User blog comment:Appelmonkey/Anime Season, Epsiode 5 Superheros/Saitama (One Punch Man) vs. Superman (DC Comics)/@comment-3189283-20160216181423

Lets see shall we

I mean looking at the powers side of thing it's clear who has the more versatile set of abilities. Superman not only has the innate abilities such as superhuman strength, speed and durability but his flight, super-breath and heat vision give him a lot more options in combat than Saitama. That being said though Saitama doesn't need a bunch of fancy powers because he hits hard and absorbs damage like a sponge so I don't really know what superman can do to really hurt him. Superman is clearly the more tactically minded of the two but that's mainly because he actually has to use his intelligence to take down his opponents whereas Saitama just has to well, One Punch them. The factor that this all comes down to is can Saitama's One Punch one shot Superman who I doubt will know about his legendary status and especially if Saitama is holding back as it will mean he won't be expecting a punch of such magnitude.

This is a tough one but I'm going to go with Superman for a couple of reasons. Firstly is that while their speed is roughly comparable, Superman does have the advantage of flight which will make it hard for Saitima to get close enough to utalise his One Punch. Secondly is that his super-breath and heat vision do allow him to stay away from Saitima and whittle him down until he can figure out a way to hurt him. Saitima is also restricted to one approach, punching hard, and if his One Punch doesn't flat out wreck superman then he has no other options whereas Superman at least has a couple of different ways to do some damage. Finally, and I do think this is the most important thing, this battle is not a fight to the death and therefore both are going to be holding back. With this in mind it means that Saitima's whole persona and main ability (the One Punch) is basically out he window as he isn't going to try and one shot Superman as he doesn't want to kill him. This puts him at a massive disadvantage and one Superman will be able to take advantage of.

Superman: 2,800

Saitima: 2,200