User blog comment:Guitarcar/Sheriff Hoyt vs Gunnery sergeant Hartman/@comment-35680048-20180908200703

Tybaltcapulet's" DROP YOUR COCKS AND GRAB YOUR SOCKS" Edges:

Melee: The baton is only really slightly longer than the KA-BAR and will be much less lethal. Like 99% of the time the blade will always beat the freaking stick...Edge: Hartman

Sidearm: Whether Hoyt is using the Vaqeuro or the M1911, he will still lose to Hartman here.

a) If he is using the M1911, Hartman's better training  will make it easier to aim and use against Hoyt.

b) If he is using the Vaquero he still loses because even though the Vaquero is stronger, it is overall a slower weapon and it has less rounds. And being the handcannon it is, it will be harder to aim as well.

Edge: Hartman

Primary: The shotgun is good for one thing only. Close range and basically nothing else. The M14 on the other hand can be used at long,medium and close range making it the better overall weapon. And the Model 1912 is exceedingly outdated anyways by its ammunition range and almost everything else. The M14 has been around for a lot longer because of its reliability, range and power that annihilates the Model 1912.MAJOR EDGE: Hartman

X-Factors: I would really have to disagree with you on experience here. I'm not scoffing at Hoyt's "police" career and his experience in Korea, but when most of your "career" is spent chasing hippies, that doesn't really compare with Hartman's experience at Iwo Jima and the training of new U.S.M.C recruits. And Hartman is also a more trained individual, making him more suited to battle. And for cunning and intellect? Hoyt is crafty but again this is against hippies, young adults who have never heard a shot fired in anger in their lives. Hartman is a trained soldier who   Speed really doesn't matter to me as there is isn't a massive difference here. Overall  in my opinion Hartman has clinched the neccessary x-factors of Experience and Training which discount almost everything else.Edge: Hartman

Overall: Officer Hoyt must have a major malfunction here because he just lost to Gunnery Sergeant Hartman. Yes Hoyt may be more physically fit than Hartman in some areas but he trumped almost everywhere else. His baton is much weaker than the KA-BAR. Whichever pistol is actually used in this fight for Hoyt will also be worse due to Hartman's better training and experience. The M14 will absolutely destroy the Model 1912 at all ranges and will be more reliable in general. And as for the warriors themselves? I believe Hartman is the better trained, more experience, equally intelligent and an overall better warrior than Hoyt who spends most of his time chasing after "Hippies".Winner: Gunnery Sergeant Hartman

Hartman: 3500

Hoyt:1500