User blog comment:Weew1213/Arno Dorian vs Shay Cormac "AC Unity vs AC Rogue"/@comment-24831695-20150707113427/@comment-5043545-20150707143746

Personally, for my vote which I guess Elgb also wanted to format for his vote due to my own guess. Arno vs. Shay


 * Hidden Blade vs. Hidden Blade
 * Phantom Blade vs. Air Rifle
 * French Cutlass vs. Sword & Dagger
 * Flintlock vs. Dual Flintlocks
 * Heavy Axe vs. Ropedarts
 * Bombs vs. Smoke Bombs

Arno is not wielding or has the chance to wield any other weapons besides these. The Flintlocks used in this battle are single shot and pistols known to fire off several shots at once were notoriously inaccurate and dangerous to operate. Also, you're forgetting, Shay has killed Master Assassins himself. And created two revolutions and tore down an entire Assassin Order.