User blog comment:Deathblade 100/Game of Thrones Season 6 release: Gregor Clegane (Game of Thrones) vs Horace Altman (Ranger's Apprentice)/@comment-3189283-20160427090759

Let's see shall we

Primary

The Greatsword has the far superior reach and is much heavier, meaning the strength behind the blows are doing to do some serious damage even if it doesn't penetrate the chainmail armour Horace is wearing. I do respect that Horace is the far superior swordsman if he can't get close enough to press that advantage then it he can't use it to his benefit.

Edge: Gregor Clegane

Secondary

The Buckler gives Horace a bit more protection against Gregor's Greatsword but it still won't help that much as the sheer force behind the blows could break his arm even through the shield. Gregor's brute strength is certainly a psychological advantage but he has to get pretty close to use it which is not a good idea against a skilled swordsman such as Horace.

Edge: Even

Armour

Gregor's heavy plate armour makes him into a walking tank and makes him immune to basically all melee weapons including the Longsword which Horace is bringing. The Chainmail is significantly lighter and allows for better movement but it won't help much against Gregor's Longsword.

Edge: Gregor Clegane

Personal X Factor

TBC