User blog comment:Alockwood1/Battle of the Rifles - Lucas McCain Versus Matthew Quigley/@comment-3189283-20170208102641

Let's see shall we

Long Range

Both are crack shots with a rifle but McCain's Winchester allows him to spit out rounds faster and doesn't reqire to to be reloaded after every shot like the Sharps does. Sure that Sharps has range but in a scenario like this the battle is going to take place at a mid-close range which makes the greater firepower of the Winchester more important.

Edge: Lucas McCain

Mid Range

Should be a fairly simple edge for Quigley. While the 1860 model is technologically inferior to the Single Action Quigley is far more proficient with it and if it ends up as a duel (and given this is a western battle that's a likely outcome) he'll be faster on the draw.

Edge: Matthew Quigley

TBC