User blog comment:Tybaltcapulet/Geronimo vs Theodore Roosevelt/@comment-17814994-20181021144820/@comment-35680048-20181021154533

Sorry Elgb but I'm not counting this vote.

"However, Roosevelt has the perfect counter for this in the form of the cowboys and the scouts he has on his Rough Riders"

This is really stretching the limits of the simulation and Roosevelts' tactical ability here. This is literally Geronimo's homeland where he knows most of the land. With Roosevelt's prior experience are you really suggesting that he will be able to do this effectively? And you are also forgetting that a) Geronimo also has scouts and b) Roosevelt is getting ambushed. The "scouts" here will include every warrior in the battle.

"The only advantage that Geronimo had is in tactics and experience",

Those are probably the two most important things to have with two warriors sort of even in tech.

"But Theodore Roosevelt had better training and equipment at his side"

Equipment yes. Training, does it really matter? Both men don't have much formal training and what training Roosevelt does have is neagted by his overall lack of experience and horrid tactics.

"but it IS a gun chambered for smokeless gunpowder as opposed to the Peacemaker chambered for blackpowder."

This whole Smokeless vs Blackpoweder thing is only really relevant when talking about long term maintenence as both will work just fine in this SKIRMISH.

Honestly I don't think you read the scenario right, and I believe you are using incorrect and incomplete knowledge of the warriors and the battle. And you have some spelliing mistakes to boot so unfortunately this will not count. Read the battle and the situation clearly before you try pull an EA or Leo vote turn. I'msure they wouldn't appreciate it.

Wishing you a nice day, Tybaltcapulet