User blog comment:Cfp3157/Percy Jackson vs. Harry Potter/@comment-24180428-20131103003408

Utter noob's "Harry is such a terrible opponent. Now Voldemort on the other hand..." edges:

Weapon-Riptide all the way. The wand is wood. One slice from Riptide and Harry wont be casting any spells. No spells and Harry is nothing. Even without Riptide, Percy can still rely on his other abilities. Edge Percy

Abilities-Harry has a greater varity, however take away the wand and all those nice abilities are gone. Percy can lose Riptide and still have access to his abilities. All Percy needs to do is stay near the lake in Hogwarts, gain his Water-God-like powers and Harry is done for. Edge Percy

Ride-Clearly Blackjack is superior. Although weirder (part horse), Blackjack is faster and, if the two collided, would easily destroy the Firebolt. Edge Percy

Winner-Percy. Now Riptide wont kill Harry, due to being celestial bronze, however it can still cut Harry's wand to pieces. Without his wand, Harry has no magic. Without his magic, Harry is nothing. Percy just has to lure Harry to the lake and get rid of his wand.