User blog comment:Battlefan237/The Pursuit of Perfection: Professor Pyg vs. Herbert West/@comment-11361577-20190402162640

Appelmonkey's "Perfection" Edges

Tranqiulzer Syringe vs. Meat Cleaver: A good heavy dose of tranquilizer should be enough to put Pyg and the Dolltrons out of the fight, however, its so short when compared to the other melee weapons that it's unlikely that West will be able to use it. The meat cleaver is not that great either, but its more lethal than a syringe. Edge: Professor Pyg

Iron Pipe vs. Buzzsaw: I am with Wass on this one. The buzzsaw is too reliant on a power source but it can tear through flesh and cause targets to bleed to death. The pipe is more durable and reliable but only really lethal when you go for the neck or head. In the end, the advantages and flaws of both weapons end up making them equal. Edge: Even

Sharpened Shovel vs. Pitchfork: The pitchfork is no bad improvised weapon by any means, but the shovel still blows it out of the water. It is more versatile, as it can be used as a thrusting weapon and a slashing weapon, and its lighter. Edge: Herbert West

M1911 vs. Swan-off Shotgun: A shotgun packs more damage than a simple pistol, but it also lacks range and magazine size, being only worth two shots before needing to be reloaded. The M1911 is indeed weaker, but it also has more range, a larger magazine size, and is more accurate than a shot. Edge: Herbert West

Chemical Cloth vs. Electric Drill: Neither of these weapons is very good. The drill might be easier to use but I doubt its long enough to hit any vital organs. The chemical cloth has even shorter range, sure, but all the victim needs are one whiff to be killed. Edge: Herbert West

Reanimators vs. Dolltrons: Ironically, the thing that gives the reanimators the big edge over the dolltrons is also the same thing that will end up working against West, namely their intellect. They are smart enough to ambush their victims and work together, however, their intellect also means they might get pissed at West and go all Frankenstein on his ass. On the flip side, the Dolltrons might be idiots they are also less likely to rebel. In the end, both groups of minions are equal in terms of physicality and their respective drawbacks make them completely even. Edge: Even

Deadliest Mad Scientist: Herbert West! Going in I expected Pyg to slam West and add him to his doll collection, but clearly, this ended up not being the case. The reanimators might end up biting him in the ass, but as long as he keeps his head down and let them handle everything there is a chance that doesn't need to enter the fray in the first place. Even if he's forced to enter the fight he has the very important fire arm and long melee edges and is presumably more physically fit than the fat Pyg. His mental health is also much better than Pyg's allowing him to keep his cool during tens situations.