User blog comment:Geekboy27/Season 2 Premiere: Booker Dewitt vs Tank Dempsey/@comment-5078776-20131120021431

CFP3157'S EDGES OF MASSIVE DESTRUCTION: "Cfp3157'! Kicking ass and playing Bioshock since 1945!' 

Melee: Tank Dempsey

While the Skyhook is a far more devastating weapon, it's clunky and heavy compared to the versatile and light Bowie knife. The Bowie can slice and thrust, and tears through flesh just as easily as the Skyhook.

Pistol: Booker DeWitt 

The Broadsider is a handgun that fires at a faster rate of fire than the Colt, along with the higher rate of fire.

TBF