User blog comment:The Deadliest Warrior/Lt. John J. Dunbar vs. Captain Nathan Algren/@comment-2149911-20110505034135

Pacheco's Charanga Edge

Colt 1851 Navy vs. Colt 1860 Army Richards-Mason Conversion: As Omnicube said The Conversion has a larger round which means more damage. Also it has much longer range in my case. Edge: Algren

12-Gauge Double Barreled Shotgun Muzzleloader vs. Smith & Wesson Schofield: Shotgun v. a pistol? sure the revlver brings the bang, but the 12-gauge brings the BOOM! Edge:Dunbar

Henry 1860 vs. Winchester Model 1873: The Winchester rifles are the most influential guns in history, they change the rifles where used and constructed. Edge:Algren

Tomahawk vs. Yumi Bow: Axe vs. Bow? Sure the Axe can be thrown at a distance, but it lacks perception. The Yumi has a much longer range and has better accuracy in this battle.

Overall Winner: Cpt. Nathan Algren. Basically his weapons are more advanced and have a longer range. Nuff said. NA:600 JD:400