User blog comment:WraithOfWaffle/Battle Twelve: Black Mask (DC Comics) vs. Big Smile Lee (Sleeping Dogs)/@comment-5795750-20140609141502

BG1's "Let's Put A Smile on That Face... wait, wrong guy!" Edges

Melee: While I think the machete gets the edge here since it has a much bigger blade with more potential power to kill than a switchblade, I may have to call this even since the big ass machete might not fare well across all areas of wherever this battle may be since both settings will involve tight corridors as well as open rooms and thus the smaller size of the switchblade might actually be more useful

EDGE: Even

Pistol 1: Aiming one pistol better than two? Well if Black Mask is capable of firing two guns accurately then that trumps being able to fire accurately with just one gun; and yes the USP may have the bigger calibre but sometimes carrying the small stuff in large amounts (i.e. the 16 bullets of two Colts vs the 12 in the USP) can definitely kill

EDGE: Black Mask

Pistol 2: Between these two Eagles, the Double Eagle wins out here for at least being that bit more user-friendly, quicker on the kill and accurate than the Deagle

EDGE: Black Mask

Shotgun: If a shotgun has no stock and is sawed off then that's bad news for the shotgun's performance in that its range is reduced significantly and it becomes a little bit discomforting on the user, drawbacks which the Remington might suffer

EDGE: Big Smile Lee

SMG 1: You said so yourself the Thompson is clunky and heavy which means most of those shots (unless they were fired by Black Mask himself) are going to miss most of the time plus its simply outdated compared to the more compact and at least that bit more accurate and deadlier UMP

EDGE: Big Smile Lee

SMG 2: The MAC-10 is a little bit like the Thompson but on a smaller scale, its high rate of fire and small size may help with the killing in some way but all those bullets go to waste in the remaining spray radius; the MP7 on the other hand is more killing-oriented and while it may not be as compact as the MAC-10 it can certainly prove itself to be the more useful and deadlier one

EDGE: Big Smile Lee

Assault Rifle: I think you mean to say 800m range there. Anyway, I have to give my edge to the G36E since it has the same performance characteristics as the M16A2 but on a more controlled/fixed level making it a formidable competitor to the M16 rifle

EDGE: Big Smile Lee

Explosive: Again, I must say even for the same reason as the melee - one weapon (the grenade launcher) is deadlier than the other (given the impact of the grenade on its target and the range) but given the circumstances that advantage is somewhat diminished (you try firing a grenade launcher down a corridor into a room... throwing a grenade down the way is perhaps a safer bet)

EDGE: Even

TBF