User blog comment:Thornclaw Braveheart/Witch-king of Angmar vs. Eragon Bromsson/@comment-422690-20111129164705

Close range: Flail wins. Marty Stu's Eragon's knife is pretty much worthless here. The Witch King's flail is massive and will crush all opposition. Edge: Witch King.

Mid range: Draw. They're both flaming longswords. Edge: even

Magic 1: Telekinesis wins. The screech is useful, but telekinesis gives more kills. Edge: Marty Stu Eragon

Magic 2: Black Breath wins. See reasoning for #1, just flipped. Edge: Witch King.

Magic 3: Black Shadow wins. Telepathically challenging a being as powerful as the Witch King is tantamount to suicide. The disease kills not only the psyche but the body, sapping both Marty Stu's Eragon's life and his will to live. Edge: Witch King.

Mount: Saphira wins. Marty Stu's Eragon's dragon slave partner, Saphira, is more intelligent than the Fell Beast. Edge: Marty Stu Eragon.

Special: Morgul Knife wins. The bow won't do too much against the Witch King, but the dagger will kill with a cut. Edge: Witch King.

X-Factors: Marty Stu Eragon wins. His average of 85.8 is ever so slightly higher than the Witch King's 85.

Overall: The Witch King wins. He's better equipped for both a quick fight and a drawn-out one, and he's a better warrior overall.