User blog comment:El Alamein/The Malmedy Survivors vs. Hiroo Onoda/@comment-5223481-20120731234936

J80's Edges

Close Range: Both of these bayonets have the same killing potential and reliablity, so it's a draw. Even

Mid Range: Another draw between these two weapons. The shin gunto has a longer reach and a much larger killing potential. While the knife is small, agile, and can be used for swift counter attacks. Even

Long Range: Between these two pistols, I'm gonna have to give it to the Colt M1911 for its power and a larger caliber bullet than the Nambu. Edge Malmedy Survivors.

X-Factors: Now in terms of X-Factors, this is how I'll break it down.

Malmedy Survivors / Onada 

80 Logisitics 75

81 Stealth 89

90 Experience 88

86 Endurance 80

87 Fatigue 82

83 Calm Under Fire 87 

84 Discipline/Extremism 95

Deadliest Warrior: Malemdy Survivors. Sure Onada kept hidden for 30 years, but it was against police and other local authorites. The Survivors on the other hand managed to make it back to allied lined facing a much larger ans superior enemy.