TT-33 is packing stronger, faster rounds (Muzzle velocity 420 m/s vs 381 m/s) but Lisbeth's Berreta 92 is holding 12 rounds vs 8. Shoin has power but Lisbeth has numbers. Lisbeth wins but by only a sliver. EDGE: Lisbeth

VOTE: Shoin. Unlike Lisbeth, Shoin will aim to kill. This drive will eventually get out of hand and Lisbeth not win the fight. However, I do see Lisbeth losing the match but escaping when she has the chance.