User blog comment:Cfp3157/Indiana Jones vs. Chuck Greene/@comment-4661256-20131122033938

El Alamein's "Oh... I'm voting again, yay" Edges:

 Iconic Weapons: Bullwhip vs. Paddlesaw:  Look, I understand that Indy is skilled with his bullwhip, and that it does all sorts of crazy stuff like defy physics itself by supporting a grown man's body weight as he swings over a chasm, but ... still. That paddlesaw is an actually deadly (if improvised) weapon. That being said, it is cumbersome, noisy, and heavy, and mostly good against undead zombies. Indy's proven himself able to take on other foes armed with superior weaponry and defeat them with the whip. I guess... I guess I'll go with the less lethal weapon here, even though I really don't want to... because, y'know, it's less lethal.

Edge: Indiana Jones

 Fighting Style: Improvised vs. Untrained:  Easy edge for Indy - at least he has a fighting style to boast of. Going hand-to-hand with zombies is a little dumb if there's a lot of them and no contest if it's one or two - so Chuck won't really have experience in the grapple-n-throw department like Indy does

Edge: Indiana Jones

 Melee: Machete vs. Anything:  Well, anything is quite subjective - it could be a vastly superior weapon to the machete like a katana, it could be a somewhat comparable weapon like a baseball bat, or it could be pathetically inferior weapon like a trash can lid. This is entirely situational, and I give a situational edge to Indy for having the constant in this equation that proves he has a weapon he's good with and a weapon he's sticking with.

Edge: Indiana Jones

 Firearms: Revolver vs. Semi:  Although Chuck Greene's weapon is semi-auto and can reload easier, he has no ammo with which to reload, which kind of negates that advantage. Edge to Indy for a logistical advantage.

Edge: Indiana Jones

 Explosive: An Actual Weapon vs. What:  Well, the BlamBow sounds pretty dangerous for the user as well as for the *intended* target. The RPG can be aimed and reloaded with greater accuracy, range, explosive payback, and most importantly, reliability.

Edge: Indiana Jones

WINNER: INDIANA JONES

Well the outcome's pretty obvious here folks. Chuck Greene is a jack of all trades, but on the flip side he's master of none. Indy is well-rounded but specializes in close-quarters combat, and he's bringing in an arsenal of weapons he's used since his first experiences with combat. The whip, machete, and revolver are second-nature to him, and his more expansive battle experience will only help him utilize his superior weapons more intelligently in the fight. Chuck Greene is simply outclassed as a warrior here.