User blog comment:WanderingSkull/Richard Winters vs. Amon Goeth/@comment-5232784-20130528060737

Okay woodcampers, lets get it on!

1. close range:

The Ka-bar knife is an awesome short range blade, still used I believe in some militaries today. However, German made weapons were generally better made and higher quality than the weapons of the allies. The German knife looks like a masterpiece of art, better made and is longer than the Ka-bar, as well as sporting two bladed sides as opposed to the Ka-Bar's 1 sharp side

EDGE: Goeth!

2. Short range

The Luger has an extra bullet over the .45, but the latter packs a wallop, ideal for close quarter combat. You could potentially get a shot off after being hit by a luger, but you would have a harder time doing that after getting slugged by a colt .45

EDGE: Winters!

3. Mid range

The Thompson has ten extra bullets over the MP-28: this alone makes the Tommy gun the better gun.

EDGE: Winters

4. Long range:

The Steyr Mannilicher has better range yet lacks three extra bullets found in the good old M1 Garand. Due to this, I give this section a tie

EDGE: Dead even

5. Explosives

Both grenades have the same blast radius, and no enough info is presented to give a good edge to either weapon.

EDGE: Dead Even!

6. X-factors

While Goeth has better training brutality, Winters has combat experience, leadership, accuracy, and better mental health. While Goeth as far as I know never fought American troops, Winters has often fought German ones, so he will have the better advantage in special experience here as well as general combat experience. He wins here hands down!

EDGE: Winters

I think Winters has this in the bag: he has better combat experience, has experience fighting German troops (while Goeth has little to no experience fighting American troops), better mental health, leadership, accuracy, and superior pistol and submachine guns. There is no wau in Heaven, Hell or Houston that Goeth will come off the winner

WINTERS WAYLAYS GOETH