User blog comment:Cfp3157/Frank West vs. Nathan Drake/@comment-5465602-20161021141428

BeastMan14's "[Mrw when the Console Wars ended https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4fWyzwo1xg0]" Edges

Melee: Even. This is definitely the toughest decision for me. While Frank's certainly physically larger, and being able to attack with any thing he can pull from the environment, Nate's fighting style usually enables him to overcome much stronger opponents like Lazarevich's lieutenant in a fight. In my mind, I think Nate could easily stay out of Frank's grasp, but Frank could lay down some real hurt if he gets his hands on Nate.

Handgun: Nathan Drake. The 92FS has widely replaced the M1911 for a reason, y'know.

Mid-Range: Nathan Drake. The Lightning Gun is a cool weapon, but it needs to hit with some force before it can kill someone, and as Leo pointed out, the shots could go wide when Frank doesn't want them to. The SPAS-12 is the good kind of videogame shotgun where anything even close to it is horribly ripped apart by gunfire. The only downside is a lack of ammo, but Nate's smart enough that ammo conservation shouldn't be a huge issue.

TBF