User blog comment:Wassboss/Season Finale: Solid Snake vs Gordon Freeman/@comment-5338740-20120527181422

THE DOCTOR'S DIAGNOSIS OF CARNAGE:

Melee: Eeeeeeh, Tough one honestly. The Knife is made for combat, but to be honest....it's kind of a crap knife. The CQC will not leave a dent in Gordon's HEV Suit. The Crowbar is heavier, sure, but with a good swing it can leave Snake bruised and battered. Add on the fact that it has more range and it gets the edge. EDGE: GORDON FREEMAN

Handgun: The Colt Python is firing a much larger round here, and with ore power behind it. But the Five-seven has 10 to 20 bullets in each magazine, and thats a lot copared to the 6 bulelts your getting with the Python. The Python also delivers a tad bit more range. With all these factors put together I'm making it a tie. EDGE: EVEN

Shotgun: K, both of these guns are firing the same gauge. But the Saiga has 10 shells per magazine, while the SPAS-12 can hold 9 shells. It's kinda hard to give an edge on this, not good with shotties. EDGE: EVEN

SMG: Both of these guns have the same sized magazine of 30. The MP5 does have more range and fires a larger round of 10mm Auto compared to the MAC-10's 9x19mm. So, the MP5 gets this edge easily thanks to it's power, range, and the larger round it's firing. EDGE: GORDON FREEMAN

I will finish my vote later