User blog comment:Leolab/User Siege Tourney, Round 25 of 63: Cfp3157 (Shengway) v MilitaryBrat (Evans)/@comment-422690-20130819181011

So...

Attacker

Overrun: Likely. Even though all Shengway has are belfries and the Elephant cannon, Evans has no crew for his countermeasures.

Force Surrender: Possible. Evans has a higher loyalty score by far, but his men are so underequipped that morale will plummet anyway.

Single Combat: Victory. See below.

Defender

Annihilate Attacker: Not likely. He's got nothing to attack Shengway with. And even if Shegway gets into the castle, 1,500 of his men - that's 1/5th of his entire army - has only spiked balls for weapons. This is what you get for not reading the entrance blog and being too lazy to add one word. "Eighth, and most importantly, BE DETAILED. For example, if you simply say "Morning Star", it will be assumed that the people having it are wielding a simple spiked ball."

- The entrance blog

Force Surrender: Not likely. Shengway's got the lower loyalty score, but he has an army with actual fucking equipment.

Survive for 4 months: Nope. Remember that lack of equipment I stated earlier? This battle's going to end in a month.

Single Combat: Loss. See below.

Tie:

Die and succeed: Possible, but not likely. Shengway does have that low loyalty score, after all.

Both die: Possible, but not likely. Shengway may die, Evans may die.

Single Combat

Ranged: Tie. They're both bows...

Polearm: Alabarda wins. In this case, the "ZOMG KOOL WEPENZ" is simply the more effective option, due to its versatility.

Melee: Gladius and Aspis wins. Evans can flail about with that one-handed grip on his claymore all he wants. Shengway can just run up and stab him.

Single Combat Edge: Shengway wins. Both users went with "ZOMG KOOL WEPENZ" when choosing their arsenal, but Shengway is at least not trying to use a claymore in one hand.

Overall

Attacker: 3

Defender: 0

Tie: 2

Shengway wins.