User blog comment:GSFB/Rephaim Giants vs Sumerian Wild Ass Chariots/@comment-5795750-20121230011337

BG1's "Call of Gilgamesh: Assyrian Warfare" Edges:

Short: Despite the fact that the Giants will be using very large versions of the Sumerians' weapons, I reckon that with enough speed and aggression, the Sumerians would be able to dodge and return fire with their weapons... if the Giants don't squash them first; and I reckon that with their giant weapons, the Giants may cause an earthly tremor of some kind

EDGE: Sumerians

Medium: Ditto

EDGE: Sumerians

Long: While a bow and arrow has greater ammunition than a javelin, I reckon that at long range, the javelin may be able to mow down several chariots in one throw; that said, the Sumerians may be able to disable a giant should they be able to use enough arrows to injure the Giant's legs and feet

EDGE: Even

Overall Winner: Sumerian War Chariots - essentially this is like the battle between David and Goliath and we know what happened in that story... if you want clarification on what I mean, I meant that the Sumerian war chariots are fast and agile which means that they would be able to disable the giant from a safe distance (ie they can outrun the giant) before going in for the kill.