User blog comment:Cfp3157/Halloween Special: The Headless Horseman vs. Jason Voorhees!/@comment-24180428-20131102021947

Utter noob's "Lets see who will pull ahead!" edges:

Weapon-This goes to Death. The Machete may have a larger cutting surface, however the Hessian Axe was made specifically for combat. The burn/fire effect and weapons training is just icing to the cake. Edge Death

Advantages-I can only think of two opponents for Jason that were true challenges: some psychic girl and Freddy Krueger. The fact that he survived both these encounters (and won the latter) is very impressive. Whilst Death is by no means a slouch, Crane isn't on par with Freddy. Because of that, Jason may be better off at facing a foe like himself. His biggest issue however is his lack of training. Had Jason possessed a form of training, his fight with Freddy would've been much easier. And that training is a huge advantage. A even better advantage: Death is far more difficult to kill. Edge Death

Weakness-Death may not have been as active as Jason, however Jason only fought two notable opponents. Now even though Death isn't the smartest warrior, he has no psychological issues like Jason, who is retarded. Finally, Jason can be killed in more ways than Death. Edge Death

Winner-Death takes this. He simply is simply a better warrior. More advantages, less disadvantages.