User blog comment:Leolab/Irving Morrell (TL-191) v Welkin Gunther (Valkyria Chronicles)/@comment-5900266-20160830011613

MoA's Edges:

Infantry: Basic Infantry vs. Scouts. Scouts take this. The Basic Infantry's Springfield is outclassed by the Gallian-A, a weapon with greater magazine capacity, fire rate and reload speed. The grenades don't have any noticeable differences so no advantage there.

Edge: Welkin Gunther

Anti-Tank: Anti-Armor Infantry vs. Lancers. Easy edge for the Lancers. As voters before me have stated, its superior explosive warhead and range easily beat out the Confederate Anti-Barrel Rocket.

Edge: Welkin Gunther

Specialists: Close-Range Infantry vs. Shocktroopers. As voters before have stated, the Mag XXX has superior range but it loses to the M1 Thompson in caliber and ergonomics. A superior submachine gun range by 50 meters will not make a significant difference.

Edge: Irving Morrell

Secondary Tank: Mark II.V Barrel vs. Shamrock. Shamrock has the superior main armament, giving it my edge right off the bat.

Edge: Welkin Gunther

Main Tank: Mark III Barrel vs. Edelweiss Tank. The Mark III Barrel has superior main armament AND more machine guns. Top that, boyz.

Edge: Irving Morrel

Overall Winner: Irving Morrell

As many before me have stated, inferior infantry means nothing if you are the superior commander with a superior main tank. Those machine guns are gonna destroy Gunther's infantry before he gets a chance for his Lancers to destroy the tanks. Irving wins very slightly.