User blog comment:BeastMan14/As A Galaxy Burns... The Reapers vs The Empire!/@comment-5138827-20121205042331

General: Darth Vade is the better general by far, having led armies and led armies successfully for about 20 years at this point (counting E.U.). Saren's only major battle was a miserable failure. In terms of 1 vs 1, Vader and his force would prevail. Edge Star Wars.

Cannon Fodder: This is a suprisingly good battle however if we factor in E.U. or even T.V. series. The Geth are pretty good, however I certainly don't feel they are as good as what the Reapers had in M.E. 2 or 3. Their guns lack in range, and the greater weapon options give Star Wars the edge. Edge Star Wars

Mobile Weapons: alright I am going with the reapers here, they can take a ton of damage and much more then the Imperial Walker.

Space: http://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/eclipse-star-destroyer-battle-group-vs-reapers.238304/ Good reasoning on why I don't like the Reapers chances in space. People make the reapers out to be the big bad wolf and all and they forget that Reapers only have the ease in which they conquer the galaxy because they LIMIT the races tech. They do NOT let the organics expand to somewhere beyond a certain point and even then have extreme difficulties in taking them out ( Prothean conquest took 150 years, modern invasion fleet took a great deal of causialties). Star Wars races have expanded far past the Rapers threshold, and wield gigatons whereas Reapers wield Kilotons. Mass Effect is considered a low-teir Sci-fi universe (above non-forruner halo ) while Star Wars is mid teir (below 40k).

OVerall : Space carries the day. the Empire wins