User blog comment:WanderingSkull/Jack vs. Frank West/@comment-11048590-20120918015921

THE DOCTOR'S DIAGNOSIS:

Close: I'll split this into two sub divisions, Melee and Pistol, then see who has the best overall.


 * Melee- Frank West. The Baseball Bat, easily. It deals powerful blunt damage, especially in the hands of the legendary Frank West. The Chainsaw will only make noise, slow Jack down, and will only be able to land of slow, but somewhat powerful Attacks that Frank can dodge. Though Frank gets this overall for his faster and more Simpler Bat.


 * Pistols- Even. The M1911 fires a superior .45 ACP round compared to the mere 9mm that the G17 fires. Both guns have about the same amount of range, so even in that department. The M1911, as brought up, also has superior stopping power. The M1911 only packs a 7 round magazine, and the G17 a 17 round mag, I will have to make it even because of this, the more shots Jack could land off the better, aside from that the M1911 is a better gun.


 * Overall Close-Frank West. He dominates close range, easily. He brings in a superior Melee weapon and damn good Handgun to boot, giving him the edge in close ranged weaponry.

Mid: Again, Sub-divisions. Shotgun and SMG.


 * Shotguns-Even. So Both of these weapons are firing the iconic and common 12 Gauge, Both Pump action. The Remington holds 3 to 8 rounds, the Mossberg 5 to 8, but I'd still call it even in this department because both can hold up to 8. Both these guns are essentially even in my opinion.


 * SMGs-I will get back to this one...


 * Overall Mid-TBD.

i'll finish later.