User blog comment:LB&SCR/Combat-Happy Joes and Amphibians: Easy Company vs. Roebuck's Squad/@comment-3189283-20160325195108

Let's see shall we

Sergent Rock vs Sergent Rock  

In terms of weaponry, I have to call it even. Their respective primary weapons have their own set of advantages and disadvantages with the Brownings greater accuracy and bigger punch being cancelled out by the Thompson's greater manoeuvrability and faster rate of fire and Roebuck's machete reach and lethality being cancelled out by the fact that Rock is a much more able close quarters fighter. However weapons are irrelevant anyway as it's not the weapons that decides this battle but the people behind it and in that respect Rock has the clear and decisive advantage. His men would willingly and without second thought give their lives up to serve him and while Roebuck has the loyalty of his men as well it's nowhere near the same level.

Edge: Easy Company 

Bulldozer vs Miller 

This is a much more difficult choice than the last one. Bulldozer clearly has the advantage in terms of manoeuvrability as the Browning M1919 is basically static and if he can get close enough to Miller then he only has his pistol to defend himself and that won't do a fat lot of good against an LMG. However the M1919 has a much further effective range and a larger ammo count to boot which allows Miller to keep up concentrated fire to stop Easy Company from making any advances and Bulldozer himself is a pretty big target to hit. In the one on one Bulldozer probably wins out if he can close the distance but Miller is more useful to the group as a whole so I'm going to call it even.

Edge: Even 

TBC