User blog comment:Wassboss/ The Rook (The Warren Comic Magazine Eerie) vs John Carter of Mars (The Basoom series)/@comment-143604-20110809010104

Drayco90's Edgey Edges from the Edge of Edgeness (We were first TDW):
 * Close Range- John Carter of Mars. Carter's bringing a sword to a knife fight, better range and better damage.
 * Mid-Range- Tie. I don't know enough to give one gun an edge over the other, and they seem relativly similar in design. So...yeah.
 * Long Range- The Rook. A black powder rifle is not going to come even close to the power of the legendary Sharps' Carbine. The carbine alone could easily make this battle, and can tear Carter apart anywhere.
 * Special Weapon- The Rook. The Laser Pistol is a Laser Pistol. I really don't see the need to go further into this.
 * The Deadliest Warrior- The Rook. While I like John Carter of Mars more, the Rook's much better weapons will win him the day.