User blog comment:Pygmy Hippo 2/Second Year Back For Blood/@comment-379205-20181221073238

119's "Hunting Assassins" Edges

Knives: The Hidden Blade may be stealthy, and technically, Connor's variant can be turned outwards to be used as a more conventional knife, but it still isn't as handy as a simple hunting knife. Edge: Cash

Melee: The Chainsaw may have a psychological impact on someone like Connor who has never seen one, however, it is not a very practical weapon, being large, bulky, noisy, and slowing the user down due to its weight. On the other hand, the Tomahawk can attack far more quickly and can even be thrown. Edge: Connor

Ranged: The Bow and Arrow has a longer effective range, fires a larger projectile, meaning greater stopping power, and is more accurate, as it is actually designed to be used as a ranged weapon. Edge: Connor

Firearm: The sawed-off shotgun take this one easily with its more modern design, meaning it can be reloaded more quickly, and do more damage at close range as it fires off a blast of shot, and has a more reliable firing mechanism- there is a lot that can go long with a flintlock. Edge: Cash

X-Factors: Cash may have taken on more dangerous opponents and proved surprisingly proficient at stealth, but at the end of the day, he doesn't have any combat training that I know of. Connor was trained to use a bow and arrow and tomahawk by his Native tribe, and then trained in silently killing and close combat as an Assassin. This gives him a massive advantage in terms of training and stealth, giving him the Edge

Overall Winner: Connor wins this battle for his superior training as an Assassin, allowing him to overcome Cash's more modern weaponry. Maybe this would be different if Cash was bringing different weapons to this fight, but he isn't, and so Connor wins this battle.