User blog comment:Leolab/User Siege Tourney, Round 9 of 91: Swg66 (Cadwalader) v Redkite (Markus)/@comment-24180428-20130422013736

Utter noob's "This vote is longer then the seige" edges

Generals

Long range-The metal bow has more durability, but poison arrows insure a kill if it hits an unarmored area. Edge Swg

Polearm-The axe is 3 weapons in one. Do you want 3 weapons or 1 weapon? Edge Swg

Main-Longswords are longer then shortswords and keep in mind the longsword's shield. Edge Swg

Off hand-1 shield vs 2 shields that are also actual weapons (sword and hammer). Edge Swg

X-factors-They are neck and neck and have the same average. Edge Even

Deadliest general-Swg has the better weapons, which will carry the day in a one on one battle; however this is a siege. Sieges require armies.

Armies

Kite's army possess more archers however Swg's army has more siege weapons. Kite's army however lacks cavalry, but thanks to his pikemen he can defend himself against a charge. Considering the pikemen being twice the size I would imagine they could defeat the cavalry with ease. But due to the sheer number of siege weaponry I don't think Kite's army could hold the location with the sappers, cannons, etc harassing the walls. Edge Swg

Winner-Swg's army is better suited for the siege thanks to the larger amount of siege weaponry, the general's superior weapons in a  general vs general, and better organaztion.