User blog comment:El Alamein/Miller's Squad vs. Roebuck's Squad/@comment-5465602-20150323145005

BeastMan14's "Was I A Good Man?" Edges

Miller vs Roebuck: Miller's Squad. Not only is Miller packing better/more versatile weapons, he's also a more respected and accomplished leader. While it is true that Miller is wielding dangerous explosives that could easily blow up in his face (literally), he'll be able to better lead his troops through the battle than Roebuck.

Horvath vs Miller: Roebuck's Squad. Horvath may have more damaging and precise weapons, like his bazooka, he doesn't quite have the experience or the versatility of Miller, who in classic COD tradition, carried his entire team through conflict, meaning that he'll be a second rallying point for the team, enabling him to overcome the greater weapons of Horvath. In a classic theme, leadership/versatility>weapons.

Jackson vs Polonsky: Miller's Squad. Daniel Jackson is, without question, the most devastating soldier in Miller's squad. His sniper rifle enables him to easily outranges Polonsky and bring him down from a distance, and then take out other members of Roebuck's crew from a distance. This isn't even close. FUN FACT: My friend actually got confused about Jackson's death, and asked why he didn't just shoot down the barrel of the tank.

Mellish vs Sullivan: Miller's Squad. While Sullivan is also a capable and intelligent leader, he's simply outgunned by Mellish. Mellish is wielding a wider variety of devastating ranged weapons, like his M1 Garand, meaning that for all his leadership, Sullivan won't hold during the gunfight.

Reiban vs Rooker: Miller's Squad. The two have similar skills, but Reiban's Browning easily beats Rooker's Thompson, so that's another good firearm edge.

Deadliest Squad: Miller's Squad. Ultimately, Roebuck's team can't hold up against Miller's squad, who is better equipped with a better leader and weapons. Roebuck's crew may have the experience, but without teamwork and leadership to back it up, they won't hold up. Final Score: 600-400