User blog comment:MilitaryBrat/Richard Winters vs Jack Churchill/@comment-5195329-20120804041301

Pistol: The Hi-Power has more rounds, but the effective strength to the bigger 1911 rounds, I believe, will make it the more effective killer. EDGE-DICK.

Rifle: The Lee-Enfield has more rounds and one of the smoothest bolts out there. But the close 8 -rounds and semi-auto effect of the M1 will make it more killer in this battle. I'm not sure which round is more effective though. EDGE-DICK.

Close: The Bayonet allows both what you get from a bayonet, and more dagger/sword like qualities. So it has more reach and actually a bit of girth. Bayonet is also, probably, at lost less in the way. EDGE-DICK.

Explosive: I think the mills bomb is lighter and looks fatter, but I doubt much will be different. Either way. SLIGHT EDGE-JACK

Other: Well, the shovel serves more than one purpose, but I think the fighting purpose will be overlooked for the bayonet. While I'm not sure about the bow's effectivness, it has it's own thing so I think that will get it more kills, but only a little. SLIGHT EDGE-JACK

OVERALL: Winner - Richard Winters, his rifle and pistol are better, those being the two most important weapons by far, it gets him the win.