User blog comment:Pygmy Hippo 2/Apache Warriors vs. New Kingdom Egyptian Soldiers/@comment-28716800-20190729041552

For unspecified reasons Fandom yet again does not allow me to edit my previous comment. Therefore the second half of my vote is posted in a seperate comment.

Long Range:As mentioned by Laq below, neither of the weapons will be particularly helpful due to the setting being in a town.And since I suppose both of the warriros featured here are good archer I believe neither of them will gain an upper hand in a duel of bows purely judging from their skills. However, the fact that the apache arrows have their heads rubbed with various nasty liquid will greatly upgrade the lethality of his weapon. Edge:Apache 

Special:Both are blunt weapons and I can't really see any of them landing a fatal strike.As mentioned by users below, both weapons have their wins and faults that basically render it even. Edge:Even

Overall:New Kingdom Egyptian Soldiers.Initially I was rooting for the Apache because of their tactics - which suits this kind of small squad engagements better than their counterpart. However, the Egyptian soldiers basically destroy the Apache warriors in terms of weapons, and their armor will be of great help, protecting them from poison-tipped arrows. In addition, they are in general better trained and more experienced thanks to the geographical location and prosperity of their civilization. With all that said, the Egyptian soldiers will in the end claim their victory.