User blog comment:WraithOfWaffle/Battle Eight: Carnegie (The Book of Eli) vs. The Governor (AMC's The Walking Dead)/@comment-5078776-20140216005354

CFP3157 EDGES OF MASSIVE DESTRUCTION: "Who needs braille when you can wear an eyepatch?"

Simply put, the Bowie Knife is both a superior weapon and wielded by a superior warrior. Oops, spoiled the ending. Anyway, the Bowie is actually designed for combat, and is capable of delivering brutal hacks and thrusts. The machete has a slight range advantage, but not to the point where it's game changing. Even up close in a fist fight, the Governor is a vastly superior fighter with a more powerful physique.
 * Melee: The Guvnah

With a marginally superior muzzle velocity, and his larger ammo count, the Governor narrowly takes this edge.
 * Pistol: The Guvnah

The 9mm may not pack the power the .45 Colt, but the fact it has nearly triple ammo count lets Carnegie lay down some suppressing fire upon the Governor and his forces.
 * Handgun: Carnegie

The UTAS shotgun has a quicker reload, with a fast and efficient system that will be a tactical godsend in this battle. Add the ammo package the UTAS has over the Mossberg, and the classic Mossberg is getting put on the shelf for a newer piece of tech.
 * Shotgun: The Guvnah


 * Assault Rifle: TBA
 * Battle Rifle: TBA
 * Explosive: TBA
 * Heavy Gun: TBA
 * X-Factors: TBA
 * Winner: TBA