User blog comment:Sidekickman/Aztec Eagle vs Mapuche Warrior/@comment-190.190.88.121-20120114023747

Lets see. At long range the Atlatl and Tlacochtli is not very accurate and the Bow and Arrow will not pierce the Ichcahuipilli armor. The sling is hard to aim and the bolas are not deadly enough, except on a head shot, and the wood helmet would protect the Aztec. Which means that the battle will be defined by close range fighting. The Mapuche has the edge on the Toqui, and the Aztec on the Maquahuitl. However, the armor of the Aztec will be useless against the Mace, both helmet and armor. The Maquahuitl is more deadly than the mace, but the Maquahuitl is a two handed weapon, and if the Aztec misses, he will be exposed. The Mace however can be handled with just one hand, and therefore is more likely to strike the Aztec.

My vote is for the Mapuche Warrior.