User blog comment:WraithOfWaffle/Battle Six: The PMC (Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3) vs. Merryweather Security (Grand Theft Auto V)/@comment-5795750-20140106005943

BG1's "Does Security Have to be THIS Tight?" Edges:

Melee - Knife vs baton, eh? Well in all fairness while the nightstick is longer than the Tatang in direct combat, I have to give the edge to the Tatang since as a knife it can actually kill a lot faster (since puncture wounds > blunt trauma) and it can also be thrown (it does have a curved handle) thus making it versatile

EDGE: PMC

Short - On this Wiki there is always a general rule of thumb when it comes to comparisons involving the Deagle: the Deagle more than often loses out since it has a very high recoil attached to it and only very high levels of training and marksmanship can cancel that defect out (a smaller round also helps since i hear that using a .45 caliber has less recoil) but since I don't see that here the edge automatically goes to the easier-to-fire gun

EDGE: Merryweather

Medium - Even though its modified, the edge goes to the MP5A3 since it can fire faster and further than the UMP45

EDGE: Merryweather

Long - I have to give the edge to the G36C since it can fire deadlier rounds at a reasonably fast rate and from a longer distance; who cares if the HK416 has parts from the G36?

EDGE: PMC

Explosive - The edge here clearly goes to the Semtex in that it can be molded into any shape, can be stuck anywhere and can either have a time-rigged detonation system or be remotely detonated; the grenade is nice since it has that large explosive radius but it also has a tendency to roll away after it lands and god knows where it ends up

EDGE: PMC

Special - The stun grenade is more useful in dealing damage to enemies than the taser; sure the taser can be lethal but that is rare and it can only take out one person at a time but the stun grenade on the other hand can blind more people than that (even if the PMC accidentally blind themselves but hey, at least Merryweather won't be able to shoot despite the fact the PMC if blinded can't shoot either)

EDGE: PMC

X-Factors: I don't even need to go into the numbers to tell you who gets the edge here

EDGE: PMC

Overall Winner: The PMC by far have this match in the bag - despite the two training regimes to be equal, the PMC have operated on a global scale as a counterterrorist-like spec-ops team while Merryweather are nothing more than a private police force working in Los Santos; and heck the reason why Merryweather lose so badly is because if they can't catch a lowlife thief in Los Santos, what chance do they have against equally-trained and more experienced people like the PMC (who have faced off against the Spetsnaz, I might add)?