User blog comment:WanderingSkull/The Road Less Traveled: Doomguy vs. Master Chief/@comment-4098900-20140727224109

Hawk's Hawk-Eyed Edges:


 * Melee: Doomguy is plain faster and stronger than MC and if Chief didn't have energy shields should be able to beat him. However Chief's shields make it a lot harder to hurt him with his meele weapon.  Overall I feel like melee weapons really aren't going to help here, but if Doomguy can somehow get Chief's shields down he can win a melee.

Edge: Doomguy

Sidearm: Thing I like about Doom's pistol is that while it's a 9mm it's got a 50 round mag so he can basically just keep spamming bullets at MC. Now the magnum does have bigger bullets, but an only 8 round mag. Chief can take cover and reload,  and if there is none his energy shields should help, especially if he makes himself a harder target to hit. I'm kind of drawn on this one, so I'll just call it even.

Edge: Even

Shotgun: Well it seems to me like we're comparing an old 50s shotgun to a shotgun from 500 years in the future. We don't have a lot information to compare the M90 to Doom's, but it seems to work really well on monsters and aliens so like Jeffery said I'll just give it the benefit of the doubt and call it even.

Edge: Even

Automatic: Doomguy gets a nice advantage here, and it might be one of his most effective weapons against Chief. Sure it's 9mm, but he can just hold down that trigger and keep hitting him until his shields are down and then once they're down he'll quickly hit him in the gut where he has no armor protecting him. Doom's strength also makes it easy for him to wield this giant gun. The MA5C doesn't nearly get this advantage

Edge: Doom (by far)

Uberweapon: Given Doom's speed and size, I don't think Chief could very easily hit him with the Spartan Laser as it's largely an anti-vehicle weapon, at close range tha charge time will leave Chief vulnerable to a counter attack. On the other hand the BFG9000 would be very hard for MC to do anything about at close range, and not easy to avoid at long either. No cover's going to help him with that thing and he can't really dodge it, that thing should also take down his shields in a heartbeat and can then be fired again.

Edge: Doom (by quite a bit as well)

TBF tonight