User blog comment:Mikeylango/John Marston vs. Niko Bellic/@comment-6389069-20130322235050

This is my vote. I will pick each teams edges for each categories.

Long Weapons: I believe that Niko BEllic's team has an obvious advantage here. Assault rifles versus Lever action rifles? Take a guess. Edge-Niko's Team.

Side-arms: I believe that John Marston's team has an advantage, because all of their revolvers and the volcanic handgun are the 1910's equivalent of today's high powered or magnum pistols. Plus they can fire as fast as they pull the trigger. Edge-John's team.

Skill: Although Niko has had army training and a reputation for good gun skills, he's the only fighter on his team with this advantage; the rest of his haven't had professional training. Everyone on John's team, on the other hand, are all superbly trained gunslingers, and can probably use a lot of weapons handed to them. John and Landon also have deadeye, and John, Jack and Uncle managed to wipe out a whole army regiment. Edge-john's team.

Historical advantages: While people on Niko's team may have learned about weapons used during the era that red dead redemption is set in, people on John's team will probably have no clue what weapons Niko team are using. Edge- Niko's team.

Now I will make comparisons of the additional weapons that some people have on each team.

Combat knife vs. Bowie knife. When fighting people with a combat knife, Niko has to stab them many times over and over, and they will often still get up or crawl away. When fighting with a Bowie knife, John can slash at them twice and they will be down for good. But Niko can stab people much faster than John can slash them. Edge-tie

RPG vs. Explosive rifle: while the RPG may look new and threatening to John's team, the explosive rifle will just look like any other rifle to Niko's team, so they may underestimate its power. The explosive rifle is faster to reload, fires a faster travelling projectile, and can literally 'pop' a person. Edge-John's team.

Overall winner: John Marston