User blog comment:LB&SCR/GWM Episode 4: John Jellicoe vs. Alekxander Kolchak/@comment-17814994-20181217134746

Elgb's '"Naval Warfare is SOOOOO UNDERRATED!!!" 'EDGES!!!

Battleship: Yep the Iron Duke no doubt. That thing ahs the bigger and deadlier main gun, more batteries in its deck, the thicker armor and slightly faster ship. The Imperartrista's no match for it overall. EDGE: Jellicoe

Cruiser #1: This is a bit of a toughie. The HMS Duke can fire the bigger bang and has the tougher belt armor, but the Pamiat has more guns and a thicker deck armor in store for her. In the end, I'll be going to what Tybalt believed, in that having the DOE's weak deck armor is to kill her. EDGE: Kolchak

Cruiser #2: In terms of arnaments the Calliope has more weapons in store for her but the Prut has the advantage in having a bigger guns. The Calliope has the faster speed but this is negated by the fact that it is vulnerable to bioler fires, which means that the sailors would have to take it easy on her or else. I can't say much for the Prut's armor by picture alone, but who knows? EDGE: Kolchak

Escorts (No, not that kind of escorts): Yeah the Russians small boats takes it easily. They got more guns with the bigger caliber, a faster speed and probably a thicker armor. The British escorts has very thin armor together with such smaller guns that they wont's stand a chance. Not even outrunning the Russian ships would save them. EDGE: Kolchak

Deadliest Warrior?

Both warriors were great ship captains/admirals but it seems that Alexander Kolchak is by far superior to John Jellicoe in almsot everyway. There is only one battle that really defined Jellicoe compared to the countless amounts of shit Kolchak has to go through. Sure the Jutland Battle was a bloody affair, but Kolchak fought in the Ruso-Japanese War, WWI against both the Germans AND the Turks, and the dude even had to stand alone as a commander against the Soviets. These feats take more intellect, tactics and resourcest than whatever Jellicoe has accomplished. This and couple with the fact that Alexander Kolchak has the better warships in store and its a complete wipeout for the Gentleman Admiral.