User blog comment:Cfp3157/Season 3 Episode 1: Frank West vs Rick Grimes/@comment-379205-20130326204645

119's "Non-Stationary Cadaver Removal" Edges


 * Melee: The Gator Machete takes the edge, as it has a blade, meaning it is more likely to do fatal damage with each strike than a blunt instrument like the baseball bat. Edge: Rick Grimes


 * Revolvers: The "Broken Butterfly" Schofield has a larger round, but the Python is a double action for faster firing. Even.


 * Handguns: The Glock takes this one as it has a much larger magazine than the M1911. Edge: Rick Grimes


 * Shotguns: The weapons are similar enough to call this even.


 * Assault Rifles: Again, the two weapons are similar enough to be called even, both being lightweight assault rifles with 30-round magazines, both firing 5.56mm rounds. Even


 * Sniper Rifles: Frank's Winchester Model 70 takes this as it is lighter than the Remington.


 * X-Factors: Rick has more training, yes, but Frank has higher physical strength, is in better mental condition, and most importantly, has experience on his side, having fought much better trained adversaries- US Special Forces.


 * Overall Winner: Frank West takes this, primarily as he has proven himself capable against enemies far more dangerous than zombies or post-apocalyptic militias.