User blog comment:Cfp3157/Frank West vs. Nathan Drake/@comment-3189283-20161010210537

Let's see shall we

Melee

It's pretty simply really. No matter how skilled of a hand to hand combatant Nathan is, his bare hands are not going to be able to do anywhere near the damage of Frank's baseball bat. Furthermore even if he does get disarmed of or loses his bat Frank can easily find something else  to fashion  into a weapon. Nathan could always do the same but whatever improvised melee weapon he can come up with won't be nearly as effective as what Frank can.

Edge: Frank West

Handgun

The Colt is certainly an iconic american sidearm but it just can't compare to the more modern Beretta with double the bullets per clip as well as being more accurate to shoot.

Edge: Nathan Drake

Mid Range

Gotta go with the Shotgun here. The Lightning Gun grabs the attention more, what with it firing off lightening and all but the shots themselves are not all that lethal and it will take several shots to finish Drake off. It can be used to stun but personally I'd rather have something that can put someone down in one blast, than a weapon that leaves them incapacitated but still able to fight back.

Edge: Nathan Drake

Long Range 

TBC