User blog comment:FEARTHEWAFFLE/Indiana Jones vs Vigilante/@comment-5559147-20131220024147/@comment-5559147-20131220053457

Nice find on the make of the Vigilantes revolvers and thank you for doing so, but they are similar enough weapons that it doesn't change the outcome much.

"but of course they never show him actually shooting someone"

I didn't mention it, but yeah this is another reason I see Jones coming out on top. He's much more likely to kill and has experience doing so.