User blog comment:Facetheslayer/Joint Ops: Round 12: Hildeard Von Krone (Soul Calibur) vs. Eowyn (Lord of the Rings)/@comment-3239346-20110312043556

Bow vs. Spears? Obvious Edge to Eowyn

Sword or Spear and Short Sword? Well, two weapons is better than one... Edge to Hilde

However, the Long Range is the most important. If Eowyn can get kills before Hilde can get close enough to hit her with her melee weapons, it's game over. My vote goes to Eowyn and her long-ranged advantage.