User blog comment:Pygmy Hippo 2/Miyamoto Musashi vs. Andrew Jackson (Collab with Elgb333)/@comment-11361577-20190130215103

'Appelmonkey's "It's Time to D-D-D-D-Duel!" Edges'

Wakizashi vs. I. Wilson Knife: Yeah, while the I. Wilson knife is made out of stronger metal, the wakizashi is simply longer and also meant as a weapon, while the Wilson knife is just meant to skin animals. Edge: Miyamoto Musashi

Katana vs. Model 1812 Officer's Sword: Like we said many times before on this wiki, Japanese steel is shit compared to other steel so the Model 1812 has an edge there. Furthermore, its also longer and the guard gives Jackson some additional protection. Edge: Andrew Jackson

Shuriken vs. Dueling Pistol: Shurikens are kinda shit, not gonna lie. They are meant to be distraction, not weapons. While they can kill if they hit a major artery or are covered in poison or dung. The flintlock pistol isn't that great either, but it has more range and while it is inaccurate, in the hands of a skilled dueler such as Jackson this is hardly an issue. Edge: Andrew Jackson

Bokken vs. Walking Cane: The bokken gets this if only because it resembles an actual weapon more than the cane does. Edge: Miyamoto Musashi

Deadliest Dueller: Miyamoto Musashi! Not gonna lie this is close as fuck, but ultimately I am going to give it to Miyamoto. While Jackson does snatch the sword edge, Miyamoto is simply fitter and a better sword fighter than Jackson and since this is mostly a melee battle this will be really, really important. Miyamoto's tactics also play straight into Jackson personality, since he already is a hot head it will be really easy to piss him off. Miyamoto will struggle against the gun though, as soon as Jackson takes aim our lovable samurai will be done for. But all in all I see Miyamoto Musashi winning this fight.